Michael McLendon

Victims
10 deaths in southeast Alabama, March 10, 2009; never tried. State investigators attributed the deaths, five of them his relatives, to him; he died by suicide the same day, uncharged
Years active
March 10, 2009
Location
Kinston (Coffee County); Samson and Geneva (Geneva County), Alabama
Method
Ten homicides attributed to him on one day in two counties; never charged
Status
Died by suicide on March 10, 2009; case never tried

On Tuesday, March 10, 2009, ten people died in the farm country of southeast Alabama, near the Florida line, in Kinston, in Coffee County, and in and around Samson, a town of about 2,000 people in neighboring Geneva County. Five of the dead were relatives of the man state investigators held responsible: his mother, his uncle, his grandmother, a cousin and the cousin's son. Two were a mother from Samson and her daughter, who had stopped by to visit. Three were people in Samson with no known connection to him at all. At least four other people were hurt and survived.

The man was Michael McLendon, 28, who lived with his mother outside Kinston. Before the day was over he was dead as well, by suicide, in the nearby town of Geneva. He was never arrested, never charged and never tried. The case against him rests on the investigation that followed, carried out by the Alabama Bureau of Investigation with the district attorneys of the two counties and the Coffee County coroner. It was the worst mass killing in Alabama's history to that time.

McLendon was a Samson boy. He grew up in the town, played Little League there and graduated from Samson High School, and as a young man he took jobs in the local factories, working beside people from town.

What investigators assembled in the week after his death was a short run of plans that did not hold. In 1999 he enlisted in the United States Marine Corps. About a month later he was discharged for fraudulent enlistment.

In 2003 he tried police work. The Samson Police Department took him on briefly, and he went to the state police academy. He lasted about a week and a half and dropped out before finishing the course.

The same year ended his time at Reliable Metal Products, a metals plant just north of Geneva, where he had worked since at least 2001. He resigned. He had no criminal record.

In July 2007 he went to work at Kelley Foods, a sausage maker in Elba. He stayed nearly two years, and on Wednesday, March 4, 2009, six days before the deaths, he quit of his own accord.

He was still living with his mother in a rural community near Kinston. Investigators later learned that in the days before March 10 he had told a confidant he was depressed and unfulfilled, and that he had spoken of failing to become either a Marine or a police officer. The person he confided in knew he was low but did not believe it would turn to violence.

The first death attributed to McLendon was his mother's. Lisa McLendon died in Kinston, in the home the two of them shared. Investigators could not fix the hour at which she died.

Five more people died at his uncle's home in Samson and the house next door. His uncle, James Alford White, was one. So was his cousin, Tracy Michelle Wise, and her son, who died with her. Next door lived his grandmother, Virginia E. White, and she died as well. One family in Samson lost four people in a single day: a grandmother, a son, a daughter and a grandson.

Two of those who died at his uncle's home were not family. Andrea D. Myers, a resident of Samson, had come by to visit with her two little girls. She died there, and so did her older daughter. Her younger daughter was hurt and survived.

Three more people died elsewhere in Samson: James Irvin Starling, Sonja Smith and Bruce Wilson Malloy. None of the three had any connection to McLendon that investigators ever found, and the deaths in town appeared to have come at random. Others were hurt that day, among them two law officers, and all of them survived. McLendon died by suicide in Geneva. Ten people were dead.

Because McLendon was dead before nightfall, there was no arrest, no interrogation and no prosecution. In place of a trial there was a state investigation led by the Alabama Bureau of Investigation, the investigative arm of the Alabama Department of Public Safety. It worked alongside the sheriff's offices of Coffee and Geneva counties, the Samson and Geneva police departments, and the district attorneys for both counties, each office answering for the deaths within its own lines.

Its first problem was plain from the start: no one knew what had set the day in motion, and the people best placed to explain it were among the dead. Within two days investigators had interviewed people who spoke to McLendon in the days before, and those interviews showed a man who was depressed. Investigators also recovered a handwritten letter he had left. They did not release a motive, and no statement of why was ever made public.

No court was ever asked to weigh the evidence. The findings of the district attorneys, the coroner and the bureau were never tested by a defense or decided by a jury, and so, although investigators attributed all ten deaths to him, McLendon stands in law as a man accused and never tried.

The motive was never established in public. Investigators pointed to depression and to a run of failed ambitions in the Marine Corps and in police work, but none of these threads was ever drawn together before a court. His responsibility for the ten deaths rests on the investigators' findings alone.

Timeline

1999: McLendon enlists in the U.S. Marine Corps and is discharged about a month later for fraudulent enlistment.

2001: He is working at Reliable Metal Products near Geneva.

2003: He is briefly employed by the Samson Police Department and spends about a week and a half at the state police academy without completing the course; the same year he resigns from Reliable Metal Products.

July 2007: He goes to work at Kelley Foods in Elba.

March 4, 2009: He quits Kelley Foods.

March 10, 2009: Ten people die in Kinston and Samson, among them his mother; McLendon dies by suicide in Geneva the same day.

March 12, 2009: Investigators say interviews show he had been depressed in the days before the deaths.