Fusilier Lee Rigby was murdered in Woolwich, in southeast London, in the early afternoon of Wednesday, May 22, 2013. He was a drummer in the 2nd Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, a veteran of Afghanistan, and he was off duty and in plain clothes. The two men who killed him, Michael Adebolajo and Michael Adebowale, were British citizens who had converted to Islam and become extremists. They murdered a soldier in public, the trial judge found, in order to advance their cause.
Police detained both men in Woolwich that day. A jury at the Central Criminal Court in London convicted them of murder on December 19, 2013, and acquitted them of attempting to murder a police officer. On February 26, 2014, Adebolajo was sentenced to life imprisonment with a whole life order, and Adebowale to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 45 years, less the 272 days he had already spent on remand. In December 2014 the Court of Appeal refused Adebolajo's challenges to his conviction and sentence and dismissed Adebowale's appeal against the length of his term.
The victim was born in Crumpsall, in Manchester, and grew up in the Middleton area of Greater Manchester. He joined the Army in 2006 and did his infantry training at the Infantry Training Centre in Catterick, North Yorkshire. From there he was selected for the Corps of Drums and posted to the 2nd Battalion of The Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, known inside the regiment as the Second Fusiliers.
His first posting was to Cyprus, where the battalion was based at Dhekelia. Early in 2008 the battalion moved to Hounslow in west London to take its turn on public duties, standing guard outside the royal palaces, and he played as a side drummer with the Corps of Drums in the Household Division's Beating Retreat. In April 2009 he deployed to Helmand Province in Afghanistan on his first operational tour, serving in the battalion's Fire Support Group at Patrol Base Woqab. After that tour came a second spell of public duties, and then a posting to Celle in Germany, where the battalion was held at high readiness for contingency operations.
In 2011 he took a recruiting post in London. The work meant meeting young people who were thinking of joining the forces, and he also helped with duties at the regimental headquarters in the Tower of London. He lived and worked out of the Royal Artillery Barracks in Woolwich, and the garrison's own statement after his death said that this was a job he loved and did well, and that he was proud to belong to the Woolwich community.
Michael Adebolajo was 29 when he was sentenced. He grew up in Romford, in the London Borough of Havering on the eastern edge of the capital, went on to the University of Greenwich, and converted to Islam in his first year there. He used the name Mujaahid Abu Hamza. He already had a criminal record: three convictions, recorded in 2008, among them one for assaulting a police constable and one for failing to surrender to custody.
Late in 2010 he was arrested in Kenya, close to the border with Somalia, together with five other young men. Kenyan anti-terrorism police held him on the coast near Lamu and brought him before a court in Mombasa, and the men detained with him were released. He was not prosecuted in Kenya. Instead he was deported to Britain, and he was back there before the year was out. By the time of the murder he had featured in five separate Security Service investigations going back to 2008, but he was not considered to pose a serious threat.
Michael Adebowale was 22 at his trial and at his sentence. He too was a British citizen raised in London who converted to Islam and was radicalised. He lived in Greenwich, and he used the name Ismail Ibn Abdullah. He had left school at 16 and converted at 17, and before the murder he had two convictions, in 2008 and 2009, for possession offenses. The Security Service first actively investigated him in 2012, about eight months before the murder.
The planning, the trial judge was sure, had taken place over a period of time. Adebolajo was the leader of what the judge called a joint enterprise and its spokesman on the day, and Adebowale played his part in it willingly. The two men went to Woolwich intending to murder a soldier, and they killed him in public, before witnesses, as they had meant to. Police officers arrived soon afterward, and both men were injured and detained. Both survived.
The Metropolitan Police's counter-terrorism officers led the inquiry. Both men spent the following week in separate hospitals under guard. Adebowale was charged on May 29 with the murder, and on June 1 Adebolajo was charged with the murder, with the attempted murder of two police officers and with a further offense.
On September 27, 2013, each man pleaded not guilty at the Central Criminal Court to the murder of the soldier, to attempting to murder a police officer and to conspiring to murder a police officer. Each later pleaded guilty to the further offenses arising from what he had carried on the day.
Before the trial Adebowale's mental state was examined. Psychiatric reports prepared in November 2013 described signs of a psychotic episode, and other psychiatrists diagnosed intermittent psychosis. The trial judge ruled that he was fit to stand trial, and no one challenged that ruling.
The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court on November 29, 2013, and ran for about three weeks. Neither man denied killing the soldier. Both denied murder. Adebolajo gave evidence, and his case was that he was a soldier at war and that the killing was therefore an act of war and not murder. His counsel argued that the prosecution had to prove that a killer was under what English law calls the Queen's peace, and that a man who believed himself a soldier at war with the Crown was not.
The trial judge rejected that argument. If the Queen's peace had any part to play in the offense, he ruled, it concerned the victim and not the killer, and the killer's belief about his own status was irrelevant. He directed the jury on that basis, and told them that a claimed war against the state was not a defense to murder. Adebowale did not give evidence.
The indictment narrowed as the trial went on. In its closing stages the count of conspiring to murder a police officer was dropped, and it never went to the jury. The two men were left facing the murder of the soldier and the attempted murder of a police officer.
The jury returned its verdicts on December 19, 2013. Both men were guilty of murder. On the count of attempting to murder a police officer, both were found not guilty. Sentence was put off until the new year.
The trial judge did not sentence at once. He waited for the Court of Appeal, which ruled on February 18, 2014, that whole life orders in England and Wales remained lawful, and the two men were brought back to the Central Criminal Court for sentence on February 26, 2014.
A sentence of life imprisonment is mandatory for murder in England and Wales, and the judge's task was to fix the minimum term each man would serve, or to decide that he should never be released. He was sure that the murder had been done to advance a political, religious, racial or ideological cause, within paragraph 4(c) of Schedule 21 to the Criminal Justice Act 2003, and that in each man's case it had a terrorist connection under the Counter-Terrorism Act 2008, though he took care not to count that feature twice. The seriousness of the offense was exceptionally high, and his starting point was a whole life order. He accepted three aggravating features: the planning and premeditation, the fact that the victim was performing a public duty, and the men's conduct after the killing.
In Adebolajo's case the judge found no mitigation, and he found it one of the rare cases in which a whole life order was the just penalty. In Adebowale's case he was persuaded that the combination of a lesser role, his youth and a mental condition that had existed before the offense and continued afterward meant that a whole life order would not be right, though the minimum term still had to be very substantial.
He sentenced Michael Adebolajo to life imprisonment with a whole life order. He sentenced Michael Adebowale to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 45 years, less 272 days spent on remand. He made a notification order against each man for 30 years and imposed no separate penalty for the further offenses to which they had pleaded guilty.
Adebowale's mental health deteriorated in May 2014, three months into his sentence, and on July 3, 2014, he was transferred from prison to a secure psychiatric hospital in England. It had been accepted at trial that his mental condition played no part in his culpability.
Both cases reached the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, which gave judgment on December 3, 2014, in R v Adebolajo and Adebowale, [2014] EWCA Crim 2779.
Adebolajo renewed his applications for leave to appeal against conviction and sentence after a single judge had refused them. His first ground was the Queen's peace argument that had failed at trial. The court held that the phrase could go only to the status of the victim and had nothing to do with the status of the killer. His second ground concerned his legal team: the trial judge had refused to replace the counsel originally assigned to him, and the Court of Appeal held that there had been no material change of circumstances to justify it and that the point could not affect the safety of the conviction. The renewed application for leave to appeal against conviction was refused.
On sentence, the court found ample evidence that the murder had been committed for a political or ideological cause aimed at the state, and rejected the argument that it should have been treated as a crime of religious hatred or as the equivalent of the murder of a police officer. Adebolajo had no mental illness, there was no mitigation, and the trial judge had been right to make a whole life order. His renewed application for leave to appeal against sentence was refused.
Adebowale had been given leave to appeal against the length of his minimum term, and he did not challenge his conviction. The court held that the trial judge had been right to treat his illness, his lesser role and his youth as mitigation, and that the evidence gave no basis for finding that psychosis had affected his culpability at the time of the offense. A minimum term of 45 years was within the appropriate range, and his appeal was dismissed.
The decision brought the criminal proceedings to an end. Adebolajo is serving a whole life order, under which he can be released only if the Secretary of State orders it in exceptional circumstances. Adebowale's minimum term of 45 years, less the time he spent on remand, runs from his sentence in February 2014.
Adebolajo's arrest in Kenya in 2010 has remained contested. Kenyan officials gave different accounts at first, saying that he had never entered the country before confirming that he had been held there. He later alleged that he had been mistreated during his detention, which Kenyan officials denied. The claim that the men arrested with him were trying to reach al-Shabab, the militant group fighting in Somalia, came from the Kenyan police; he was not prosecuted in Kenya. In Kenya he had been recorded under a different name, Michael Olemindis Ndemolajo.
The question of what drove the murder was settled by the courts, not by the men's own accounts. Adebolajo's counsel invited the sentencing judge to treat the killing as a crime of religious hatred rather than a political one, and the judge and later the Court of Appeal found that it was done to advance a political or ideological cause aimed at the state, with a terrorist connection. The men's own claim that the killing was an act of war was rejected as a matter of law at trial and on appeal.
The jury acquitted both men of attempting to murder a police officer. The confrontation with the police therefore forms no part of either conviction, and no court found that either man intended to kill an officer.
2006: The victim joins the Army; he is later posted to the 2nd Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Fusiliers.
2008: Adebolajo's three earlier convictions are recorded, among them one for assaulting a police constable; he first features in a Security Service investigation.
April 2009: The victim deploys to Helmand Province, Afghanistan.
Late 2010: Adebolajo is arrested in Kenya near the Somali border, brought before a court in Mombasa and deported to Britain.
2011: The victim takes up a recruiting post in London.
2012: MI5 begins actively investigating Adebowale.
May 22, 2013: The soldier is murdered in Woolwich; both men are detained by police.
May 29, 2013: Adebowale is charged with murder.
June 1, 2013: Adebolajo is charged with murder and the attempted murder of two police officers.
September 27, 2013: Both men plead not guilty at the Central Criminal Court.
November 2013: Adebowale is ruled fit to stand trial.
November 29, 2013: The trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.
December 2013: The count of conspiring to murder a police officer is dropped during the trial.
December 19, 2013: Both men are convicted of murder and acquitted of attempted murder of a police officer.
February 18, 2014: The Court of Appeal rules in Attorney General's Reference (No. 69 of 2013) that whole life orders remain lawful.
February 26, 2014: Adebolajo is sentenced to life with a whole life order; Adebowale to life with a minimum term of 45 years less 272 days.
July 3, 2014: Adebowale is transferred to a secure psychiatric hospital.
December 3, 2014: The Court of Appeal refuses Adebolajo's applications and dismisses Adebowale's appeal.