For five years Martin Sommer controlled the cell building at Buchenwald, the block of punishment cells at the entrance to the concentration camp outside Weimar. Men were held there in solitary confinement under his authority, and many of them died there. In July 1958, fifteen years after he left the camp, a court in Bayreuth found him guilty of the murder of 25 prisoners and sentenced him to life imprisonment, the heaviest penalty West German law allowed. He came into court in a wheelchair, having lost an arm and a leg at the front.
The path to that verdict was long and unlikely. Sommer had already faced one court, an SS tribunal convened in 1943 by the regime he served, and had confessed there to brutality toward prisoners. After the war he lived under his own name in American custody and then in a German veterans' hospital, and his identity as the Buchenwald overseer surfaced only in 1950, when his first wife sued for divorce. Physicians then declared him unfit to stand trial, and the proceedings against him were dropped in 1955. Only after he remarried and applied for a larger war pension did the authorities change their view. He was taken into custody in 1957, and in May 1959 the Federal Court of Justice let the life sentence stand.
The SS opened Buchenwald for male prisoners in July 1937, on a hill about five miles northwest of Weimar in east-central Germany. Its first inmates were mostly political prisoners. Jews arrived in large numbers in 1938, and the camp also held Jehovah's Witnesses, Sinti and Roma, repeat offenders, men the regime classed as "work-shy" and, later, German military deserters. After the pogrom of November 1938, SS and police sent almost 10,000 Jewish men to Buchenwald, and more than 250 of them died from the effects of their arrest or from mistreatment in the first weeks. Between 1937 and 1945 about 250,000 people passed through the camp and its subcamps. The SS murdered at least 56,000 of them, about 11,000 of them Jews. Many prisoners were never registered, so every total is an estimate.
At the entrance to the main camp stood the punishment block that prisoners called the Bunker. It was a place apart even within Buchenwald, where prisoners were mistreated and often killed.
Sommer was born on February 8, 1915. Before the war he worked as an agricultural laborer. In the SS he rose to the rank of first sergeant, and from 1938 to 1943 he was master of the camp's punishment cell building, the man who ran the guardhouse for most of the camp's early years.
Among the men held in the cells in those years were prisoners whose names the Buchenwald Memorial keeps today. Paul Schneider, a member of the Confessing Church from the Hunsrück, arrived at Buchenwald on November 28, 1937, after the Gestapo arrested him for defying an order that banned him from his own district. On April 20, 1938, he refused to take off his cap for the swastika flag at a camp roll call. The SS put him in the cell building, and he remained there in solitary confinement for fourteen months, repeatedly mistreated, until his death on July 18, 1939. From the window of his cell he called out words of the Gospel to the prisoners gathered on the roll-call square, and each time he was punished for it.
Otto Neururer, from Tyrol, had been arrested on December 15, 1938, after he prevented a forced marriage between a woman of his parish and a member of the SA. He was sent to Dachau in March 1939 and on to Buchenwald at the end of September. In late May 1940 he was locked in the cell building because he had helped a fellow prisoner who wished to convert and had baptized him. He died there on May 30, 1940. Matthias Spanlang, also from Austria, was murdered at Buchenwald in 1940 after giving the same baptism instruction, and the memorial lists him among the dead of the cell building.
The memorial's list also includes the Social Democrat Ernst Heilmann, who died in 1940; Julius Silbermann, who died in 1938; Rudolf Opitz, who died in 1939; Johann Lang, a Czech prisoner who died in 1940; and prisoners from Poland, among them Wladyslaw Chodnicki and Stanislaw Wycisk, who died in 1941. The names of the 25 men in the 1958 judgment are not on record, and the memorial's list covers the whole life of the building, through 1945, so no individual death on it can be placed among the counts proved against Sommer.
An SS judge was sent to investigate corruption at Buchenwald during the war. His inquiry reached the cell building, and Sommer was brought before an SS court in 1943. There he confessed to brutality toward prisoners and was convicted on that and other charges. Fifteen years later two former SS officials, one of them the judge who had led that inquiry, told the Bayreuth court that Sommer had confessed in 1943 to killing at least 50 prisoners.
The SS court sentenced him to serve time at Buchenwald itself, and he was then released to serve at the front. Toward the end of the war he was posted to Bavaria as a tank driver in the SS. He was badly wounded there, lost his left leg and an arm, and was captured by American troops. Army doctors kept him alive through about 30 operations.
In American custody Sommer was held under his own name, and no one connected the wounded tank driver with the overseer of the Buchenwald cells. His name was spoken in Nuremberg in 1947, in two of the American military trials that followed the main war crimes tribunal, but only because a defendant there shared his surname.
On April 23, 1947, in the Pohl case, counsel for a defendant named Karl Sommer cross-examined a witness who had been held at Buchenwald. The witness had written of a "Sommer" at the camp, and counsel wanted to show that this was a different man. The Sommer the witness remembered had been in charge of a bunker. Asked whether that man was in the dock, the witness said no. Two months later, on June 24, 1947, in the trial of the SS doctors, the question came up again under cross-examination. Who was Sommer? A supervisor in the bunker, came the answer, an SS man, who had nothing to do with the Sommer then on trial in Nuremberg.
The connection was made in 1950, when Sommer's first wife sued for divorce. By 1956 the files of the state prosecutor at Bayreuth held sworn statements from about 400 witnesses. They described 67 murders inside the camp and 11 outside it, several hundred assaults that ended in death, most of them on sick prisoners, and many further cases of manslaughter and aggravated assault.
The case stalled on the question of his health. In March 1955 German physicians found him physically unfit to stand trial, the proceedings were dropped, and he was set free. He lived at a German veterans' hospital and drew a substantial pension. In 1956 he married again and had a child, and a further medical finding gave him an extended leave from the hospital after the wedding. That marriage, together with his application for a higher veterans' pension, led the West German authorities to reverse their earlier view that he could not be tried.
Sommer was taken into custody in July 1957. He challenged the arrest, and at the beginning of August 1957 the Superior Court at Bamberg rejected his appeal and ordered him held to await trial. He then faced 67 counts of murder, along with alleged participation in other killings, all from his years at Buchenwald. He had avoided trial for about seven years.
The case was narrowed before it reached court. The prosecution's evidence pointed to about 200 Jewish and other victims, but the court chose to hear 53 cases, so that the trial would not place too heavy a strain on a defendant whose war wounds had already held up the proceedings for years.
The trial opened in March 1958 before the court at Bayreuth, in Bavaria, and former prisoners came to testify about the cell building.
Sommer pleaded not guilty. He insisted that he had never treated anyone brutally and had killed no one on his own initiative. When a justice confronted him with what he had said before the SS court in 1943, he denied killing anyone at Buchenwald and denied the other cruelties charged against him. Yet in his own defense he admitted that he had mistreated both men and women prisoners, and said he had done so on orders.
Other testimony described the deaths of a Protestant churchman and a Catholic priest in the cell building. The former SS judge testified to what his wartime inquiry had found inside the building. When he and the second former SS official described Sommer's 1943 confession to at least 50 killings, Sommer answered that the record of it was forged.
A psychiatric expert examined him and found him legally sane.
In early July 1958 the court and jury found Sommer guilty of murder. The judgment covered the murder of 25 inmates of Buchenwald, and the court imposed life imprisonment, the maximum penalty permitted under West German law.
Within days of the verdict Sommer appealed to a higher court. In May 1959 the Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal for a retrial, and the conviction and life sentence stood.
As of May 1959, he was serving the life sentence. His later custody, any release and the date of his death are not on record. The Central Office of the State Justice Administrations for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes, at Ludwigsburg, kept a file in his name, now held by the German Federal Archives, with papers dated 1987 and 1988.
The number of murders on which Sommer was convicted is 25 in the Jewish Telegraphic Agency's reports of the verdict and the appeal, and 23 in Time's account, which says the prosecution and defense reduced the counts to 23 during the trial. The figure of 25 is the one tied directly to the judgment.
The larger totals were never proved in court. The 67 murders inside the camp and 11 outside it come from sworn statements gathered before 1956; the figure of about 200 victims was the prosecution's estimate; and the 53 counts were those set down for trial. Sommer's 1943 confession to at least 50 killings was described to the Bayreuth court by two former SS officials, and he called it forged.
No court has settled whether Sommer was personally responsible for the death of any of the cell-building prisoners named here.
His place of birth and the date he joined the SS are not on record.
February 8, 1915: Martin Sommer is born.
July 1937: The SS opens Buchenwald concentration camp near Weimar.
1938: Sommer becomes master of the camp's punishment cell building, a post he holds until 1943.
November 1938: Almost 10,000 Jewish men are sent to Buchenwald after the pogrom.
1943: Sommer is tried before an SS court, confesses to brutality toward prisoners and is later sent to the front.
Late in the war: Sommer, badly wounded in Bavaria, is captured by American troops.
April 23 and June 24, 1947: Witnesses at two Nuremberg trials describe a Sommer who supervised the Buchenwald bunker; he is not a defendant.
1950: His identity as the Buchenwald overseer comes to light in his first wife's divorce suit.
March 1955: Physicians declare him unfit to stand trial, and the proceedings are dropped.
1956: He remarries; the authorities reverse their finding on his fitness.
July 1957: He is taken into custody.
August 1957: The Superior Court at Bamberg rejects his appeal against detention; he faces 67 murder charges.
March 1958: His trial opens at Bayreuth on 53 counts.
July 1958: The Bayreuth court convicts him of the murder of 25 Buchenwald prisoners and sentences him to life imprisonment; he appeals within days.
May 1959: The Federal Court of Justice rejects his appeal.