Lowell Lee Andrews was 18 years old and in his second year at the University of Kansas when he came back to Wolcott for the Thanksgiving holiday of 1958. On the evening of Friday, November 28, the day after Thanksgiving, he killed his father, his mother and his older sister. He confessed after his arrest, spent the next four years under sentence of death at the state penitentiary in Lansing while his appeals moved through the courts, and was executed there on November 30, 1962.
Wolcott is a small town in the northwestern part of Wyandotte County, Kansas. Andrews grew up there and went on to the university in Lawrence, where he studied zoology and played bassoon in the university band. He was a large, mild-mannered young man, more than six feet tall and about 260 pounds. During term he boarded in Lawrence, and for the long Thanksgiving weekend he went back to his parents in Wolcott.
Four people gathered for Thanksgiving in 1958: Lowell, his father, William L. Andrews, his mother, Opal Andrews, and his older sister, Jennie Marie Andrews. The family owned a farm near Wolcott, and his father kept a savings account in his own name. Little more about the lives of the three is on record.
The deaths took place in Wolcott on the evening of Friday, November 28, 1958. All three of the other members of the family died that night. The Wyandotte County Sheriff's Office learned of the deaths the same night and took charge of the inquiry. Andrews was taken into custody.
After his arrest Andrews confessed. He told investigators that he had wanted to inherit the family farm and to get the $1,800 that was in his father's savings account. Those were the reasons he gave at the time, and they were the only reasons on record from his own mouth for what he had done.
To a reporter who spoke with him he gave a different kind of answer. "I'm not sorry and I'm not glad I did it," he said. "I just don't know why I did it." The two statements, one about land and money and one about not knowing, sat side by side for the rest of his life.
Andrews was condemned to death and sent to the Kansas State Penitentiary at Lansing, the institution now called the Lansing Correctional Facility. He spent four years there while his appeals ran their course.
Twice his case reached the Supreme Court of the United States, and twice the Court declined to hear it. The first petition, Andrews v. Kansas, came from the Kansas decision reported at 187 Kan. 458; on October 9, 1961, the Court denied certiorari, with one justice recording that he would have granted review. The second, Andrews v. Hand, was a habeas case brought against the warden of the penitentiary, and on October 22, 1962, the Court denied certiorari again.
The appeals failed. Lowell Lee Andrews was executed at Lansing on November 30, 1962. He was one of the last people executed in Kansas.
What drove Andrews has never been settled. His confession put the reason in money and property: the farm he expected to inherit and the savings in his father's account. His remark to a reporter, that he did not know why he had done it, pointed the other way. No court finding on his motive is on record, and the words he used at the time are the only direct evidence of what he thought he was doing.
November 1958: Lowell Lee Andrews, an 18-year-old sophomore at the University of Kansas, comes back to Wolcott, Kansas, for Thanksgiving.
November 28, 1958: His father, mother and sister die in Wolcott on the Friday evening after Thanksgiving.
Late 1958: Andrews is arrested in Wyandotte County and confesses, naming the family farm and his father's savings as his reasons.
1958 to 1962: He is held under sentence of death at the Kansas State Penitentiary at Lansing.
October 9, 1961: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari in Andrews v. Kansas, from the Kansas decision reported at 187 Kan. 458; one justice would have granted review.
October 22, 1962: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari in Andrews v. Hand, his habeas case against the penitentiary warden.
November 30, 1962: Andrews is executed at Lansing, Kansas.