Emanuel Weiss, known to the men around him as Mendy, was convicted in Brooklyn in November 1941 of murder in the first degree. The victim was Joseph Rosen, who died in Brooklyn in September 1936. Weiss stood trial beside two other men, Louis Buchalter, who led the syndicate Weiss served, and Louis Capone. The jury found all three guilty, and all three were sentenced to death.
The conviction rested on the prosecution's account that Buchalter had ordered the killing and that Weiss and Capone had carried it out. Two appellate courts upheld the verdict: the New York Court of Appeals, by the narrowest possible margin, and the Supreme Court of the United States, in June 1943. Weiss then spent most of another year under sentence of death while the state and the federal government disputed custody of Buchalter, who was serving a federal sentence. On March 4, 1944, Weiss, Capone and Buchalter were executed in New York on the same night.
The New York Police Department photographed him for its identification files on October 4, 1939, under the name Emanuel Weiss, with "Mendy" given as his alias. By then he was one of the men closest to Buchalter.
By the prosecution's account, the man who died in September 1936 had begun to speak about going to the authorities over the pressure Buchalter's organization put on the businesses around it. The case against the men accused of his murder took more than four years to reach a courtroom.
The killing came back into view in 1940, when a member of the Brooklyn group who had begun to cooperate with the Kings County district attorney's office described it to prosecutors. A second former member of the group gave the evidence that mattered most at trial: he testified that he had been within earshot when Buchalter gave the order.
In April 1941 the district attorney announced the indictments of Buchalter, Weiss and Capone for the murder; a fourth man charged in the case was later granted a separate trial. Buchalter had surrendered to federal authorities in 1939 and was serving a federal sentence, and he was handed over to the Brooklyn prosecutors to face the state charge.
The three defendants were tried together in the County Court of Kings County on a single charge of murder in the first degree. The testimony of the former group member who had overheard the order was, in the end, enough to convict all three. On November 30, 1941, the jury returned verdicts of guilty against Buchalter, Weiss and Capone. Two days later the court sentenced the three men to death, with the execution set for the first week of January 1942. It would be more than two years before that sentence was carried out.
The three men appealed to the New York Court of Appeals, arguing that their trial had denied them the protection of the Fourteenth Amendment. The court rejected those claims and affirmed the convictions over a dissent, holding that the errors made at the trial had not affected the verdict. When the defense moved for reargument, the court examined the documents the motion relied on and found that they bore on none of the issues in the case.
Weiss then petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States together with Buchalter and Capone. They complained that they had been denied an impartial jury and an impartial judge, and that the prosecution had used unfair methods, including the suppression of evidence. The Court affirmed on June 1, 1943. It held that the due process clause did not allow it to review errors of state law, that the defendants had not shown their trial to be essentially unfair, and that there was no convincing showing of actual bias on the jury.
The Court took the other complaints one at a time. The objections to the newspaper publicity before the trial, to the refusal to move the trial to another county and to the rulings on challenges to jurors raised, it said, no due process question it could review. The claim of suppressed evidence failed on its facts: the documents in question had been in the courtroom, and the trial judge had ruled that the prosecution need not hand them to the defense. If that ruling was wrong, the Court said, the error was the trial court's own, and nothing showed that the prosecution had hidden evidence or connived at false testimony. The prosecutor's remarks to the jury, which the Court found had apparently been provoked by the defense's own speeches, raised no due process question either.
The question that kept Weiss alive after June 1943 had nothing to do with his own case. Buchalter was still held on a federal narcotics sentence, and New York took the position that it could carry out its own sentence only if the federal government released him by a conditional pardon. The governor of New York tied the two other condemned men to that dispute: by December 1943 he had twice postponed the executions of Capone and Weiss, and he declined to act on their cases while Buchalter remained beyond the state's reach. In January 1944 a fourth execution date was set. Later that month Buchalter was handed over to the State of New York, and his execution was scheduled for February 7.
The execution date was put back again and again, from the first week of January 1942 until March 1944. The last date fixed for the three men was March 2, 1944. That day Buchalter's lawyer won a reprieve of forty-eight hours so that he could make a final application to the Supreme Court of the United States, and the Court refused it on March 4, 1944. That night Louis Capone, Emanuel Weiss and Louis Buchalter were executed in New York.
Weiss was convicted of one murder, the Brooklyn death of September 1936. Four deaths in Newark, New Jersey, on October 23 and 24, 1935, were later attributed to him in an accomplice's testimony. He was never charged with or tried for those deaths, and they are not convictions; another man named in that testimony was the only person ever convicted in the case.
October 23 and 24, 1935: four men die in Newark, New Jersey; a later accomplice's testimony names Weiss among those responsible; he is never charged.
September 1936: the victim dies in Brooklyn.
1939: Buchalter surrenders to federal authorities.
October 4, 1939: the New York Police Department photographs Emanuel Weiss, alias Mendy, for its identification files.
1940: a member of the Brooklyn group begins to cooperate with the Kings County district attorney's office.
April 1941: the district attorney announces the indictments of Buchalter, Weiss and Capone for the Brooklyn murder.
November 30, 1941: the Kings County jury finds Buchalter, Weiss and Capone guilty of murder in the first degree.
December 1941: the three are sentenced to death; the execution is set for the first week of January 1942.
Before May 1943: the New York Court of Appeals affirms the convictions, four votes to three.
June 1, 1943: the U.S. Supreme Court affirms the judgments.
December 1943: the governor has twice postponed the executions of Capone and Weiss while Buchalter remains in federal custody.
January 1944: a fourth execution date is set; later in the month Buchalter is handed over to the State of New York, and his execution is scheduled for February 7.
March 2, 1944: the date then fixed for the three executions; a forty-eight-hour reprieve is granted so that Buchalter's lawyer can make a final application to the U.S. Supreme Court.
March 4, 1944: the Supreme Court refuses the final application; Capone, Weiss and Buchalter are executed in New York.