Six children died in Derby on May 11, 2012. Within three weeks the man at the head of their household, Michael Philpott, known to everyone as Mick, had been arrested on suspicion of murder. Within a year a jury at Nottingham Crown Court had convicted him, his wife and a friend of the family of six counts of manslaughter, one count for each child. The trial judge found that Philpott had been the driving force behind the plan that caused the deaths, and that the two others had helped him carry it out.
The outcome was not a murder conviction. The prosecution replaced the murder charges with manslaughter before the trial, and the judge sentenced on the basis that none of the three had intended to kill the children or to cause them really serious harm. Even so, she imposed on Philpott the maximum sentence the law allows for manslaughter: life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 15 years before the Parole Board could consider his release. His wife and the friend each received 17 years.
Philpott was 55 in early 2012 and 56 when he was sentenced. He had served in the army as a young man. In December 1978, at the age of 21, he was convicted of attempted murder and of a further offense under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act, and was sentenced to seven years. He served that sentence.
The jury that tried him in 2013 heard nothing of it. His previous convictions were among the issues argued before the trial judge in the absence of the jury, and she excluded the 1978 conviction from the evidence. It became public only after the verdicts, when the judge set out in her sentencing remarks what she had kept from the jury and why it mattered to the sentence she had to pass.
By early 2012 Philpott was the head of a large household in Allenton, a district of Derby.
The six children who died were Jade, John, Jack, Jesse, Jayden and Duwayne. They lived in Allenton, and all six died in May 2012.
The court that tried the case found that the children had been well looked after in the ordinary, daily sense. The evidence, the judge said, showed that they were well fed and well clothed and that they went to school regularly. She accepted that their mother loved them and cared for them, and the Court of Appeal later accepted the same thing. At sentencing the judge began from the children rather than from the defendants: each of the six counts on the indictment, she said, represented the death of a child, and every sentence she passed was measured against that.
Derbyshire Police opened an inquiry on the day of the deaths. Within days officers arrested two other people from Derby, a man and a woman, on suspicion of murder. Both were released without charge the following day, and neither was ever charged. The trial judge later found that those arrests followed a report Philpott himself had made to the police, and that when he made it he knew that the two had nothing to do with the deaths.
The force made public appeals for information. Behind them, detectives from its serious and organized crime unit obtained covert recordings of Philpott and his wife talking to each other in the weeks after the deaths. Those recordings were to become one of the central strands of the prosecution case. At sentencing the judge relied on them directly, finding that the tapes showed Philpott knew the people he had pointed the police toward were innocent.
On Tuesday, May 29, 2012, Derbyshire Police arrested Philpott and his wife on suspicion of murder. On the evening of May 30 both were charged with six counts of murder.
The couple appeared before Southern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court on May 31, 2012, and the case was sent on to the Crown Court. They stayed in custody from then on. On June 18, 2012, they came before a High Court judge at Nottingham Crown Court for a preliminary hearing. Both were remanded in custody, a trial date was fixed for January 14, 2013, and a plea and case management hearing was listed for the autumn.
The inquiry did not stop with the parents. On the afternoon of Monday, November 5, 2012, officers arrested a friend of the couple, and that evening Derbyshire Police charged him with six counts of murder. He appeared before Derby magistrates the next day and was remanded in custody. That same week the Philpotts were due back at Nottingham Crown Court for the plea and case management hearing. From the day of the deaths to the trial, the police investigation ran for about ten months.
The case was managed at Nottingham Crown Court through the second half of 2012. On December 17, 2012, the three defendants came before Birmingham Crown Court. The murder charges were withdrawn and replaced with six counts of manslaughter against each of them. The change meant that the Crown Prosecution Service no longer alleged that any of the three had intended to kill the children. All three pleaded not guilty to the manslaughter counts, and the trial, first fixed for January, was now expected to begin in February.
The trial opened at Nottingham Crown Court on Tuesday, February 12, 2013, before a High Court judge and a jury of six men and six women. It lasted about eight weeks. All three defendants denied manslaughter. The prosecution case was that the deaths were the result of a plan that had gone wrong.
The Crown built that case over the following weeks from several kinds of evidence. The jury heard the recording of the emergency call made that night. It heard from people who knew the defendants and described what had been said to them, before and after the deaths, about a plan. On February 28 the jury began to hear the covert police recordings of Philpott and his wife. Before they were played, the admissibility of the surveillance evidence had been one of the matters contested in legal argument; the judge admitted it, and it went before the jury.
Philpott went into the witness box on March 13, 2013, questioned first by his own counsel. He denied the charges and denied any part in what had happened. His evidence ran over more than three days. His wife also gave evidence. The friend also denied manslaughter.
On Tuesday, April 2, 2013, the jury returned its verdicts. Philpott and the friend were found guilty of all six counts of manslaughter by unanimous verdicts. Philpott's wife was found guilty of all six counts by a majority.
Sentencing was expected the next day, but the judge adjourned it after hearing argument so that she could reflect further. She passed sentence on Thursday, April 4, 2013, describing it at the outset as a unique sentencing exercise.
She began from the verdicts. Because the jury had convicted of manslaughter and not murder, she said, she had to sentence on the basis that none of the three had intended to kill the children or to cause them really serious harm. Within that limit she made her findings plainly. All three, she found, were responsible for the deliberate act that caused the deaths, and all three were responsible for the deaths themselves. The plan was Philpott's. She found that he had been considering it for some time before it was carried out, that he had devised it and driven it forward, and that his wife and the friend had assisted him. What the three had intended, she found, was to put the children through a frightening ordeal, waking them in the middle of the night so that he could rescue them.
She then turned to what followed. Philpott, she found, had lied to the police and lied to the jury. He had checked with his wife at every opportunity that she was keeping to the account the two of them had given, and without him, she found, his wife would never have become involved in the plan.
For Philpott she passed a sentence of life imprisonment, the maximum for manslaughter, concluding that the six offenses were so serious, and the danger he posed so great, that no lesser sentence was proper. The law then required her to fix a minimum term. She identified the determinate sentence she would otherwise have passed as 30 years. Parliament required her to halve that figure, to reflect the point at which a determinate sentence ends in release, which gave a minimum term of 15 years. From that she deducted the 307 days he had already spent on remand, leaving 14 years and 58 days before he could be considered for release. Whether he would ever be released, she told him, would be a matter for the Parole Board.
For Philpott's wife the judge found a determinate sentence appropriate, while saying it had to reflect the magnitude of the offenses, and passed 17 years' imprisonment. She accepted that the plan was her husband's, but found that she had shown at other times that she could refuse him when something mattered enough to her, and that her first responsibility had been to her children. The wife had no previous convictions. She would serve half before release on license, with the time already spent on remand deducted, and could be recalled if she offended during the license period. For the friend the judge said she saw no proper basis on which to distinguish his case from the wife's, and passed the same sentence of 17 years, again with release on license at the halfway point.
Philpott did not appeal his conviction or his sentence, and he made no move to do so after his wife's challenge failed.
His wife sought permission to appeal against her 17-year term. The application was refused in July 2013, and she renewed it before the full court. The friend had intended to bring the same appeal but withdrew it before the hearing.
The renewed application was heard on November 29, 2013, by the Court of Appeal, sitting at Nottingham Crown Court rather than in London. The court was made up of the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales and two High Court judges.
Her counsel argued that her near-complete dependence on her husband had not been given enough weight in the sentence, while accepting that it did not excuse her, and that she had been unable to stand up to him. He also pointed to the public pressure for a severe sentence before she was sentenced, and to the hardship the sentence would bring her in custody and after release.
The court rejected the argument. It accepted that she had loved and cared for the children, but held that, as their mother, her responsibility was to them. It held that the plan had not been formed on the spur of the moment, that its risks must have been obvious to her, that the evidence showed she had taken part in the act itself, and that after her arrest she had kept to an account she knew to be false, blaming others. The court said it found it hard to see why she had not exposed her husband's deception during the trial, or during the long period she had spent apart from his control after their arrest. The Lord Chief Justice announced that the court had concluded, without any hesitation, that the appeal must be dismissed. The 17-year sentence stood.
Philpott remained in custody in England as of 2025, serving the life sentence passed in April 2013. His minimum term ends in 2027. Reaching that point does not mean release. He can be released only if the Parole Board directs it.
The verdicts settled responsibility for the six deaths as manslaughter, not murder, and the sentences rest on the express finding that none of the three intended to kill or to cause really serious harm.
The jury's verdict against Philpott's wife was by a majority. The verdicts against Philpott and the friend were unanimous.
The man and woman arrested in the first days of the inquiry were released without charge, and the trial judge found that they had nothing to do with the deaths.
December 1978: Philpott is convicted of attempted murder and an offense under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act and is sentenced to seven years.
May 11, 2012: The deaths in Derby; all six children die in May 2012.
May 2012: Two people arrested on suspicion of murder are released without charge the next day.
May 29, 2012: Derbyshire Police arrest Philpott and his wife on suspicion of murder.
May 30, 2012: Both are charged with six counts of murder.
May 31, 2012: First appearance at Southern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court; both remain in custody.
June 18, 2012: Preliminary hearing at Nottingham Crown Court; trial fixed for January 14, 2013.
November 5, 2012: A friend of the couple is arrested and charged with six counts of murder.
November 6, 2012: The friend appears before Derby magistrates and is remanded in custody.
December 17, 2012: At Birmingham Crown Court the murder charges are replaced by six counts of manslaughter; all three plead not guilty.
February 12, 2013: The trial opens at Nottingham Crown Court.
February 28, 2013: The jury begins to hear the covert police recordings.
March 13, 2013: Philpott begins his evidence and denies the charges.
April 2, 2013: Philpott and the friend are convicted of six counts of manslaughter unanimously; Philpott's wife is convicted by a majority.
April 4, 2013: Philpott is sentenced to life imprisonment, minimum term 15 years less 307 days on remand; his wife and the friend are sentenced to 17 years each.
July 2013: The wife's application for permission to appeal is refused.
November 29, 2013: The Court of Appeal, sitting at Nottingham, dismisses her renewed application; the friend's appeal is withdrawn.
2027: Philpott's minimum term ends.