Mary Bateman was executed at York on Monday, March 20, 1809, three days after a jury at the York Assizes found her guilty of the wilful murder of Rebecca Perigo, a woman from Bramley, near Leeds, who had come to her for help. For more than two years before that verdict Bateman had taken the couple's money, furniture, china and clothing through letters she wrote in the name of a wise woman who did not exist. Her client's death in May 1807 did not end the scheme. It went on for another seventeen months, until the widower cut open the charms he had been told to keep in his bed and found nothing of value inside.
She was not tried for witchcraft. The indictment at York named only murder. What the trial set out was a long and careful fraud that had worked on many people across Leeds before it reached Bramley, and a death at the center of it that Bateman denied to the end.
She was born Mary Harker in 1768 at Aisenby, near Thirsk, in the North Riding of Yorkshire. She learned to read and write. Around 1780, at about 12 or 13, she went into domestic service in Thirsk. She was already stealing, and she passed through several employers in her teens.
In 1787 she moved to York. Within a year she was caught stealing from her mistress, and she left for Leeds without waiting for her wages or her clothes. In Leeds she found work as a mantua maker, sewing gowns, and spent more than three years in the trade. Fortune telling began as a sideline and became her living.
In 1792 she married a wheelwright after a courtship of about three weeks. Within two months of the wedding her frauds had come to light. The couple took rooms in lodging houses, and she stole from the other residents. She bought goods from Leeds shops in the names of established customers. She went from door to door asking for linen and clothing for "the sick and poor," then pawned or sold what she was given.
Her husband found that she had sold all their furniture to pay off one of the people she had cheated. He enlisted in the supplementary militia, and the couple moved from place to place while he served.
In 1799 the couple settled again in Leeds, and over the next few years Bateman built a reputation there as a wise woman. She told fortunes and sold charms and potions that were said to ward off evil, to lift curses and to cure illness. She claimed to be able to remove an "evil wish." She sold slips of paper marked "JC" as seals that would admit the holder to heaven.
Her method rested on intermediaries she had invented. One was a Mrs. Moore. Another, more important, was a Miss Blythe, who could read the stars and was said to live at Scarborough. Clients gave Bateman their names and their payments, and Bateman passed back predictions and instructions as if they came from these women. She charged postage on letters that were never sent. She also attended meetings of followers of Joanna Southcott, a Christian millenarian prophet, and she used Southcott's name, apparently without permission, to lend weight to her own work.
The scheme that made her name in Leeds came in about 1805 or 1806. She claimed that a hen she kept was laying eggs inscribed "Crist is coming," a sign that the end of the world was near, and she charged a penny to see them. The eggs had been marked by hand and returned to the bird. Skeptics who watched the bird found out how it was done. Bateman sold the hen to a neighbor, and the inscribed eggs stopped.
Her client lived with her husband, William Perigo, at Bramley, near Leeds. In the spring of 1806 she began to suffer from what she believed was a nervous or spiritual complaint, and a man she consulted told her that an evil wish had been laid on her. A niece of hers, who was in service in Leeds, suggested that the couple go to Mary Bateman.
Bateman told them that their case was beyond her own skill but within the power of her friend Miss Blythe at Scarborough, and from then on the instructions came in letters bearing Miss Blythe's name. The first demands were for money to be sewn into small silk bags and placed in the corners of the bed, where it had to stay untouched for eighteen months if the charm was to work. Horseshoes were to be nailed to the door. Then the requests widened. Miss Blythe asked for china, silver, a new bed, furniture, provisions and household goods, and the couple sent them, by way of Bateman, to a woman they had never met.
Over about ten months they handed over roughly 70 pounds in money and a great deal more in goods.
In May 1807 a letter warned them that God had an illness in store for them that spring, and it told them to follow Miss Blythe's directions exactly. Bateman's client died on Sunday, May 24, 1807. Her husband survived. No inquest was held, and her death passed without any inquiry for well over a year.
The widower did not go to the authorities. He went on consulting Bateman, and he went on sending things to Miss Blythe, among them his late wife's dresses. The bags in the bed were not to be touched for eighteen months, and he kept to that, so the fraud ran on through the rest of 1807 and most of 1808.
In October 1808 he opened the silk bags. The money he had sewn into them was gone. In its place were pennies, worthless farthings, scraps of paper and rotten cabbage leaves. When he confronted Bateman, she told him that he had opened them too soon.
On October 20, 1808, he went to the authorities in Leeds, and Bateman was arrested. Most of the goods that the couple had sent to Miss Blythe turned up in her own rooms. She said that he had set out to trap her. She was charged with wilful murder and committed to York Castle to wait for the assizes.
She spent the winter in the newest building at York Castle. Even there she sold charms, and she took the savings of a young woman held in the same building. The governor made her pay the money back, and her friends in Leeds made up what she could not.
Her trial opened on Friday, March 17, 1809, at the York Assizes.
The widower described the two years of letters, payments and instructions, and other witnesses supported much of what he said. Others showed that no Miss Blythe lived at Scarborough, and the letters that had come in her name were shown to be in Bateman's own handwriting. Medical witnesses gave evidence on the cause of death. People from across Leeds came forward to describe the money and goods Bateman had taken from them, and the trial grew into an account of her whole career in the town.
Bateman's defense was a flat denial. In a written statement she denied the charge outright. The jury found her guilty of murder, and the judge sentenced her to death, the sentence to be carried out on the following Monday.
Once the sentence had been passed, Bateman told the court that she was 22 weeks pregnant. The judge ordered a jury of matrons. The married women sworn to it examined her and found that she was not with quick child, and the plea was rejected.
While she waited for execution, Bateman went on making charms for other prisoners. She would not confess. She wrote to her husband, and on the day before her execution she wrote to her family, admitting the frauds and denying the murder. On the morning of Monday, March 20, 1809, she took communion. She was executed at York that day, still maintaining that she was innocent of her client's death.
Bateman never admitted the murder. She admitted fraud in her last letters and on the day of her execution still denied any part in the death at Bramley. The jury's verdict rested on the letters in her handwriting, the evidence of the surviving husband, the medical evidence and the goods recovered from her rooms.
Later accounts attribute other deaths to her. They describe three women of the Kitchin family, Quakers who kept a draper's shop in Leeds, who died in 1803 while Bateman was attending them, and say that the deaths were put down to plague at the time and that the shop and its account books were later found stripped. Some accounts add a fourth death in the same household. Bateman was never charged with, tried for or convicted of any of these deaths, and they remain attributions.
The dates of several earlier events vary between accounts. The hen is placed in 1805 by some and 1806 by others, and the age at which she first reached Leeds also differs. The trial is dated March 17, 1809, with the indictment in some accounts on March 18; the execution on Monday, March 20, is not in dispute.
1768: Mary Harker is born at Aisenby, near Thirsk, Yorkshire.
About 1780: She enters domestic service in Thirsk.
1787: She moves to York; within a year she leaves for Leeds.
1792: She marries a wheelwright; her frauds come to light within two months.
1799: The couple settle again in Leeds, where she builds a reputation as a wise woman.
1803: Deaths in the Kitchin household in Leeds, later attributed to her; she is never charged.
About 1805 to 1806: The inscribed eggs of her hen draw paying visitors until the trick is exposed.
Spring 1806: A Bramley couple first consult her.
May 24, 1807: Her client dies at Bramley.
October 1808: The widower opens the charms in the bed and finds them worthless.
October 20, 1808: He goes to the authorities; Bateman is arrested in Leeds and committed to York Castle on a charge of wilful murder.
March 17, 1809: Her trial opens at the York Assizes; she is found guilty of murder and sentenced to death; a jury of matrons rejects her plea of pregnancy.
March 20, 1809: She is executed at York.