Matthew Murray

Victims
4 deaths attributed to him in Colorado, 2007; never tried. Arvada and Colorado Springs police attributed the four deaths to him; he died by suicide the same day and was never charged.
Years active
December 9, 2007
Location
Arvada and Colorado Springs, Colorado
Method
Four deaths ruled homicides and attributed to him by police; never charged
Status
Died by suicide on December 9, 2007, per the El Paso County Coroner's Office; Colorado Springs police closed the case in March 2008

On Sunday, December 9, 2007, four people died in two Colorado towns roughly 65 miles apart, about twelve hours from the first deaths to the last. Two of them died in the early hours in Arvada, a suburb west of Denver, at the training center of Youth With a Mission, the international Christian missionary organization. The other two, sisters, died early that afternoon in Colorado Springs, on the grounds of New Life Church, a congregation of about 10,000 members where the same organization kept a small office. Five more people were injured across the two towns.

Police in both towns attributed all four deaths to Matthew J. Murray, a 24-year-old who had trained at the Arvada center five years earlier and had left without finishing the course. He died in Colorado Springs that same afternoon, after a volunteer security guard at the church confronted him. The El Paso County Coroner's Office ruled after an autopsy that he died by suicide. Because he died within hours of the deaths attributed to him, Murray was never arrested, never charged and never tried. No court has ever heard evidence about what happened that day, and no verdict exists. What stands in place of one is the work of the Arvada Police Department and the Colorado Springs Police Department, the findings of the coroner, and a 460-page final report that Colorado Springs police released in March 2008 before closing the case.

Murray lived in the Englewood area, in unincorporated Arapahoe County south of Denver.

In 2002 he enrolled in a Discipleship Training School at the Youth With a Mission center in Arvada. The program ran in two parts, a twelve-week lecture phase followed by a twelve-week field assignment. The Arvada center, founded in 1984, sat on the campus of Faith Bible Chapel and trained about 300 people a year. Murray completed neither part of the course. When the time came for field training, the program's directors decided he should not travel with the other trainees. The organization later said that the directors had judged his health made it unsafe for him to take part, and it did not elaborate. He left the center that year.

The two sides of that departure were never squared in public. Youth With a Mission said Murray had left in 2002, five years before the deaths, and that no one at the center could recall any visit or contact from him afterward. Colorado Springs police, in court papers filed on December 10, 2007, described him as having been dismissed from the program about three years before. The same papers stated that in the weeks before December 9 he had sent hate mail to the program, its director, or both. The police gave no details of what the mail contained.

In the early hours of Sunday, two people died at the Youth With a Mission center in Arvada and two more were injured.

The two who died were Tiffany Johnson, of Chisholm, Minnesota, and Philip Crouse, of Alaska.

No one was in custody by daylight.

New Life Church in Colorado Springs had been told of the Arvada deaths that morning.

That afternoon Stephanie Works and her sister Rachael died at the church, and three other people were injured.

A volunteer security guard, a member of the congregation who had come to the church that day as part of its safety team, confronted Murray within minutes. He died at the church. Colorado Springs police officers arriving at the church found him already dead.

The two police departments moved quickly to establish whether one man was responsible for both events. On Monday, December 10, Colorado Springs police identified the man who died at the church as Matthew Murray of Arapahoe County, and Colorado Springs police released the names of the two sisters. The same day, officers from both Arvada and Colorado Springs executed a warrant at the Murray family residence in Englewood.

In the court papers supporting that warrant, Colorado Springs police wrote that "through both investigations" the suspect in the two events was most likely the same person, and they named Youth With a Mission as the "common denominator in both locations." It was in those papers that the police set out Murray's dismissal from the program and the hate mail sent in the weeks before. The affidavit, sworn by a Colorado Springs detective, set out the deaths in Arvada alongside the events at the church. On Monday, Arvada's deputy police chief said a link was a good possibility but that police still had to prove it. Within days, physical evidence recovered in the two towns was matched, and police in both departments attributed all four deaths to Murray. Colorado Springs police also released a photograph of him.

The investigation then drew in federal agents. Murray had posted messages online in the period before the deaths, and Colorado Springs police, Arvada police and the FBI examined those postings together.

Investigators did not say whether Murray had intended to harm any particular person. Two of the four who died, the sisters in Colorado Springs, had close ties to Youth With a Mission: they had taken part in a summer outreach program that New Life Church ran together with the organization's ministry, which rented office space on the church campus.

On Tuesday, December 11, Colorado Springs police announced the result of the autopsy. The El Paso County Coroner's Office found that the guard's actions had not caused his death and that he died by suicide. The finding changed the first public account of the day, which had credited the guard with ending his life. Investigators continued to credit the guard with stopping the attack.

The office of the Fourth Judicial District Attorney, which covers El Paso County, reviewed the guard's actions. In a statement issued while that review was still under way, the office found that the guard's actions appeared appropriate and justified under Colorado law. The guard was never charged with any offense.

Colorado Springs police completed their investigation in early 2008. On March 12, 2008, the department released its final report, 460 pages long, covering the events at New Life Church and the department's work on them. The report traced the link between the two towns back to the hours before the deaths at the church. Because of the ties between New Life and Youth With a Mission, church officials had told police of their "heightened concern" after the deaths in Arvada, and for the same reason investigators connected the afternoon's events to Arvada at once. It recorded the confusion on the campus that afternoon, when many people at first did not recognize what was happening and so many called for help that numerous calls could not get through. A department lieutenant said that, barring new information, the case was closed.

That closure is the last formal act in the case. Murray was dead, and no charge was ever filed in connection with the four deaths.

Arvada lies in Jefferson County and Colorado Springs in El Paso County, so the two events fell to separate police departments, separate coroners and separate district attorneys. The decision of Colorado Springs police to state in court papers, a day after the deaths, that the two investigations pointed to one person is what brought the cases together on the public record. The Colorado Springs department's March 2008 report is the fullest official account of the afternoon in that city.

The deaths were also counted by the state. Colorado's crime statistics are compiled by the Colorado Bureau of Investigation from what local agencies submit, and those figures feed the FBI's national hate crime statistics. In its 2007 Hate Crime Report, published as part of the Crime in Colorado report, the bureau listed none of the four deaths as hate crimes. A bureau spokesman said in December 2008 that the local agencies had reported the events as homicides and not as hate crimes, and that the national figures would therefore record them the same way. The sergeant who reviewed possible hate crimes for the Colorado Springs Police Department's intelligence unit said that the case was never flagged to him for that review.

Because Murray never stood trial, every finding about his role rests on police work and the coroner's rulings, not on a court's judgment. The attribution of the four deaths to him was made by the Arvada and Colorado Springs police and was not tested by a defense.

The record is divided on his time at Youth With a Mission. The organization said he left in 2002 for reasons of health, and that it had no contact with him afterward. Colorado Springs police described a dismissal about three years before 2007 and stated that he had sent hate mail to the program in the weeks before the deaths.

His motive was never settled by any court or official finding. The state's crime statistics list the four deaths as homicides rather than hate crimes.

Timeline

1984: Youth With a Mission opens its training center in Arvada, Colorado.

2002: Murray enrolls in the center's Discipleship Training School and leaves without completing either phase.

Late 2007: Police later state that he sent hate mail to the program or its director in the weeks before December 9.

December 9, 2007, early hours: Two people die and two are injured at the Youth With a Mission center in Arvada.

December 9, 2007, early afternoon: Two sisters die and three people are injured at New Life Church in Colorado Springs; Murray dies there.

December 10, 2007: Colorado Springs police identify Murray; officers from both departments execute a warrant in Englewood; court papers state that the two events most likely share one suspect.

December 11, 2007: Police announce the El Paso County Coroner's ruling that Murray died by suicide.

March 12, 2008: Colorado Springs police release their 460-page final report and close the case.

December 2008: The Colorado Bureau of Investigation confirms that its 2007 hate crime report lists none of the deaths as hate crimes.