Michael Dale St. Clair was a convicted murderer awaiting sentence in an Oklahoma jail when he broke out in September 1991. By the time he was caught again, two more men were dead. Timothy Keeling, 22, had been taken in Colorado and shot in New Mexico, and Frank Brady, a distillery worker from Bardstown, Kentucky, had been taken in Hardin County and shot in neighboring Bullitt County. In both cases the men's pickup trucks were stolen.
In Kentucky, St. Clair was tried for Brady's murder in Bullitt County and, separately, for his kidnapping in Hardin County. In a series of rulings from 1999 to 2015 the Kentucky Supreme Court reversed two death sentences in the murder case and two convictions in the kidnapping case, overruled one of its own precedents in an early ruling in his case, and finally upheld a third death sentence for the murder in 2014. In 2017 he pleaded guilty in the kidnapping case. By then he had been convicted of four murders in Oklahoma and one in New Mexico as well.
The Kentucky Supreme Court's opinions give the Oklahoma background. In September 1991, Oklahoma juries had found St. Clair guilty of two murders: those of his uncle, Ronnie St. Clair, and of William Henry Kelsey Jr. The verdict in the Kelsey case was returned in Murray County. Judgment on both convictions was not formally entered until November 22, 1991, about six weeks after Brady's death, and that gap later mattered a great deal in Kentucky.
Evidence about the Oklahoma killings was put before the Bullitt County jury that resentenced St. Clair in 2011, and the court's 2014 opinion summarizes it. According to that summary, his uncle had witnessed two of the other killings, which the court described as giving St. Clair a motive, and the uncle and St. Clair had each sought to have the other killed.
The two other killings were those of Mary Louise Smith and Edward Jefferson Large. St. Clair was not tried for them until 1994, and he was convicted. In a footnote to its 2015 opinion, the Kentucky Supreme Court wrote that he had been convicted of all four murders by the time of his 1998 Kentucky trial and had been given consecutive life sentences for them. A federal judge in 2015 described the Oklahoma judgments of 1991 and 1994 as producing what appeared to be four sentences of life without parole.
At his 2011 resentencing, St. Clair admitted the four Oklahoma killings on cross-examination, the Kentucky Supreme Court recorded. He claimed the men he had killed deserved to die, said that killing people was like killing dogs, and boasted of bribing jailers.
In September 1991, while he was awaiting final sentencing on the first two murder convictions, St. Clair escaped from the jail at Durant, Oklahoma, with another inmate, Dennis Gene Reese. According to the court's 2005 opinion, the two men fled in a pickup stolen from a jail employee. They then stole another pickup and other property in a burglary and headed toward Dallas. St. Clair's wife at the time met them in Texas and gave them money, clothing and other items, the court said.
At his later trials, St. Clair testified that he and Reese split up in Texas. Reese testified that they stayed together and went on to Colorado.
Timothy Keeling was 22 when he was killed. The Associated Press reported that he was kidnapped near Denver. In the account Reese gave the Kentucky courts, the two escapees abducted Keeling in Colorado and took his pickup, then drove south through New Mexico, and before they reached Texas one of them shot Keeling to death. Each man blamed the other for the killing.
Keeling's widow testified in Kentucky about his life and their life together, both at the 2011 resentencing in Bullitt County and at the 2012 kidnapping trial in Hardin County. In each case the Kentucky Supreme Court later held that her testimony should not have been admitted, because Keeling was not the victim of the crime on trial there. A New Mexico State Police trooper who had investigated Keeling's death also testified in Kentucky.
Kentucky courts had no jurisdiction over Keeling's death, the Kentucky Supreme Court noted. In New Mexico, according to St. Clair's own appeal brief as quoted by the court, he was indicted for Keeling's murder, with other charges, in April 2012. The Kentucky attorney general's office reported in 2017 that he had been convicted of second-degree murder in New Mexico in 2014 in the death of a man kidnapped in Denver and shot in New Mexico during the two men's trip back toward Texas.
From New Mexico the two men drove Keeling's truck through Louisiana, Arkansas and Tennessee, the Kentucky Supreme Court said, and in October 1991 they reached southern Hardin County, Kentucky. There Francis "Frank" Brady was abducted and his pickup was taken.
Brady lived in Bardstown, in Nelson County, and worked at a distillery. Little else about his life has been made public, but his widow became a constant presence in the case: according to the Kentucky attorney general's office, she attended every one of St. Clair's trials over the following decades.
Brady was taken into Bullitt County and shot to death near Lebanon Junction. Reese testified that St. Clair kidnapped and killed him. St. Clair, at his later trials, told a different story: he testified that Reese alone had approached Brady and had later come back alone with the truck.
The two men then returned to Hardin County, where Keeling's pickup was set on fire. People who saw Brady's truck near the fire described it to the Kentucky State Police.
Kentucky State Police Trooper Herbert "Butch" Bennett spotted a truck matching the description in Hardin County and pulled it over. It was Brady's truck, and both men were in it. St. Clair fired at the trooper, and the two men escaped after a chase.
St. Clair later testified that he had fired at the trooper because he was facing a sentence of life without parole. The Kentucky Supreme Court held in 2015 that this earlier testimony, and the references to his Oklahoma sentences that went with it, could be used at the kidnapping trial to show his motive for shooting at the trooper.
The two men separated after the chase. Reese was arrested in Las Vegas, Nevada, about two weeks later and waived extradition. St. Clair was arrested about two months after Brady's death in Hugo, Oklahoma. At the 2012 kidnapping trial, Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation Agent Perry Unruh testified that police believed close friends who had sheltered St. Clair after his return to Oklahoma could be in danger; the trial judge struck the remark and told the jury to disregard it, and the Kentucky Supreme Court later held that the remark was inadmissible but that the admonition was enough.
Reese pleaded guilty and agreed to testify for the Commonwealth. The court's opinions do not give his sentence.
On December 20, 1991, St. Clair was indicted in Hardin County for receiving stolen property, attempted murder and second-degree arson. On January 17, 1992, a Hardin County grand jury indicted him for the capital kidnapping of Brady. In February 1992 a Bullitt County grand jury indicted him, with Reese, for Brady's capital murder.
In 1995, under a governor-to-governor executive agreement, Oklahoma released him to Kentucky for trial on the pending charges, according to a 2015 federal court order.
The prosecution at first obtained an order, without notice to the defense, moving the Hardin County charges to Bullitt Circuit Court so that they could be tried together. St. Clair moved to sever them and send them back to Hardin County, and the motion was granted. The two cases ran on separate tracks from then on. On June 19, 1998, the Commonwealth filed notice that it would seek the death penalty in the kidnapping case.
The Bullitt County murder case was tried first, in 1998. Reese testified for the Commonwealth. St. Clair testified and claimed an alibi, telling the jury among other things that he had never been in Kentucky; the Kentucky Supreme Court later noted that several details of that account were proven false. The jury convicted him of Brady's murder and recommended death, and the judge imposed that sentence.
The evidence included comparative bullet lead analysis, then offered by the FBI, which compared trace elements in bullet lead. Testimony from an FBI agent described bullets from the Keeling and Brady killings as very close in composition. The method was later shown to be unreliable and was abandoned by the FBI, and in 2009 the bureau sent a letter saying the testimony in St. Clair's case had been inappropriate. St. Clair sought a new trial on that basis in July 2010; the circuit court denied the motion in January 2011, and the Kentucky Supreme Court upheld the denial in 2014, finding that the bullet evidence was a small part of the proof of guilt.
While the murder conviction was on appeal, St. Clair asked the Kentucky Supreme Court to stop Hardin Circuit Judge Hugh W. Roark from trying him for capital kidnapping, arguing that a death sentence for the kidnapping, on top of the death sentence for the murder, would punish him twice for the same killing. The court refused in an opinion by Justice Cooper decided November 18, 1999, in St. Clair v. Roark. It overruled its 1989 decision in Cosby v. Commonwealth, which had barred two death sentences for the murder and capital kidnapping of the same victim, holding that it is the victim's death, not a murder conviction, that raises kidnapping to a capital offense. Justice Stumbo dissented, arguing that the questions were not yet ripe.
In 2004 the Kentucky Supreme Court affirmed St. Clair's murder conviction but reversed his death sentence and ordered a new penalty trial. The main reason was that the trial judge had not told the jury that life without parole was among the sentences it could choose. The court also directed that, at the new hearing, the jury be instructed on the prior-murder aggravating circumstance in the words of the statute.
A new penalty trial was held in August 2005, and in September 2005 St. Clair was again sentenced to death. On April 22, 2010, in an opinion by Chief Justice Minton, the Kentucky Supreme Court reversed that sentence too.
The problem lay with the Oklahoma convictions. Kentucky law allows a death sentence when the defendant had a prior conviction for a capital offense at the time of the crime. The jury had been asked only whether St. Clair had "a prior record of conviction of murder," which allowed it to rely on any of the Oklahoma convictions. The September 1991 verdicts for the murders of his uncle and Kelsey came before Brady's death and qualified; the court treated the jury verdict as enough even though formal judgment came only in November. The 1994 convictions for the murders of Smith and Large came after Brady's death and could not qualify. Because the jury might have relied on either set, the court could not be sure that its finding was unanimous, and it held that such an error, when properly raised, could not be excused as harmless. It ordered that any new instruction name the specific qualifying conviction, such as the September 1991 Murray County conviction for Kelsey's murder.
Justices Scott and Cunningham each concurred in part and dissented in part, arguing that the error was harmless. The court also rejected several other claims for the guidance of the trial court, holding among other things that a 1995 executive agreement between the two states did not have to be shown to the jury as mitigation, since it did not guarantee how long or where he would be imprisoned. The court denied rehearing and issued a modified opinion on September 23, 2010.
The Hardin County kidnapping case came to trial in 2001 before Judge Janet Coleman. St. Clair was convicted of capital kidnapping, two counts of receiving stolen property, attempted murder and second-degree arson, and was sentenced to death for the kidnapping; he waived jury sentencing on the other counts and accepted a total of 50 years for them.
On October 20, 2005, in an opinion by Chief Justice Lambert, the Kentucky Supreme Court reversed those convictions. The decisive issue was marital privilege. St. Clair's wife at the time of the escape had testified about statements he made to her, and the court held that at least two of them were confidential spousal communications that should have been excluded, and that the error was prejudicial because her testimony was crucial. The court ordered a hearing on two other statements and gave directions for a retrial: the jury had to be told that a death sentence for kidnapping required a finding that St. Clair murdered Brady during the kidnapping; the September 1991 Oklahoma murder convictions should be treated as final before the kidnapping; testimony about people who pressured a witness, a transcript of an Oklahoma preliminary hearing and statements attributed to Brady were to be excluded. Justice Wintersheimer, joined by Justices Graves and Scott, dissented on the privilege question, and Justice Cooper dissented on the use of the Oklahoma convictions as an aggravating circumstance.
In 2008 the court refused to bar a retrial. The second kidnapping trial, before Judge Stephen Ryan in 2009, ended in a mistrial when the prosecutor's opening statement referred indirectly to Keeling's killing, which earlier rulings had excluded. St. Clair argued that the prosecutor had provoked the mistrial and that a new trial was barred by double jeopardy; the trial court found no intent to provoke it, and the Kentucky Supreme Court later agreed.
The third kidnapping trial took place in 2012 before Judge Thomas Castlen. This time the court admitted evidence about Keeling's abduction and death. The jury convicted St. Clair on every count except arson, on which it returned the lesser offense of criminal facilitation to second-degree arson. It found three aggravating circumstances and recommended death for the kidnapping, with 20 years for attempted murder and five years for each of the other three counts, 35 years in all, to run consecutively. The judge imposed those sentences.
On February 19, 2015, in an opinion by Justice Noble for a unanimous court, the Kentucky Supreme Court reversed again. It held that evidence of how Keeling was abducted was properly admitted, because it showed a distinctive method relevant to identity, but that evidence of Keeling's murder was not: its value rested on a chain of inferences drawn from Reese's uncorroborated account, and it was outweighed by unfair prejudice. The testimony of Keeling's widow about his life was also irrelevant there. Taken together, the court said, the errors were not harmless. It also held that the death of the victim during a kidnapping could not by itself serve as the aggravating circumstance that supports a death sentence. The court rejected St. Clair's double jeopardy claim and upheld the exclusion of evidence about a separate killing he attributed to Reese.
Meanwhile the Bullitt County murder case went back for a third penalty trial, before Judge Geoffrey P. Morris, in October 2011. The trial lasted nine days, four of them spent choosing a jury from a pool of about 80. Part of the earlier trial testimony was presented in summaries. St. Clair pursued what the court called a truth-telling strategy, volunteering details of the Oklahoma killings. He denied any part in the deaths of Keeling and Brady.
The jury deliberated for a little over two hours, according to the Kentucky Supreme Court; WAVE News reported three hours. It returned a verdict of death, finding that St. Clair had a prior conviction for a capital offense, and the court sentenced him accordingly.
On August 21, 2014, in an opinion by Justice Noble, the Kentucky Supreme Court affirmed. St. Clair had raised 32 claims. The court held that the widow's testimony about Keeling should not have been admitted at a resentencing for Brady's murder, but that the error, about twelve minutes of testimony, was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. It found no reversible error in the remaining claims, including the jury-selection method, which defense counsel had agreed to, and the evidence of the Oklahoma killings, most of which St. Clair had volunteered himself. "That the strategy was ineffective does not matter," the court wrote. It concluded that the death sentence had been legally imposed.
The Associated Press, reporting the ruling, described St. Clair as a man with six murder convictions.
Representing himself from death row at the Kentucky State Penitentiary in Eddyville, St. Clair also sued the Kentucky corrections commissioner in federal court. He argued that because Kentucky had sentenced him to death, all of his Oklahoma sentences should be declared satisfied under the agreement between the two states. On April 2, 2015, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky dismissed the suit without prejudice as premature, because neither Kentucky case was yet final: the kidnapping conviction had just been reversed, and the affirmed murder judgment could still be taken to the U.S. Supreme Court.
A fourth trial on the kidnapping was set for May 8, 2017. Instead, on April 12, 2017, St. Clair, then 60, pleaded guilty in Hardin Circuit Court before Special Judge John David Seay under an agreement with the attorney general's Office of Special Prosecutions. He was sentenced to 30 years for kidnapping Brady, 20 years for the attempted murder of Trooper Bennett, and five years each on two counts of receiving stolen property and one of facilitation to second-degree arson.
Brady's widow could not attend the plea hearing, the attorney general's office said, but prosecutors and its victims' advocates had consulted her before the agreement was signed. Attorney General Andy Beshear said the office had worked on the case for several years for the sake of Brady's family. After the hearing, St. Clair was returned to death row at the Kentucky State Penitentiary in Eddyville.
Who killed Timothy Keeling has been disputed in court testimony. Reese described both abductions; St. Clair said the two men split up in Texas and, later, that Reese had taken Brady alone. The Kentucky Supreme Court noted that the prosecution's account of Keeling's death rested entirely on Reese. The Kentucky attorney general's office reported that St. Clair was convicted of second-degree murder in New Mexico in 2014; whether that case ended in a plea or a verdict has not been reported.
St. Clair's own accounts changed. In 1998 he claimed an alibi and said he had never been in Kentucky; at the 2012 kidnapping trial he testified that Reese alone had taken Brady and the truck.
Accounts of his custody at the time of the escape differ. The Kentucky Supreme Court said he was in jail awaiting sentencing for two murders, while a 2014 Associated Press report said he escaped from a prison where he was serving four life sentences. The second pair of Oklahoma murder convictions came only in 1994.
The bullet lead analysis used at the 1998 trial was later discredited, though the Kentucky courts held that it did not affect the outcome.
September 1991: Oklahoma juries find St. Clair guilty of the murders of his uncle, Ronnie St. Clair, and of William Henry Kelsey Jr. (the Kelsey verdict in Murray County).
September 1991: awaiting sentence, he escapes from the jail at Durant, Oklahoma, with Dennis Gene Reese.
1991: Timothy Keeling, 22, is abducted in Colorado and shot in New Mexico.
October 1991: Frank Brady of Bardstown is abducted in Hardin County, Kentucky, and shot in Bullitt County; Keeling's truck is burned; Trooper Herbert Bennett stops Brady's truck and is fired on.
About two weeks later: Reese is arrested in Las Vegas.
November 22, 1991: judgments entered on the two Oklahoma murder convictions.
About two months after Brady's death: St. Clair is arrested at Hugo, Oklahoma.
December 20, 1991: Hardin County indictment for receiving stolen property, attempted murder and arson.
January 17, 1992: Hardin County indictment for capital kidnapping.
February 1992: Bullitt County indictment for capital murder.
1994: convicted in Oklahoma of the murders of Mary Louise Smith and Edward Jefferson Large.
1995: Oklahoma releases him to Kentucky under an executive agreement.
June 19, 1998: notice of intent to seek death in the kidnapping case.
1998: Bullitt County jury convicts him of Brady's murder; death sentence.
November 18, 1999: St. Clair v. Roark; the Kentucky Supreme Court allows a capital kidnapping prosecution and overrules Cosby.
2001: Hardin County conviction for capital kidnapping and other counts; death sentence.
August 23, 2004: murder conviction affirmed, death sentence reversed.
August to September 2005: second penalty trial; second death sentence.
October 20, 2005: kidnapping convictions reversed (marital privilege).
2008: retrial of the kidnapping case allowed.
2009: second kidnapping trial ends in a mistrial; FBI letter on bullet lead testimony.
April 22, 2010: second death sentence reversed (modified opinion September 23, 2010).
January 2011: motion for a new trial over bullet lead evidence denied.
October 2011: third penalty trial; third death sentence.
2012: third kidnapping trial; death sentence plus 35 years; New Mexico indictment for Keeling's murder (April).
August 21, 2014: Kentucky Supreme Court affirms the third death sentence.
2014: convicted of second-degree murder in New Mexico.
February 19, 2015: kidnapping convictions reversed again.
April 2, 2015: federal detainer suit dismissed as premature.
April 12, 2017: guilty pleas in Hardin Circuit Court; returned to death row at Eddyville.