Michael Atherton

Victims
3 women killed in Horden, County Durham, 2012; never tried. Durham Police and the IPCC attribute the three deaths to him; he died by suicide the same day, January 1, 2012
Years active
January 1, 2012
Location
Horden, near Peterlee, County Durham, England
Method
Three deaths attributed to him by police and the IPCC; no charge was ever brought
Status
Deceased (died by suicide, January 1, 2012). IPCC found missed chances to assess his suitability for his arms licenses; no criminal or misconduct case to answer

On the first day of 2012, three women of one family died in Horden, a village near Peterlee in County Durham. They were Susan McGoldrick, the partner of Michael Atherton; her sister, Alison Turnbull; and Alison's daughter, Tanya Turnbull. Atherton, a 42-year-old taxi driver who held licenses for six arms, died by suicide the same day. Durham Police named him as the man responsible, and the Independent Police Complaints Commission later set out the same account. Because he died the same day, he was never charged, never tried and never convicted of anything.

The deaths led not to a trial but to two official inquiries, both aimed less at Atherton than at the people who had licensed him. Durham Constabulary knew of domestic incidents involving him before he ever applied for a license. In 2008 its officers took his arms away after a domestic argument, then returned them within weeks. The police watchdog called the force's handling of his licenses "inexcusable." The coroner who held the inquest in 2013 said the licensing system in place had not been fit for purpose and called for reform from the root up. The case belongs to the record less for its single night than for the four years of paperwork that came before it.

Atherton lived and worked in the Peterlee area of east Durham. He drove a taxi for a living. By the middle of the 2000s the household was known to the local police. Officers had been called to four domestic incidents involving him. The last of them, on April 24, 2004, ended with a police caution for assault. He was never arrested in connection with any of them.

Atherton was granted arms licenses by Durham Constabulary in 2006 and 2008, although a note on his first application had recommended refusal because of the domestic incidents. In 2008 officers removed his arms after a domestic argument, and the licensing unit returned them to him that September.

On Sunday, January 1, 2012, the three women died in Horden. Other members of the household survived and raised the alarm. Atherton died by suicide the same day.

Within days, the questions turned to how a man with a record of domestic incidents had come to hold six arms legally, and how he had come to hold them again after the police had once taken them away.

Durham Constabulary referred its earlier dealings with Atherton to the Independent Police Complaints Commission within days of the deaths. The commission found that the force had known of incidents that should have cast doubt on his suitability and that his past had not been properly investigated, but found no criminal or misconduct case to answer against any officer. It concluded that the force had missed chances to judge whether he was fit to keep his arms, and had failed to act to take them from him. The commission held its full report back until the inquest was over, and released it in March 2013, on the day the inquest into the three deaths concluded.

The inquest sat at Crook, in County Durham, in March 2013. It heard that Atherton had a history of domestic abuse and of threats to harm himself, and that he had nonetheless held six arms lawfully. The coroner concluded that the three women had been unlawfully killed and that Atherton had taken his own life.

No court ever heard evidence about the deaths in Horden. Atherton died before he could be arrested, and the account of New Year's Day rests on the police investigation, the commission's report and the inquest, none of which is a criminal trial.

The 2008 seizure turned on a disagreement that was never resolved. His family told officers he had threatened to harm himself; he told the licensing unit he had made no such threat. The force treated the matter as one account against another and returned the arms. The commission did not decide which account was true. Its criticism was that the unit had returned the arms without interviewing anyone who could have settled the question.

The reasoning of the senior staff who overturned the 2006 recommendation for refusal is not on the file. The commission found no record of why the 2008 decision was made either.

Timeline

April 24, 2004: Atherton receives a police caution for assault, the last of four domestic incidents known to Durham Police.

2006: He applies for his first arms license; a recommendation to refuse it is overturned and the license is granted.

2008: A further license follows, bringing the arms he may lawfully keep to six.

2008: Officers remove his arms after a domestic argument in which family members say he threatened to harm himself.

January 1, 2012: Three women of his partner's family die in Horden, County Durham; Atherton dies by suicide the same day.

January 2012: Durham Constabulary refers its earlier dealings with Atherton to the Independent Police Complaints Commission.

November 2012: The commission's findings become public; it finds no criminal or misconduct case to answer and holds its full report until after the inquest.

March 2013: The inquest at Crook, County Durham, concludes that the three women were unlawfully killed and that Atherton took his own life; the commission's full report is released the same day.