Lionel Tate

Victims
One death, Broward County, 1999. Convicted of first-degree murder (2001; reversed 2003); pleaded guilty to second-degree murder (2004)
Years active
July 28, 1999
Location
Broward County; Pembroke Park; Fort Lauderdale (Florida)
Method
Murder (second-degree murder by guilty plea, January 29, 2004)
Status
Life without parole (2001), reversed December 10, 2003; plea and probation 2004; 30 years for violating probation (May 18, 2006), upheld 2007

Lionel Tate was 12 years old in the summer of 1999, when a young girl died in Broward County, Florida, and the state chose to prosecute him as an adult. A grand jury indicted him for first-degree murder. A Broward Circuit Court jury found him guilty in January 2001, and because Florida law fixed one penalty for that verdict, he was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole at the age of 14.

The conviction did not stand. In December 2003 the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed the judgment and sentence, holding that the trial court had violated due process by never ordering an evaluation of whether a boy of his age and development was competent to stand trial. Weeks later Tate pleaded guilty to second-degree murder on the same terms he had turned down before the first trial and walked out of custody on probation. Within a year and a half he was back in court, and in 2006 a judge sentenced him to 30 years for violating that probation. In 2008 his release from Florida state custody was scheduled for 2031.

The death in July 1999

The victim, Tiffany Eunick, died on July 28, 1999, in Broward County. Tate, the boy accused of her death, had been born in January 1987.

The death was investigated in Broward County, and the case went from a juvenile matter to an adult prosecution. Under Florida law as the appeals court later described it, a child younger than 14 could not be charged as an adult by a prosecutor's information. The state had two choices: keep the case in juvenile court, or take it to a grand jury and seek an indictment. Prosecutors went to the grand jury. Because he was younger than 14 and charged by indictment, he received no hearing of the kind Florida law gave older children before their cases moved to adult court. The grand jury returned an indictment for first-degree murder, and with it Tate's case left the juvenile system for good.

That step carried the sentence with it. In Florida, a first-degree murder conviction carried a mandatory sentence of life without parole under a law enacted in the mid-1990s. There was no sentencing range for the judge to work within and no separate penalty for a defendant who was a child. If a jury convicted Tate of first-degree murder, the only lawful sentence was life.

The offer he turned down

Before trial the state offered a way out. Prosecutors proposed that Tate plead guilty in exchange for three years in a juvenile detention facility followed by ten years of probation.

It was rejected. About five days before trial the court held a plea colloquy. Tate stood before the judge with his lawyer and a court-appointed psychiatrist. His lawyer told the court that, after consulting Tate, they wished to reject the offer and go to trial. The judge questioned the boy. Tate said he understood what his lawyer had said, that he wanted a trial and that no one had pressured him. The trial court found that he had sufficient ability to make the decision, and the case went to a jury.

No one had asked the court to determine whether Tate was competent to stand trial. Before trial a psychologist for the state had spent about 20 minutes with him, without a court order, and concluded that he was legally competent and that he understood a conviction could mean a long time in prison. No court-ordered evaluation of his competency took place before the jury was sworn, and that gap became the center of the appeal.

The trial

The trial was held in Broward Circuit Court in Fort Lauderdale in January 2001, and Tate, then 13, was tried as an adult. Because he had been younger than 16 at the time of the death, the state could not seek the death penalty. The state presented its case on two theories of first-degree murder. The first was premeditated murder. The second was felony murder, in which the underlying felony was aggravated child abuse: if the jury found that Tate had committed aggravated child abuse and that the girl died as a result, the law treated the killing as first-degree murder whether or not he meant to kill.

The defense contested intent. Its case was built around Tate's immaturity and developmental delays, which the appeals court later described as the core of the defense, and defense experts testified that his development lagged years behind his age.

On January 25, 2001, the jury returned a general verdict finding Tate guilty of first-degree murder. The form did not say which theory the jurors had accepted, premeditation or felony murder, and on appeal the court treated the verdict as resting on both. His lawyers said the day of the verdict that they would appeal, and sentencing was set for March.

The motions and the sentence

The verdict left the trial court one sentence to impose, and the weeks between verdict and sentencing were taken up with efforts to undo the verdict itself. The defense moved for a new trial and asked for an evidentiary hearing. The defense also asked for a hearing on whether the plea offer had been adequately explained to him before he turned it down. New appellate counsel entered the case and asked for a competency evaluation and hearing.

At a hearing on March 2, 2001, the defense made an oral motion for a competency evaluation, telling the court that Tate was not then competent to understand what it would mean to waive the attorney-client privilege. When the judge asked him whether he understood, Tate answered "no." The trial judge at first indicated that a minimal evaluation was warranted, then reversed himself after the state argued that a written motion was required, and denied relief, reasoning that no one had raised competency before or during the trial and that a defendant's apparent disinterest was not the same as incompetence. The defense followed with a written motion supported by affidavits stating that Tate was not presently competent and that, before trial, he had not been competent to assist his lawyers or to decide whether to accept the plea offer. The defense also argued that no one had explained to him that losing at trial meant only one outcome, life without parole, so that he could not have knowingly rejected the offer.

One obstacle ran through all of it. Tate declined to waive the attorney-client privilege, and without that waiver his trial lawyers could not fully tell the court what had concerned them about his understanding before and during the trial. The judge, for his part, pointed to the record as it stood: two days before trial Tate had said he wanted to go forward, and his lawyers had never raised incompetency before or during the trial.

On March 9, 2001, the judge denied the requests to set aside the conviction, to reduce it to second-degree murder or manslaughter, or to order a new trial, and imposed the mandatory sentence of life imprisonment without parole. Tate was 14.

The appeal

Tate's appeal was argued before a three-judge panel of the Fourth District Court of Appeal, which sits in West Palm Beach. The court issued its opinion on December 10, 2003. It ran nine pages, written by one judge of the panel and joined by the other two without a separate opinion. The panel was unanimous.

The defense raised more than ten issues, and the court rejected most of them. It rejected the argument that a mandatory life sentence without parole for a child of his age violated the federal and Florida constitutional bans on cruel or unusual punishment, holding that the legislature's choice of penalty for first-degree murder deserved substantial deference and that the sentence was not grossly disproportionate to the crime. It rejected an equal protection argument that indictment, which exposed younger children to adult sentencing, treated them more harshly than older juveniles charged by information, reasoning that the indictment requirement was a protection for the accused. The defense also attacked the aggravated child abuse statute that supported the felony murder theory, arguing that it was unconstitutionally vague as applied to a child who was not the victim's caregiver. The court disagreed. The statute's plain language reached any person, and an earlier decision had settled the point. It rejected the claim that a child under 14 was entitled to a judicial hearing before being tried as an adult, and it declined to revisit the statute that allowed a grand jury indictment to carry his case out of juvenile court. It rejected a challenge based on the privacy and confidentiality of juvenile proceedings, and it rejected separation of powers and due process challenges to the statutes. On felony murder, it held that the legislature had displaced the old common-law defense of infancy, and it noted that Tate had been allowed to put his immaturity before the jury on the question of intent. On the remaining points, the panel found no reversible error or abuse of discretion.

One issue required reversal. The court held that, given Tate's young age, his lack of any prior exposure to the courts, his developmental delays and the complexity of a first-degree murder charge that carried a mandatory life sentence, a competency evaluation had been constitutionally required. The trial court's failure to order one on its own motion before trial, and its denial of the request after trial, violated due process. The question, the court said, was not whether a defendant was incompetent but whether he might be.

The panel found the plea colloquy inadequate to answer that question. A few questions from the bench could not show whether he understood an offer of three years against the certainty of life. His developmental delays had been at the core of his own defense, so the concern was never hidden from the court. The state's psychologist had found him competent, but that was a 20-minute assessment made without a court order, and there was no court-ordered evaluation anywhere in the record.

Because a hearing held years later could not reach back and protect his rights at the time of trial, a new competency hearing was not enough. The disposition was brief: "The judgment and sentence are reversed and we remand for a new trial."

The opinion also looked ahead. Any new trial would have to be preceded by an evaluation of his competency. If plea discussions resumed, the trial court would have to make sure that a defendant of his age, facing a mandatory life sentence, could understand the offer, what accepting or rejecting it meant, and the evidence on each side; a brief exchange from the bench would not be enough. The panel made clear that the same obligation had applied the first time, when an offer of three years stood against the risk of life.

The plea and the release

The reversal sent the case back to the same Broward circuit judge who had imposed the life sentence. For a few weeks it was unclear whether Tate would be tried again or released, and he remained in a maximum-security juvenile facility in Florida. Rather than try the case again, prosecutors renewed the offer Tate had turned down three years earlier.

On Sunday, January 25, 2004, Tate signed papers agreeing to plead guilty to second-degree murder. The agreement still had to be ratified by the judge, and a psychologist was to test his competence before the plea hearing.

On Monday, January 26, 2004, the judge ordered Tate freed without bail, and he was released from custody in Broward County, four days before his 17th birthday. He had served about three years. A guardian had been appointed for him. Three days later, on Thursday, January 29, 2004, he appeared in Broward Circuit Court and pleaded guilty to second-degree murder.

The terms tracked the original offer. He received credit for the three years he had already served. He was to spend the first year under house arrest, followed by ten years of probation, with 1,000 hours of community service and regular counseling as conditions. If he failed to meet those terms over the next eleven years, he could again face a sentence of up to life.

The probation years

The first break came within months. In September 2004 Tate was arrested for a violation of his probation, and that October the judge extended his probation by five years and warned him that further violations would not be tolerated.

On May 23, 2005, Tate was arrested in Pembroke Park, Florida, and charged with robbery and related offenses, and with violating his probation. The arrest came about seven months after the judge's warning. He was held without bail. Through his lawyer, he denied any involvement. Because the alleged violation was of his probation in the murder case, it exposed him once more to a possible sentence of life in prison.

The two proceedings ran together in Broward Circuit Court before the judge who had handled the murder case from the start, and his competency became an issue again. In December 2005 the assistant public defender on the case withdrew and a private lawyer took over the defense. A competency hearing was set for December 19.

On December 19, 2005, Tate pleaded guilty to robbery and admitted that he had violated his probation, under a deal with prosecutors in which he faced ten to thirty years, with any sentence on the probation matters to run alongside the robbery sentence. He remained held without bail, and sentencing was set for April 3, 2006. The question of his competency came back before then. At the end of February 2006 the judge found him competent to proceed in the probation case, and in April he ruled, for the second time, that Tate was competent to face the robbery charge.

On May 18, 2006, the judge allowed Tate to withdraw his guilty plea to the robbery charge, which was set for trial on September 18, 2006. The admitted probation violation stood. On that, the judge sentenced him to 30 years. Tate was 19.

The later appeals and the robbery plea

The robbery trial did not go forward in 2006. In April 2007, shortly before a new trial date, his new lawyers moved to overturn the 30-year sentence, arguing that the lawyer who had represented him when he admitted the probation violation, who had since died, had been constitutionally ineffective, and the robbery trial was postponed so that a state appeals court could rule first on that claim.

In October 2007 the Fourth District Court of Appeal upheld the 30-year sentence for violating probation. The robbery charge was still pending.

The trial never took place. On February 19, 2008, Tate pleaded no contest to the robbery charge. He was sentenced to ten years, to run concurrently with the 30-year sentence for the probation violation, so that the plea added no time. It brought the last of his open cases to a close. At that time his release was scheduled for 2031.

Disputed and unproven points

How the death occurred was contested at trial, and the defense case turned on intent rather than on who was responsible; the jury's general verdict did not say whether it rested on premeditation or on felony murder, and the 2001 conviction was reversed in full. The governing conviction for the death is the 2004 guilty plea to second-degree murder.

In the 2005 case, Tate denied involvement through his lawyer when he was arrested. He later admitted the probation violation and, in 2008, pleaded no contest to the robbery charge, a plea that does not admit guilt but on which he was sentenced. His guilty plea to robbery of December 2005 had been withdrawn with the court's permission in May 2006, so the conviction on that charge rests on the 2008 plea alone.

The 30-year sentence rests on his admission that he violated his probation, not on a robbery conviction. His later lawyers argued in 2007 that the counsel who negotiated that admission had been ineffective; that October the Fourth District Court of Appeal upheld the sentence.

Timeline

January 1987: Lionel Tate is born in Florida.

July 28, 1999: A young girl dies in Broward County, Florida; Tate is later indicted for first-degree murder.

January 2001: Tate rejects in court a plea offer of three years in juvenile detention and ten years of probation; his trial follows in Broward Circuit Court.

January 25, 2001: The jury finds him guilty of first-degree murder.

March 2, 2001: The trial court denies a defense request for a competency evaluation.

March 9, 2001: Sentenced to life imprisonment without parole at 14.

December 10, 2003: The Fourth District Court of Appeal reverses the judgment and sentence and remands for a new trial.

January 25, 2004: Signs papers agreeing to plead guilty to second-degree murder.

January 26, 2004: Ordered freed without bail and released from custody in Broward County.

January 29, 2004: Pleads guilty to second-degree murder; one year of house arrest and ten years of probation.

September to October 2004: Arrested for a probation violation; probation extended by five years.

May 23, 2005: Arrested in Pembroke Park and charged with robbery and with violating probation.

December 19, 2005: Pleads guilty to robbery and admits the probation violation.

February and April 2006: Twice found competent to proceed.

May 18, 2006: Allowed to withdraw the robbery plea; sentenced to 30 years for violating probation.

April 17, 2007: The robbery trial is postponed to September 4, 2007, pending an appeals ruling on a claim of ineffective counsel.

October 2007: The Fourth District Court of Appeal upholds the 30-year sentence.

February 19, 2008: Pleads no contest to the robbery charge; ten years, concurrent with the 30-year sentence.