Megan Haines

Victims
2 aged-care residents murdered in Ballina, Australia, 2014. Convicted of two counts of murder by a jury in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, November 3, 2016
Years active
May 2014
Location
Ballina, New South Wales; Victoria; Lismore and Sydney, New South Wales
Method
Murder of two aged-care residents in her care while she was working as a registered nurse
Status
Sentenced December 16, 2016, to 36 years with a non-parole period of 27 years; appeal against conviction dismissed, 2018; eligible for parole in 2041

Megan Haines had been working in Ballina, on the far north coast of New South Wales, for about two months when two of the elderly residents in her care made complaints about her. She learned of the complaints at the start of a night shift in May 2014. By the next day both women were dead. In November 2016 a jury in the Supreme Court of New South Wales found her guilty of two counts of murder, and in December of that year she was sentenced to 36 years in prison with a non-parole period of 27 years.

The Crown's case turned on motive and opportunity. Haines had been suspended from nursing in Victoria after earlier complaints about her conduct, and when she came to Ballina her registration was subject to conditions, including obligations to report. Fresh complaints, the prosecution argued, threatened to end her career altogether. The jury accepted that she had decided to remove the source of those complaints. She had pleaded not guilty and, in the witness box, denied that she had harmed anyone.

Before she moved north she had nursed in Victoria, and it was there that her professional troubles began. Complaints about her conduct led to her suspension from practice. By the time she started work in Ballina she was entitled to practice again, but only on terms: her registration carried conditions that required her to report to the regulator, and any new complaint would be read against that history.

She had been at the Ballina facility for about two months by May 2014. She worked nights.

Three residents complained about Haines in May 2014. Their grievances were small and specific and concerned the way she had treated them on her shifts: one resident said that Haines had refused to help her, another that Haines had turned down something she had asked for.

On the night of May 9, 2014, Haines began her shift and was told that complaints had been made against her by three residents. Two of the three were the women who died before the night was over. The third complaint was still pending when the deaths occurred.

Marie Darragh was a resident of the Ballina facility and one of the women who had complained. Isabella Spencer lived there too, and she had made her own complaint about the nurse on duty. Both were elderly, both depended on staff for their care, and both were in the facility through the night that Haines worked.

Neither woman lived beyond the following day. Their deaths in May 2014 were the subject of the two murder counts on which Haines was later tried.

Haines worked several more days at the facility after the deaths. She then resigned and left New South Wales for Victoria.

The deaths had by then become a homicide inquiry, led by the Homicide Squad of the New South Wales Police Force. In early July 2014 the squad obtained warrants for her arrest.

In July 2014 detectives arrested Haines in Victoria. She appeared in the Melbourne Magistrates' Court, where the New South Wales police sought her extradition, and was taken to Sydney by homicide detectives the same day. In New South Wales she was charged with two counts of murder and one count of assault, which police described as common assault. Haines remained in custody from her arrest in July 2014 until the end of the trial more than two years later.

The murder trial was listed in the Supreme Court sitting at Lismore, the court closest to Ballina, and it began in 2016. It ran into trouble almost at once.

Two juries were discharged, and the case was moved to Sydney, where the third trial opened in late October 2016. Haines pleaded not guilty to both counts of murder.

The prosecution put its case to the Sydney jury as a chain of circumstances. Haines had been told of the complaints at the start of her shift. She had been on duty that night. Within hours of learning that the two women had complained about her, both were in a condition from which neither recovered. The Crown argued that she had decided to eliminate the cause of the complaints, and that her conditional registration supplied the reason: for a nurse who had already been suspended once, a fresh round of complaints threatened her livelihood.

Haines gave evidence. Under cross-examination she said that she did not harm anyone. She denied murder throughout.

On November 3, 2016, the jury found Megan Haines guilty of the murder of both women.

Haines was sentenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on December 16, 2016, by the judge who had presided over the Sydney trial. The court imposed a sentence of 36 years in prison with a non-parole period of 27 years.

The judgment built the total from the two counts. For each murder the court fixed an indicative sentence of 30 years, with a non-parole period of 22 years and six months, and it then set the aggregate term of 36 years, with 27 years before parole, for the two killings together. The court recorded that when the offenses were committed Haines had previous findings of misconduct against her as a nurse and was working under reporting conditions.

Haines appealed against both convictions to the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal. Three judges heard the appeal, and in 2018 they dismissed it.

Her main complaint went to the way the two murders had been joined together at trial. Before the trial the Crown had served notice that it might rely on coincidence evidence, but it never asked the trial judge for leave to use that notice. On appeal Haines argued that the Crown had been allowed to argue coincidence all the same, that the judge had treated the evidence on each count as admissible on the other, and that the jury had never been told to consider each count separately. The trial, she said, had miscarried.

The court answered on two levels. The first was procedural: no objection had been taken at trial, so under the court's rules the ground could be raised only with its leave. The second went to the substance. The Crown had not run a coincidence case at all. Its case was circumstantial, resting on motive and opportunity, and it had treated the two deaths as parts of a single transaction: the same person must have killed both women, and that person was Haines. On that case, each murder could not truly be understood without the evidence of the other. Nobody at the trial had suggested that two different people were responsible. The question for the jury was who the one person was.

Evidence of a connected course of conduct of that kind, the court held, was admissible on the ordinary test of relevance, and it was not being used to argue that two related events were unlikely to have happened by chance, because on the Crown's case there was only one event. Since neither tendency nor coincidence reasoning had been used to link the murders, the judge had not been obliged to direct the jury to look at each count in isolation or to warn it against that kind of reasoning. The evidence on each count was admissible on the other, and the ground failed.

Her remaining grounds, which concerned the admission of other evidence at the trial, also failed. The convictions stood.

Haines has always denied the murders. She pleaded not guilty, gave evidence that she did not harm anyone, and was convicted by the jury on a circumstantial case built on motive and opportunity. Her appeal against the convictions was dismissed in 2018.

The police allegation that the third resident who complained about her was also assaulted on the same night formed a separate charge of assault when Haines was first brought before the courts in July 2014. That count remained an allegation; the trial that ended in November 2016 was on the two counts of murder.

Timeline

2014 (early months): Haines begins work at an aged-care facility in Ballina, New South Wales, while her nursing registration is subject to conditions after an earlier suspension in Victoria.

May 9, 2014: At the start of a night shift she is told that three residents have complained about her.

May 2014: The two residents die; Haines resigns days later and moves to Victoria.

July 2014: The Homicide Squad obtains arrest warrants; Haines is arrested in Victoria, extradited to New South Wales and charged in Sydney with two counts of murder and one count of common assault.

2016: The first two juries at the Supreme Court sitting in Lismore are discharged.

Late October 2016: The trial is moved to Sydney; the third trial begins.

November 3, 2016: The jury finds Haines guilty of two counts of murder.

December 16, 2016: Sentenced to 36 years in prison with a non-parole period of 27 years.

2018: The New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses her appeal against conviction.