Malkit Kaur Sidhu

Victims
1 killing charged, of her own daughter. Accused, not convicted, of conspiring from Canada in her daughter's death and the attempted murder of her daughter's husband; trial pending
Years active
June 8, 2000
Location
Narike village, Sangrur district, Punjab, India (killing); Maple Ridge, British Columbia, Canada (alleged conspiracy; arrest); Sangrur, Punjab, India (trial)
Method
Throat cut with a blade by hired men (court rulings on the co-accused and extradition record); she is charged with conspiracy, not with taking part herself
Status
Untried. In custody in Canada 2012 to 2019 and in Punjab 2019 to 2020; bail from the Punjab and Haryana High Court, December 16, 2020. On bail in India, trial pending, as of June 2022.

Malkit Kaur Sidhu, a Canadian citizen from Maple Ridge, British Columbia, stands accused in India in the death of her own daughter. On June 8, 2000, near the village of Narike in Punjab's Sangrur district, Jaswinder Kaur "Jassi" Sidhu was killed by a group of hired men, and her husband was gravely injured. Under the charges framed against her in Sangrur on September 17, 2019, Malkit Kaur Sidhu faces counts of murder, attempted murder and criminal conspiracy. The prosecution's case is that she and her brother, the young woman's uncle, arranged the attack from Canada after learning of a marriage made without the family's knowledge. In the extradition proceedings in British Columbia, the Crown put the family's alleged aim as restoring its "honor." Both accused deny any part in the killing.

The case has run on two tracks for more than two decades. In India, men tried in Sangrur were convicted, and after two rounds of appeals three of them were left serving life sentences. In Canada, the mother and the uncle were arrested in 2012 and contested extradition all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada, which ruled against them in 2017. They were flown to India in January 2019. Malkit Kaur Sidhu has been free on bail since December 2020, and as of June 2022 her trial had not reached a verdict.

Her daughter was born in Canada and grew up in Maple Ridge, a suburb east of Vancouver. On a family trip to Punjab in the mid-1990s she met a young man from a village near Jagraon, in Ludhiana district, and over the following years the two kept in touch by letter and by telephone. In 1999, on another visit to India, they married without telling her family. She went back to Canada and began the paperwork to bring her husband there.

The family learned of the marriage in early 2000. The Crown later told the extradition hearing that the family then set out to undo it. She signed a notarized statement saying she had been coerced into the wedding, and the Crown alleged that her uncle had threatened to kill both her and her husband unless she signed a letter making that claim. In India, a complaint was lodged accusing her husband of abducting her. She told officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police that her family was threatening her, and she swore an affidavit stating that she feared for her own life and her husband's.

In the spring of 2000 she flew back to India. There she told police that she had been forced to disavow the marriage, and in April 2000 she cleared her husband of the complaint against him. By May she was with him in Punjab. On June 8, 2000, near Narike village, in the area of the Amargarh police station, the couple were set upon by a group of hired men. Her husband survived. She did not.

Police registered a case that included murder, abduction and criminal conspiracy, and in July 2000 the Punjab Police named Malkit Kaur Sidhu and her brother in it. Thirteen people were charged in all, among them a police inspector. The mother and the uncle were in Canada, beyond the reach of the Indian courts, and in 2003 both were declared proclaimed offenders.

The other eleven were tried together in Sangrur. On October 21, 2005, the sessions court convicted seven of murder, attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder and sentenced each to life imprisonment; four were acquitted. In February 2008 the Punjab and Haryana High Court acquitted three of the seven. In 2015 the Supreme Court of India upheld the life sentences of the police inspector and two of the hired men, and acquitted the fourth, a relative by marriage of the family, on the benefit of the doubt. That left the mother and the uncle as the only accused still waiting to be tried.

India asked Canada, under the extradition treaty the two countries had had since 1987, to surrender them to stand trial for conspiracy to commit murder. In early January 2012 the Supreme Court of British Columbia issued warrants under the Extradition Act, and the pair were arrested in Maple Ridge. She was 63. Both were held in custody to await a hearing that ran over about eight months in Vancouver, with testimony from the young woman's friends and co-workers about her life and her marriage. The Crown conceded that its evidence was circumstantial but argued that it was enough to send them to India for trial. On May 9, 2014, the extradition judge committed both for surrender on charges of conspiracy to commit murder and murder, finding that a properly instructed jury could conclude that the two had hired the men who carried out the attack.

The federal Minister of Justice then ordered both surrendered. India gave formal assurances that the death penalty would not be imposed, that the two would receive the medical care they needed and reasonable protection in custody, that Canadian consular officials would have access to them, and that Canadian officials could attend the court proceedings. On February 26, 2016, a majority of the Court of Appeal for British Columbia set the surrender orders aside, holding that the minister's acceptance of those assurances on health and safety in custody was not reasonable. Malkit Kaur Sidhu had by then been taken to hospital twice from custody with a heart condition. The third judge dissented.

The Attorney General of Canada, acting for India, appealed, and on September 8, 2017, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled unanimously that the appeal "is allowed and the Minister of Justice's surrender orders are restored." A reviewing court, it held, must ask whether the minister considered the relevant facts and reached a defensible conclusion, and it was reasonable for him to conclude, on India's assurances, that there was no substantial risk of torture or mistreatment.

Even that did not end the fight. A Punjab Police team came to Canada that month to take custody of the two, but the transfer was halted at Toronto's airport, and on September 28, 2017, the minister issued a fresh extradition order. The pair challenged it in the Court of Appeal for British Columbia, which in December 2018 found that the minister's conduct had amounted to an abuse of process but did not justify a stay, and dismissed their applications. They did not seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada.

On January 23, 2019, officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police escorted the two to New Delhi, where they were handed to the Punjab Police. Two days later a magistrate in Malerkotla, in Sangrur district, remanded them to four days of police custody. On September 17, 2019, the Additional District and Sessions Judge at Sangrur framed the charges of murder, attempted murder and criminal conspiracy against both.

On December 16, 2020, the Punjab and Haryana High Court granted Malkit Kaur Sidhu regular bail, citing the long detention she had already served, counted from the start of the extradition proceedings, her age and the fact that she is a woman. Her brother received bail from the same court on March 1, 2022.

The trial in Sangrur has moved slowly. On November 3, 2021, the young woman's husband testified for the prosecution, facing the mother and the uncle for the first time since June 2000, and was cross-examined by the defense. In their own testimony the two said they had not approved of the marriage but denied any part in the killing, and they told the court they were innocent and had been falsely implicated. As of June 2022, some of the more than 20 prosecution witnesses had been heard, both accused were on bail, and the court had not reached a verdict.

Malkit Kaur Sidhu has not been convicted of any offense. The allegation that she and her brother arranged the killing is the prosecution's case under the charges framed in Sangrur, tested so far only to the standard needed for extradition, and both deny it. The Crown in British Columbia acknowledged that its evidence was circumstantial.

The Canadian courts decided only whether the evidence justified a trial and whether surrender was lawful, and the Indian courts that tried the hired men did not try the mother or the uncle. Whether the prosecution's account holds is for the trial court at Sangrur, which had not ruled as of June 2022.

Timeline

1999: The daughter of Malkit Kaur Sidhu secretly marries in Punjab.

Early 2000: The family learns of the marriage.

April 2000: In India, the daughter clears her husband of a complaint lodged against him.

June 8, 2000: She is killed near Narike village, Sangrur district; her husband survives.

July 2000: Punjab Police name Malkit Kaur Sidhu and her brother in the case.

2003: Both are declared proclaimed offenders in India.

October 21, 2005: A Sangrur sessions court convicts seven men and acquits four.

February 2008: The Punjab and Haryana High Court acquits three of the seven.

January 2012: Malkit Kaur Sidhu and her brother are arrested in Maple Ridge, British Columbia.

May 9, 2014: The Supreme Court of British Columbia commits both for surrender.

2015: The Supreme Court of India upholds three life sentences and acquits a fourth man.

February 26, 2016: The Court of Appeal for British Columbia sets aside the surrender orders.

September 8, 2017: The Supreme Court of Canada restores the surrender orders.

September 28, 2017: The federal Minister of Justice issues a new extradition order.

December 2018: The Court of Appeal for British Columbia dismisses the final challenges.

January 23, 2019: Both are extradited to India.

September 17, 2019: A Sangrur sessions court frames charges of murder, attempted murder and criminal conspiracy.

December 16, 2020: The Punjab and Haryana High Court grants Malkit Kaur Sidhu regular bail.

November 3, 2021: Her daughter's husband testifies at the trial.

March 1, 2022: The High Court grants her brother regular bail.

June 2022: The trial continues, with both accused on bail.