Manu Sharma

Victims
1 murder: Jessica Lal, Delhi, April 30, 1999. Convicted of murder, criminal conspiracy and an arms law offense by the Delhi High Court, December 18, 2006
Years active
April 29 to 30, 1999
Location
Mehrauli, south Delhi, India (killing); Chandigarh, India (surrender); New Delhi, India (trial and appeals)
Method
Shot (Delhi High Court and Supreme Court findings)
Status
Life imprisonment and a fine (Delhi High Court, December 20, 2006); upheld by the Supreme Court, April 19, 2010. Released early from jail in Delhi, June 2, 2020; free as of June 2020.

In the early hours of April 30, 1999, Jessica Lal died after a private party in Mehrauli, in south Delhi, with other guests still present. The man the police charged with her murder was Manu Sharma, whose legal name is Sidhartha Vashisht. He was the son of a Congress politician from Haryana who had served as a Union minister. Within a week he was in custody, and within three months the police had filed a charge sheet against him and eleven others.

Seven years later, on February 21, 2006, a Delhi trial court acquitted Sharma and all eight co-accused who had stood trial. Key eyewitnesses had changed their accounts on the stand, and the court held that the prosecution had failed to prove its case. On the state's appeal, the Delhi High Court reversed the acquittal on December 18, 2006, convicted Sharma of murder, criminal conspiracy and an offense under the arms law, and on December 20 sentenced him to life imprisonment and a fine. The Supreme Court of India upheld the conviction and the sentence on April 19, 2010. In 2020 Delhi's Sentence Review Board recommended his early release, the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi approved it, and he walked out of jail on June 2, 2020.

The prosecution's case, which the High Court and then the Supreme Court accepted, was that Sharma killed her in front of other people at the party and left the premises immediately afterward. Two of his companions, the courts later found, helped screen him from the crime by destroying evidence.

On May 6, 1999, Sharma surrendered to the police in Chandigarh. The Delhi Police kept charge of the inquiry, and on August 3, 1999, they filed a charge sheet against Sharma and eleven others. He faced charges of murder, destruction of evidence, criminal conspiracy, harboring offenders and offenses under the arms law. The others were accused, in different combinations, of destroying evidence and of sheltering him after the killing. Two of the twelve absconded and were never brought to trial. The remaining nine went on trial in the sessions court in Delhi.

The prosecution examined 101 witnesses, and its case rested above all on the people who had been at the party. What it lost, one witness at a time, was the eyewitness evidence.

The most damaging reversal came on May 3, 2001. The complainant, a guest whose statement had started the case and who had earlier identified Sharma, told the court that Sharma was not the person responsible. Over the next months an electrician who had been working at the premises, another guest and a hotel manager also turned hostile. One witness who disavowed his statement said the police had written it down in Hindi, a language he said he barely spoke. A witness who was a citizen of Nepal could not be summoned at all.

Some witnesses held. In July and October 2001 the woman who owned the premises and her daughter each identified Sharma in court. Through these years Sharma spent long stretches out of custody on bail.

On February 21, 2006, the Additional Sessions Judge acquitted all nine accused on every charge. The court accepted that Sharma had been at the party, but held that presence alone proved nothing. It rejected the testimony of three guests as not that of true eyewitnesses, found that the evidence of the owner and her daughter did not help the prosecution, and found no proof that Sharma had absconded or that the others had sheltered him. It went further, finding that the police had set out early to frame Sharma and that photographs of the accused had been shown to witnesses before they identified them in court. The links in the chain of evidence, the court concluded, were "either missing or broken."

The verdict set off a sustained public campaign in Delhi, with candlelight marches and petitions calling for the case to be reopened. On March 13, 2006, the Delhi Police appealed the acquittals to the Delhi High Court.

The High Court heard the appeal day by day from October 2006 and gave its judgment on December 18. It reversed the acquittals of Sharma and his two companions and upheld the acquittals of the other six. It found that the trial court had misread the evidence, and it relied heavily on the accounts of the owner of the premises and her husband, corroborated by their daughter. It rejected the defense's alternative account of the killing, which rested on the complainant's changed testimony. It also weighed Sharma's own conduct: he had failed to account for evidence shown to be in his possession, and the court found false his claim that the police had taken it from him the day after the crime.

Sharma was convicted of murder, criminal conspiracy and an offense under the arms law, and he surrendered to the Delhi Police the same day. His two companions were convicted of criminal conspiracy and destruction of evidence.

On December 20, 2006, the court sentenced Sharma to life imprisonment and a fine of 50,000 rupees, to be paid to the victim's family. It considered the death penalty and rejected it, finding that the case did not fall within the "rarest of rare" category and that the killing, though intentional, had been committed without any prior motive. The two companions received four years of rigorous imprisonment each. The court also opened perjury proceedings against some 30 witnesses who had gone back on their statements at trial.

Sharma and his companions appealed to the Supreme Court of India, which refused in May 2008 to suspend his sentence while the appeal was pending. It decided the appeal on April 19, 2010, upholding the conviction and the life sentence. The court held that the High Court had given adequate reasons for reversing the acquittal, and that Sharma's presence at the scene was proved by the eyewitness evidence of seven prosecution witnesses, corroborated by three calls to the police control room. It found that the evidence, the witnesses' statements and his conduct after the killing proved his guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and it rejected his argument that the case had been planted. It also rejected his procedural complaints, holding that a delay in recording some statements did not discredit otherwise credible testimony and that the failure to give him one expert report had not prejudiced him. The four-year sentences of his companions were confirmed.

Sharma was first granted parole in September 2009 and was granted it several more times in the years that followed. In custody he completed a postgraduate diploma in human rights and enrolled in a law degree. By early 2018 he had been moved to an open section of the jail system in Delhi, the last stage before release, where he could leave each morning to work and had to return each evening.

His case went before the Sentence Review Board several times. On October 4, 2018, the board rejected his petition for early release, along with 85 others. At its meeting of May 11, 2020, it recommended his premature release, citing his good conduct inside the jail and outside it. The Lieutenant Governor of Delhi accepted the recommendation, and an order dated May 28, 2020, remitted the unexpired portion of his sentence. He was already outside the jail on emergency parole at the time, under the steps taken to reduce crowding during the coronavirus pandemic. The formalities of his release were completed on June 1, and he walked out of jail on June 2, 2020. He remained free as of June 2020.

Sharma denied the murder from the start and maintained at every stage that he had been falsely implicated. His defense put forward an alternative account of the killing, relying on the complainant's changed testimony and on expert evidence that was never settled, because the material the expert needed was never recovered. The trial court accepted the defense's view of the evidence; the High Court rejected it; and the Supreme Court, upholding the High Court, rejected the claim that the case had been planted. The conviction is final.

The allegation that witnesses had been paid or pressured to retract was made by the police and in a television investigation in 2006, and it led to the perjury proceedings. In the one perjury case whose outcome is known, the Supreme Court cleared the prosecution expert in January 2016. The trial court's finding that the police had set out to frame Sharma was reversed on appeal. Of the others named in the 1999 charge sheet, two absconded and were never tried, and the six acquitted at trial stayed acquitted.

Timeline

April 29 to 30, 1999: The killing at a private party in Mehrauli, south Delhi; the victim dies on April 30.

May 6, 1999: Sharma surrenders to the police in Chandigarh.

August 3, 1999: The Delhi Police file a charge sheet against Sharma and eleven others.

May 3, 2001: The complainant turns hostile at the trial.

July and October 2001: The owner of the premises and her daughter identify Sharma in court.

February 21, 2006: The Additional Sessions Judge acquits all nine accused.

March 13, 2006: The Delhi Police appeal to the Delhi High Court.

October 2006: Day-to-day hearings begin in the High Court.

December 18, 2006: The High Court convicts Sharma and his two companions and upholds the other six acquittals.

December 20, 2006: Sharma is sentenced to life imprisonment and a fine of 50,000 rupees; his companions to four years each.

April 19, 2010: The Supreme Court upholds the conviction and life sentence.

October 4, 2018: The Sentence Review Board rejects his petition for early release.

May 11, 2020: The Sentence Review Board recommends his premature release.

May 28, 2020: The Lieutenant Governor's order remits the rest of his sentence.

June 1 to 2, 2020: Sharma is released.