Mehmet Goren

Victims
1 teenage daughter murdered in London, 1999. Father convicted of murder December 17, 2009; acquitted of conspiracy to murder her boyfriend
Years active
January 1999
Location
London, England
Method
Murder
Status
Life imprisonment, minimum term of 22 years (December 17, 2009); earlier jailed for an assault on the girl's boyfriend (2000)

In December 2009 a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London found Mehmet Goren guilty of murdering his teenage daughter, a decade after she had disappeared from her family's life in January 1999. The girl had fallen in love with an older man from a different branch of Islam, and the Crown's case was that her father killed her because he believed her relationship had destroyed the family's reputation. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 22 years. The same jury acquitted his two brothers of murder, and acquitted all three men of conspiring to murder the boyfriend.

The case had stalled for nearly a decade. Early arrests ended without charge, and the file sat unresolved until detectives reopened it and, in November 2008, arrested Goren and his brothers. What finally carried the prosecution was the evidence of his wife, who testified against him years after the girl vanished. It was also the first trial in Britain in which prosecutors called expert witnesses to explain a code of family "honor" to a jury.

Goren was a Turkish Kurd from Elbistan in Turkey who claimed asylum in Britain in 1996 and settled in London. He was 49 when he went on trial.

In 1998 the girl began a relationship with a man considerably older than she was. After arguments with her father over him, she left her parents twice. For a time, by late 1998, the family appeared to accept the couple, and the two lived together on the understanding that they would marry. A wedding was arranged for December 1998, but it fell through at the register office because she was below the legal age for marriage.

The arrangement was already under strain. In the weeks before she disappeared, police had been drawn into the family's troubles. She went back home all the same.

That uneasy truce broke on January 6, 1999. Her parents learned that another man was sharing the couple's address, which they would not accept, and the girl went back to her parents the same day. That night, the court heard, the family pressed her to give the man up.

What happened next came to the jury chiefly through Goren's wife. She told police, years later, that after he had brought their daughter back, he sent her and their other children away to stay with relatives. When she came back, she never saw her daughter again. Police came to believe that the girl was killed on January 7, 1999.

Within two weeks Goren turned on the boyfriend. On January 20, 1999, he assaulted the man, who survived. Goren was convicted in 2000 of the assault and jailed for it; he served three years.

For about two months after the girl vanished, police did not treat the case as a murder. A file put together in 2000 did not hold enough evidence to bring charges, and for years the case went no further. The inquiry was later revived, and on November 25, 2008, detectives arrested Goren and his two brothers on suspicion of murder and conspiracy to murder. All three were charged with the girl's murder and with conspiring to murder her boyfriend, and all three denied the charges.

The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court in October 2009 and ran until December. The heart of the prosecution was his wife. She described the days of January 6 and 7, 1999, from inside the household, above all her husband's decision to send the rest of the family away. The girl's sister also testified for the prosecution, and the jury heard expert evidence on "honor"-based crime.

Goren's defense did not rest on denying the violence in the household. He admitted that he had hit his wife and daughter. He denied that he had killed the girl and told the court that he believed she was still alive.

On December 17, 2009, the jury found Goren guilty of murder and acquitted him of conspiracy to murder the boyfriend. His two brothers were found not guilty on both counts. The court sentenced him the same day to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 22 years, a decade after his daughter vanished.

The murder conviction is Goren's alone: his brothers were acquitted of murder and of conspiracy to murder, and he was acquitted of conspiring to murder the boyfriend. How and where the girl died was never established in court.

Timeline

1996: Goren claims asylum in Britain.

1998: His daughter begins a relationship with an older man of a different branch of Islam.

December 1998: A planned wedding falls through at the register office because she is below the legal age for marriage.

January 6, 1999: She returns to her parents after they object to her living arrangements.

January 7, 1999: The date police came to believe she was killed.

January 20, 1999: Goren assaults the boyfriend.

2000: Goren is convicted of the assault and jailed; a police file on the disappearance does not hold enough evidence for charges.

November 25, 2008: Goren and his two brothers are arrested on suspicion of murder and conspiracy to murder.

October 2009: Trial opens at the Central Criminal Court in London.

December 17, 2009: Goren is convicted of murder and sentenced to life with a minimum term of 22 years; his brothers are acquitted.