Mario Jascalevich

Victims
5 patient deaths charged in Oradell; acquitted, 1978. Indicted in 1976 for allegedly murdering five patients who died in 1965 and 1966; acquitted of all charges, October 1978
Years active
1965 to 1966 (deaths charged); indicted May 1976; trial 1978; acquitted October 1978
Location
Oradell and Hackensack, New Jersey, USA
Method
Murder (five counts in the indictment); acquitted of all charges
Status
Acquitted of all charges by a jury after less than three hours of deliberation, October 1978

Mario Jascalevich was a surgeon from Argentina who had built a career in the suburbs of northern New Jersey. In the middle of the 1960s he was chief surgeon at a small hospital in Oradell, a borough in Bergen County, and in 1965 and 1966 a series of patients there died in ways that the hospital and its doctors could not explain. An inquiry in 1966 ended without charges. A decade later the deaths were taken up again, and in May 1976 a grand jury indicted him for allegedly murdering five of those patients. He pleaded not guilty. His trial in Hackensack began in 1978 and ran into the fall, and in the last week of October 1978 the jury, after less than three hours of deliberation, acquitted him of all charges.

He was never convicted of any killing. The deaths of the five patients named in the indictment have never been attributed by any court to anyone, and the verdict of 1978 is the last word the criminal law spoke on them.

Jascalevich was Argentine-born and trained as a surgeon. By the time the case against him was revived he was 48 years old and still operating, and he was performing surgery at two other New Jersey hospitals. In Oradell he had held the post of chief surgeon.

The deaths began in December 1965 and ran on through 1966. More than a dozen patients of that hospital died in those months in circumstances that seemed to have no medical explanation, and by the time the case was revived the count stood at thirteen. In 1966 a younger doctor at the hospital acted on his suspicions of the chief surgeon, and the hospital's directors were told.

The matter then passed to the Bergen County prosecutor's office. The county prosecutor of the day questioned the surgeon himself. What his office had in hand was not, in its judgment, enough to press a charge, and the inquiry was dropped. No charge of homicide was brought against anyone.

Early in 1967 the surgeon left the Oradell hospital. He went on practicing medicine elsewhere in New Jersey, and for most of the following decade the case was nearly forgotten.

The indictment of 1976 named five patients, all of whom had died at the Oradell hospital in 1965 or 1966 while in its care. The prosecution's case was that each death was a murder and that the surgeon had caused it. The defense's case was that none of the five had been murdered at all, and that the man on trial had been made the subject of a frame-up.

The jury heard both cases. Its verdict did not declare what had happened to the five patients. It found only that the state had not proved that Jascalevich murdered any of them.

The road back began in 1975, when a source with knowledge of the hospital approached a reporter at a New York newspaper. The reporter spent months on the story, questioning doctors and local officials about what had happened at Oradell nearly ten years before.

The case returned to public view in early 1976, when the newspaper published his series of articles about the deaths. The articles did not name the surgeon at first. They led the state of New Jersey to reopen its investigation. The Bergen County prosecutor's office, now under a new prosecutor, took the file up again, and the prosecutor led the renewed inquiry himself, going to the court for the authority each step required. By spring the case was before a grand jury in Bergen County.

The investigation moved quickly once it had resumed, and in May 1976 a grand jury returned an indictment charging Jascalevich with murdering all five. He appeared for arraignment and pleaded not guilty. He was released on $150,000 bail to await trial, and he went on practicing surgery at the two hospitals where he still held privileges, since nothing in the indictment itself removed his license.

The charges were murder, five times over, for five deaths that had occurred ten and eleven years before the grand jury sat.

The case was assigned to the Superior Court of New Jersey in Bergen County, which sits in Hackensack, the county seat. A trial judge of that court presided over the murder trial from its opening to the verdict.

Jury selection and the trial opened on February 28, 1978, in the Superior Court in Hackensack, and eighteen jurors were seated to hear the case. By the end of July the trial was in its fifth month, and by the time a second ruling on the defense's demands for evidence was entered it had run for about 22 weeks. The jury did not receive the case until late October, after some 34 weeks of trial.

The prosecution presented its evidence that the five patients had been murdered and that the chief surgeon was responsible. The defense met that case point by point and called 21 expert witnesses of its own, one of whom traveled from Sweden to testify. Its central theme was that the case against him had been manufactured. Jascalevich did not need to prove any of this, and the burden stayed on the state throughout.

For much of the trial the defendant himself was in the background. A dispute over the reporter's files took over the second half of the proceedings and drew more attention than the evidence about the deaths. The jury, however, was asked to decide only the charges against the surgeon.

During the trial the defense subpoenaed the reporter's files on the case. When the reporter and his newspaper refused to produce them, the reporter was jailed for contempt; he was released during the jury's deliberations.

The case went to the jury in the last week of October 1978. The jurors deliberated for less than three hours. Their verdict was unanimous, and it acquitted Jascalevich of all charges.

The acquittal ended the criminal case, more than two years after the indictment and twelve years after the first inquiry had closed.

The central point is not disputed in law. Jascalevich was charged with murdering five patients and was acquitted of all charges. He was never found responsible for any death. The state's theory that the deaths were murders was never accepted by a jury, and the defense theory that the case was a frame-up was never tested as a finding of fact, because the jury needed only to find the state's proof insufficient.

The total number of unexplained deaths at the Oradell hospital in 1965 and 1966 was given as more than a dozen in 1976 and as thirteen in 1978. Only five were ever charged.

Timeline

December 1965 to 1966: More than a dozen patients die at a small hospital in Oradell, New Jersey, where Jascalevich is chief surgeon.

1966: The Bergen County prosecutor's office looks into the deaths; the inquiry is dropped without charges.

Early 1967: Jascalevich leaves the Oradell hospital.

1975: A reporter begins looking into the deaths.

Early 1976: A series of newspaper articles leads New Jersey to reopen the investigation.

May 1976: A grand jury indicts Jascalevich for allegedly murdering five patients; he pleads not guilty and is released on $150,000 bail.

February 28, 1978: Jury selection and the trial open in the Superior Court of New Jersey in Bergen County, in Hackensack.

July 1978: A reporter who refused a defense subpoena is jailed for contempt.

Last week of October 1978: After less than three hours of deliberation, the jury acquits Jascalevich of all charges.