In December 2014 a jury in the Quebec Superior Court in Montreal found Luka Rocco Magnotta guilty of the first-degree murder of Jun Lin, a man from Wuhan, China, who had made his home in Montreal the year before. The killing had taken place in the city in late May 2012. Magnotta never denied the acts. At his trial he admitted everything the five charges described and asked the jury to find that he had been so ill at the time that the law did not hold him criminally responsible. The jury rejected that argument on every count. He was sentenced the same day to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for 25 years, the only sentence the Criminal Code allows for first-degree murder, and to the maximum term available on each of the four other offenses.
The case began with a search for a man who had already left the country, and it ended in Berlin, where he was arrested days later. A preliminary hearing, a trial of about ten weeks and a contest between psychiatrists over the state of his mind followed. Two months after the verdict he abandoned his appeals, and the case closed.
The man he killed was born in Wuhan, the capital of Hubei province in central China. He arrived in Montreal in July 2011 to study, and enrolled as an undergraduate in the faculty of engineering and computer science at Concordia University. Friends in the city knew him as Justin, and sometimes as Patrick. People who worked beside him and lived near him in Montreal remembered him as trustworthy and reliable, a gentleman.
Magnotta was born Eric Clinton Newman on July 24, 1982, in the east end of Toronto, in Scarborough. He grew up in and around Peterborough, Ontario, where much of his extended family lived, and he was raised largely by his maternal grandparents; he later described his grandmother as the person who had chiefly cared for him. He went to school for a few years in Lindsay, a town near Peterborough. The few former classmates who remembered him at all recalled a boy who was bullied.
His mental health became a matter of medical record early. Hospital records from Lindsay, produced at his trial, showed that he had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia by August 2001, when he was 19, and that he was then living in a group home for people with schizophrenia. Around 2001 he moved back to Toronto.
His first brush with the criminal courts came in the city. In 2004 he was charged in Toronto with several offenses arising from roughly $17,000 in credit card fraud. He pleaded guilty in June 2005 and received a nine-month conditional sentence followed by a year of probation. In 2006 he legally changed his name from Eric Newman to Luka Rocco Magnotta, and in 2007 he declared bankruptcy.
By the spring of 2012 he was living in Montreal. In April of that year he was referred to a psychiatrist at a Montreal hospital, who, after an assessment of about an hour, diagnosed borderline personality disorder.
The killing took place in Montreal in late May 2012. On May 26 Magnotta left Canada for Europe. On May 30 Montreal police named him as their prime suspect and a Canada-wide warrant was issued for his arrest, and Interpol placed him on its list of wanted fugitives. On June 1 police identified the victim, and the warrant was upgraded to a charge of first-degree murder.
Police in Berlin arrested him on June 4, 2012. He did not fight extradition, and on June 18 he was returned to Quebec and taken into the custody of the Montreal police. By then he faced five charges: first-degree murder; criminally harassing Prime Minister Stephen Harper and other members of Parliament; and three offenses under sections 163, 168 and 182 of the Criminal Code. He pleaded not guilty.
A preliminary hearing before a judge of the Court of Quebec opened in Montreal on March 11, 2013, under the customary ban on publishing the evidence heard at such hearings. On April 12, 2013, the judge ordered Magnotta to stand trial on all five charges.
The trial opened on September 29, 2014, before a justice of the Quebec Superior Court and a jury. As each of the five counts was read, Magnotta answered "not guilty." His defense then admitted the physical acts behind every offense and set out to show that at the time he had not been criminally responsible.
The Crown's case was that the killing had been planned and deliberate, the two words that make a murder first-degree murder under the Criminal Code, and that his conduct before and after it was not that of a person in the grip of a disease of the mind. Because the acts were admitted, most of the evidence that mattered went to his state of mind. Psychiatrists called by the defense testified that he had schizophrenia and had been in a state of psychosis when the victim was killed; one of them found that he understood what he was doing but could not rationally tell that it was wrong. The Crown's psychiatrists testified that he had a personality disorder and had known right from wrong. His father testified for the defense. Magnotta himself did not testify.
In his final instructions on December 15, 2014, the judge told the jurors that they were not being asked whether Magnotta had committed the acts, which he had admitted, but to decide the state of his mind. On that question the burden lay on the defense, which had raised it, and the standard was the balance of probabilities, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The jury deliberated for eight days.
On December 23, 2014, it returned its verdict: guilty of first-degree murder, and guilty on each of the four other counts. The defense of mental disorder had failed in full. Sentence followed the same day. For first-degree murder the law allowed only one sentence, and the judge imposed it: life imprisonment, with no eligibility for parole until Magnotta had served 25 years. On each of the other four offenses the judge imposed the maximum term the law allowed, nineteen years in all.
In January 2015 the defense filed two appeals with the Quebec Court of Appeal, seeking a new trial. On February 18, 2015, Magnotta appeared before a judge of that court and withdrew both, confirming that he did so of his own free will. The convictions and the sentence stand.
He began his sentence in a maximum-security penitentiary in Quebec. On August 11, 2022, the Correctional Service of Canada moved him to a medium-security institution in the province. The transfer was not announced and became public in March 2024; on March 4 of that year the service confirmed that he was living in a medium-security prison and continued to serve an indeterminate life sentence. As of May 2024 he remained in a medium-security institution in Quebec.
The diagnosis was the one great dispute of the case. The defense relied on a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia dating from 2001 and on experts who found him psychotic and unable to know that his acts were wrong. The Crown's experts found a personality disorder and a man who knew right from wrong, and the Montreal psychiatrist who saw him for about an hour in April 2012 had diagnosed borderline personality disorder. The jury's verdict settled the legal question of criminal responsibility; it did not settle, and was not asked to settle, every medical question the experts raised.
The planning that the Crown alleged and the jury found is part of the verdict of first-degree murder. Magnotta never gave his own account in court, since he did not testify, and he withdrew his appeals before any higher court could examine the trial.
July 24, 1982: Born Eric Clinton Newman in Toronto (Scarborough), Ontario.
August 2001: Diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, at 19, in Lindsay, Ontario.
2004: Charged in Toronto with offenses arising from about $17,000 in credit card fraud.
June 2005: Pleads guilty; nine-month conditional sentence and a year of probation.
2006: Legally changes his name to Luka Rocco Magnotta.
July 2011: The victim arrives in Montreal from Wuhan.
April 2012: Referred to a Montreal psychiatrist, who diagnoses borderline personality disorder.
Late May 2012: The killing in Montreal.
May 26, 2012: Magnotta leaves Canada for Europe.
May 30, 2012: Montreal police name him as prime suspect; a Canada-wide warrant is issued and Interpol lists him as wanted.
June 1, 2012: The victim is identified; the warrant is upgraded to first-degree murder.
June 4, 2012: Arrested in Berlin.
June 18, 2012: Returned to Quebec.
March 11, 2013: Preliminary hearing opens in Montreal.
April 12, 2013: Ordered to stand trial on all five charges.
September 29, 2014: Trial opens in the Quebec Superior Court; not guilty pleas to all five counts.
December 15, 2014: The judge charges the jury.
December 23, 2014: Guilty on all five counts; sentenced to life without parole eligibility for 25 years.
January 2015: Two appeals filed with the Quebec Court of Appeal.
February 18, 2015: Appeals withdrawn.
August 11, 2022: Transferred from maximum to medium security in Quebec.
March 4, 2024: The Correctional Service of Canada confirms the transfer.