On December 19, 2016, Russia's ambassador to Turkey, Andrei Karlov, was speaking at the opening of a photography exhibition in central Ankara when Mevlüt Mert Altıntaş, a 22-year-old officer of the Ankara riot police who was off duty that day, killed him. Three other people were hurt. Altıntaş refused to surrender, and police killed him at the scene. He was never charged with any offense, and no court ever tried him.
Everything a court has said about him was said in the trial of other men. On March 9, 2021, the Ankara 2nd Heavy Penal Court brought a 28-defendant trial to its verdict, and in the written reasoning it completed that April it found that Altıntaş had been "a secret member of FETÖ," the name Turkish courts and the Turkish government give the network of the United States-based preacher Fethullah Gülen. The court held that the order for the killing had come from Gülen and had reached Altıntaş through the network's members inside the police and the National Intelligence Organization, and it placed the killing in the same campaign as the failed coup attempt of July 15, 2016. Gülen, named in the indictment as the prime suspect, always denied any part in the killing.
Altıntaş was born on June 24, 1994, in Söke, a small town in Aydın province near Turkey's Aegean coast. After high school he trained at the İzmir Rüştü Ünsal Police Vocational School, one of the colleges that prepared recruits for the national police, and from there he was posted to the Riot Police Branch Directorate in Ankara, the force known in Turkish as Çevik Kuvvet. By December 2016 he had served there for about two and a half years. Before that month almost nothing about him had reached the public.
The man he killed had spent four decades in his country's diplomatic service. Born in Moscow in 1954, the ambassador graduated from the Moscow State Institute of International Relations in 1976 and joined the Soviet foreign service the same year. For a long stretch of his career he worked on the Korean peninsula: he served at the Soviet embassy in North Korea and stayed on in the service of Russia after the Soviet Union dissolved, remaining there until 1997. Between foreign assignments he held a series of posts in the foreign ministry in Moscow.
He was appointed Russia's ambassador to Turkey in July 2013, at a time when the war in Syria was straining relations between the two countries. Moscow backed the government of Bashar al-Assad, which Ankara opposed. In November 2015 Turkey brought down a Russian military aircraft near the Syrian border, and Russia answered with sanctions. The ambassador stayed at his post through the rupture. The Turkish president apologized in 2016, and by the end of that year relations between the two governments were recovering. He was still Russia's envoy in Ankara when he died.
Russian investigators arrived in Ankara the next day, and the two governments ran the inquiry jointly. The indictment, made public on November 23, 2018, charged 28 people, and the trial opened on January 8, 2019. At its verdict the court sentenced five men to aggravated life imprisonment. Three of them, among them the man it found had been Altıntaş's superior in the network, were convicted of attempting to overthrow the constitutional order and of deliberate killing for purposes of terrorism and received two such terms each; two former public servants, one of them an officer of the National Intelligence Organization, received one term each for the attempt on the constitutional order and a further 15 years for aiding the killing. Seven defendants were convicted of membership of an armed terrorist organization and given terms of seven years and six months to 10 years and six months. The exhibition's organizer was convicted of aiding the organization and sentenced to three years and nine months. Six defendants were acquitted, as the prosecutor had asked, and the files of nine fugitives, Gülen among them, were separated and suspended. The Ankara Regional Court of Appeal upheld the judgment in a decision made public in February 2022. In June 2023 the Court of Cassation confirmed it for 12 of the 13 convicted defendants and reversed the organizer's conviction, finding no conclusive evidence that he had knowingly and willingly helped the network. Gülen died in Pennsylvania in October 2024 without ever facing a court over the killing.
Altıntaş died before any charge could be brought, so no court ever judged him, and he could not answer what was said about him in the trial of others. The facts of the killing were not in dispute in Ankara; the dispute was over who, if anyone, had sent him.
The Gülen movement denied any involvement from the first day, and the convicted defendants rejected every accusation against them. Their convictions are final in Turkey, and the finding that Altıntaş was a secret member of the network stands as the conclusion of the Turkish courts. An early claim by an armed group in Syria that he had been one of its fighters was not adopted by the investigation or by any court. The Court of Cassation's reversal of the organizer's conviction removed from the case the only finding that anyone connected with the exhibition had knowingly helped the network.
June 24, 1994: Mevlüt Mert Altıntaş is born in Söke, Aydın province.
July 2013: The ambassador takes up his post in Ankara.
December 19, 2016: The ambassador is killed at an exhibition opening in Ankara; three others are hurt; police kill Altıntaş at the scene.
November 23, 2018: The indictment charging 28 people is made public.
January 8, 2019: The trial opens at the Ankara 2nd Heavy Penal Court.
March 9, 2021: Five defendants receive aggravated life imprisonment, seven are convicted of membership, the organizer is convicted of aiding, six are acquitted and nine files are separated.
April 18, 2021: The court completes its reasoned decision, describing Altıntaş as a secret member of FETÖ.
February 2022: The Ankara Regional Court of Appeal's decision upholding the verdict is made public.
June 2023: The Court of Cassation upholds the convictions of 12 defendants and reverses the organizer's conviction.
October 20, 2024: Fethullah Gülen dies in Pennsylvania without having been tried in the case.