On the afternoon of August 29, 1995, Mark Winger called 9-1-1 in Springfield, Illinois, and told police that he had killed an intruder in defense of his wife. His wife, Donnah Winger, died that day. So did the man he named as the intruder, Roger Harrington, who had driven her back to Springfield from St. Louis a few days before. Within a day the county's prosecutor announced that Winger had acted in self-defense and that no charges would be filed.
Nearly seven years later a Sangamon County jury found Winger guilty of two counts of first degree murder, one for each death, and in August 2002 he was sentenced to natural life in prison. The State's case at trial was that the second man had not been an intruder at all, that he had come by arrangement, and that Winger had killed both of them and framed the dead man for his wife's death. Winger has denied it from the beginning. He did not testify at his trial, and the Illinois courts have rejected every challenge to the verdict that has come before them since.
Winger worked as a nuclear engineer for the State of Illinois. He and his wife married in 1989 and settled in Springfield, the state capital, and in June 1995 they adopted a baby girl.
That summer his wife rode the last stretch home to Springfield from the St. Louis airport in a van driven by the second man, and the ride frightened her. Winger complained to the van company, obtained the driver's telephone number and, by his own later account to police, told the driver that he would not file a police report if the man left the family alone. The company suspended the driver after the complaint.
Less than a week after that ride, the driver came to the Wingers in Springfield. Winger told police that he had killed the man in his wife's defense, the account the Illinois Appellate Court later set out as the one he gave police on August 29, 1995.
The investigation that followed was short. The next day the prosecutor ruled the driver's death an act of self-defense. One detective did not accept the account and pointed to evidence found that day that the driver had expected to meet Winger that afternoon, but the case stayed closed for more than three years.
Winger stayed in Springfield. He filed a civil suit over his wife's death against the transport company that had employed the driver, and it was later voluntarily dismissed.
The case turned on a single witness. She was his wife's close friend from work, and she had begun an affair with Winger shortly before the killings. It continued for months afterward.
She testified at trial that in August 1995, in one conversation, Winger told her it would be easier if his wife just died. He had been thinking about it for a while, he said, and all she would have to do was come in and find her. She told him the idea was crazy and refused any part in it. In a later conversation, she said, he again said things would be easier if his wife died, and she refused again.
On August 28, 1995, she testified, Winger talked to her about getting the van driver to come to them. On the day itself he asked her whether she would love him no matter what. Afterward, she testified, he told her to stay as far from the police as she could and to say nothing about the affair.
The relationship went on, but she grew suspicious. Winger told her once that dead men don't talk. Another time he said that the killing had not happened the way the newspaper described it and that he did not want her to know what had happened, because ignorance was bliss.
She went to the police early in 1999, about three and a half years after the deaths. In March 1999 she gave a formal statement and received a grant of immunity for her testimony.
Her statement led to the case being reopened. Investigators returned to the physical evidence and to photographs taken by one of the first officers to respond, and they concluded that the evidence could not be reconciled with Winger's account. They also returned to the evidence that the driver had come that afternoon for a meeting arranged with Winger.
On August 23, 2001, a Sangamon County grand jury returned a six-count indictment charging Winger with the first degree murders of his wife and of the driver under sections 9-1(a)(1) and (a)(2) of the Illinois Criminal Code. He pleaded not guilty.
The trial opened in Sangamon County Circuit Court on May 20, 2002, nearly seven years after the deaths, and ran for about three weeks. The State's theory was that Winger had killed his wife and had tried to frame the second man by claiming to have found him attacking her. Winger's position was that he had seen exactly what he told police he saw.
Both sides called experts, and they disagreed sharply about what the physical evidence showed. The State's expert testified that the evidence was inconsistent with Winger's account; the defense expert testified that it was consistent with the version Winger had given the detective on August 29, 1995. The defense attacked the credibility of the friend, who was the only new witness and who testified under immunity. It also pointed out that police had possessed the photographs and the evidence of the meeting since 1995.
The van company's owner testified that Winger had complained about the driver and had asked to speak with him directly. Winger did not testify.
The jury deliberated for 13 hours. On June 5, 2002, it found him guilty of the first degree murders of both victims. On August 1, 2002, the trial court sentenced Winger to a term of natural life in prison. He has maintained his innocence ever since.
On direct appeal to the Fourth District of the Illinois Appellate Court, Winger argued that the State had failed to prove him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the failure to record jury selection had denied him a fair trial. On May 14, 2004, the Fourth District affirmed the conviction and sentence in an unpublished order. In October 2004 the Illinois Supreme Court denied his petition for leave to appeal.
While serving his sentence, Winger was charged with trying to arrange new killings: in the spring of 2005 a fellow inmate told the authorities that Winger had tried to recruit him to have two people killed, one of them the friend who had testified against him. In June 2007 a jury in Pontiac, Illinois, convicted him of solicitation of murder after deliberating less than three hours, and he was sentenced to 35 more years.
In March 2005 Winger filed a petition under the Illinois Post-Conviction Hearing Act, claiming that his trial lawyers had been ineffective in their handling of the State's expert and of the friend, and that his appellate lawyers had been ineffective for not raising those issues. The trial court dismissed it in November 2007, and on August 7, 2009, the Fourth District affirmed in an unpublished order.
He also asked, in March 2005, for further testing of the trial evidence under section 116-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In July 2005 the trial court denied the motion, finding that the methods used before trial had been state of the art and that more testing would be cumulative and not materially relevant, and on August 28, 2007, the Fourth District affirmed in an unpublished order.
Two more rounds of filings reached the appellate court together: a 2008 motion for testing by a newer method, a 2009 petition for relief from judgment under section 2-1401 of the Code of Civil Procedure (claiming that the friend was an undisclosed accomplice, that two jurors had lied during jury selection, and that a police sergeant had lied about why the case was reopened), and a 2014 petition claiming that the State's expert had described the killing differently after trial. The trial court denied or dismissed all three.
The Fourth District consolidated the three appeals and affirmed on November 8, 2016, in an unpublished order. On the testing motion, it did not decide the disputed questions of identity and chain of custody. It held that even if those were resolved in his favor, the testing he wanted could not significantly advance a claim of actual innocence, because the State's case had rested on far more than laboratory evidence: on his statements to the friend before and after the killings, on the physical evidence compared with his own account, and on the evidence that the driver had a prearranged meeting with him.
On the 2009 petition, the court held that his juror claim was barred by the two-year limit in section 2-1401. He had not shown when he learned the facts, so he had shown neither diligence nor timeliness. Even if the petition had been timely, the court held, it failed on its own terms: the only affidavit was his own and rested on hearsay.
On the 2014 petition, the appellate court agreed with Winger that the trial court had been wrong to say it lacked jurisdiction, since a petition under section 2-1401 is a new action. It affirmed anyway, on a ground the record supported: he had raised the identical claim in his motion to reconsider the dismissal of the 2009 petition, so the doctrine of res judicata barred it.
Winger also took a case to the federal courts. The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit decided his appeal on April 8, 2013, and denied rehearing on May 14, 2013. On January 21, 2014, the Supreme Court of the United States denied his petition for a writ of certiorari, and on March 24, 2014, it denied rehearing.
Winger is serving natural life without the possibility of parole in the Illinois prison system, with the 35-year solicitation sentence added. As of April 2025 he remained imprisoned and continued to maintain his innocence.
Winger has never accepted the verdict. His account, from his statement to police on August 29, 1995, through his later petitions, is that he found the driver attacking his wife and killed him in her defense; the jury rejected it, and the courts have upheld the verdict.
His claims that the friend was an accomplice, that a juror concealed a family tie to a State witness, that a police sergeant lied about why the case was reopened, and that the State's expert and a detective worked together to secure the conviction were raised in his petitions for relief from judgment. None was ever found proven. The appellate court rejected them on the time limit, on the lack of supporting affidavits and on res judicata, without deciding whether any of them was true.
The friend was never charged. She testified under a grant of immunity, and the defense challenged her reliability at trial; the jury convicted.
1989: Winger marries; the couple settles in Springfield, Illinois.
Summer 1995: Winger complains to a van company about the driver who took his wife home from the St. Louis airport.
August 29, 1995: Winger's wife and the driver die in Springfield; Winger tells police he acted in her defense.
Late August 1995: The prosecutor rules the driver's death self-defense and files no charges.
March 1999: His wife's friend gives police a formal statement and receives immunity.
August 23, 2001: A Sangamon County grand jury indicts him on six counts of first degree murder.
May 20, 2002: Trial opens in Sangamon County Circuit Court.
June 5, 2002: The jury finds him guilty of both murders.
August 1, 2002: Sentenced to natural life in prison.
May 14, 2004: The Fourth District affirms on direct appeal.
October 2004: The Illinois Supreme Court denies leave to appeal.
June 2007: Convicted in Pontiac of solicitation of murder; sentenced to 35 more years.
August 7, 2009: The Fourth District affirms the dismissal of his post-conviction petition.
April 8, 2013: The Seventh Circuit decides his federal appeal.
January 21, 2014: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari.
November 8, 2016: The Fourth District affirms in a consolidated order.
April 2025: He remains imprisoned in Illinois and maintains his innocence.