On March 16, 1988, in west Belfast, Michael Stone, a loyalist, killed three men in a single attack. A year later, at Belfast Crown Court, he was convicted of six counts of murder, five counts of attempted murder and three counts of conspiracy to murder, together with 21 further counts. The six murders were the three in west Belfast and three earlier killings to which he had made a voluntary confession to police. He received a life sentence. The trial judge recommended that he serve 30 years.
He served 12 of them. In July 2000 he walked free under the early release scheme created by the Good Friday Agreement, one of hundreds of paramilitary prisoners released under the Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998. Six years later, on the day the Northern Ireland Assembly was due to nominate a power-sharing government, he went to the Assembly building at Stormont. The court that tried him found that he had gone there to murder two Sinn Féin leaders, and convicted him of two counts of attempted murder. His licence was revoked, and a long fight in the courts over when he could be released again ended only in January 2021, when the Parole Commissioners for Northern Ireland directed his release on life licence.
Patrick Brady was killed in south Belfast in November 1984. A year later Kevin McPolin was killed in Lisburn, County Antrim, and in May 1987 Dermott Hackett was killed in County Tyrone. Their deaths are on Stone's record not because a jury heard evidence about them but because he gave police a voluntary confession to all three. Each became one of the six counts of murder on which he was convicted on March 3, 1989.
Three men died in the attack in west Belfast that day. Thomas McErlean and John Murray were civilians.
Kevin Brady, whose name in Irish was Caoimhín Mac Brádaigh, was a west Belfast man and a member of the IRA. He grew up in Belfast but spent his summers, and a large part of his life, in Meenaleck in the Gaoth Dobhair district of County Donegal, where he was well known in the community. He loved fishing in Donegal and spoke Irish fluently from childhood.
Police arrested Stone on March 22, 1988. While in custody he made the voluntary confession that tied him to the three earlier murders, and the prosecution brought all six murder counts together, with five counts of attempted murder, three counts of conspiracy to murder and 21 further counts.
On March 3, 1989, Belfast Crown Court convicted him on every one of them. The life sentence, passed under section 1(1) of the Northern Ireland (Emergency Provisions) Act 1973, was imposed for the six murders; for the other convictions the court passed concurrent terms of between 20 and 27 years. The trial judge recommended a tariff of 30 years. What those 30 years meant, and when they ran out, would occupy the courts three decades later.
When the Belfast Agreement of April 1998 promised an accelerated release program for prisoners convicted of paramilitary offenses, Stone applied to the newly created Sentence Review Commissioners. All six murders were qualifying offenses under the Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998. On February 17, 1999, the commissioners declared him eligible for early release and fixed July 22, 2000, as the day that eligibility would take effect. Because his sentence had been passed before the Act, section 10 gave him a right to be released two years after it became law, and on that basis he was released on licence on July 24, 2000, after 12 years and 124 days in custody.
The licence carried three conditions only: that he not support a specified organization, that he not become involved in acts of terrorism connected with Northern Ireland, and, because he was a life prisoner, that he not become a danger to the public.
Parliament had fixed Friday, November 24, 2006, as the day the Assembly would nominate a First Minister and deputy First Minister or be prorogued. That day Stone went to the Assembly building at Stormont, where members were sitting, and police arrested him there. That evening, with his solicitor present, he told detectives that his purpose had been to assassinate two Sinn Féin leaders and to disrupt the nomination.
The next day, November 25, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland suspended his licence with immediate effect on the ground that he had broken its conditions, and Stone was detained under the life sentence that same day. He was remanded in custody on the new charges.
The case was heard at Belfast Crown Court in 2008. The defense did not dispute that Stone had been at Stormont. Its case was about intention. Stone gave evidence that the whole episode was a work of performance art, a protest aimed at both Sinn Féin and the Democratic Unionist Party, meant to clear the building rather than to harm anyone.
The court rejected that account. It found that his evidence contradicted what he had told police on the day, and that a claim to be making art could never be a defense to conduct that was otherwise criminal. On the whole of the evidence it was satisfied that Stone went to Stormont to try to murder the two men. It also rejected the argument that he had done no more than prepare, which is not enough for an attempt under Article 3 of the Criminal Attempts and Conspiracy (Northern Ireland) Order 1983: he had entered the building where his intended victims were sitting.
On November 14, 2008, he was convicted of the attempted murder of Gerard Adams and the attempted murder of Martin McGuinness, and of seven further counts. He was acquitted of two counts. On December 8, 2008, he received 16 years for the attempted murders, with shorter concurrent terms for the other offenses.
On January 6, 2011, the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland dismissed his appeal against the attempted murder convictions. It held that there had been more than sufficient evidence of intention, and that Stone had moved from intention, preparation and planning into the execution of the plan to kill the two men.
On September 6, 2011, after the criminal proceedings were complete, the Sentence Review Commissioners revoked his licence. That brought him under the Life Sentences (Northern Ireland) Order 2001, which required a judge to fix the minimum term for an existing life prisoner. On July 29, 2013, the Lord Chief Justice set the tariff for the 1989 life sentence at 30 years. The Northern Ireland Prison Service counted the six years Stone had spent on licence between 2000 and 2006 as time served. By its reckoning he had spent 12 years and 124 days in custody before July 2000, six years and 123 days on licence, and a further 11 years and 116 days in custody from November 24, 2006. On that calculation the tariff ran out on March 21, 2018.
On April 16, 2018, a panel of the Parole Commissioners decided that he should not yet be released, citing among other things his continued insistence that the Stormont offenses had not been a genuine attempt at violence.
In January 2019 the Divisional Court of the High Court held that the six years on licence could not count toward the 30-year tariff, which in its view meant time actually spent in custody. On that reading Stone's earliest release date moved to around July 2024. The court quashed the Department of Justice's decision to treat him as eligible for parole, and the parole hearing due that month was put on hold while the ruling was appealed. On February 19, 2020, the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom held unanimously that it had no jurisdiction to hear the appeal against that ruling, and that the proper route was the Court of Appeal in Belfast. On November 6, 2020, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeals. All sides accepted that during those six years he had been lawfully at liberty and serving his sentence. Nothing in the 2001 Order excluded time lawfully spent on licence, it held, there was no reason to think Parliament had overlooked such periods of release when it framed the Order, and keeping Stone in custody for a further six years would interfere with his liberty without the clear authority of law that such interference required.
The parole case resumed. On January 25, 2021, a panel of the Parole Commissioners directed that Stone be released on life licence, and he left custody the following day.
The panel found that he still represented a risk of serious harm, given six murders and the offenses of 2006, although that risk appeared to be declining. Stone told the panel that he now accepted he had broken the law. The panel said it could not test whether his remorse was genuine but treated it as a movement in his position. It weighed in his favor his record in custody, his age and failing health, and his stated rejection of violence and of paramilitary organizations, and concluded that the risk could be managed in the community under strict conditions, including electronic monitoring, a curfew, controls on travel and on his means of communication, and a ban on approaching the families of his victims.
Under the 2001 Order a life licence stays in force until the prisoner's death unless it is revoked. Stone was still on parole in October 2024.
Stone's account of Stormont changed over time. On the day he told police he had gone to kill the two men; at trial he said it was performance art; before the Parole Commissioners in 2021 he accepted that what he had done was unlawful and that he deserved punishment. The courts accepted none of the performance-art claims, and the attempted murder convictions were upheld on appeal.
His standing with loyalist paramilitary groups is also unsettled. A 2018 prison security report that described him as a member of one was later withdrawn as entered in error, and by 2021 the Parole Commissioners accepted his submission that he was not a member or supporter of any such group.
November 1984: The first of three earlier murders, in south Belfast; the second follows a year later in Lisburn, County Antrim.
May 1987: The third earlier murder, in County Tyrone.
March 16, 1988: Three men are killed in an attack in west Belfast.
March 22, 1988: Stone is arrested; in custody he makes a voluntary confession to three earlier murders.
March 3, 1989: Belfast Crown Court convicts him of six counts of murder, five of attempted murder and three of conspiracy to murder; life sentence, with a recommended tariff of 30 years.
February 17, 1999: The Sentence Review Commissioners declare him eligible for early release.
July 22, 2000: The date fixed for his eligibility for early release.
July 24, 2000: Released on licence under the Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998.
November 24, 2006: Arrested at Stormont, Belfast; his licence is suspended the next day.
November 14, 2008: Convicted at Belfast Crown Court of two counts of attempted murder.
December 8, 2008: Sentenced to 16 years.
January 6, 2011: The Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal against conviction.
September 6, 2011: The Sentence Review Commissioners revoke his licence.
July 29, 2013: The Lord Chief Justice fixes the tariff on the life sentence at 30 years.
April 16, 2018: The Parole Commissioners decide he should not yet be released.
January 15, 2019: The High Court rules that his time on licence does not count toward the tariff.
February 19, 2020: The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom rules that it has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
November 6, 2020: The Court of Appeal rules that the time on licence does count; the tariff is treated as having expired on March 21, 2018.
January 25, 2021: The Parole Commissioners direct his release on life licence; he is released the next day.
October 2024: Still on parole.