On June 11, 2007, after a trial that had lasted three months, a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London convicted two brothers from Mitcham, in south London, of the same murder. Mahmod Mahmod was the dead woman's father. Ari Mahmod was her uncle. The prosecution never claimed that either man had carried out the killing himself. Its case was that the two of them had decided, at a family meeting, that she had to die, and that they had then set younger men to the task. The victim was Banaz Mahmod. She died in January 2006, weeks after she had told the police, in writing, that men around her family were planning to kill her.
Both brothers were sentenced to life imprisonment in July 2007. The father was ordered to serve at least 20 years before he could be considered for release, the uncle at least 23. Three other men were later convicted of her murder: a close friend of the uncle, who pleaded guilty and received life with a minimum term of 17 years, and two cousins who had left for Iraq after her death and were convicted at the Old Bailey in November 2010, after becoming the first suspects ever extradited from Iraq to the United Kingdom. A third cousin was convicted in 2013 of perverting the course of justice and a further offense.
By late 2005 she had left an arranged marriage entered as a teenager and was in a relationship with another man. In the prosecution's account, the father and the uncle held that this had shamed the family, and that claimed "honor" was the reason they gave for her death. The jury heard it as the motive for a murder, and convicted both men.
The prosecution traced the decision to a single day. On December 1, 2005, the young woman and the man she was seeing were seen together. That day, by the account later set out by the Court of Appeal, a meeting was held at the uncle's address, and it was decided there that she would be killed.
She did not wait for it to happen. On December 5, 2005, she handed the police a letter naming five men she believed were planning to kill her. On New Year's Eve she said that her father and her uncle were trying to kill her. On January 23, 2006, she went to the police again. In April 2008 the Independent Police Complaints Commission found that the Metropolitan Police and West Midlands Police had let her down.
The prosecution placed her death on January 24, 2006, in south London, the day after her last visit to the police. Police inquiries began the following day, and her death was confirmed in April 2006.
The Metropolitan Police's Homicide and Major Crime Command took over the case. Its detectives had something unusual to work with: the young woman's own words. In a recorded police interview, and in other statements she had made in the weeks before her death, she had described the threats against her and named the men she feared. Those records became part of the evidence against the men she had named. Two of them, her cousins, had already left Britain for Iraq.
The father and the uncle went on trial together at the Old Bailey. Mahmod Mahmod was 52, his brother 51. The prosecution case was that the two men had planned the killing together at the family meeting. As the High Court later set that case out, the uncle was the dominant member of the family group, the one who gave the order to kill her, and others carried it out.
Some of the strongest evidence against the uncle came from his own mouth. While he was held on remand, visits to him in prison were covertly recorded, and in those conversations, the Court of Appeal later recorded, he admitted his part in the killing. He was convicted after a trial, that court said, no doubt in part because of what the recordings contained.
The verdicts came on Monday, June 11, 2007. The jury found Mahmod Mahmod guilty of murder. It found Ari Mahmod guilty of murder and of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. A third man, tried alongside them on the conspiracy charge, was found not guilty.
The two brothers and the uncle's friend were sentenced together at the Old Bailey on July 20, 2007, by the Common Serjeant of London. All three received life imprisonment. What the judge set was the minimum term each man had to serve before he could be considered for release. For the father it was 20 years. For the uncle it was 23 years, the longest of the three. The father's term runs until April 9, 2027.
The father has served his sentence in closed conditions. By November 2025 he was a Category C prisoner in a closed prison in England, and he still denied any involvement in his daughter's murder. As his minimum term drew toward its end, the prison system began the reviews that come before release can even be considered. A first sentence planning review was held on October 31, 2023. In April 2024 the Ministry of Justice's Public Protection Casework Section refused to refer his case to the Parole Board. A second review, on October 11, 2024, recommended that he be moved to open conditions, and asked for a pre-tariff review by the board.
The casework section said no again on November 30, 2024. It found that he had not made enough progress during his sentence in reducing his risk to a level consistent with protecting the public, given that a move to open conditions could mean unsupervised release, and it confirmed that his parole review would begin when his minimum term expired. He went to the High Court. A judge refused him permission to seek judicial review on the papers on September 8, 2025, and on November 26, 2025, the Administrative Court refused his renewed application on every ground. The court held that the policy governing the sift for pre-tariff reviews was a lawful and rational use of scarce resources, that the casework section had been entitled not to follow the review meeting's recommendation, and that he had been treated fairly, since the sifting process, in the court's words, "was not a trial."
In August 2025 the High Court struck out a libel claim Ari Mahmod had brought over television programs about the case, recording that he did not dispute his conviction for his niece's murder. He was then serving his life sentence in a prison in England.
The two brothers were convicted on the prosecution's case that the decision to kill was taken at a family meeting on December 1, 2005, and that they then left the killing to others. The meeting itself rests on that case as the jury accepted it and as the Court of Appeal later summarized it.
The uncle's friend admitted murder but disputed the prosecution's account of the part he played. A third man tried with the brothers was acquitted of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.
The two brothers have answered the verdict differently. The uncle, in his 2025 libel claim, accepted as a matter of fact that he had been convicted of his niece's murder and was serving a life sentence for it. The father, as the High Court recorded in November 2025, continued to deny any involvement.
December 1, 2005: The young woman and the man she was seeing are seen together; the prosecution case is that a family meeting that day decided she would be killed.
December 5, 2005: She gives the police a letter naming five men she believes are planning to kill her.
December 31, 2005: She says her father and uncle are trying to kill her.
January 23, 2006: She goes to the police again.
January 24, 2006: She is killed in south London.
April 2006: Her death is confirmed.
June 11, 2007: Mahmod Mahmod is convicted of murder; Ari Mahmod is convicted of murder and conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.
July 20, 2007: Both are sentenced to life imprisonment, with minimum terms of 20 and 23 years.
November 10, 2010: Two cousins, extradited from Iraq, are convicted of her murder at the Old Bailey.
November 30, 2024: The Public Protection Casework Section declines to refer Mahmod Mahmod's case to the Parole Board for a pre-tariff review.
August 8, 2025: The High Court strikes out Ari Mahmod's libel claim.
November 26, 2025: The Administrative Court refuses Mahmod Mahmod's renewed application for permission to seek judicial review.
April 9, 2027: Mahmod Mahmod's minimum term expires.