Mary Winkler

Victims
1 death: her husband, Matthew Winkler; convicted of voluntary manslaughter, April 19, 2007, after a trial on first-degree murder
Years active
March 22, 2006
Location
Selmer, Tennessee (killing and trial); Orange Beach, Alabama (arrest); McMinnville, Tennessee (residence)
Method
Shot with a shotgun
Status
Sentenced June 8, 2007, to three years, with 210 days to serve before probation. Released on probation August 14, 2007, after 67 more days in custody; living privately as of April 2024.

On the evening of Wednesday, March 22, 2006, members of the Fourth Street Church of Christ in Selmer, Tennessee, found their minister, Matthew Winkler, dead. His wife, Mary, and the couple's three young daughters were gone. The next evening police in Orange Beach, Alabama, about 340 miles to the south, located Mary Winkler and the girls, and within a day she was charged with first-degree murder.

For a year the case was one of the most closely followed in the South. A popular young preacher was dead, and the woman charged with his death was the quiet wife his congregation thought it knew. Prosecutors built their case around money: overdrawn accounts, foreign checks and a bank appointment set for the morning after the death. The defense built its case around the marriage, and in April 2007 Mary Winkler took the stand in a McNairy County courtroom and testified to years of abuse that no one in the town had heard about. The jury rejected first-degree murder and convicted her of voluntary manslaughter. She was sentenced to three years, served 67 more days in custody, most of them in a mental health facility, and was released on probation in August 2007.

The couple met at Freed-Hardeman University in Henderson, Tennessee, a school affiliated with the Churches of Christ. Neither of them graduated. They married in 1996, and by the spring of 2006 they had been married about ten years and had three daughters.

Before Selmer the family lived in McMinnville, about 65 miles southeast of Nashville, where he served as youth minister at the Central Church of Christ. From McMinnville he went west to Selmer, in McNairy County, a town of about 4,500 people roughly 80 miles east of Memphis. The Fourth Street congregation had about 200 members, and they found him a charismatic speaker whose sermons kept closely to the book. Members of the church described Mary Winkler as quiet, and they said they had seen no sign of trouble in the marriage. To friends from McMinnville the couple were, in one church member's words, "a good Christian family."

The marriage Mary Winkler later described in court was a different one. She testified in April 2007 that she had asked her husband for a divorce in 2002, after the family moved to McMinnville. None of that was known in Selmer in March 2006.

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation took charge of the case. No motive was made public, and the court papers filed in the first days gave none.

Mary Winkler had kept the family's books. On March 21, the day before the death, a manager at the couple's bank spoke with her about the accounts, and an appointment had been set for the following morning. That conversation would become the center of the prosecution's case a year later.

On the evening of Thursday, March 23, Orange Beach police located Mary Winkler and her daughters in the Gulf Coast resort town. She was taken into custody that night. Alabama investigators questioned her, and in a statement later read and played in court she described the night of March 21: an ordinary family evening, then an argument with her husband that ran through the night and turned on the family's finances.

She told the investigators that the money problems were "mostly my fault," because she was the one who kept the books. She said her husband had been criticizing her and that the criticism had built up until she "snapped." "I was just tired of it," she said. She said she remembered little of the moment itself. She also called her husband a good man, and said she had thought about killing him before.

On Friday, March 24, she was charged with first-degree murder in Tennessee. She appeared that day in court in Foley, Alabama, and agreed to return to Tennessee without contesting extradition. On March 25 she was brought back to Selmer and booked into the McNairy County Jail, where she would stay for nearly five months.

On Monday, June 12, 2006, a McNairy County grand jury indicted Mary Winkler on a charge of first-degree, premeditated murder, and she pleaded not guilty.

The first public account of what prosecutors believed came at a bond hearing in Selmer on June 30, 2006. A Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agent read aloud the statement she had given in Alabama. Authorities said that over several months before the death she had deposited about $17,500 in checks from unidentified foreign sources into the family's bank accounts, part of a check-kiting scheme in the state's account. The defense answered that her husband had known about the checks and that both spouses had been victims of the scheme.

On July 7, 2006, the circuit judge of McNairy County set bond at $750,000. Through those months members of the Fourth Street congregation visited her in the county jail and sent her personal things, among them a study Bible.

Mary Winkler posted the $750,000 bond and left the McNairy County Jail on August 15, 2006. Under the terms of her release she lived with friends from the Central Church of Christ in McMinnville, about 160 miles east of Selmer, and worked at a dry cleaning business there. She could leave the county only to meet her lawyers or to see her children.

She spent eight months that way. The trial, first set for October 2006, was reset for the spring of 2007, and before it began the court found her competent to stand trial.

Jury selection began in Selmer on Monday, April 9, 2007, and testimony opened on Thursday, April 12. The state's case was that she had acted deliberately, to hide a negative bank balance from her husband. The defense case was that the marriage had been abusive and that the death had not been intended.

On Friday, April 13, the jurors heard the recording of her statement to the Alabama investigators, which the prosecution presented as a confession. In it she said that her husband had threatened her in a way that "really scared" her. On Saturday, April 14, five bank employees testified about overdrawn accounts, fraudulent checks and check kiting, and one of them described the March 21 conversation and the appointment set for March 22.

The state's witnesses, among them friends of the couple, described the dead man as a good husband and a loving father. The state rested on Monday, April 16.

The defense opened its case the next day. A Tennessee Highway Patrol sergeant testified about a 2003 encounter with the minister, and former members and staff of churches where he had served testified about his conduct. A psychologist who had evaluated Mary Winkler for the defense testified that she had depression and post-traumatic stress disorder, with symptoms reaching back to her early teens.

On Wednesday, April 18, Mary Winkler testified in her own defense. She told the jury that her husband had abused her physically and emotionally for years, that he had hit and kicked her, and that he had pressed her into things she found degrading. She said she had asked him for a divorce in 2002. She said she had withdrawn cash at his request. She denied that she had meant to kill him and told the jurors that the death was an accident.

Under cross-examination by the assistant district attorney general, she agreed that her husband had done nothing that deserved death. She also agreed that no friend or relative had known the details of her marriage. Closing arguments followed the same afternoon.

On Thursday, April 19, 2007, after about eight hours of deliberation, the jury found her not guilty of first-degree murder and guilty of voluntary manslaughter. (A 2024 network account gives the verdict date as April 18; the wire reports of the day give April 19.) She remained free on bond until sentencing.

At the sentencing hearing in Selmer on Friday, June 8, 2007, Mary Winkler asked the court for leniency. She told the judge that she thought of her husband every day, and that she would always miss and love him. She apologized to his family.

The circuit judge sentenced her to three years. He denied her request for full probation and for judicial diversion. She was required to serve 210 days before release on probation, and she received credit for the 143 days she had already spent in the McNairy County Jail, which left 67 days. The judge ruled that up to 60 of those days could be served in a facility that provided mental health treatment.

She served 12 days in jail and the rest in an inpatient mental health facility that her lawyers did not name. On Tuesday, August 14, 2007, after 67 days in custody, she was released, to serve the rest of the three-year term on probation. The next day she was back in McMinnville, living with friends, and that September she returned to work at the dry cleaning business where she had worked while free on bond.

As of April 2024, she was living privately and declined to discuss the case, saying only that the family had moved on.

The two sides never agreed on why the minister died, and the verdict did not settle the question. The prosecution's case rested on money. It argued that she had cashed fraudulent checks, run up debts of more than $16,000 and moved money between accounts to cover the shortfall, and that she had acted on the night before a bank meeting that would have exposed it. She was never charged with any of those financial offenses, and the defense said her husband had known about the checks.

The abuse she described rests on her own testimony and on the defense psychologist's evaluation of her. A state trooper and former church members testified about the minister's conduct in other settings, while the prosecution's witnesses described a good husband and father.

Her own accounts also differed. In her statement to the Alabama investigators she spoke of an argument, years of criticism and a moment when she "snapped," and she said she remembered little of the death itself. At trial she testified that it was an accident. The jury's verdict of voluntary manslaughter rejected the state's theory of premeditation without accepting that the death was accidental.

Timeline

1996: Mary Winkler marries the man she met at Freed-Hardeman University in Henderson, Tennessee.

2002: After the family's move to McMinnville, Tennessee, she asks for a divorce, by her later testimony.

March 21, 2006: A bank manager speaks with Mary Winkler about the family's accounts and sets an appointment for the next morning.

March 22, 2006: Members of the Fourth Street Church of Christ find their minister dead in Selmer, Tennessee.

March 23, 2006: Orange Beach, Alabama, police take Mary Winkler into custody.

March 24, 2006: She is charged with first-degree murder and agrees to return to Tennessee.

March 25, 2006: She is booked into the McNairy County Jail in Selmer.

June 12, 2006: A McNairy County grand jury indicts her for first-degree murder; she pleads not guilty.

June 30, 2006: At a bond hearing, an investigator reads her statement aloud.

July 7, 2006: Bond is set at $750,000.

August 15, 2006: She posts bond and moves to McMinnville.

April 9, 2007: Jury selection begins in Selmer.

April 12, 2007: Testimony opens.

April 18, 2007: Mary Winkler testifies in her own defense; closing arguments are heard.

April 19, 2007: The jury convicts her of voluntary manslaughter.

June 8, 2007: She is sentenced to three years, with 210 days to serve before probation.

August 14, 2007: She is released on probation after 67 days in custody.

April 2024: She is living privately and declines to discuss the case.