Marion Albert Pruett was serving a 23-year federal sentence for bank robbery when the government let him go in 1979. According to the federal appeals court that later heard his case, the release was apparently given in exchange for his testimony against an underworld figure he had served time with. He was placed in the Federal Witness Protection Program and settled in New Mexico under an assumed identity, with his wife, Pamela Sue Carnuteson.
Within two years, five people were dead. His wife was found murdered in April 1981. A savings and loan officer, Peggy Lowe, was taken hostage in a robbery in Jackson, Mississippi, and shot. In Fort Smith, Arkansas, a convenience store clerk named Bobbie Jean Robertson was robbed, driven away from her store and shot. Four days after that, two store clerks, James R. Balderson and Anthony Taitt, were shot in separate robberies in two Colorado cities on the same day. Pruett was convicted of every one of those killings, in four states, and of federal robbery and abduction charges besides. He was executed in Arkansas at the age of 49.
His case became known for two things: the failure of the witness program that had given him a new name, and the label he gave himself. Held in a Mississippi jail in October 1981, he told reporters he was a "mad dog killer." The phrase followed him through every trial and into the federal courts, where it became part of the legal argument over whether he could get a fair trial anywhere.
Almost nothing is known of Pruett's early life; his history begins with the bank robbery sentence. In 1979, the Eighth Circuit wrote, he "was released from a 23-year federal penitentiary sentence for bank robbery." The court added that the release was "apparently" in return for testimony against an underworld figure who had been in prison with him. His date and place of birth were not reported; he was 49 when he died.
After his release he went into the Federal Witness Protection Program and lived in New Mexico under a name that was not his own. His wife lived there with him. The program's records later became an issue at his New Mexico trial, when his lawyers tried and failed to get documents from it in time.
Pamela Sue Carnuteson was Pruett's wife and lived with him in New Mexico while he was in the witness program. She was found murdered in April 1981. According to the Eighth Circuit, Pruett left before investigators had gathered enough evidence against him and set out on a run of armed robberies, abductions and killings across several states.
He was tried for her murder in New Mexico only after the other states had dealt with him. He was arraigned there on September 14, 1982, and said he would represent himself with help from the public defender. The trial was first set for December 13, 1982; after a conflict led the court to appoint new counsel, it was moved to February 7, 1983.
The defense built its case around an anonymous tip. A Crimestoppers informant had named another man as the killer, and that man became the State's principal witness at trial. Pruett argued that he had been rushed to trial before the informant could be identified, and so had lost the chance to use the tip to attack the witness's testimony. He also said the short time before trial had kept him from getting FBI reports and witness program documents, which arrived only after the verdict.
The jury convicted him of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. On January 31, 1984, the Supreme Court of New Mexico affirmed. Justice Walters wrote that eight weeks between the appointment of counsel and trial was reasonable and that the defense had not shown due diligence in seeking the federal records. A defendant who claims a continuance was wrongly refused, the court said, must show "not only" an abuse of discretion "but that it was to his injury or prejudice."
The court also upheld the use of a confession Pruett had given to a police officer in Jackson, Mississippi. Pruett testified that he would have said anything to get cocaine and that he had been promised a supply in return for confessing. The officer testified that Pruett was read his rights, refused to sign a waiver, and then confessed to several crimes, this one among them. The trial judge believed the officer, and the Supreme Court found the evidence enough to support that finding.
Peggy Lowe was a loan officer at a savings and loan office in Jackson, Mississippi. Her last morning was described in testimony at Pruett's Arkansas sentencing hearing in 1982.
A teller who was working that day testified in Arkansas about the robbery. A gunman came in and threatened to kill the employees if an alarm went off. He demanded $100,000 from the vault. The manager told him there was only about $10,000 there, and he told her to collect it. He chose Peggy Lowe as his hostage. She went to her office, where she took a telephone call from her son, and then put the money into a sack the gunman had given her. He left with the money and with her.
Sergeant O. T. McAlphin of the Jackson police testified that Pruett confessed to shooting Peggy Lowe and helped the police find her. She died of a gunshot wound.
Pruett pleaded guilty in federal court to robbing a federally insured savings and loan and abducting Peggy Lowe, offenses under 18 U.S.C. 2113, and received consecutive sentences of 25 years and life. Mississippi tried him separately for her murder.
Bobbie Jean Robertson worked the overnight shift, 11 p.m. to 7 a.m., at a convenience store in Fort Smith, Arkansas.
The Eighth Circuit set out the night of her death from the record. Pruett arrived in Fort Smith on Sunday, October 11, 1981, looking for a place to rob. He spent several hours taking cocaine and drinking whiskey. After midnight he went to the store, where the clerk was working alone. In his later confession he said: "I pulled in and was going to get gas and I seen that there was a girl working there by herself." He robbed the store at gunpoint, abducted her and shot her, taking about $165. She was found the next day. Press reports at his execution dated her killing October 12, 1981.
James R. Balderson and Anthony Taitt were store clerks. Each was shot during a robbery, in two different Colorado cities on the same day. The press later reported that the Colorado killings came four days after Robertson's death. The two cities have not been reported.
Pruett's run ended at a roadside. According to the Arkansas Supreme Court, an officer in Texas stopped him for speeding. He could not produce a driver's license, so the officer asked for the registration. When Pruett opened the passenger door to look in the glove compartment, the officer saw drug paraphernalia inside and a strap under the front seat that he recognized as part of a gun holster. The holster held Pruett's .38 caliber revolver. He was arrested for speeding, driving without a license and possessing drug paraphernalia. The court later ruled the gun and the paraphernalia were lawfully seized in plain view, so ballistics evidence from the revolver could be used against him.
He was returned to Mississippi and charged in state court with Peggy Lowe's murder.
On October 28, 1981, Pruett held a televised press conference in Mississippi and called himself a "mad dog killer." The Arkansas Supreme Court noted that the statement was not introduced at his Arkansas trial, but its effect on the trial became one of the main questions in the long appeals that followed.
The Eighth Circuit described how the phrase spread. While he waited for trial in Mississippi, Pruett "elected to make several statements" to newspaper and television reporters, admitting to various crimes and labeling himself a "mad-dog killer." A videotape of the statement was reportedly played several times by nearly every local television station and many radio stations. A defense expert told the federal court that it became common to describe Pruett as a "self-confessed mad-dog killer."
The investigation of the Arkansas case went on from Mississippi. On November 8, 1981, an officer from Fort Smith traveled to Mississippi and took a statement from Pruett after giving him the Miranda warnings. An edited version was admitted at his Arkansas trial. While he was awaiting the Mississippi trial, Pruett also gave Detective Larry Hammond of the Fort Smith Police Department a detailed confession to Robertson's killing.
A Mississippi jury convicted Pruett of Peggy Lowe's murder and sentenced him to death. The Supreme Court of Mississippi affirmed the conviction and sentence in 1983, in Pruett v. State, 431 So. 2d 1101, and a later petition for a writ of error coram nobis was denied.
The death sentence did not stand. A federal district court in Mississippi granted Pruett a new trial because a biased juror had served on the jury. He was retried in February 1988 and convicted again of Peggy Lowe's murder, but the jury could not agree on a penalty, and the court imposed a life sentence.
After the first Mississippi verdict, Pruett was transferred to federal custody and sent to Colorado. He pleaded guilty there to the murders of James R. Balderson and Anthony Taitt and received consecutive life sentences.
Pruett was then returned to Arkansas to answer for Bobbie Jean Robertson's death. He was arraigned on a capital murder charge in the circuit court of Sebastian County and pleaded not guilty. The Eighth Circuit gave the date as June 12, 1982; the Arkansas Supreme Court gave June 14. The public defender was appointed, but Pruett asked to represent himself, and the court assigned counsel to stand by and advise him.
The court set trial for August 30, 1982. Pruett objected that he needed time to work on the appeal of his Mississippi death sentence, and his appointed lawyer was handling another death penalty appeal at the same time. The court refused to delay the trial, though it said it would grant delays in other cases involving the public defender. "We cannot appreciably slow the flow of the criminal justice system to accommodate overworked attorneys or judges," the Arkansas Supreme Court later wrote.
Because of the publicity in Sebastian County, the court moved the trial to Van Buren, in neighboring Crawford County, which lies in the same judicial district. Requests for a second change of venue, for a new jury panel and for more time were denied. Jury selection took days. The first panel ran out after five days; the first eleven jurors came from a 65-member panel, and eight more people from a supplemental panel were questioned before the twelfth juror was seated. Twenty-six prospective jurors were excused because they had formed opinions or knew about the case, and six because they would always vote for death. Pruett used all his peremptory challenges and said he had to accept jurors he would otherwise have struck. Circuit Judge Robert E. Boyer presided.
The defense wanted a physician as a witness but learned the doctor's name only after jury selection had ended, and the doctor could not come to court. His expected testimony reached the jury through statements by Pruett's lawyer.
Pruett gave his own closing argument. In it he admitted killing Bobbie Jean Robertson but argued that he was not responsible because he had been intoxicated. On September 9, 1982, the jury convicted him of capital murder.
At the penalty phase, the State relied on two aggravating circumstances: that he had previously committed another felony involving violence or the threat of violence, and that he had killed Robertson for pecuniary gain. To prove the first, it called the teller and Sergeant McAlphin to describe the Jackson robbery and Peggy Lowe's death, and introduced records of Pruett's federal guilty pleas to armed robbery and kidnapping. The defense called Detective Hammond and a clinical psychologist, Dr. Douglas A. Stevens, who testified that cocaine and amphetamine psychosis had left Pruett "not clearly in contact with reality" at the time of the killing. Pruett did not testify. When the prosecutor asked the psychologist, "Do you put your patients under oath when you talk to them," the defense called it an improper comment on Pruett's silence and asked for a mistrial, which was refused.
The jury found some evidence that drug abuse had impaired Pruett's mental capacity, but found that no mitigating circumstance existed at the time of the murder. It unanimously found that the aggravating circumstances outweighed any mitigation beyond a reasonable doubt and sentenced him to death by electrocution. The court set the execution for March 10, 1983. He was then sent to New Mexico for trial in his wife's death, and afterward returned to Mississippi custody.
The Arkansas Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and death sentence on April 30, 1984, in an opinion by Justice John I. Purtle that dealt with 21 points of appeal. It upheld the change of venue to Crawford County, the refusal to sequester the jury, the denial of a continuance, the death qualification of the jury, the use of the Mississippi statement, and the seizure of the revolver. It said only three of the twelve jurors had known about the case. On the prosecutor's question to the psychologist, the court said the remark was arguably a comment on Pruett's silence but found no prejudice, while warning that such statements should be avoided.
Chief Justice Adkisson and Justice Hickman wrote separate concurrences on whether the court should keep comparing death sentences across cases; Justice Hollingsworth dissented on the death qualification issue alone, saying Pruett should have been allowed to try to prove that jurors who accept the death penalty are more likely to convict. Rehearing was denied on June 18, 1984.
Pruett then asked for postconviction relief under the state's Rule 37. By then he was held in Mississippi under the Mississippi death sentence and had never been committed to the Arkansas Department of Correction. On October 7, 1985, the Arkansas Supreme Court held that he could still seek relief and denied his petition. It rejected his claims about two jurors, one of whom later said he had been pressured and had suffered from mental illness, noting that "there is a strong presumption that jurors are unbiased." It also rejected the claims that his trial lawyer had been ineffective.
In June 1987, Governor Bill Clinton demanded Pruett's return to Arkansas to face execution. In March 1988, after the Mississippi retrial, Pruett was extradited from Mississippi to Arkansas, placed in the Department of Correction, and scheduled to die on April 7, 1988. On April 4, 1988, he filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in federal court under 28 U.S.C. 2254, and the district court stayed the execution the same day.
The case stayed in federal court for about nine years. In 1988 Pruett's lawyers learned that the teller had been hypnotized in September 1981 during the FBI's investigation of the Jackson robbery. The district court found that the State did not know this at the time of sentencing. After an evidentiary hearing in December 1994, the court compared the teller's statements and found her account after hypnosis more detailed and embellished, adding a gun held at Peggy Lowe's back and the call from her son.
In 1997 the district court granted the petition (Pruett v. Norris, 959 F. Supp. 1066). It held that pretrial publicity, together with the refusal of a second change of venue and a continuance, had denied Pruett a fair trial, and that the use of hypnotically refreshed testimony at the penalty phase violated his right to confront the witnesses against him. It vacated the conviction and sentence and ordered Arkansas to release or retry him within 120 days. It rejected fourteen other claims and his challenge to the extradition. When the State appealed, the Eighth Circuit stayed the order.
On August 7, 1998, a panel of the Eighth Circuit, Circuit Judges Wollman and Loken and District Judge Andrew W. Bogue of South Dakota, reversed and sent the case back with instructions to dismiss the petition. Judge Wollman wrote the opinion.
On publicity, the court found that Pruett himself had invited much of it. Most coverage came in the weeks after Robertson's death, roughly ten months before trial, and the trial began about eleven months after the crime. The district court had found that 22 of 77 potential jurors, 29 percent, said they probably could not be impartial, and that eleven of the twelve seated jurors had some prior exposure to the facts. The appeals court held that this did not show the deep and bitter prejudice needed to presume an unfair trial, and that each juror had sworn to be impartial. Pruett's own trial lawyer had testified that he was "disappointed it was not as extensive as I had been afraid it would be." The court wrote: "The accused is not entitled to an ignorant jury, just a fair one."
On the hypnosis claim, the court assumed without deciding that there was a confrontation violation and held that it did not matter. The gun at Lowe's back added little, since the threat to the employees and McAlphin's testimony already proved the robbery was armed, and the phone call mattered even less. Any error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. The court also rejected Pruett's cross-appeal, which argued that the jury should have been told it had to find "reckless indifference to human life" under Tison v. Arizona; the Arkansas instruction requiring "extreme indifference to the value of human life" was enough.
The Tampa Bay Times later summarized the ruling: the appeals court had reinstated the conviction and death sentence, finding that Pruett had helped create the publicity by confessing to crimes and adopting the "mad-dog" name.
Pruett was executed in Arkansas for the murder of Bobbie Jean Robertson. He was 49. The Tampa Bay Times, reporting the execution, noted that he had received life sentences for the killings outside Arkansas and that only the Arkansas conviction carried a death sentence.
The reason for his 1979 release. The Eighth Circuit said Pruett was released "apparently" in exchange for testimony against an underworld figure he had served time with. The court did not name the man or say what the testimony concerned, and the arrangement has not been described further.
His wife's death. Pruett was convicted of murdering Pamela Sue Carnuteson. At trial his defense pointed to a Crimestoppers tip naming another man, who testified for the State. The jury and the Supreme Court of New Mexico rejected his arguments, and the conviction stands.
The confessions. Pruett said he confessed to a Jackson officer because he wanted cocaine and was promised it. The New Mexico courts believed the officer, who denied it. In Arkansas the courts found his November 1981 statement voluntary despite conflicting testimony.
The hypnosis. Whether the teller's hypnosis changed her testimony about the Jackson robbery was disputed for a decade. The district court thought it did; the Eighth Circuit held that the changes were minor and harmless.
1979: Pruett is released from a 23-year federal bank robbery sentence and placed in the Federal Witness Protection Program in New Mexico.
April 1981: his wife, Pamela Sue Carnuteson, is found murdered in New Mexico.
1981: Peggy Lowe is taken hostage during a savings and loan robbery in Jackson, Mississippi, and shot.
October 11, 1981: Pruett arrives in Fort Smith, Arkansas.
October 12, 1981: Bobbie Jean Robertson, an overnight clerk, is killed after a robbery in Fort Smith.
Four days later: store clerks James R. Balderson and Anthony Taitt are shot in separate robberies in two Colorado cities.
1981: stopped for speeding in Texas and arrested; returned to Mississippi.
October 28, 1981: calls himself a "mad dog killer" at a televised press conference in Mississippi.
November 8, 1981: a Fort Smith officer takes his statement in Mississippi.
1981 to 1982: convicted in Mississippi of Peggy Lowe's murder and sentenced to death; pleads guilty in Colorado to the Balderson and Taitt murders (consecutive life terms); pleads guilty to federal robbery and abduction charges (25 years and life).
June 1982: arraigned in Sebastian County, Arkansas, on a capital murder charge.
August 30, 1982: jury selection begins in Van Buren, Crawford County.
September 9, 1982: convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death by electrocution.
February 7, 1983: date set for his New Mexico trial; he is convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life.
1983: the Supreme Court of Mississippi affirms the Mississippi conviction and death sentence.
January 31, 1984: the Supreme Court of New Mexico affirms.
April 30, 1984: the Arkansas Supreme Court affirms; rehearing denied June 18, 1984.
October 7, 1985: Arkansas postconviction petition denied.
June 1987: Governor Bill Clinton demands his return to Arkansas.
February 1988: retried in Mississippi, convicted again, sentenced to life after the penalty jury deadlocks.
March 1988: extradited to Arkansas; execution set for April 7, 1988.
April 4, 1988: federal habeas petition filed; execution stayed.
December 1994: evidentiary hearing in federal district court.
1997: district court vacates the Arkansas conviction and sentence.
August 7, 1998: the Eighth Circuit reverses and orders the petition dismissed.
After the 1998 ruling: executed in Arkansas, aged 49.