Michael Peterson

Victims
1 death, Durham, 2001; Alford plea to manslaughter. His wife, Kathleen Peterson; a 2003 first-degree murder conviction was vacated in 2011; he maintains his innocence.
Years active
December 9, 2001
Location
Durham, North Carolina
Method
Voluntary manslaughter (Alford plea; he maintains his innocence)
Status
Life without parole (2003), vacated in 2011; 64 to 86 months (2017) with credit for time already served; released February 24, 2017

Michael Peterson was a Durham novelist, a former newspaper columnist and a one-time candidate for mayor when his wife, Kathleen Peterson, died in Durham, North Carolina, on December 9, 2001. That month he was indicted for her murder. In October 2003 a Durham County jury convicted him of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life in prison without parole. He has denied, from the first week to the last hearing, that he killed her.

The conviction did not hold. Eight years later the judge who had presided over the trial ruled that the State Bureau of Investigation analyst at the center of the prosecution's case had misled the jury about his own experience and the reliability of his work. The conviction was vacated, a new trial was ordered, and the state's appeals failed. In February 2017, with a second trial set for that May, Peterson entered an Alford plea to voluntary manslaughter, maintaining his innocence. He was sentenced to time he had already served and walked out of the Durham County Courthouse a free man, fifteen years after the case began.

Before the case, Peterson was known in Durham as a writer and a public figure. He was a graduate of Duke University and a decorated veteran of the Vietnam War, and the war became the subject of his fiction. His novel A Time of War appeared in 1990, and its sequel, A Bitter Peace, followed in 1995; he also wrote a third novel, The Immortal Dragon. He wrote a column for the local paper, The Herald-Sun, and he had run for both mayor and the city council. His wife was a familiar figure in Durham's civic life and served on the city's arts council.

He denied any wrongdoing from the start. Later in December a Durham County grand jury indicted Peterson for murder. He turned himself in, and a Superior Court judge denied bond. He said he was innocent and that he would never have done anything to hurt her.

The trial, before a Durham County Superior Court judge, ran for months in 2003 and became one of the longest in North Carolina history. Testimony lasted about thirteen weeks. The state's case on the physical evidence rested above all on the State Bureau of Investigation analyst, who told jurors he had worked about two hundred cases and was the only witness who claimed to know how the death had come about. The jury also heard evidence about the 1985 death of a family friend in Germany, in which Peterson was never charged; the defense objected to it throughout, and the trial judge allowed it.

Peterson did not testify. On October 10, 2003, the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. He began serving the sentence in a North Carolina state prison.

On September 19, 2006, a panel of the North Carolina Court of Appeals ruled against him over a dissent. Material from the family's computers had been admitted at trial under a warrant that was found lacking in probable cause. Yet the majority found the error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, because the computer material was, in its words, "nothing more than repetition of other properly admitted evidence."

On everything else the majority sided with the state. Evidence about Peterson's private life was admissible to answer the defense's opening portrait of a loving marriage. The couple's finances were relevant to motive. Of the prosecution's closing remarks, the court found one improper but cured by the trial judge's instruction, and a second, which the state conceded had gone too far, not prejudicial enough to have changed the verdict.

The dissenting judge would have ordered a new trial. He found the similarities between the two deaths "tenuous, circumstantial." And because the credibility of the competing experts had decided the verdict, he concluded that the trial judge should have given the jury specific curative instructions after the closing remarks the state itself called excessive.

The split decision gave him a right of appeal to the Supreme Court of North Carolina. On November 9, 2007, that court affirmed. It rejected his other challenges. He remained in prison, serving the life sentence the law fixed for first-degree murder.

The case reopened not through Peterson's own appeals but through a review of the State Bureau of Investigation laboratory. In 2010 the state's Attorney General commissioned an independent review, which found that results in roughly two hundred criminal cases from 1987 to 2003 had been misstated or falsely reported; it identified 34 cases in which the analyst who had testified against Peterson had misreported results, withheld them or overstated the evidence in the prosecution's favor. The bureau fired him in January 2011.

On February 15, 2011, Peterson filed a motion for appropriate relief, raising claims under the federal Constitution on the ground of newly discovered evidence about the analyst. The trial judge heard testimony on it from December 6 through December 15, 2011. During that hearing a State Bureau of Investigation official testified that the analyst had issued reports in only 47 cases, far fewer than the roughly two hundred he had described to the jury.

On December 14, 2011, the trial judge granted the motion, vacated the conviction and ordered a new trial, finding that the analyst had misled the court and the jury about his expertise and the accuracy of his tests. Peterson was released that week on bond, to house arrest. He said he wanted the chance to "vindicate myself and prove my innocence in a fair trial this time."

In a written order on May 9, 2012, the judge found that the analyst had reached his conclusion before carrying out any tests and had exaggerated his qualifications, that the testimony had a material impact on the verdict, and that prosecutors had been obliged before the 2003 trial to disclose the analyst's bias and the scientific questions over his methods, a failure that violated Peterson's right to a fair trial.

The order's conclusions of law rested on the federal Constitution, under the disclosure duty set by Brady v. Maryland. The judge concluded that the analyst's testimony about his education, knowledge, training and experience, about his lack of bias, and about the scientific basis of his opinions and experiments had each been "materially misleading and deliberately false." The facts that would have exposed it lay in the files or the knowledge of the State Bureau of Investigation, an agency that took part in the investigation and prosecution. They were never given to the defense before or during the trial, and at no point in the trial did the state correct the testimony. Had he known, the judge found, he would have sustained the defense objection to the analyst testifying as an expert at all.

Because the analyst was the only witness for the state to draw a specific scientific connection between the death and Peterson, the judge found that his misrepresentations had a "substantial and injurious effect" on the outcome, and that there was a reasonable probability of a different result had the defense been given the material. Peterson, he concluded, "did not receive a fair trial," and the verdict was "not worthy of confidence." The order held the state responsible for what its agents failed to disclose whether or not the district attorney had known of it, and it made no finding that any prosecutor had failed to look into the analyst's competence or bias, because Peterson had not argued that point. Under the state's post-conviction statute and the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, the judge concluded that the conviction had been obtained in violation of the Constitution of the United States, and he ordered it vacated.

On July 16, 2013, a panel of the North Carolina Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed the order. It identified four misrepresentations, about the number of cases of his kind the analyst had worked on, the reports he had written, the times he had qualified as an expert and the times he had attended a potential crime scene of the kind at issue. Because the analyst had been the state's only witness on how the death came about, the court held that discrediting him would probably have undermined the state's whole theory, and that his testimony had played a determinative role in the outcome. On December 20, 2013, the Supreme Court of North Carolina declined to hear the case, and the order for a new trial was final.

Peterson stayed under house arrest in Durham until July 8, 2014, when the trial judge lifted the restrictions and ended the electronic monitoring. A retrial was set for May 8, 2017.

It never took place. On February 24, 2017, in Durham County Superior Court, Peterson entered an Alford plea to voluntary manslaughter in his wife's death, under an agreement with the district attorney's office that resolved every pending charge. The trial judge accepted the plea and sentenced him to 64 to 86 months in prison, with credit for the more than seven years he had already served. Because the time served exceeded the maximum, he was released the same day.

Outside the courtroom he called the plea "the most difficult thing I've done in my life" and said again that he had not killed his wife. He left the courthouse convicted not of murder but of voluntary manslaughter, still denying the act.

He stayed in North Carolina after his release. A French documentary series and a dramatized television series later brought the case to a wide audience. His 2017 conviction for voluntary manslaughter remains the final legal result.

Peterson has never admitted killing his wife. His Alford plea is a conviction for voluntary manslaughter, entered while he maintained his innocence; it is not an admission, and no murder conviction stands against him. The first-degree murder verdict of 2003 was vacated because of the testimony of the state's principal expert, which the trial court found deliberately false and the appellate courts found material and determinative; the Court of Appeals affirmed on the ground of newly discovered evidence about his qualifications.

The prosecution's account of motive, built on finances and on private correspondence, was disputed by the defense at trial; the correspondence was obtained under a warrant the state's highest court found lacking in probable cause. Peterson was never charged in the 1985 death in Germany, and its admission at his trial was one of the contested questions on appeal.

Timeline

1990: Peterson's Vietnam War novel A Time of War is published; its sequel, A Bitter Peace, follows in 1995.

December 9, 2001: Peterson's wife dies in Durham, North Carolina.

December 12, 2001: Investigators obtain a warrant to search the family's computers.

December 2001: A Durham County grand jury indicts Peterson for murder; he surrenders and is denied bond.

October 10, 2003: The jury convicts Peterson of first-degree murder; he is sentenced to life without parole.

September 19, 2006: The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirms, two votes to one.

November 9, 2007: The Supreme Court of North Carolina affirms the conviction.

January 2011: The State Bureau of Investigation fires the analyst who testified at the trial.

February 15, 2011: Peterson files a motion for appropriate relief.

December 6 to December 15, 2011: The trial judge hears testimony on the motion.

December 14, 2011: The trial judge vacates the conviction and orders a new trial; Peterson is released on bond to house arrest that week.

May 9, 2012: The judge issues his written order, concluding that the conviction was obtained in violation of the federal Constitution.

July 16, 2013: The Court of Appeals unanimously affirms the new-trial order.

December 20, 2013: The Supreme Court of North Carolina declines review.

July 8, 2014: House arrest and electronic monitoring are lifted.

February 24, 2017: Peterson enters an Alford plea to voluntary manslaughter, is sentenced to 64 to 86 months with credit for time served, and is released.