Milan Babić was a dentist from a village near Sinj who, within two years of entering politics, became the first president of the self-declared Republic of Serbian Krajina, the Serb-held territory carved out of Croatia in 1991. Between August 1991 and February 1992, while he held the highest civilian offices in that territory, Serb forces drove virtually the whole Croat and non-Serb population out of the region. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia later found that more than 200 civilians, women and elderly people among them, were murdered, and that several hundred more were held in inhumane conditions in Knin.
Babić did not wait to be caught. In October 2001 he approached the tribunal himself, after learning that he had been named as a co-perpetrator in the Croatia indictment against Slobodan Milošević. He testified against Milošević in 2002, surrendered when his own indictment was made public a year later, and on January 27, 2004, pleaded guilty to persecutions on political, racial and religious grounds, a crime against humanity. He asked the Croats to forgive the Serbs. The judges sentenced him to 13 years, two more than the prosecution had asked for, and the Appeals Chamber let that stand. On March 5, 2006, in the middle of his evidence against another Krajina leader, Milan Martić, he died by suicide in the tribunal's custody in The Hague.
Babić was born on February 26, 1956, in Kukar, in the municipality of Sinj, in Croatia. He studied dental medicine in Belgrade, and by the late 1980s he was working at the medical center in Knin, the main town of the inland region of northern Dalmatia. In 1989 he became one of the center's acting directors.
He came to politics through the League of Communists of Croatia. He was a delegate at the party's last congress in December 1989, the meeting at which the old Yugoslav communist order came apart. Within weeks, as Croatia prepared for its first multi-party elections since the Second World War, he had moved to a new party. On February 17, 1990, Serbs from the Krajina region founded the Serbian Democratic Party, known as the SDS, at a rally in Knin, under the leadership of Dr. Jovan Rašković. Babić was among the founders. He later told the tribunal that he joined because the region, poor and long neglected, needed a party that would speak for its own interests.
The SDS won majorities in four municipalities, Knin, Donji Lapac, Gračac and Benkovac, in the spring elections of 1990, while the Croatian Democratic Union took two-thirds of the seats in the Croatian parliament. Babić became president of the SDS municipal committee in Knin and, from 1990 until April 1994, president of the Knin municipal assembly.
The summer of 1990 set the course of the next five years. On July 25, 1990, several thousand Croatian Serbs, Babić among them, gathered at Srb and adopted a declaration on the sovereignty and autonomy of the Serbian nation. It created a Serbian assembly with an executive organ, the Serbian National Council, and on July 31 Babić became the council's president. The council called a plebiscite on Serb autonomy, which the Croatian government declared illegal on August 17, 1990. That day Serbs in and around Knin, organized by the local police inspector Milan Martić, put up barricades, and from then on armed Serb formations supported by the Yugoslav People's Army, the JNA, controlled the town. The vote went ahead, limited to Serb voters, and returned 99.7 percent in favor.
Babić went to Belgrade in August 1990 looking for support. He later testified that a member of the federal presidency promised political backing and the protection of the army. He also sought a channel to Slobodan Milošević, the president of Serbia, whom he regarded at the time as the protector of Serb interests throughout Yugoslavia.
On December 21, 1990, Croatian Serbs in Knin, led by Babić, adopted a statute creating the Serbian Autonomous District, or SAO, of Krajina. On January 4, 1991, Martić became its secretary of the interior. In February and April 1991 the district declared itself independent of Croatia and decided to join the Republic of Serbia, and a referendum in May endorsed annexation by 99.8 percent. Babić was elected president of the district's executive council on April 30, 1991, and on May 29 he became its prime minister. From at least June 1, 1991, he was the de jure commander of its Territorial Defense forces, known as the TO, and in August he made Martić his deputy in that command.
By then Babić had been arguing openly, since February 1991, for an independent Serbian state in Krajina. Croatia declared its own independence on June 25, 1991. On December 19, 1991, the SAO Krajina proclaimed itself the Republic of Serbian Krajina, with Babić as its president.
The crimes Babić admitted ran from August 1, 1991, to February 15, 1992. In those months, the tribunal found, Serb forces attacked and took control of towns, villages and settlements in the Krajina region. The forces named in the case were the JNA, local Serb TO units and TO units from Serbia and Montenegro, local and Serbian police units, including the Krajina police commonly called "Martić's Police," and paramilitary groups. Once a place was under their control, those forces and the local Serb authorities established what the tribunal called a regime of persecution, designed to drive the Croat and other non-Serb population from the region.
That regime took several forms, all of them set out in the factual basis of Babić's plea. Croat and other non-Serb civilians were murdered in Dubica, Cerovljani, Baćin, Saborsko, Poljanak, Lipovača and other places; the court put the number of murdered civilians at more than 200. Hundreds more were imprisoned for long periods in inhumane conditions in Knin. Thousands were deported or forcibly transferred out of the region. Private and public property, including buildings of cultural value to Croats and other non-Serbs, was deliberately destroyed.
The indictment against him set out the killings village by village. By its count, fifty-six non-Serb civilians from Dubica, Baćin and Cerovljani were killed near Baćin on October 21, 1991, and fifty-four more people from those villages were killed at about the same time. It listed seven civilians killed in Lipovača on October 28, ten in the hamlet of Vukovići, near Poljanak, on November 7, and twenty-nine Croat civilians in Saborsko on November 12. It listed thirty-eight non-Serb civilians killed in Škabrnja, near Zadar, on November 18, and seven in neighboring Nadin the next day, and ten people, nine of them Croats, in Bruška and the hamlet of Marinović on December 21, 1991. The 1991 census had counted 286,716 people in the territory that became the Republic of Serbian Krajina, 78,611 of them Croats. By the end of the campaign virtually the whole of the Croat, Muslim and other non-Serb population had been removed, deported or killed.
Babić admitted that he contributed to that persecution in eight ways. He formulated, promoted and encouraged policies that advanced the aim of the joint criminal enterprise, which was the forcible and permanent removal of the majority of Croats and other non-Serbs from about one-third of Croatia, so that the territory could become part of a Serb-dominated state. He was instrumental in setting up and maintaining the institutions that ruled the SAO Krajina and carried out that aim. He helped reorganize and recruit the TO forces that took part in the crimes. He cooperated with the commander of "Martić's Police," who, by Babić's own account, was involved in the crimes. He took part in providing financial, material, logistical and political support for the military takeover of territory. He requested JNA help, or made it easier for the army to take part, in seizing and holding that territory. He made ethnically inflammatory speeches at public events and in the media, propaganda that helped unleash violence against Croats and other non-Serbs. And he encouraged and helped to organize military supplies for Serbs to further the campaign.
He admitted that he took part knowingly and intentionally. He knew that crimes such as mistreatment in prisons, deportation, forcible transfer and the destruction of property were being committed. He knew that civilians were being killed as non-Serbs were forced out, and that such killings were the likely outcome of the campaign.
Babić's hold on power ended over a peace plan. In November 1991 Milošević, the federal defense secretary and the Croatian president signed a ceasefire agreement in Geneva under the auspices of the United Nations special envoy. A second ceasefire in January 1992 opened the way for the Vance plan, which placed the Serb-held areas under United Nations protection and provided for the JNA to withdraw and for displaced people to return. Babić opposed the plan in its proposed form, despite repeated pressure from Yugoslav officials. He objected to the disbanding of the TO, to the withdrawal of the JNA, which he regarded as the Croatian Serbs' only protector, and to the placement of the international forces and the borders of the protected areas.
On February 16, 1992, the assembly of the Republic of Serbian Krajina adopted the Vance plan against his expressed will. Isolated by Belgrade and its allies in Knin, Martić among them, he was replaced as president on February 26, 1992. He stayed in politics for the rest of the republic's existence, but with far less power. He became president of the SDS in 1992 and led it until 1995; he became foreign minister of the Krajina government in April 1994, and in July 1995 was elected its prime minister. In that period, by his later account, he tried to help bring the fighting to an end along the lines of the Z-4 peace plan, working with the United States ambassador to Croatia. He held the office only until the beginning of August 1995, when the Croatian offensive known as Operation Storm retook Knin and the entire Krajina leadership, Babić with it, fled. He went to Belgrade.
For six years Babić lived quietly in Serbia. Then, in September 2001, the tribunal's prosecutor issued an indictment against Milošević for crimes in Croatia that named Babić as one of his co-perpetrators. In October 2001 Babić contacted the tribunal. Over the next two years he gave a series of interviews to investigators and made statements that were both revealing and incriminating to himself. In 2002 he entered the tribunal's witness protection program and left the region.
He took the stand against Milošević on November 18, 2002, as a protected witness, and testified until December 9. He described the founding of the SDS, the summer of 1990 and his meetings in Belgrade, and he told the court that Milošević controlled Serbia's institutions, the Yugoslav army, and the Bosnian Serb and Croatian Serb leaders. He described a parallel structure, financed and directed from Belgrade through the Serbian State Security Service, that ran the units committing crimes in Croatia, and he testified that villages of no military importance had been attacked and their residents driven out. Facing the accused, he told him that he had dragged the Serb people into war. On the first day he also acknowledged that he hoped, if it came to it, to be treated leniently himself. His identity did not stay protected for long, and after his testimony he went public.
His own indictment was issued on November 17, 2003. It charged him with five counts: persecutions on political, racial and religious grounds, a crime against humanity, and four violations of the laws or customs of war, namely murder, cruel treatment, wanton destruction of villages, and destruction of institutions dedicated to education or religion. It named his co-participants in the joint criminal enterprise, Milošević and Martić among them, and said that he took part in it until at least February 1992. On November 26, 2003, Babić surrendered voluntarily and was transferred to the tribunal's custody.
His first plea agreement described him as an aider and abettor of the enterprise. The Trial Chamber expressed doubts about that description, and the parties filed a new agreement under which he would plead guilty as a co-perpetrator. In return for the plea and his continued cooperation, the prosecution agreed to recommend a sentence of no more than 11 years.
On January 27, 2004, Babić pleaded guilty to Count 1, persecutions on political, racial and religious grounds, a crime against humanity under Article 5(h) of the tribunal's Statute, as a co-perpetrator in a joint criminal enterprise. He then made a statement to the court. "I come before this Tribunal with a deep sense of shame and remorse," he said. He told the judges that innocent people had been persecuted, evicted by force and killed, that he had kept silent after he learned what had happened, and that he had stayed in office. He asked "my brothers, Croats" to forgive the Serbs, and he urged other Serbs to face what had been done. The next day the Trial Chamber accepted the plea, finding it voluntary, informed, unequivocal and supported by a factual basis, and entered a finding of guilt on Count 1. The four remaining counts were withdrawn with the Chamber's consent.
At a sentencing hearing in April 2004 he gave evidence in support of the factual basis of his plea, and in June, before the judgment, he testified for the prosecution again, in the trial of the Bosnian Serb leader Momčilo Krajišnik.
The Trial Chamber delivered its sentencing judgment on June 29, 2004. It gave primary weight to the gravity of the crime, which it found extreme: virtually the whole Croat and non-Serb population had been expelled, more than 200 civilians had been murdered, and several hundred had been confined in inhumane conditions. It held that his high political positions counted against him. As a regional leader he had enlisted resources for the enterprise and, through his speeches and media appearances, prepared Serbs to accept that their goals could be reached through persecution; by staying in office as the campaign went on, he amplified its consequences. He had not been the prime mover, the Chamber found, but he chose to remain in power and gave significant support to the persecution.
Against that the Chamber set his admission of guilt, his extensive cooperation with the prosecution, given at great risk to himself, his voluntary surrender and his remorse, which it found sincere. It declined to count his conduct after the crime, because that conduct had not included steps to relieve the suffering of victims. It held that a sentence of no more than 11 years would not do justice, and it sentenced him to 13 years' imprisonment, with credit for the time already served in detention.
Babić appealed, with the prosecution's support. He argued that he had been pushed into pleading as a co-perpetrator, that the judges had not explained why 13 years was just when 11 was not, that his sentence was out of line with that of the Bosnian Serb leader Biljana Plavšić, and that the Chamber had misjudged his mitigating circumstances and overstated his role.
The Appeals Chamber gave its judgment on July 18, 2005. It found that he had not been coerced into the second agreement, that the Trial Chamber had explained its departure from the recommended sentence, and that his case would not be measured against Plavšić's. On one ground it agreed with him in part: the Trial Chamber had erred in refusing to treat his conduct after the crime as mitigation simply because it had not directly relieved the victims' suffering, and it should have weighed his attempts to further peace, including the effort tied to the Z-4 plan. By majority, the Appeals Chamber found that the error did not affect the sentence, and it affirmed the term of 13 years.
After the sentencing judgment Babić waited at the tribunal's detention unit for a country willing to take him. Some other detainees regarded him as a traitor. On September 19, 2005, he was transferred to the United Kingdom to serve the rest of his sentence.
In January 2006 the Trial Chamber hearing the case against Martić ordered him brought back to give evidence for the prosecution once more. He returned to the United Nations Detention Unit in The Hague on February 7, 2006, was kept apart from all other detainees at his request, and testified against Martić through February and into early March, when he was under cross-examination by the defense. He was due back in court on March 6.
He died by suicide at the detention unit on March 5, 2006. The tribunal's president ordered an inquiry the next day, and the Dutch authorities investigated separately. In May 2006 the Dutch prosecution service closed its criminal investigation, having found no indication of a crime and no sign that anyone else was involved. The tribunal's inquiry, reported on June 8, 2006, after interviews with some forty witnesses, found no criminal conduct in the death and no lack of proper care.
His death cut short the cross-examination in the Martić trial, and the defense asked the judges to strike his evidence. The Trial Chamber kept it, and on September 14, 2006, the Appeals Chamber upheld that decision, holding that the interruption, coming after most of the cross-examination had been completed, was unforeseeable and unavoidable. His testimony went on to be admitted in later cases, among them the trials of the Serbian State Security officials Jovica Stanišić and Franko Simatović and of the Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadžić.
Babić's conviction rests on the persecution count alone. He admitted that he knew civilians were being killed and that killings were the likely outcome of the campaign, but he consistently maintained that he had no knowledge of the specific murders listed in the indictment, and the prosecution itself told the court it had evidence that he learned of the killings of Croat civilians only years later.
The factual basis of his plea, as the Trial Chamber summarized it, named murders in Dubica, Cerovljani, Baćin, Saborsko, Poljanak and Lipovača "and in other places." The indictment also listed killings in Škabrnja, Nadin and Bruška. The village-by-village figures come from the indictment; the court's own finding was that more than 200 civilians were murdered.
After his death, claims circulated in Serbia that he had been murdered. The Dutch investigation and the tribunal's inquiry found no evidence of any crime.
February 26, 1956: Born in Kukar, in the municipality of Sinj, Croatia.
1989: Becomes one of the acting directors of the medical center in Knin.
February 17, 1990: Helps found the Serbian Democratic Party in Knin.
July 31, 1990: Becomes president of the Serbian National Council.
August 17, 1990: Serb barricades go up around Knin; armed Serb formations take control of the town.
December 21, 1990: Leads the adoption of the statute creating the SAO Krajina.
April 30, 1991: Elected president of the SAO Krajina executive council.
May 29, 1991: Becomes prime minister of the SAO Krajina; de jure commander of its Territorial Defense from at least June 1.
August 1, 1991: The joint criminal enterprise he later admitted joining comes into existence.
October 21, 1991: Fifty-six non-Serb civilians are killed near Baćin, according to the indictment.
November 12, 1991: Twenty-nine Croat civilians are killed in Saborsko, according to the indictment.
November 18 and 19, 1991: The indictment lists thirty-eight civilians killed in Škabrnja and seven in Nadin.
December 19, 1991: The Republic of Serbian Krajina is proclaimed, with Babić as president.
February 15, 1992: The period of his admitted participation ends.
February 26, 1992: Replaced as president after the assembly adopts the Vance plan against his will.
July 1995: Elected prime minister of the Republic of Serbian Krajina.
August 1995: Flees with the Krajina leadership during Operation Storm.
October 2001: Contacts the tribunal after being named in the Milošević Croatia indictment.
November 18 to December 9, 2002: Testifies against Slobodan Milošević as a protected witness.
November 17, 2003: Indictment issued.
November 26, 2003: Surrenders voluntarily to the tribunal.
January 27, 2004: Pleads guilty to persecutions on political, racial and religious grounds, a crime against humanity.
January 28, 2004: Plea accepted; finding of guilt entered on Count 1.
June 29, 2004: Sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment.
July 18, 2005: Appeals Chamber affirms the sentence by majority.
September 19, 2005: Transferred to the United Kingdom to serve his sentence.
February 2006: Returns to The Hague to testify against Milan Martić.
March 5, 2006: Dies by suicide at the United Nations Detention Unit in The Hague.
June 8, 2006: Tribunal inquiry finds no criminal conduct in his death.
September 14, 2006: Appeals Chamber rules that his evidence in the Martić trial may be retained.