Michael Magidson and Jose Merel

Victims
1 murder: both convicted of second-degree murder of a transgender teenager, Newark, California, 2002; hate-crime allegations not found true.
Years active
October 4, 2002
Location
Newark, California (killing); Fremont, California (arraignment); Hayward, California (trials).
Method
Beaten and strangled (trial testimony and the coroner's finding as reported).
Status
Each sentenced to 15 years to life, January 27, 2006; affirmed May 2009. Merel granted parole October 2016. Magidson imprisoned in California as of October 2016.

Michael Magidson and Jose Merel were 22 years old in the fall of 2002, two young men from the East Bay city of Newark, California, whose circle of friends that year included a 17-year-old transgender girl from the same town. In the first hours of October 4, 2002, after the men learned that she was transgender, she was killed in Newark. Four men were charged. It took two trials in Hayward, two hung juries, two plea bargains and an appeal before the courts were done with the case, and when they were, Magidson and Merel stood convicted of second-degree murder. Each was sentenced to 15 years to life in state prison.

The case drew national attention for the argument at its center. The defense never seriously disputed that she died at the hands of the men in Newark. What it disputed was the degree of the crime: the defense told two juries that learning her gender identity had provoked the men into a rage the law should treat as manslaughter rather than murder. The state charged murder with hate-crime allegations. The first jury could not agree on any defendant. The second rejected the provocation argument and convicted Magidson and Merel of murder, but it did not find the hate-crime allegations true. In May 2009 a state appellate court unanimously upheld the convictions.

She had begun her transition in her early teens. In the late summer of that year she began spending time with a group of young men in town: Magidson, Merel, Jason Cazares and Jaron Nabors. Over the following weeks Magidson and Merel came to suspect that she was transgender. The suspicion came to a head in the first hours of October 4, and once the men confirmed it, she was killed. Trial testimony later placed Magidson and Merel at the center of the violence.

Newark police moved quickly. Within days officers had learned of a confrontation among the young men, and on October 9, 2002, they questioned Nabors, Magidson and Merel. Nabors became the first of the four to cooperate and went on to become the prosecution's chief witness. On October 18 Magidson, Merel and Nabors were arraigned in Fremont, and Cazares was arrested the following month.

The Alameda County District Attorney's Office charged the men with murder and added hate-crime allegations, which in this case could have added four years to a sentence. The state sought the most serious verdict available, first-degree murder. On February 24, 2003, Nabors pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and accepted an 11-year prison term as part of an agreement to testify. That left Magidson, Merel and Cazares to be tried together.

The first trial opened in the spring of 2004 in Alameda County Superior Court in Hayward, with Nabors as the state's central witness. Magidson's defense conceded that he had played a role in the killing and argued that it was manslaughter, committed in the heat of passion on learning her gender identity. Merel's defense argued that the jury had only Nabors's word for his involvement, and that even on that account the evidence supported no more than manslaughter. All three defense teams attacked Nabors's credibility, pointing to the conflicting statements he had first given police.

The jurors were told to take the verdicts in order of gravity: they could consider second-degree murder or manslaughter only after unanimously acquitting on first-degree murder. The stakes were plain in the penalties. First-degree murder carried 25 years to life, second-degree murder 15 years to life, voluntary manslaughter up to 11 years. After about nine days the panel still could not reach a verdict on any defendant. On the last ballot it stood 10 to 2 for acquitting Merel and Cazares of first-degree murder and 7 to 5 for convicting Magidson of it. On June 22, 2004, the trial judge declared a mistrial, and the state said it would try the three men again.

The retrial began in Hayward in the spring of 2005, and this time the defendants turned on one another. Merel, who had not testified the first time, took the stand in July 2005. He admitted taking part in the violence, said he had not wanted her to die, and placed the fatal acts on Magidson. Magidson also testified, and his defense again asked the jury to treat the killing as provoked.

The verdicts came on September 12, 2005. The jury found Magidson and Merel guilty of second-degree murder. It did not find the hate-crime allegations true against either man. By returning second-degree murder it had turned away both the provocation defense, which would have meant manslaughter, and the state's first-degree charge. The jury could not reach a verdict on Cazares, and the judge declared a mistrial on his count. In December 2005 Cazares pleaded no contest to voluntary manslaughter, and he was sentenced to six years.

Magidson and Merel were sentenced on January 27, 2006, in Alameda County Superior Court. Each received the mandatory term for second-degree murder, 15 years to life in state prison.

They appealed together to the California Court of Appeal for the First Appellate District, arguing again that they had been provoked when they learned she was transgender and that the convictions should be reduced to manslaughter. They also challenged the way the trial judge had defined the crimes for the jury. On May 13, 2009, a three-justice panel unanimously affirmed both second-degree murder convictions, holding that the jury had been properly instructed and that substantial evidence supported the verdicts. The sentences stood.

Both men came before the California Board of Parole Hearings in October 2016. A board panel granted Merel parole, a decision still subject to review by the board and the governor. At his own hearing that month Magidson stipulated that he was unsuitable for parole, which put off his next hearing for three years. As of October 2016 he remained in a California state prison.

Each man's share of the violence was contested at both trials, and the two juries read the evidence differently: the first leaned toward acquitting Merel of first-degree murder and toward convicting Magidson of it, while the second convicted both of second-degree murder. At the retrial Merel testified that his own part had not been fatal; the jury did not accept that account as a defense to murder.

The hate-crime allegations were never found true against any defendant. Reporting on the case has consistently tied the killing to the men's discovery that she was transgender, but the jury convicted Magidson and Merel on the murder charge alone.

Timeline

Late summer 2002: Magidson, Merel, Cazares and Nabors begin spending time with a 17-year-old transgender girl in Newark, California.

October 4, 2002: She is killed in Newark.

October 9, 2002: Newark police question Nabors, Magidson and Merel.

October 18, 2002: Magidson, Merel and Nabors are arraigned in Fremont.

February 24, 2003: Nabors pleads guilty to voluntary manslaughter, with an 11-year term.

Spring 2004: The first trial of Magidson, Merel and Cazares opens in Alameda County Superior Court, Hayward.

June 22, 2004: The jury deadlocks; the judge declares a mistrial.

July 2005: Merel testifies at the retrial.

September 12, 2005: Magidson and Merel are convicted of second-degree murder; the jury does not find the hate-crime allegations true.

December 2005: Cazares pleads no contest to voluntary manslaughter and is sentenced to six years.

January 27, 2006: Magidson and Merel are each sentenced to 15 years to life.

May 13, 2009: The First District Court of Appeal unanimously affirms both convictions.

October 2016: The Board of Parole Hearings grants Merel parole, subject to review; Magidson stipulates to unsuitability and a three-year denial.