Louis-Pierre Louvel

Victims
1 assassination: Charles-Ferdinand, duc de Berry, nephew of King Louis XVIII; convicted by the Cour des pairs under article 87 of the Penal Code, June 6, 1820.
Years active
February 13, 1820
Location
Paris, France (killing); Versailles, France (birth); Paris, France (trial and death)
Method
Stabbed with a dagger (charge in the procureur-général's conclusions, found proved by the Cour des pairs).
Status
Guilty under article 87 of the Penal Code; sentenced to death and to the costs of the trial, June 6, 1820. Executed in Paris, June 7, 1820.

On the night of February 13, 1820, in Paris, a saddler named Louis-Pierre Louvel killed Charles-Ferdinand d'Artois, duc de Berry, the nephew of King Louis XVIII. The duke died the next morning. Louvel was seized on the spot, and he said from the first that he had acted alone. His purpose, as he described it, was political and dynastic: the duke was the one member of the reigning family still in a position to give the Bourbons an heir, and Louvel meant to end the line.

The case went to the highest court the Restoration monarchy possessed. A royal ordinance of February 14 turned the Chamber of Peers into the Cour des pairs and ordered it to try him without delay. The peers spent three months on an inquiry into whether anyone had stood behind him, cleared every other person drawn into it, and heard the case in public on June 5 and 6, 1820. On June 6 they found him guilty of "le crime prévu par l'article 87 du code pénal," the offense of an attack on the life of a member of the royal family, and sentenced him to death. He was executed in Paris on June 7, 1820, less than four months after the assassination.

Louvel was born in Versailles on October 7, 1783. The court's indictment order of May 1820 gave a plain description of him: about 1.61 meters tall, with chestnut hair and eyebrows, a small forehead, blue eyes, a small nose and mouth, a round chin and an oval face. A portrait print sold after his arrest called him a "garçon sellier," a journeyman saddler, 36 years old and a native of Versailles. By 1820 he was working at his trade in Paris, and the court record gave his address as the King's own stables.

His politics were formed by the fall of the Empire. He admired Napoleon and followed him to the island of Elba after the first abdication in 1814. He blamed Louis XVIII for handing France over to the foreign powers, and in 1814 he went to Calais intending to kill the returning king, an intention he did not carry out. The grievance stayed with him, and his hatred settled on the dynasty as a whole.

The duke spent the evening of February 13, 1820, out in Paris with his wife, and Louvel reached him as the evening ended. The duke died a few hours later, in the night of February 13 to 14. Before he died he asked that the man who had killed him be spared.

Louvel was in custody before the duke was dead. From the first he said that he had acted alone, out of conviction against the monarchy, that no one had sent him, and that he bore the duke no personal grudge.

The ordinance of February 14 rested on article 33 of the Constitutional Charter, which gave the Chamber of Peers jurisdiction over high treason and attacks on the security of the state, and on article 87 of the Penal Code, which placed an attack on the life of a member of the royal family among those crimes. A procureur-général was specially appointed to prosecute. The peers met as a court for the first time on February 15, declared themselves competent to try Louvel and any accomplices, and ordered the Chancellor of France, as President of the court, to conduct the inquiry.

The central question of that inquiry was not whether Louvel had killed the duke, which no one disputed, but whether he had acted for someone else. For three months a string of people in Paris and the provinces were questioned, and some were held. One witness who believed he had once met Louvel was brought face to face with him, and the two men did not recognize each other.

The answer came on May 23, 1820. The procureur-général himself asked the peers to declare that there were not sufficient charges against the others the inquiry had drawn in, and the court went further: it found in the record "aucune trace de crime, délit ou contravention prévus par la loi" against a dozen people and declared that there was no ground to proceed against them. The court had looked for a conspiracy and found none. The same day it ordered the indictment of Louis-Pierre Louvel for the crime under article 87 of the Penal Code and fixed the opening of the public hearings for June 5.

The trial followed the rules of the cours d'assises, the ordinary criminal courts of the time, with one large difference: there was no jury, and the peers themselves would decide the facts and the law. Louvel appeared unrestrained, with two counsel the court had appointed for him. The President questioned him, and the prosecution's witnesses were then heard one at a time.

On June 6 the procureur-général delivered his submissions. Defense counsel argued that the court lacked jurisdiction and that the case failed on the merits. Then Louvel spoke for himself, reading a written statement he had composed in his own justification. The prosecution closed by asking the court to reject the plea of incompetence, to declare him guilty under article 87 and to impose the penalty that article prescribed, which was death.

The peers withdrew to deliberate in private, and their judgment answered the defense point by point. On jurisdiction, it held that the Penal Code remained in force under article 68 of the Charter and that the crime fell within article 33, being a crime against the security of the state committed through an attack on a member of the royal family. On the facts, it found that on February 13 Louvel had committed an attack on the duke's person and life. It declared him guilty of "le crime prévu par l'article 87 du code pénal," and, applying that article together with article 12 of the same code, it condemned Louis-Pierre Louvel, born at Versailles on October 7, 1783, saddler, "à la peine de mort." It also ordered him to pay the costs of the trial.

Louvel was executed in Paris on June 7, 1820, the day after the verdict.

Whether Louvel had accomplices was the one real question the case left open in 1820, and the court's May ruling answered it: every other person drawn into the inquiry was released on the finding that there was no ground to proceed. Louvel said from his arrest onward that he had acted alone, and the court tried him alone.

His politics have been labeled in more than one way, as Bonapartist for his attachment to Napoleon and as republican for his hostility to the crown. What he said himself was narrower: that he hated the Bourbons and meant to end their line. On that measure the assassination failed. The duke's widow was pregnant when her husband died, and on September 29, 1820, she gave birth to a son, Henri, the heir the assassination had been meant to prevent.

Timeline

October 7, 1783: Louis-Pierre Louvel is born in Versailles.

1814: After Napoleon's first abdication, Louvel follows him to Elba; the same year he goes to Calais intending to kill Louis XVIII and does not carry it out.

February 13, 1820: Louvel kills the duke in Paris and is seized at once.

February 14, 1820: The duke dies; a royal ordinance orders the Chamber of Peers, sitting as the Cour des pairs, to try Louvel without delay.

February 15, 1820: The court holds its first sitting, declares itself competent and orders the Chancellor to conduct the inquiry.

May 23, 1820: The court finds no ground to proceed against a dozen other people drawn into the inquiry and orders Louvel's indictment under article 87 of the Penal Code.

June 5, 1820: The public trial opens before the peers.

June 6, 1820: The court rejects the plea of incompetence, finds Louvel guilty under article 87 and sentences him to death and the costs of the trial.

June 7, 1820: Louvel is executed in Paris.

September 29, 1820: The duke's widow gives birth to a son, Henri.