On the Tuesday after Easter in 2003, a man named Max Sica called emergency services in Brisbane to report that three young people were dead in Bridgeman Downs, a suburb on the city's northern edge. They were Neelma Singh, a woman of 24 with whom he had been in a relationship, her 18-year-old brother Kunal, and their sister, who was 12. Their parents were away in Fiji on business. Sica had lived next door to the family for several years, and he presented himself to detectives that afternoon as a shocked and grieving friend.
The prosecution's case was that the call was a pretense: that Sica had killed his former girlfriend on the night of Easter Sunday, April 20, and then killed her brother and sister so that they could never say he had been there. Police regarded him as a person of interest from the first day and as their main suspect within a year, but they did not charge him until December 30, 2008. On July 3, 2012, after an 80-day trial in the Supreme Court of Queensland, a jury found him guilty of three counts of murder. Two days later he was sentenced to life imprisonment on each count with a minimum of 35 years before he could be released, the longest such term ever ordered in Queensland. He has maintained his innocence ever since, through a failed appeal, two petitions for a pardon, two challenges in the Supreme Court and, in January 2025, an application for a second appeal under a law Queensland passed in 2024.
Massimo Sica, known as Max, was 33 years old in April 2003. By then he already had a long criminal record. His offending began in 1988 and included a series of arson offenses, one of them at a police station, for which he was sentenced in 1993. He was sentenced again in 1998. When the siblings died he was on parole.
Their family were Sikhs who had come to Brisbane from Fiji, and the three were former Fiji citizens. Their father and mother kept business ties to the islands, and in April 2003 they were there together, which left the eldest daughter, her brother and their younger sister alone in Bridgeman Downs over the Easter weekend. A fourth sibling survived them.
Sica and the eldest daughter had been in a relationship in 2002, and the prosecution's case was that she ended it. In the weeks before her death she began to see him again. The Crown said he won back her sympathy by telling her he had a brain tumor and only weeks to live. He did not. Part of the reason for his visit on the night of April 20, the court heard, was to talk about holding a prayer meeting for his supposed illness. The two had been in touch by text message and telephone about meeting that Sunday evening, and the sentencing judge found that she was expecting him.
The sentencing judge found that something passed between them that night, that Sica had most likely been enraged by jealousy, and that he killed her intending to do so. He found that Sica then killed her brother and sister to stop them from revealing what he had done. The Court of Appeal later held that the first killing was unplanned and that the other two were premeditated, carried out to silence the two people who could identify him.
Nobody raised the alarm until the afternoon of Tuesday, April 22, when Sica returned to Bridgeman Downs. He told police she had not been answering his calls and that he had come to check on her, and he called emergency services to say he had found the three of them dead. The sentencing judge found that the whole discovery had been staged: that Sica had feigned distress on the emergency calls and in his dealings with police in the days that followed, and that he lied repeatedly afterward, including about where he had been on the Sunday night and when he had arrived on the Tuesday.
Detectives interviewed Sica at Petrie Police Station on April 22 and into the next day, with his father present for the first part, and on Anzac Day, April 25, they filmed a walk-through with him at the property. By March 2004 police considered him their primary suspect, and on March 31, 2004, they questioned him again at length. He denied any part in the killings.
The case against him was built slowly and was almost entirely circumstantial. There was his contact with his former girlfriend on the Sunday evening. There were his denials that he had been in Bridgeman Downs that night and the account of the Tuesday that the Crown said was false. And there was evidence from two experts who could not exclude him, though neither identified him positively.
The decisive piece came in March 2008, when Sica made statements to a woman who had been his friend. The prosecution said that what he told her could amount to a confession. He was held in custody briefly in late 2008, and on December 30 of that year homicide detectives arrested him in Stafford, a suburb in Brisbane's north. He appeared in Brisbane Magistrates Court that day charged with three counts of murder and said through his lawyer that he was innocent.
Sica was refused bail and stayed in custody. His committal hearing in Brisbane Magistrates Court ran for 94 days. The friend gave evidence that he had confessed to her, and the magistrate held that the words she attributed to him could amount to a confession and that the case as a whole was strong enough to go to a jury. In October 2010 Sica was ordered to stand trial in the Supreme Court. He then asked to be tried by a judge sitting alone, pointing to the length of the trial and the publicity about the case, and on August 26, 2011, the Chief Justice of Queensland refused.
The trial opened in Brisbane in 2012 and ran for 80 days, the longest murder trial in Queensland's history. The jury heard the history of the relationship, the false claim of illness, the plan to meet on the Sunday evening and the inconsistencies in Sica's accounts, and it saw the recordings of his police interviews and the Anzac Day walk-through. It was directed that the expert evidence could show no more than that he could not be excluded. The friend repeated her account of what he had told her in 2008. Sica's case was that he had found the three already dead on the Tuesday and that someone else had killed them.
On July 3, 2012, the jury found him guilty of three counts of murder. Asked whether he had anything to say, Sica answered that he had killed no one and that the Queensland justice system and the police were corrupt.
Murder carried mandatory life imprisonment in Queensland, so the question at sentencing was the minimum term. On July 5, 2012, the Senior Judge Administrator of the Supreme Court sentenced Sica to life imprisonment on each of the three counts and ordered that he serve at least 35 years before release, the longest non-parole period ever imposed in Queensland, with credit for the time he had already spent in custody. The judge placed the murders in the worst category of the offense, found that Sica had shown no remorse and that his only concern had been self-preservation, and took into account his criminal history and the fact that he had been on parole when he killed.
Sica appealed against his convictions and sought leave to appeal against his sentence. He argued that he should have been tried by a judge alone, that the police recordings and the expert evidence should never have been admitted, and that the minimum term was too long. On September 2, 2013, the Court of Appeal rejected every ground. It upheld the refusal of a judge-alone trial, found that the interviews and the walk-through had been properly conducted and properly admitted, held that the expert evidence had been admissible within the limits the trial judge set for it, and found that the sentencing judge had been entitled to set the minimum well above the statutory floor of 20 years. The appeal was dismissed and leave to appeal against sentence refused. Sica did not seek special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia.
In April 2019 he petitioned the Governor of Queensland for a pardon, asking in the alternative that the Attorney-General refer his convictions back to the Court of Appeal. Both requests were declined in late 2020. On November 26, 2021, the Supreme Court dismissed his challenge to the Attorney-General's refusal, holding that such a refusal is not open to judicial review and that nothing he alleged could support an inference of bad faith.
In March 2023 Sica complained to the Crime and Corruption Commission, Queensland's anti-corruption body, alleging that police had planted and withheld evidence and that the trial prosecutor had failed to call evidence in his favor. In October 2023 he petitioned for a pardon a second time. On February 9, 2024, the Commission decided to take no further action, finding no evidence sufficient to raise a reasonable suspicion of corrupt conduct, and it confirmed that decision on internal review. On November 1, 2024, the Governor rejected the second petition. Sica dropped a court challenge to the Commission's decision in March 2025, and on May 28, 2025, the Supreme Court ordered him to pay the Commission's costs.
On January 28, 2025, he applied for leave to bring a second appeal against his convictions under provisions of the Queensland Criminal Code, in force from September 1, 2024, that allow a further appeal on fresh and compelling or new and compelling evidence. The outcome of that application is not on record. As of May 2025 he remained in prison in Queensland, serving three life sentences.
Sica has never admitted the murders. He has said that he found the three already dead and that another person killed them, and since 2023 he has alleged that police planted evidence and withheld material that would have helped him and that the trial prosecutor failed to call evidence in his favor. The Crime and Corruption Commission found no evidence sufficient to raise a reasonable suspicion of corrupt conduct. No court has found any of his allegations proved.
The prosecution case was circumstantial, and the committal magistrate called parts of it tenuous and inherently weak. The expert evidence went no further than failing to exclude him. The jury convicted on the whole of the evidence, and the Court of Appeal found no error in the admission of any of it.
The motive rests on the sentencing judge's finding that jealousy most likely drove the first killing and that the second and third were committed to remove witnesses. What passed between Sica and his former girlfriend in the minutes before her death is not on record.
1988: Sica's criminal offending begins, including arson offenses; he is sentenced in 1993 and again in 1998.
2002: Sica and his future first victim are in a relationship, which she ends.
Early 2003: She begins to see him again after he falsely tells her he is gravely ill.
April 20, 2003 (Easter Sunday): Three siblings, a woman of 24, her brother of 18 and their 12-year-old sister, are killed in Bridgeman Downs, Brisbane, while their parents are in Fiji.
April 22, 2003: Sica calls emergency services to report the deaths and is interviewed by police over that day and the next.
April 25, 2003: Police film a walk-through with Sica at the property.
March 31, 2004: Sica, by then the primary suspect, is questioned again.
March 2008: He makes statements to a friend that the prosecution later calls a confession.
December 30, 2008: He is arrested in Stafford and charged with three counts of murder.
October 2010: After a 94-day committal hearing he is ordered to stand trial.
August 26, 2011: The Chief Justice refuses his application for a judge-alone trial.
July 3, 2012: A Supreme Court jury convicts him of three counts of murder after an 80-day trial.
July 5, 2012: He is sentenced to life imprisonment on each count with a 35-year minimum.
September 2, 2013: The Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal and refuses leave to appeal against sentence.
April 2019: He petitions the Governor for a pardon or a referral to the Court of Appeal; both are declined in late 2020.
November 26, 2021: The Supreme Court dismisses his challenge to the Attorney-General's refusal to refer.
March 2023: He complains to the Crime and Corruption Commission.
October 2023: He petitions for a pardon a second time.
February 9, 2024: The Commission decides to take no further action.
November 1, 2024: The Governor rejects his second pardon petition.
January 28, 2025: He applies for leave to bring a second appeal against his convictions; the outcome is not on record.
May 2025: He remains in prison in Queensland, serving three life sentences.