Michael Bruce Ross: The Roadside Strangler

Victims
8 killings admitted in Connecticut and New York, 1981-1984. Convicted of 6 in Connecticut, 4 of them capital; sentenced in New York for Paula Perrera; death of Dzung Ngoc Tu never charged
Years active
May 1981 to June 13, 1984
Location
Ithaca and Wallkill, New York; Brooklyn, Griswold, Norwich, Jewett City, Preston and Lisbon, Connecticut; Rhode Island (where two of the victims died)
Method
Strangulation (court records and press reports)
Status
Death on 6 counts, 1987; reversed 1994; reimposed 2000, affirmed 2004. Gave up his appeals, was found competent and was executed by lethal injection at Somers, Connecticut, May 13, 2005

Michael Bruce Ross admitted in the summer of 1984 that he had killed eight girls and young women over three years, in upstate New York and in eastern Connecticut. He was a 1981 graduate of Cornell University who had studied agricultural economics and then gone to work selling insurance. The youngest of his victims were 14. Two of them were hitchhiking together when he picked them up, and a third had set out to hitchhike home from school.

He was caught after a witness saw a car near the place where 17-year-old Wendy Baribeault had disappeared in Lisbon in June 1984. On June 28 he met a state police detective at the Lisbon town hall, asked him whether he thought he had killed her, and then began to confess. A jury in 1987 rejected his insanity defense and convicted him of six counts of capital felony for four of the deaths, and he was sentenced to death. He pleaded guilty to two more Connecticut murders and, many years later, was sentenced in New York for a third killing. A death he admitted in Ithaca in 1981 was never charged.

His case then spent two decades in the courts. The Connecticut Supreme Court threw out his first death sentences in 1994 because the jury had not been allowed to hear certain psychiatric evidence. A second jury sentenced him to death again in 2000. In 2004 he told the courts he wanted no more appeals, and a long fight followed over whether a man who had spent nearly 20 years in solitary confinement on death row could competently choose to die. He was executed on May 13, 2005, the first execution in New England in 45 years and, as of 2026, the last.

Cornell

Ross studied at Cornell's College of Agriculture and Life Sciences and graduated in 1981 with a Bachelor of Science in agricultural economics, according to The Cornell Daily Sun. He belonged to the Future Farmers of America and to Alpha Zeta, an agricultural fraternity. The fraternity revoked his membership in the early 1980s, when he was first tied to the Connecticut killings, and gave photographs and records to investigators. After graduation he worked as an insurance salesman.

The court records describe him as well educated, intelligent and articulate, and as a prolific writer, a finding the trial court made during the later penalty proceedings. His father and his sister both took part in the court fight over his execution in 2005.

Dzung Ngoc Tu

The first death Ross admitted took place at Cornell in May 1981, the month he graduated. Dzung Ngoc Tu was a 25-year-old Cornell student. At the time investigators could not say whether her death was an accident, a suicide or a homicide, and friends told reporters she had been depressed. Ross later admitted that he had killed her.

He was never prosecuted for it. In late 2004 the Tompkins County district attorney, George Dentes, told The Cornell Daily Sun that he saw no real point in prosecuting Ross for the killing while Ross was under a sentence of death in Connecticut. Amnesty International's 2004 summary of the case also lists her death as one he admitted but was never charged with.

Ohio and Illinois

In the year after he left Cornell, Ross was arrested twice in other states, though no one connected him at the time with any killing. An Associated Press chronology published in 2005 lists an attack on a teenage girl in Illinois in September 1981, for which he was convicted of unlawful restraint, fined $500 and placed on probation. In April 1982 he attacked a woman in Licking County, Ohio, and was arrested the next day and charged with assault. He pleaded guilty in that case in August 1982, was fined $1,000 and was sentenced to six months in jail.

The same chronology lists an assault on a woman in North Carolina in August 1981. No charge or court record in that case was reported.

Tammy Williams was 17 and lived in Brooklyn, Connecticut. She was killed in January 1982. For more than two years no one knew what had happened to her. After his arrest in June 1984 Ross led police to her remains, and he was later charged with her murder in Windham County.

Paula Perrera

Paula Perrera was 16 and lived in Wallkill, in Orange County, New York. On March 1, 1982, she left high school early because she felt ill and set out to hitchhike home, according to The Cornell Daily Sun. Her body was found 17 days later. Her death went unsolved for 18 years.

According to New York investigators, as reported by The Cornell Daily Sun, Ross said in a 1994 interview that he had committed at least one killing in New York that had never been linked to him. The investigators then obtained a search warrant for his DNA, and the samples linked him to her case. "Until [Ross] gave that one interview in 1994, we always were holding off," a New York investigator told the Sun in 2000. An Orange County grand jury indicted him on a murder charge and other counts in September 2000, while he was on death row in Connecticut. The Orange County district attorney, Frank Phillips, handled the prosecution. In 2001 Ross received a sentence of up to 25 years in New York for her death.

Debra Smith Taylor was 23 and lived in Griswold, Connecticut. She was killed in June 1982. Like Tammy Williams's death, hers was later charged in Windham County, and it was one of the two murders to which Ross pleaded guilty in 1985.

Robyn Stavinsky was 19 and lived in Norwich, Connecticut. On Thanksgiving Day 1983 Ross encountered her in Norwich and killed her, according to the Connecticut Supreme Court. The court records spell her first name Robyn; Associated Press reports from 2005 spell it Robin. Her death was the first of the four for which he was later tried in New London County.

April Brunais and Leslie Shelley

April Brunais and Leslie Shelley were both 14 and both lived in Griswold, Connecticut. On Easter Sunday 1984 they were hitchhiking toward Jewett City when Ross picked them up. Instead of taking them where they were going, he drove past their destination and across the state line into Rhode Island, where both girls were killed. They were found in Preston, Connecticut, after his arrest, when he led police to them.

The route he took mattered later in court. Because the girls died in Rhode Island, the trial court dismissed two of the capital counts for lack of territorial jurisdiction. The state went forward on the theory that the girls' kidnapping had begun in Connecticut, and the Connecticut Supreme Court held in 1994 that the state's capital felony statute plainly reached a killing in the course of a kidnapping that started inside Connecticut, even when the death occurred in another state.

Wendy Baribeault was 17 and lived in Lisbon, Connecticut. On June 13, 1984, Ross encountered her in Lisbon, and she was killed that day. Her death was the last of the eight. A witness reported seeing a blue car at the scene, and that report led investigators to Ross, according to the Associated Press chronology of the case.

The Lisbon town hall

On June 28, 1984, Ross drove to the Lisbon town hall at the invitation of State Police Detective Michael Malchik. The trial court later found that he came voluntarily. He sat with Malchik in a conference room. He was not restrained, and he had been told twice that he was free to leave.

It was Ross who started the conversation about the case. He asked Malchik whether he thought Ross had killed Wendy Baribeault. Malchik said that he did. Ross then admitted the killing, without further questioning. At that point Malchik stopped the conversation, treated Ross as a suspect in custody, read him his Miranda rights and obtained a signed waiver. Everything Ross said afterward followed repeated warnings and waivers, the Connecticut Supreme Court found.

Over the following hours he gave a series of oral and written statements. Ross admitted killing Wendy Baribeault and Robyn Stavinsky in New London County. He confessed to killing April Brunais and Leslie Shelley in Rhode Island and to other killings in Windham County. In the days after his arrest he led police to the bodies of the two Griswold girls and to the remains of Tammy Williams, and he was charged with Wendy Baribeault's murder. In July 1984 he was charged in the deaths of the other Connecticut victims, according to the Associated Press chronology.

Ross later argued that he had been in custody from the moment Malchik invited him to drive to the town hall, and that his statements should have been suppressed. He abandoned that claim. Judge Hendel, who heard the suppression motion, found that the police had not illegally detained or arrested him, and the Supreme Court upheld the denial of the motion in 1994.

The Windham County cases were resolved first. In November 1985 Ross pleaded guilty to the murders of Tammy Williams and Debra Smith Taylor, and he later received life sentences for them, according to the Associated Press chronology and Amnesty International's summary of his convictions.

The New London County trial

For the four New London County deaths the state charged Ross in three cases with eight counts of capital felony. After the trial court dismissed two counts over the Rhode Island question, six remained. The case was tried before Judge Ford and a jury in 1987. The prosecutor was C. Robert Satti Sr.

Ross did not deny the kidnappings or the killings at trial. His defense was insanity. His lawyers argued that he suffered from a mental disorder that left him unable to control his conduct. Connecticut law required corroboration of a confession in a capital case, and Judge Ford told the jury that it had to find substantial evidence, apart from Ross's own statements, that corroborated his admissions. The jury rejected the insanity defense and convicted him on all six counts.

At a separate penalty hearing, where the defense called the psychiatrist Fred Berlin, the same jury found one aggravating factor and no mitigating factor on each count. In July 1987 Ross was sentenced to death on each of the six counts.

The 1994 ruling

On July 26, 1994, the Connecticut Supreme Court, in an opinion by Chief Justice Peters, affirmed all six convictions. It rejected his claims about territorial jurisdiction, the suppression of his statements, limits on the cross-examination of Detective Malchik, the instructions on corroboration and the severance of the cases.

The court reversed the death sentences. At the penalty hearing the trial court had excluded a letter and a report by Robert Miller, a court-appointed psychiatrist, that bore on whether Ross's mental condition was a mitigating factor. The Supreme Court held that the sentencing hearing had not substantially complied with the death penalty statute, and it ordered new penalty hearings on all six counts.

Miller had diagnosed Ross before trial as a sexual sadist. He died in 1991, before the case returned to the trial court. The diagnosis became the center of the defense case for the rest of the litigation. Ross himself said, in interviews and letters over the years, that the disorder drove him to kill, and that medication and religious faith had changed him, according to The Cornell Daily Sun.

The second penalty hearing

Before the new hearing could begin, the case went back to the Supreme Court. The defense wanted the state held to the ordinary rules of evidence in rebutting mitigation, and it argued that the prosecution should be barred entirely because Satti's trial notes had not been disclosed. In December 1999 the Supreme Court ruled against Ross on both points. It held that the statute meant what it said, so the state was not bound by the ordinary rules of evidence in rebutting mitigating evidence, although the trial judge could still exclude unreliable or unfairly prejudicial material. It upheld a finding that the notes had been disclosed orally before trial and held that they were not material in any case. Justice Norcott dissented on the ground that the death penalty violated the Connecticut constitution.

The new penalty hearing went ahead in 2000. Ross called the psychiatrist Donald Grayson. The defense offered two statutory mitigating factors, that his mental capacity and his ability to conform his conduct to the law had been significantly impaired, and 14 others. The jury found the statutory aggravating factor for especially cruel or depraved killings on each count, and no mitigating factor. Judge Miano imposed a death sentence on each count. The Associated Press chronology dates the jury's decision to April 2000; The Cornell Daily Sun dates it to May 2000.

In November 1998, while the case was pending, Ross had tried to take his own life by overdosing on prescription sedatives. The trial court found him competent and declined to order a competency examination, and the Supreme Court later upheld that decision.

On June 1, 2004, the Connecticut Supreme Court affirmed the new death sentences. It rejected claims about jury selection, severance, the use in the second hearing of the testimony of the state psychiatrist who had died, and the denial of a competency examination, among others.

Death row

Ross spent close to 20 years under sentence of death. For most of that time he was held in solitary confinement, as Judge Robert N. Chatigny of the federal district court in Connecticut described it in January 2005. He was first held at Northern Correctional Institution, where, according to a psychiatrist's report quoted by the Connecticut Supreme Court, he suffered verbal abuse and taunts from other prisoners. In 2003 he was moved to Osborn Correctional Institution in Somers, where he was the only prisoner on his tier. A corrections officer sat outside his cell around the clock, and a mental health clinician visited him for about an hour a day.

He wrote a great deal. For years he produced a monthly letter of reflections and prayers under the title "Walking with Michael," which a friend sent on to as many as 150 readers. He said he had become religious, and that he now opposed the death penalty. Psychiatrists who examined him agreed on a set of diagnoses: sexual sadism, an anxiety disorder, depression or a mood disorder controlled by medication, and a personality disorder with narcissistic, borderline and antisocial traits. They also agreed that his intellect was not impaired.

Giving up the appeals

In September 2004 a lawyer named T.R. Paulding took over from the state public defenders who had represented Ross for 17 years. Paulding wrote to the trial judge, Patrick J. Clifford of the Superior Court, that Ross intended to waive any further appeals or challenges and wanted an execution date set. Judge Clifford questioned Ross, saw no sign of incompetence and set the execution for January 26, 2005.

Ross gave several reasons. The one he repeated most was that he wanted to spare the families of his victims another penalty hearing. In a letter to Governor M. Jodi Rell he urged her to let the execution go ahead, and argued that any legislative debate on the death penalty would turn into a referendum on whether he should live or die, according to Amnesty International. Psychiatrists who interviewed him heard other reasons too: that dying was the morally right thing to do, that he wanted to avoid another public airing of his crimes, that he did not want to grow old in prison, and that he saw execution as inevitable.

The public defender's office did not accept the waiver. It took a petition to the United States Supreme Court on his behalf, which was denied in January 2005, and it asked to appear for him as his "next friend," arguing that he was not competent. The state asked the trial court to decide the question. After a hearing, Judge Clifford ordered an examination by Dr. Michael Norko, a forensic psychiatrist who had known the case since 1995. On December 28 he found Ross competent. The Connecticut Supreme Court later upheld the decision to deny the public defenders next-friend standing.

January 2005

The public defenders, led by Chief Public Defender Gerard A. Smyth, then went to federal court. Judge Chatigny granted the office next-friend standing, ordered a full hearing on Ross's competency and, on January 24, stayed the execution. The state psychiatrist's evaluation, he found, had not addressed whether Ross's choice was truly voluntary, and a psychiatrist who specialized in the effects of long solitary confinement, Dr. Stuart Grassian, had testified that Ross understood his legal position but could not make a rational choice to give up his appeals. Grassian linked the decision to despair brought on by years of isolation and warned that Ross could make himself appear competent. Chatigny also had before him a 1998 letter in which Ross had written privately that his main motive was to end his own suffering.

On January 25 the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit refused to lift the stay. It held that it was too early to decide whether Smyth had standing until the district court had built a record on Ross's competency, and urged that court to hold its hearing as quickly as reasonably possible. On January 27 the United States Supreme Court vacated the stay, and the execution was reset.

The next day, January 28, Chatigny held a conference call with the lawyers. He raised concerns about Norko's evaluation and about Paulding's own position, and he sharply criticized Paulding's efforts to speed the execution. Paulding then asked for a delay to examine a possible conflict of interest. The state agreed, and the execution was put off, first to January 31. On January 31 the Connecticut Supreme Court stayed the execution until the death warrant expired at midnight. A psychiatrist writing in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law later reported that the January execution was halted about 75 minutes before it was due, and quoted Chatigny's view of Ross: "He looks rational, he sounds rational, but in fact he's at the end of his rope."

The April competency hearing

In February 2005 Judge Clifford held hearings on the conflict question, appointed a lawyer, Thomas J. Groark Jr., as special counsel to investigate and present any evidence that Ross was not competent, and set a new execution date of May 11, 2005.

The hearing ran for six days, from April 7 to April 14. Ross testified, as did his father and four psychiatrists. Norko and Dr. Suzanne Gentile, a suicide specialist retained by Paulding, found Ross's decision rational and not driven by compulsion. Grassian and Dr. Eric Goldsmith found it was not voluntary; in Grassian's view, Ross's narcissism made it impossible for him to back down once he had announced his decision in public. Testimony from a journalist who had known Ross for years and from a woman with whom he had a relationship, both of whom said his stated reasons were false, was read into the record. The judge gave little weight to their evidence or to his father's, finding that all three opposed the death penalty and were close to Ross.

On April 22, 2005, Judge Clifford found Ross competent. His disorders, the judge wrote, did not substantially affect his understanding of his legal position, and his decision was "the product of a rational intellect and an unconstrained will." On May 9 the Connecticut Supreme Court affirmed, holding that the special counsel had standing to appeal only because of the unusual circumstances of the case and that the trial court's finding "was supported by the evidence and was not clearly erroneous."

In the final days his father filed a federal lawsuit arguing that the execution would set off suicide attempts among Connecticut inmates, and his sister tried separately to intervene. A federal appeals court in New York and the United States Supreme Court rejected the father's suit on May 12, and the courts turned down his sister's request as well. His family and the public defenders had argued that he suffered from what they called "death row syndrome." Anti-death penalty activists made a final appeal to Governor Rell, who did not intervene.

May 13, 2005

On Thursday, May 12, Ross was moved to a holding cell near the death chamber at Osborn Correctional Institution. His family, friends and lawyers visited him there. He had a Bible, a book of Bible verses, a coffee cup and some candy. About 300 people gathered outside the prison, some holding candles in protest and some in support of the execution.

He was put to death by lethal injection early on Friday, May 13, 2005. The warden, Christine Whidden, announced that he was pronounced dead at 2:25 a.m. "The execution of Michael Bruce Ross has been carried out," she said. He was 45.

The sister of Robyn Stavinsky watched. She said afterward that she had felt anger rather than relief, watching him lie there as if asleep after what he had done, though she expected to find closure later. The father of Leslie Shelley had said before the execution that he planned to witness it and expected to be at ease. Governor Rell said that no one had looked forward to the day, and that she hoped the families would find some measure of relief and closure. A lawyer for Ross's father said the state would live to regret it. Paulding, who had represented Ross in ending his appeals, called it a decision that required courage.

After the execution

Ross was the first person executed in Connecticut since Joseph Taborsky died in the electric chair on May 17, 1960, and the first in New England in 45 years. He was also the only person executed in Connecticut since 1976, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

On April 25, 2012, Governor Dannel Malloy signed a law abolishing the death penalty in Connecticut for future crimes. The law did not apply to the 11 men then on death row. In 2015, in State v. Santiago, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled 4 to 3 that the death penalty violated the state constitution and that the remaining death row prisoners were entitled to be resentenced to life without parole. The court reaffirmed that ruling by a 5 to 2 vote on May 26, 2016. Ross's execution therefore remains the last in the state.

The case also left a mark on the debate over prisoners who volunteer for execution. A Cornell law professor who directed the university's death penalty project, John Blume, told The Cornell Daily Sun in 2005 that his research found such prisoners resembled people who die by suicide, and that judges should look at their motives. The psychiatrist Harold I. Schwartz, writing in 2005, argued instead that treating severe demoralization as mental illness would set a standard of competence few prisoners on death row could meet.

Disputed and unproven points

The number of his convictions is often stated loosely. Ross was convicted in Connecticut of six capital felony counts covering four deaths, and of two murders on guilty pleas, and he was sentenced in New York for a seventh death. Some 2005 reports said he had been convicted of killing eight women; that overstates the record, because one of the eight deaths, that of Dzung Ngoc Tu, was never charged. Other reports said he was sentenced to death for four deaths and confessed to four more, which leaves out the Windham County and New York convictions.

The death of Dzung Ngoc Tu was not treated as a homicide when it happened. Investigators in 1981 could not determine whether it was an accident, a suicide or a killing. The only basis for counting it among his victims is Ross's own admission, and no court has ever ruled on it.

The Cornell Daily Sun wrote in 2004 that two of the killings occurred while Ross was a Cornell student. Only the Ithaca death, in May 1981, fell within his time at Cornell by the reported dates; the Wallkill death came in March 1982, after he graduated. The same article said that he had confessed to about two dozen other attacks and that two attacks at Cornell had been linked to him, but no charges were brought in those cases.

The age range given for his victims also varies. Amnesty International gave Dzung Ngoc Tu's age as 25 and the Associated Press did the same; The Cornell Daily Sun described the victims as aged 14 to 26.

Whether Ross was competent to give up his appeals was contested to the end. Two psychiatrists found his choice rational and voluntary, two found it was not, and the courts sided with the first two. His father, his sister and the public defenders argued that years of isolation had left him unable to make a free choice. The state courts rejected that view, and the federal courts did not stop the execution.

Timeline

1981: Ross graduates from Cornell University with a B.S. in agricultural economics.

May 1981: Dzung Ngoc Tu, 25, a Cornell student, dies in Ithaca, New York. Ross later admits killing her; he is never charged.

September 1981: Ross attacks a teenage girl in Illinois; he is convicted of unlawful restraint, fined and placed on probation.

January 1982: Tammy Williams, 17, of Brooklyn, Connecticut, is killed.

March 1, 1982: Paula Perrera, 16, disappears in Wallkill, New York; her body is found 17 days later.

April 1982: Ross attacks a woman in Licking County, Ohio, and is arrested the next day.

June 1982: Debra Smith Taylor, 23, of Griswold, Connecticut, is killed.

August 1982: Ross pleads guilty in the Ohio case and is sentenced to six months in jail and a $1,000 fine.

Thanksgiving Day 1983: Robyn Stavinsky, 19, is killed in Norwich, Connecticut.

Easter Sunday 1984: April Brunais and Leslie Shelley, both 14, of Griswold, are picked up while hitchhiking and killed in Rhode Island.

June 13, 1984: Wendy Baribeault, 17, is killed in Lisbon, Connecticut.

June 28, 1984: Ross confesses to Detective Michael Malchik at the Lisbon town hall and is arrested; he leads police to the bodies of the two Griswold girls and to Tammy Williams's remains.

July 1984: He is charged in the deaths of the other Connecticut victims.

November 1985: He pleads guilty to the murders of Tammy Williams and Debra Smith Taylor; life sentences follow.

1987: A jury rejects his insanity defense and convicts him of six counts of capital felony; in July 1987 he is sentenced to death on each count.

July 26, 1994: The Connecticut Supreme Court affirms the convictions and reverses the death sentences.

November 1998: He attempts suicide in prison.

December 14, 1999: The Connecticut Supreme Court rules on evidence rules for the new penalty hearing and rejects his claim about the prosecutor's notes.

2000: A second jury finds no mitigating factor; Judge Miano imposes six death sentences.

September 21, 2000: An Orange County, New York, grand jury indicts him in the death of Paula Perrera.

2001: He receives a sentence of up to 25 years in New York.

2003: He is moved to Osborn Correctional Institution.

June 1, 2004: The Connecticut Supreme Court affirms the death sentences.

September 21, 2004: T.R. Paulding enters an appearance and informs the court that Ross will waive further appeals.

December 28, 2004: Judge Patrick J. Clifford finds him competent; the execution is set for January 26, 2005.

January 24, 2005: Judge Robert N. Chatigny stays the execution.

January 25, 2005: The Second Circuit refuses to lift the stay.

January 27, 2005: The United States Supreme Court vacates the stay.

January 28 to 31, 2005: After a conference call with Chatigny, Paulding raises a possible conflict of interest; the execution is postponed and the warrant expires.

February 2005: Thomas J. Groark Jr. is appointed special counsel; a new date of May 11 is set.

April 7 to 14, 2005: Six-day competency hearing.

April 22, 2005: Judge Clifford finds Ross competent.

May 9, 2005: The Connecticut Supreme Court affirms.

May 12, 2005: Federal courts reject his father's suit; his sister's request is also denied.

May 13, 2005: Ross is executed by lethal injection at Osborn Correctional Institution, Somers, Connecticut, at 2:25 a.m.

April 25, 2012: Connecticut abolishes the death penalty for future crimes.

2015: State v. Santiago ends the death penalty for those already sentenced; reaffirmed May 26, 2016.