On February 5, 2004, 21 people in a gang of workers gathering cockles on the sands of Morecambe Bay, off Hest Bank in Lancashire, died there. Police came to believe that two more were lost that night as well. The man who had put them on the sands was Lin Liang Ren, a Chinese national in his late twenties who lived in Liverpool and ran the gang.
Two years later a jury at Preston Crown Court found him guilty of 21 counts of manslaughter. The prosecution's case was that his criminal negligence had cost the lives of 21 people. The same jury convicted him of facilitating breaches of immigration law and of conspiring to pervert the course of justice, the last for a false account, put together with a co-accused, that shifted his role onto one of the dead. On March 28, 2006, he was sentenced to 14 years, with a recommendation that he be deported once the sentence was served. Two of his co-accused were convicted with him; two others were acquitted.
The prosecution's case was that Lin was the gangmaster: he organized the operation, and the workers labored for him. The workers had no right to be in Britain or to work there, and that was the substance of the facilitation charge. Lin denied that he was the head of the group, and he denied every charge against him.
One member of the group survived the night. He later gave evidence against Lin, and his evidence helped to secure the convictions.
Lancashire Constabulary investigated the deaths, and by late February 2004 they had been raised in the House of Commons during debate on a bill to license gangmasters. The bill became law that summer: the Gangmasters (Licensing) Act 2004 received Royal Assent on July 8, 2004, as an Act providing for the licensing of those who supply or use workers in agricultural work, in the gathering of wild creatures and wild plants, and in certain processing and packaging. Inquest proceedings into the deaths had opened by June 2004. The inquiry led to Lin. After his arrest he lied to the police about his part in the operation, and with a co-accused he tried to conceal his role by placing the blame for running the gang on one of the workers who had died. That account became the basis of the charge of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.
Five people stood trial. Lin faced 21 counts of manslaughter, a count of conspiracy to facilitate breaches of immigration law and a count of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. His girlfriend was charged with the immigration conspiracy and with conspiracy to pervert the course of justice, and his cousin with facilitating breaches of immigration law. The other two defendants, a father and son who ran a fishing company, were charged with employing people who had no right to work in Britain.
The trial opened at Preston Crown Court on September 12, 2005, before a High Court judge. The prosecution put its case on three fronts: Lin was the gangmaster; his criminal negligence on the sands had caused the 21 deaths; and after the deaths he had set out to deceive the police about who had been in charge. The jury heard the evidence of the survivor. Lin's defense was a denial of all three.
The verdicts came on March 24, 2006, at the end of a trial that had lasted the better part of seven months. Lin was found guilty of 21 counts of manslaughter, of facilitating breaches of immigration law and of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. His girlfriend was convicted of facilitating breaches of immigration law and of three counts of conspiring to pervert the course of justice. His cousin was convicted of facilitating breaches of immigration law. The father and son were acquitted.
On March 28, 2006, the judge passed a term of 12 years for manslaughter and a term of six years for facilitating breaches of immigration law, the two to run concurrently. To those he added two years for conspiracy to pervert the course of justice, to run consecutively, which brought the total to 14 years. He recommended that Lin be deported on his release. The cousin was sentenced to four years and nine months, and the girlfriend to two years and nine months, with a recommendation that she, too, be deported at the end of her sentence.
The number of dead is the main point on which accounts divide. Twenty-one people were named in the manslaughter counts. Police believed the true figure was 23. The two further deaths were never the subject of any charge, and Lin stands convicted of 21 counts of manslaughter only.
Lin's denial that he was the gangmaster was rejected by the jury, which convicted him on every count he faced.
February 5, 2004: Twenty-one people in Lin's gang die in Morecambe Bay off Hest Bank, Lancashire; police believe two more died that night.
February 27, 2004: The deaths are raised in the House of Commons while the Lancashire police inquiry is under way.
June 2004: Inquest proceedings into the deaths are under way.
July 8, 2004: The Gangmasters (Licensing) Act 2004, the bill debated in February, receives Royal Assent.
September 12, 2005: The trial of Lin and four co-defendants opens at Preston Crown Court.
March 24, 2006: Lin is convicted of 21 counts of manslaughter, facilitating breaches of immigration law and conspiracy to pervert the course of justice; two co-accused are convicted of immigration offenses and two are acquitted.
March 28, 2006: Lin is sentenced to 14 years, with a recommendation for deportation.