On June 8, 2001, eight children died at an elementary school in Ikeda, Osaka Prefecture, a school affiliated with Osaka Kyoiku University. Thirteen other children and two adults were injured. The man arrested that day was Mamoru Takuma, 37, an unemployed former school caretaker with a past record of psychiatric treatment. He admitted the killings, was tried in the Osaka District Court and, on August 28, 2003, was sentenced to death for murder and attempted murder.
The case then took an unusual course. His lawyers lodged an appeal, and Takuma withdrew it. The sentence became final in September 2003 without any review by a higher court. He was executed on September 14, 2004, less than a year after the sentence became final.
Ikeda lies about 20 kilometers outside Osaka. Eight children died there that day, and 15 more people were hurt: 13 children and two adults. Takuma was arrested in Ikeda the same day. In July 2001 the Ministry of Education sent emergency school security measures to every prefectural board of education.
Prosecutors indicted Takuma for murder and attempted murder, and the case went to the Osaka District Court. There was no dispute over who had caused the deaths. Takuma pleaded guilty to the killings of the eight children and to the injuries suffered by the 15 others.
At an early hearing he told the court that he wanted to pay for the crime with his own life. That wish shaped the defense. His lawyers did not contest the facts. Their case turned on his mind: they argued that he had been insane, or that his capacity had been diminished, when the children died.
The trial was therefore fought over psychiatry. Takuma had received treatment for mental illness before 2001, and he had at one time been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Soon after his arrest he appeared mentally unstable.
The psychiatrists who examined him for the court took a different view of the man in the dock. They testified that he was fit to stand trial and that he had been able to tell right from wrong at the time of the offenses. They suspected a paranoid personality disorder rather than the schizophrenia diagnosed years before.
Prosecutors asked for the death penalty.
The Osaka District Court delivered its judgment on August 28, 2003. It rejected the defense case on his mental state. It found that Takuma had a personality disorder but that he was fully accountable for the crimes: he had been able to tell right from wrong, and he bore full criminal responsibility. It imposed the sentence the prosecution had asked for, death.
An appeal to the High Court was lodged on his behalf. Takuma withdrew it, and the death sentence of the Osaka District Court became final in September 2003. No appeal court ever reviewed the verdict, the finding on his responsibility or the sentence. From that month he was a condemned prisoner awaiting an order of execution.
Mamoru Takuma was executed on September 14, 2004.
The central dispute of the case was his mental state. Before 2001 he had been treated for mental illness and diagnosed with schizophrenia, and his lawyers argued that he had been insane or of diminished capacity on June 8, 2001. The psychiatrists before the court found him fit to stand trial and able to tell right from wrong, and the Osaka District Court found a personality disorder, not a condition that reduced his responsibility. Because the appeal was withdrawn, no higher court ruled on the question.
June 8, 2001: Eight children die and 15 people are injured at an elementary school in Ikeda, Osaka Prefecture; Mamoru Takuma is arrested the same day.
July 2001: The Ministry of Education sends emergency school security measures to every prefectural board of education.
2001 to 2003: Trial in the Osaka District Court on charges of murder and attempted murder; Takuma pleads guilty.
August 28, 2003: The Osaka District Court sentences him to death.
September 2003: Takuma withdraws the appeal lodged on his behalf, and the death sentence becomes final.
September 14, 2004: Takuma is executed.