Michael Skakel was 15 years old in October 1975, when a 15-year-old girl who lived near his family in Greenwich, Connecticut, died on the night of October 30. He was not charged until January 2000, and a jury in Norwalk found him guilty of her murder on June 7, 2002. He was sentenced to 20 years to life. He served more than 11 years before a Superior Court judge ruled that his trial lawyer had failed him, and in May 2018 the Connecticut Supreme Court, by a single vote, agreed that he must be tried again. He never was. In October 2020 the state announced that it would not try him a second time, and the murder charge was dropped.
That leaves an unusual legal position. No conviction stands for the girl's death, no one else has ever been charged with it, and Skakel, who has always denied killing her, has never been acquitted.
Greenwich police opened a murder inquiry the next day. For years their attention fell on other people. In 1976 police sought an arrest warrant for one of them, but the state's attorney declined to sign it, finding no probable cause, and none of the others was ever charged. The case went cold.
Michael Skakel told police in 1975 that he had spent the evening with cousins in another part of Greenwich. That account would later become the center of his defense and, decades afterward, the issue on which his conviction fell.
The case moved again in the early 1990s, when Skakel's father hired a private investigative firm, Sutton Associates, to look into it. In interviews with the firm's investigators, Michael admitted that he had lied to police in 1975. Michael now gave a different account of the night: that after coming home from his cousins' he had gone out again later and had been outdoors in the neighborhood, near the girl's family's property.
In September 1998 Connecticut convened a one-judge grand jury. The investigation ran for 18 months. The judge concluded that there was enough evidence to proceed, and on January 19, 2000, Michael Skakel was arrested and charged with murder. He was released on bond.
Because he had been 15 at the time of the death, the case was filed in juvenile court. On January 31, 2001, the juvenile court judge ruled that he should be tried as an adult and transferred the case to the regular criminal court. The defense appealed the transfer, but in November 2001 the Connecticut Supreme Court declined to send the case back to juvenile court.
The defense also moved to dismiss the charge as too late. In 1975 Connecticut allowed only five years to bring a prosecution for murder that was not a capital offense, and the defense argued that the deadline had passed in 1980. The trial judge refused to dismiss the case, concluding that the state had never been bound by such a deadline for this charge.
The trial opened in Norwalk in May 2002. There was no physical evidence connecting Skakel to the death and no eyewitness. The prosecution rested instead on what it said he had admitted. Its two central witnesses were men who had known him in the late 1970s at a residential school in Maine for troubled teenagers. Each testified that Skakel had confessed the killing to him there. The Connecticut Supreme Court later called their testimony the cornerstone of the state's case.
Skakel's defense was an alibi. His brothers and two cousins testified that he had been with them in the other part of Greenwich during the hours when the evidence suggested the death had occurred. The prosecution told the jurors that there was not a single independent alibi witness, and the defense called no one from outside the family to answer that point. On June 7, 2002, the jury found Michael Skakel guilty of murder.
He was sentenced in Norwalk Superior Court on August 29, 2002, to 20 years to life. He was 41.
His direct appeal turned largely on the claim that the prosecution had come too late. On January 24, 2006, the Connecticut Supreme Court rejected that claim, overruling its own 1983 precedent on the old time limit, and affirmed the conviction. He asked the Supreme Court of the United States to hear the case, and it declined.
He then petitioned for a new trial on the ground of newly discovered evidence, a claim that two other men had been responsible for the death. The trial court rejected it, and in 2010 the Connecticut Supreme Court upheld that ruling, finding that the claim lacked credibility.
In October 2012 the state parole board heard his application for early release. It voted unanimously to deny parole, and he was told he could not apply again for five years.
By then he had filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus claiming that his trial lawyer had represented him so poorly that the trial was constitutionally unfair. The habeas trial before a Superior Court judge lasted two weeks in 2013. In October 2013 the judge granted the petition. He found ten separate failings in the defense and three that, in his judgment, had prejudiced the outcome: the lawyer had not found a witness who could support the alibi; he had not found a man who could have challenged one of the prosecution's confession witnesses; and he had not pointed the jury toward another man who had long been a suspect. The judge vacated the conviction and ordered a new trial.
On November 21, 2013, a judge in Stamford Superior Court set bail at $1.2 million, and Skakel was released the same day. He had served more than 11 years of his sentence.
The state appealed. In December 2016 the Connecticut Supreme Court reversed the habeas judge by a vote of four to three, holding that Skakel had proved none of his claims and that his trial lawyer had given him an adequate defense. The conviction was restored, though he remained free on bail. Skakel asked the court to reconsider, limiting his request to the alibi claim, and the court agreed.
On May 4, 2018, the Connecticut Supreme Court, again dividing four to three, reversed its own 2016 ruling and affirmed the habeas judgment ordering a new trial. The decision turned on one witness. On the night of October 30, 1975, a cousin who was with Skakel had a guest of her own, a retired psychologist. At the habeas trial he testified that he had seen Michael Skakel and two of his brothers watching television at the cousins' that evening. In her grand jury testimony the cousin had mentioned the guest only as her "beau," and the trial lawyer never identified or interviewed him. The habeas judge found him a disinterested and credible witness.
The majority held that the lawyer's failure to find him was constitutionally inexcusable and that it had prejudiced the defense. The alibi had been Skakel's primary defense, the state carried the burden of disproving it beyond a reasonable doubt, and the hours it covered were the hours in which the evidence placed the death. The prosecution had told the jury that there was no independent alibi witness; this witness would have answered that claim directly, and his account also cut against the testimony of three of the state's witnesses. The majority described the state's case as entirely circumstantial and highly open to impeachment, resting on witnesses who had come forward more than two decades after the death, and it concluded that the case had been far from overwhelming.
Three justices dissented. They argued that the alibi covered only part of the relevant period and so could not have changed the result, that the state's evidence had been strong enough to convince the jury, that the majority had made credibility findings of its own and relied on material outside the trial record, and that the trial lawyer's performance had not been deficient at all.
The state asked the Supreme Court of the United States to review the decision. On January 7, 2019, the Court declined without comment, leaving the conviction vacated.
The case returned to Stamford Superior Court. On October 30, 2020, Connecticut's chief state's attorney announced at a hearing there that the state would not seek a second trial, because the case could not be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. The murder charge was dropped.
In November 2023 Skakel filed a civil suit against the town of Greenwich and the investigator who had led the inquiry, alleging malicious prosecution and violations of his civil rights; the suit was unresolved as of January 2024.
No court has found who caused the girl's death. Michael Skakel was convicted of her murder in 2002, but the conviction was vacated in 2018 and the charge was dropped in 2020 without a retrial, so in law he stands neither convicted nor acquitted.
The two confession witnesses were never tested before a second jury, and the Connecticut Supreme Court majority treated their late emergence, after a reward and a published book, as a weakness in the state's case. The dissenting justices regarded the same evidence as strong. His claim that two other men were responsible was rejected by the courts, finally in 2010, as lacking credibility. The other people who were suspects at different stages were never charged.
October 30, 1975: A 15-year-old girl dies in Greenwich, Connecticut; Michael Skakel, a neighbor, is 15.
1976: Police seek an arrest warrant for another suspect; the state's attorney finds no probable cause.
Early 1990s: A private firm hired by Skakel's father interviews him; he admits lying to police in 1975.
September 1998: A one-judge grand jury is convened.
January 19, 2000: Skakel is arrested and charged with murder in juvenile court.
January 31, 2001: The juvenile court transfers the case to adult court.
May 2002: Trial opens in Norwalk.
June 7, 2002: Found guilty of murder.
August 29, 2002: Sentenced to 20 years to life.
January 24, 2006: Conviction affirmed.
2006: The Supreme Court of the United States declines review.
2010: The Connecticut Supreme Court upholds the denial of a new-trial petition.
October 2012: Parole denied.
October 2013: A habeas judge vacates the conviction and orders a new trial.
November 21, 2013: Released on $1.2 million bail.
December 2016: The Connecticut Supreme Court reinstates the conviction, four to three.
May 4, 2018: On reconsideration, the court vacates the conviction and orders a new trial, four to three.
January 7, 2019: The Supreme Court of the United States declines the state's petition.
October 30, 2020: The state announces it will not retry him; the murder charge is dropped.
November 2023: Skakel sues the town of Greenwich and the lead investigator.