Michael Lee Lockhart was sentenced to death in three states. In Texas a jury convicted him in October 1988 of the capital murder of Paul Douglas Hulsey Jr., a Beaumont police officer he shot in a motel room on March 22, 1988. In Indiana a Lake County jury convicted him of the murder of Windy Gallagher, a 16-year-old girl killed in her home in Griffith on October 13, 1987. In Florida he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murder of Jennifer Colhouer, a 14-year-old girl killed in her home in Land O' Lakes, north of Tampa, on January 20, 1988. Each court that reviewed those judgments affirmed them.
Texas had convicted him first, and Texas executed him by lethal injection on December 9, 1997. He was 37. In his last minutes he turned to members of his victims' families and told them he was deeply sorry. Shortly before he died he said that he did not think he could have stopped killing, and that he had been fortunate to be caught.
Associated Press reports from his 1988 trial describe Lockhart as a native of Toledo, Ohio, and the second youngest of 10 children of a couple from Walbridge, a small town just outside Toledo. His parents and several of his brothers and sisters traveled to San Antonio to testify for him at the punishment stage of the Texas trial.
One sister, then 25, told the jury that her brother had been a dreamer. His greatest wish, she said, was to become a New York City police officer, and he had also talked about becoming a firefighter, going to Hollywood or working as a comedian. His sisters said he had tried to keep up with his older brothers, who were more athletic, and that he always fell short; the brothers mocked him and called him a "sissy." His oldest sister, then 40, said she had often warned him not to be too hopeful about what he could do, because he "set his goals too high." In her view he wanted to prove to the family that he could do things they did not believe he could.
Family members testified that he grew up in a violent home, and they asked the jury to spare his life. A defense psychologist who had spent about 20 hours interviewing him, and who had also interviewed his parents and three of his sisters and read his medical, prison and school records, testified that he had been sexually abused as a child and suffered from anxiety and other problems as a result. She also told the court that his anger toward women was "totally out of control."
By the time he was in his twenties Lockhart had a prison record. The prosecutor in the Texas trial told jurors that he had served time in the Wyoming penitentiary on burglary charges and had learned there to stay calm while committing crimes. The Florida Supreme Court later listed a Wyoming robbery among his prior convictions. In 1989 he told a Florida jury that he had a daughter who was then 7 years old.
The first crimes in the court record came in Chicago. On Monday, October 12, 1987, Lockhart attacked and robbed a woman who was walking in her neighborhood on the north side of Chicago. She later identified him.
The next day, October 13, Windy Gallagher was at home in Griffith, a town in Lake County in northwest Indiana. She was 16. She was found dead that day. She had been stabbed. There were no signs that anyone had forced a way in.
Several things were missing from the apartment: a photograph of Windy, her grey clutch purse and a pocket calendar with her name on it. The Indiana courts later held that evidence of the Chicago robbery the day before was properly admitted to help show who had killed her. Investigators also lifted fingerprints from a water glass and a palm print at the scene, which a fingerprint expert testified were Lockhart's.
Lockhart left his blue Toyota at a motel in Toledo, where staff identified him. A witness in Chicago told investigators that Lockhart later turned up driving a red Corvette.
In early November 1987 Lockhart pulled a gun on a car salesman in Toledo, took his wallet, pushed him out of the car and drove away, according to the Indiana opinion, which dates the robbery to November 9, 1987, in its account of the penalty evidence. The Indiana trial heard about it as part of his criminal history. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, describing the evidence heard by the Texas jury, also listed a sexual assault on an adult woman, who survived, among the other offenses proved against him in that period.
Jennifer Colhouer was 14 and lived with her family in Land O' Lakes, in Pasco County, Florida, about 20 miles north of Tampa. On January 20, 1988, she was found dead. She had been stabbed.
The Florida Supreme Court found no evidence that anyone had forced a way into the house, and it inferred that Lockhart had persuaded Jennifer to let him in. The weapon was a knife from the family's kitchen. Reviewing the case in 1995, the court said the killing "was not something that occurred on the spur of the moment" and that Lockhart had intended what he did when he entered the house.
When Indiana later tried him for Windy Gallagher's death, prosecutors there offered the Florida killing as evidence. DNA testing linked Lockhart to the Florida case, and the Indiana Supreme Court treated the two crimes as so alike that the Florida killing could be admitted as a "signature crime" to show who had killed Windy.
Before he reached Beaumont, Lockhart robbed a bank in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, according to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. He also committed a burglary in which he obtained the gun he later used in Beaumont. An Associated Press report from October 1988 said he was also accused of a robbery in New Orleans earlier that year.
By March 1988 he was driving a red Corvette that had been reported stolen. It carried a Florida license plate, and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals records that the plate itself was stolen.
Paul Douglas Hulsey Jr. was a patrolman with the Beaumont Police Department. Associated Press reports from the 1988 trial gave his age as 29 and said he had been with the department for eight years; later local reports give his age as 30. He had graduated from Little Cypress-Mauriceville High School, in Orange County, Texas, and his father was a former police chief. He was married, and his wife and parents were in court when the man who killed him was sentenced.
On March 22, 1988, Hulsey saw the red Corvette with the Florida plate in an area of Beaumont that the Texas courts describe as a high-crime area. A local drug dealer was in the passenger seat. When Lockhart saw the officer he sped off, running stop signs, and Hulsey's pursuit failed.
Later that evening Hulsey found the Corvette in a motel parking lot. According to a 2015 Port Arthur News account, he ran the tags and learned the car was stolen, the manager told him which room the driver was in, and he asked for backup, but the backup unit was sent instead to a fatal crash involving a pedestrian. He went to the room alone to make the arrest. He did not know that the driver was wanted for the killings of two girls in Indiana and Florida.
What happened in the room comes mostly from Lockhart's own statement to police, as the federal appeals court later summarized it. He had planned, he said, to reach his gun and "get the drop" on the officer. The two men struggled, and Lockhart shot Hulsey. He then took the officer's keys and money and left the room. At the trial Lockhart claimed self-defense, saying that Hulsey had asked for identification and that the gun had gone off in the struggle before he fired the fatal shots.
An investigating officer testified at the trial that, after being warned of his rights, Lockhart chuckled and said he would never forget the look in Hulsey's eyes as the officer begged him not to shoot him any more. Police also found a 1988 datebook in the motel room, which a witness said belonged to Lockhart; the Texas courts later held that it had been properly admitted as evidence.
About 30 minutes after the shooting, officers in neighboring Orange County were chasing the Corvette, according to a 2018 account by KOGT, the Orange radio station. The car crashed, and Lockhart, then 28 by that account, ran from the wreck on foot and hid in woods. He persuaded a young man in Orange to drive him to Beaumont for $50, and in Beaumont he paid a cab driver $100 to take him toward Houston. Beaumont police stopped the cab near the Old and Lost rivers. "I'm the one you want," he told them, by KOGT's account. "I'm the one you're looking for."
The Port Arthur News later wrote that the investigation of Hulsey's death led officers to capture Lockhart the same evening.
A Jefferson County grand jury indicted Lockhart for the capital murder of a peace officer. Because of the heavy publicity in Beaumont, the case was moved to Bexar County, on an agreed motion, and tried in San Antonio before a jury. The prosecutor was Tom Maness, the Jefferson County district attorney. Lockhart was defended by Charles Carver, a lawyer from Port Arthur.
Jury selection was about to begin on August 18, 1988, when Lockhart made a break for it. Returning from lunch, without handcuffs, he ran for a window of the third-floor courtroom and dove through it. He landed on a roof about 15 feet below and was caught soon afterward. He was taken to a hospital with injuries that included an injury to his pelvis, and he was returned for trial.
The escape attempt shaped the rest of the trial. The court kept him in visible restraints in front of the jury, after hearing testimony that he had threatened to make trouble for the deputies who took him to and from court; at an earlier hearing he had stood up, yelled obscenities and fought the officers' efforts to control him. During jury selection he left the courtroom at his own insistent request. The state courts found he was physically able to stay and had chosen to give up his right to be present.
While he was recovering in the hospital, according to the Indiana Supreme Court, Lockhart volunteered a statement that he had killed between 20 and 30 people.
Lockhart testified in his own defense and told the jury that Hulsey had provoked the confrontation that led to his death. Carver argued that the officer had been too eager to make an arrest, had not followed police procedure, and that his client had only been protecting himself; he also said police and prosecutors had not put before the jury all the evidence that might have cleared Lockhart. Maness told jurors that it was Lockhart who had provoked Hulsey, who was tracking the driver from the earlier chase, and that Lockhart had no regard for any life except his own. Believing him, the prosecutor said, would amount to approving the killing of a police officer.
On October 4, 1988, the jury of eight women and four men deliberated for less than two hours and found Lockhart guilty of capital murder. He sat without moving as the verdict was read. "I'm absolutely pleased," Maness told reporters, crediting a large investigation by many law enforcement agencies.
At the punishment stage the jury heard about the crimes in other states, including the two killings of teenage girls in Indiana and Florida, the sexual assault on a woman and the Baton Rouge bank robbery. Defense witnesses, including his family and the psychologist, described his childhood.
Under the Texas law of the time, the jurors had to decide whether Lockhart had killed deliberately, whether he would be a continuing threat to society, and whether his response to any provocation by the officer had been unreasonable. A "no" on any one of those questions would have meant a life sentence. After about two hours the jury answered yes to all three, and he was sentenced to death by lethal injection. Lockhart showed no emotion. Hulsey's widow and parents embraced when the sentence was read.
His father said that his son's own investigation had led to his death and that the jury had finished the job. His widow said the sentence was deserved, but that the prick of a needle was far less painful than the death her husband had suffered. Lockhart was handcuffed, shackled, put in a wheelchair and taken out of the courtroom. Carver said his client was not surprised and that the case would be appealed. Jefferson County prosecutors said they planned to work with the other states on their cases against him.
Indiana charged Lockhart with the murder of Windy Gallagher and added a death penalty count. The state alleged two aggravating circumstances: that he killed her while committing a robbery, and that he had been convicted of another murder, the Texas killing of Officer Hulsey.
A Lake County jury convicted him of murder. The trial court found both aggravating circumstances and no mitigating circumstances, and it sentenced him to death. The Indiana Public Defender Council's records list 1989 as the year he was sentenced to death in Indiana.
The prosecution's case rested on the fingerprints and palm print found at the scene, the missing items traced to the Chicago robbery, the identifications in Chicago and at the Toledo motel, and the Florida killing. Testing by Cellmark Laboratories matched DNA evidence to a sample of Lockhart's blood. The defense attacked the reliability of that testing, but the trial court admitted it, and the Indiana Supreme Court held that the challenge went to how much weight the jury should give the evidence, not to whether it could be heard.
The Indiana Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and the death sentence on March 8, 1993, in an opinion by Chief Justice Shepard. The court held that the Chicago robbery was properly admitted to show identity, that the Florida killing was a "signature crime," and that a pathologist could compare two autopsy reports prepared by others. It found that the trial court had been wrong to read the jury the full list of possible aggravating circumstances, including one that did not apply, but held the error harmless.
Lockhart also argued that his Texas conviction could not count as an aggravating circumstance, because his Texas appeal had not been decided when he was sentenced in Indiana. The court disagreed. "Indiana has not chosen to require a conviction to be 'final' for admission in subsequent proceedings," it wrote. Justice DeBruler agreed that the conviction should stand but dissented on the sentence. In his view the evidence did not support the robbery aggravator, and the prior-murder aggravator required a conviction that had been affirmed on appeal; he would have ordered a new sentencing hearing or a 60-year prison term.
In Florida, Lockhart was charged with first-degree murder in Pasco County. The court appointed an assistant public defender, William Eble, to represent him. Eble asked to withdraw, and the judge refused. Lockhart then asked to represent himself, and the court allowed it, keeping Eble as advisory counsel. Against his lawyer's advice, Lockhart pleaded guilty to first-degree murder. A United Press International dispatch from Dade City, the county seat, gives the date of the plea as October 26 and says he was then 29.
He asked to be sentenced without a jury. Circuit Judge Maynard F. Swanson refused to impose a death sentence without a jury's recommendation, so a jury was seated for the penalty phase. Lockhart chose the jurors himself, dismissing eight candidates before a panel of five men and seven women was seated. "You're going to hear evidence that will make you sick," he told them. "I'm not going to stand before you and make excuses for myself."
He said he had given up his right to a trial to spare Jennifer's family more grief. "The one last thing I can do in this world is accept responsibility for what I've done," he told the jurors. He said that if his own daughter were killed as Jennifer had been, he would want her killer punished. He told them that 36,000 people were in prison for murder and 2,000 were on death row. "They get to live, I get to die," he said.
The Pasco County detective on the case, Fay Wilber, presented the evidence, including photographs of Jennifer and of Windy Gallagher. Jennifer's parents, sitting in the courtroom, signaled to a prosecutor to keep the photographs out of the view of the people in the gallery. Lockhart called no witnesses of his own. At the start of the penalty phase Eble withdrew, and Lockhart represented himself to the end.
The jury unanimously recommended death, and the judge sentenced him to death. The judge found four aggravating circumstances and no mitigating ones. The aggravating circumstances were his prior convictions for violent felonies, including the Texas and Indiana murders and the Wyoming robbery; that the killing was committed during another felony; that it met Florida's statutory aggravating circumstance for an especially cruel killing; and that it was cold, calculated and premeditated.
The Florida Supreme Court decided Lockhart's appeal on March 16, 1995, in an unsigned opinion joined by all seven justices. He raised 12 issues. The court held that his guilty plea was valid ("we find that he understood the nature of the charges against him"), that he had knowingly given up his right to a lawyer before the penalty phase, and that the trial court had properly admitted the evidence of the Indiana killing, including eight photographs.
The court did find one error. In his sentencing order the judge had relied on interviews Lockhart gave to newspaper reporters, which were not part of the court record. The justices held that the error was harmless, because three other aggravating circumstances remained and there was no mitigation, and that it "did not injuriously affect Lockhart's substantial rights." They declined to require the appointment of independent counsel for a defendant who chooses not to present mitigating evidence. "Accordingly, we affirm the conviction and death sentence imposed on Lockhart," the court concluded. It denied rehearing on June 1, 1995.
Lockhart's direct appeal in Texas raised 22 points of error. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed his conviction and death sentence on December 2, 1992, in an opinion by Judge Maloney. It held that the stolen car, the stolen license plate and the attempted drug deal that preceded the chase were properly admitted as part of the context of the crime. Evidence of the Baton Rouge bank robbery and of the burglary in which he got the gun should not have been admitted at the guilt stage, the court said, but the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt because Lockhart admitted the killing. The court also held that the evidence did not support a self-defense instruction. Judge Clinton dissented, arguing that the other-offense evidence should have been kept out. Rehearing was denied on February 24, 1993, and the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case on October 4, 1993.
An execution date was set for November 23, 1993. On November 17, six days before it, Lockhart filed a motion on his own behalf asking for a stay so that the Texas Resource Center could find him a lawyer for a habeas corpus petition. The convicting court, the 186th District Court of Bexar County under Judge Larry Gist, denied the request on November 22, finding that no colorable habeas claim had been raised and that Lockhart and the center had deliberately manipulated access to habeas corpus review. The same day the Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that it had no power to grant the stay. Presiding Judge McCormick concurred. Judge Clinton dissented, writing that Lockhart was without a lawyer and that Texas had reached "the crisis stage in capital representation"; Judge Overstreet also dissented.
In November 1993 Lockhart filed a motion on his own behalf in the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas. That court stayed his execution and appointed a lawyer, who filed a petition for habeas corpus raising 15 claims. In July 1996 the district court denied relief. A new execution date was set for September 10, 1996, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit stayed it while the appeal went forward.
On appeal Lockhart pressed three claims: that he should not have been kept in visible restraints in front of the jury, that he should not have been allowed to leave the courtroom during jury selection, and that his trial lawyer had a conflict of interest, because the lawyer or his firm was representing the trial judge in an unrelated civil case at the time. In an opinion by Judge Davis, dated January 9, 1997, the Fifth Circuit rejected all three. On the restraints, the court pointed to the escape attempt, his threats against the deputies and his conduct at the pretrial hearing. On his absence, it said he could point to no Supreme Court decision barring a defendant from giving up his presence during jury selection. On the conflict claim, it held that he had not shown how the conflict affected anything his lawyer did or failed to do. The court refused to let the appeal go forward and lifted the stay of execution.
Texas executed Michael Lee Lockhart by lethal injection on the night of Tuesday, December 9, 1997. He was 37. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice lists his as execution number 144, and the Death Penalty Information Center lists him as number 430 among executions in the United States since 1976. The Deseret News reported that he was the 37th prisoner executed in Texas that year, extending a state record. He still faced death sentences in Indiana and Florida, but Texas had convicted him first.
In the death chamber he acknowledged all three killings. He turned toward five members of his victims' families, who were watching a few feet away, and said, "I am deeply sorry." He added, "It is my hope my death will give you some kind of comfort." His last statement, as the Texas Department of Criminal Justice recorded it, was addressed to the prison staff. "A lot of people view what is happening here as evil, but I want you to know that I found love and compassion here," he said, and he thanked them for the kindness they had shown him. He ended, "That's all, Warden, I'm ready."
Shortly before his execution he said, "I don't think I could have stopped." He said he "was fortunate to get caught."
Nearly 100 Beaumont police officers attended, and they responded with applause and cheers. "We're not here to celebrate an execution, but to pay respect to the victims and the families of the victims," said Detective Jimmy Carpenter. Officer Hulsey's father was blunter. "It's thumbs-up all the way," he said. "Forgiveness is not in my vocabulary."
Paul Hulsey Jr.'s name is on the Texas Peace Officers' Memorial, which records that he died by gunfire on March 22, 1988. When a Discovery Channel program featured his case in 2015, the department said in a statement that it still felt the sacrifice he had made.
In 2018 KOGT recalled the night the Corvette came through Orange and the people who joined the search, and noted that a book about Lockhart, "A Perfect Gentleman" by Jaye Slade Fletcher, had been published in 1997. The daughter of a local constable told the station that the real heroes were Paul Hulsey Jr. and every officer who holds the line every day.
Lockhart was tried for three killings, and at his execution he acknowledged those three. His larger claims are a different matter. While in the hospital after his August 1988 escape attempt, he volunteered that he had killed between 20 and 30 people, according to the Indiana Supreme Court. KOGT later recalled that he had bragged of killing two dozen girls. The larger figures rest on his own statements; he was convicted of three killings.
Some details of the Beaumont shooting also differ between accounts. The Texas courts describe Hulsey first seeing the Corvette in traffic and losing it in a chase, while later local reports say he was investigating a car with stolen license plates when he found it in the motel lot. The two accounts are not exclusive, and both agree that the officer went to the room to arrest him.
Accounts of his early criminal history differ. The Texas prosecutor said Lockhart had served time in Wyoming for burglary, while the Florida Supreme Court lists a Wyoming robbery among his convictions. An Associated Press report from 1988 said he was accused of a robbery in New Orleans, and a 2015 Port Arthur News account said Indiana wanted him for a bank robbery; the Texas courts name a bank robbery in Baton Rouge.
October 12, 1987: Lockhart attacks and robs a woman in Chicago.
October 13, 1987: Windy Gallagher, 16, is killed in her home in Griffith, Indiana.
November 9, 1987: Lockhart robs a car salesman at gunpoint in Toledo, Ohio, and drives off.
January 20, 1988: Jennifer Colhouer, 14, is killed in her home in Land O' Lakes, Florida.
Before March 22, 1988: a bank robbery in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and a burglary in which he gets a gun.
March 22, 1988: Officer Paul Hulsey Jr. is shot and killed in a Beaumont, Texas, motel room; Lockhart is caught that evening after a chase in Orange County.
August 18, 1988: As jury selection is about to begin in San Antonio, he dives through a third-floor courtroom window and is recaptured.
October 4, 1988: A Bexar County jury convicts him of capital murder.
October 1988: The jury's answers to the special issues lead to a death sentence.
1989: Sentenced to death in Indiana for the murder of Windy Gallagher.
October 26 (year unreported): Pleads guilty in Pasco County, Florida, to the first-degree murder of Jennifer Colhouer; a penalty jury later unanimously recommends death and the judge imposes it.
December 2, 1992: Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the Texas conviction and sentence.
March 8, 1993: Indiana Supreme Court affirms the Indiana conviction and sentence.
October 4, 1993: United States Supreme Court declines to review the Texas case.
November 22, 1993: Texas courts refuse a stay; a federal court then stays the November 23 execution date.
March 16, 1995: Florida Supreme Court affirms the Florida conviction and sentence.
July 1996: Federal district court denies habeas relief.
January 9, 1997: Fifth Circuit denies further appeal and lifts the stay.
December 9, 1997: Executed by lethal injection in Texas, aged 37.