On February 22, 2008, a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London found Mark Philip Dixie guilty of the murder of Sally Anne Bowman. She was 18 years old and lived in south Croydon, and she died there on September 25, 2005. The verdict was unanimous. Dixie, a pub chef and the father of three children, had denied murder from the start. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 34 years.
The verdict did not close the case. A year later the Court of Appeal refused him permission to challenge the conviction. In January 2015 he admitted to detectives that he had killed her. By then a Spanish court had reopened a 2003 case on the Costa del Sol in which another man had already served more than a decade, after evidence pointed to Dixie. And in 2017, by then in his forties, he pleaded guilty to two attacks on women in Croydon, one committed when he was 16 and one in 2002, and received two more life sentences.
Dixie's first serious offense was in Croydon. In 1987, at the age of 16, he committed a rape in the borough. She survived, but no one was charged at the time. He admitted the offense only after his murder conviction, and he pleaded guilty to it in 2017, three decades later.
The following year he was before the courts for a different attack. In 1988 he assaulted a woman, pleaded guilty to indecent assault and to assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and was sentenced to six months' youth custody. Twenty years later he told the jury in his murder trial that the 1988 assault had not been sexual and that he had pleaded guilty only to avoid a more serious charge. That conviction became the center of his appeal.
In the 1990s Dixie lived in Australia. He spent about six years in the country, the last three of them in Western Australia, and he was deported in 1999 for overstaying his visa. A sexual assault on a woman in Perth in 1998 was later linked to him by evidence. He was never tried for it in Australia or anywhere else, but the judges in his murder trial allowed the jury to hear about it.
In 2002 he attacked another woman in Croydon and indecently assaulted her. She survived. Like the earlier rape, the case went unsolved until his own confession years later.
From late 2002 until October 2003 he lived and worked on the Costa del Sol in southern Spain. On August 10, 2003, three women were attacked in Fuengirola. A Dutch man living in the town was arrested the following month, and in 2005 a provincial court in Málaga convicted him of all three attacks and sentenced him to 15 and a half years in total. He maintained throughout that he was innocent. The question of who had committed one of the Fuengirola attacks would come back to Dixie in 2014.
The young woman at the center of the murder case lived in south Croydon, in the London Borough of Croydon, and she died there on Sunday, September 25, 2005. The Metropolitan Police Service led the murder inquiry, and for nine months it produced no charge.
Then, in June 2006, evidence taken from Dixie after an unrelated incident linked him to the killing. On June 27, 2006, officers arrested him in Horley, Surrey, where he was then working as a chef. In interview he answered "no comment" to every question. He was charged with murder and remanded in custody. The charges also included two separate allegations dating from July 15, 2001: indecently assaulting a woman in Purley, south of Croydon, and outraging public decency.
Dixie was 36 when he first appeared at the Old Bailey, on October 6, 2006. The trial did not begin until February 2008. Before it started, the Recorder of London heard argument about his past. The prosecution wanted the jury to hear about two earlier episodes: the 1988 conviction and the 1998 offense in Australia for which he had never been tried. The Crown's case was that both showed a tendency to commit violent offenses in order to achieve or heighten sexual gratification. The defense argued that the 1988 episode was too old, too different and too minor to show any relevant tendency. The Recorder ruled both admissible as evidence of propensity, and when the trial judge looked at the 1988 conviction again, he found that nothing had changed.
Dixie denied murder and gave evidence in his own defense. The woman attacked in Perth gave evidence too; British investigators had worked with the Australian authorities so that her evidence could be put before a jury in London. Under cross-examination Dixie was asked about the 1988 conviction and his explanation for his guilty plea. On February 22, 2008, the jury found him guilty of murder. The judge sentenced him to life imprisonment and set a minimum term of 34 years, the period he must serve before the Parole Board can consider his case.
Dixie needed the leave of the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) to challenge the conviction. His central argument was that the jury should never have been told about the 1988 attack, 20 years earlier, and that hearing about it had prejudiced the trial. A single judge refused leave, and he renewed the application before the full court without counsel. It was heard at the Royal Courts of Justice in London on February 3, 2009, and the judgment is cited as R v Dixie [2009] EWCA Crim 188.
The court found that both the Recorder and the trial judge had weighed the time that had passed, Dixie's age in 1988 and the less serious nature of that offense, and that their decision was neither demonstrably wrong nor unreasonable. It found that the 1988 episode had not taken an unduly prominent place at trial: once Dixie chose to explain away his guilty plea in evidence, cross-examination about it was inevitable. It found the prosecution's closing speech and the judge's summing-up fair and accurate. Further grounds he raised himself, that the Crown had misled the jury over photographic evidence and that press coverage had made a fair trial impossible, did not help him. The court found the application entirely without merit and refused it. The conviction and the 34-year minimum term stood.
For almost seven years after the verdict, Dixie kept to the position he had taken before the jury. In January 2015 that changed. He wrote to the police saying he wanted to tell the truth about her death, and when detectives interviewed him that month he admitted that he had killed her. The admission altered nothing in law, since the conviction was already final, but it ended his denial.
While serving his sentence he also confessed to two other attacks on women, the 1987 rape and the 2002 attack in Croydon. Both women were found, and proceedings were brought against him.
The Fuengirola case was reopened in September 2014; evidence had linked Dixie to the attacks as early as 2007. A British police report reached the court in Fuengirola in February 2015, and the Dutch man's lawyers used it to ask Spain's Supreme Court, the Tribunal Supremo, to review his conviction. In June 2015 a foundation that supports Dutch prisoners held abroad, and had raised money for the Dutch man's defense, said that Dixie had confessed to one of the attacks and could not remember the other two.
On February 10, 2016, the Supreme Court's criminal chamber partly granted the review. It annulled the sentence of six years and six months imposed on the Dutch man for the sexual assault and injury of one of the three women, holding that newer scientific evidence excluded his participation in that assault, and it ordered that the case concerning her be investigated again, without prejudice to proceedings against Mark Philip Dixie. The Dutch man's convictions for the attacks on the other two women, carrying nine years in total, were upheld, and he walked free that month after about 12 years in custody. Dixie has never been charged in Spain. The ruling cleared another man of one offense; it did not convict Dixie of it.
On July 26, 2017, Dixie, then 46, appeared at Southwark Crown Court in London by video link and pleaded guilty to rape, indecent assault and causing grievous bodily harm with intent. The rape was the 1987 offense in Croydon; the indecent assault and the grievous bodily harm were the 2002 attack in the same borough. In November 2017 the court imposed two further life sentences, one for the rape and one for causing grievous bodily harm with intent, with a minimum term of 28 years. Under them he cannot apply for parole until 2044.
As of May 2021 Dixie was serving life in England. He has never been tried in Australia or Spain for the offenses linked to him there.
Dixie denied the murder at trial and for almost seven years afterward; he admitted it to detectives in January 2015. The jury's verdict rested on the evidence at trial, not on that later admission.
The year of the first Croydon rape is given as 1987 in reports of the 2017 plea; a later wire report gives 1986.
The 1998 offense in Perth was linked to him by evidence and was put before the jury as evidence of propensity, but he was never charged with it or tried for it, and no court has convicted him of it.
The Fuengirola attack of August 2003 has never been tried against Dixie. His admission to the rape was relayed in 2015 by the foundation that supported the Dutch man, and the Spanish Supreme Court left open, without deciding, whether proceedings against him should follow.
The outcome of the 2001 Purley allegations included in the 2006 charges is not on record.
1987: Dixie, 16, commits a rape in Croydon; he pleads guilty to it in 2017.
1988: He pleads guilty to indecent assault and assault occasioning actual bodily harm; six months' youth custody.
1990s: Lives in Australia for about six years, the last three in Western Australia.
1998: A sexual assault in Perth later linked to him by evidence; never tried.
1999: Deported from Australia for overstaying his visa.
July 15, 2001: Date of the Purley allegations later charged in 2006.
2002: Attack on another woman in Croydon; he pleads guilty to it in 2017.
Late 2002 to October 2003: Lives and works on the Costa del Sol, Spain.
August 10, 2003: Three women attacked in Fuengirola; a Dutch man is convicted in 2005.
September 25, 2005: The murder in south Croydon.
June 27, 2006: Dixie arrested in Horley, Surrey, and charged with murder.
February 22, 2008: Unanimous guilty verdict at the Central Criminal Court; life imprisonment with a minimum term of 34 years.
February 3, 2009: Court of Appeal refuses the renewed application for leave to appeal, [2009] EWCA Crim 188.
September 2014: The Fuengirola case reopened.
January 2015: Dixie admits the murder to detectives.
February 10, 2016: Spanish Supreme Court annuls one of the Dutch man's sentences; he walks free that month.
July 26, 2017: Guilty pleas at Southwark Crown Court to rape, indecent assault and causing grievous bodily harm with intent.
November 2017: Two further life sentences, minimum term 28 years.
May 2021: Serving life in England.