Levi King

Victims
5 people shot dead in Missouri and Texas, 2005, by guilty pleas. Two first-degree murders in Missouri and three capital murders in Texas, one of a pregnant mother; her daughter, 10, lived.
Years active
September 29, 2005 (Missouri) and September 30, 2005 (Texas)
Location
Rural Pineville, McDonald County, Missouri; near Pampa, Gray County, Texas; arrest at El Paso, Texas; Texas trial in Lubbock
Method
Shot to death
Status
Missouri: two consecutive life terms without parole on a 2008 plea that removed the death penalty. Texas: life without parole, October 6, 2009, after the jury could not agree on death.

Levi King was 23 when, over about a day at the end of September 2005, he shot and killed five people in two states. On September 29 he killed Orlie McCool, 70, and his daughter-in-law Dawn McCool, 47, in rural Pineville, McDonald County, Missouri. Early the next morning, hundreds of miles away near Pampa in the Texas Panhandle, he killed Brian Conrad, 31, his wife Michell Conrad, 35, who was about six months pregnant, and her son Zach Doan, 14. Michell Conrad's 10-year-old daughter survived. That night King was stopped at the Mexican border in El Paso, driving Orlie McCool's pickup.

He had no known link to either family. He pleaded guilty to the two Missouri murders in 2008 in exchange for a life sentence and to the three Texas murders in 2009 without any such promise. A Lubbock County jury, unable to agree unanimously on death, left him with life without parole.

Background

King came from Missouri. His own lawyers, arguing for his life at his Texas trial in 2009, told the jury he grew up poor, around guns and drugs. According to the defense, his parents regularly used drugs and neglected him emotionally, he left school at 15, and his parents eventually gave up custody of him. The defense said he was diagnosed with bipolar disorder at 20.

King himself told the Texas judge that he had once been diagnosed with bipolar disorder and paranoid schizophrenia and had been told he was psychotic, and his lawyer Maxwell Peck III said he had been suicidal. King also told the court that he was sane and fully competent when he committed the killings, according to NewsChannel 10 in Amarillo.

In 2003 he was sentenced in Missouri to 14 years in prison for second-degree arson and burglary. He was paroled after serving 17 months, according to NewsChannel 10 and The Pampa News, and in July 2005 he was released to a halfway house in St. Louis. CBS News's 48 Hours later put his time served at less than three years, and his own lawyers told the Texas jury he had served two years.

The walk-away

In late September 2005, King left the St. Louis halfway house and did not return. NewsChannel 10 reported in 2006 that he left seven days before the Texas killings, in violation of his parole, and that authorities were not notified. KOMU, the University of Missouri's television station, said he walked out a week before his arrest.

According to 48 Hours, he went to his father's place in Pineville and took several guns. One of his Texas lawyers, Joe Marr Wilson, told 48 Hours that whether or not the family had food, it had money for ammunition. His own lawyers told the Texas jury that the weapon used near Pampa belonged to his father.

Texas Monthly reported in 2014 that his father had thrown him out, and that King said the anger this caused led him to decide to shoot people.

Orlie and Dawn McCool

Orlie McCool was 70 and lived in rural McDonald County, near Pineville. Dawn McCool was 47. The Associated Press and Missouri reports described her as his daughter-in-law; the Joplin Globe called her his former daughter-in-law. Little else about either of them is on record.

Steve Geeding, then the McDonald County prosecutor, said the two were killed between about 1:30 and 3 p.m. on September 29, 2005. Both had been shot.

Accounts of his motive differ. In a videotaped interview with El Paso detectives, played for the Texas jury in September 2009, King said he killed the couple after an argument about stray horses and then drove off in their truck, according to KCBD in Lubbock. Investigators interviewed by 48 Hours said they believed he chose the McCools for their Dodge Dakota pickup. 48 Hours also reported that ballistic evidence from the Missouri killings matched a gun reported stolen, and that a local man told authorities his son, Levi King, had broken in and taken several guns from him.

King left in Orlie McCool's pickup and drove south and then west on Interstate 40, according to Missouri authorities quoted by KHOU. Several reports described the truck as maroon.

Near Pampa

The Conrad family lived outside Pampa, the seat of Gray County. Brian Conrad, 31, was a farmer. His wife, Michell, was 35 and about six months pregnant. Her son, Zach Doan, was 14 and in high school, and her daughter was 10. 48 Hours described the family as well liked, which at first left investigators without any idea of a motive.

King left the interstate at Pampa; according to 48 Hours, the family was a random choice. In the early hours of September 30, 2005, near Pampa, he shot and killed Brian Conrad, Michell Conrad and Zach Doan. Michell Conrad's unborn child did not survive.

Michell Conrad's 10-year-old daughter survived and, after he had gone, called for help. Gray County deputies who answered the call took her to safety.

Investigators collected ballistic evidence. They also found shoe prints and the tracks of an unknown vehicle, but no fingerprints or DNA, according to 48 Hours.

The border

King drove on to El Paso and crossed into Ciudad Juárez, Mexico. He came back within hours. On the evening of September 30, at the Bridge of the Americas, a Customs and Border Protection officer noticed the pickup because it was following the car in front too closely.

Three officers described the stop to the Texas jury in September 2009, KCBD reported. The first said King seemed very nervous and shaky and handed over Brian Conrad's identification card. When King could not give the correct birthday from the card, the officer asked whether he had any firearms. King said he did and that one was loaded, and he was handcuffed without a struggle. A second officer described him as "calm, cool, and collected" and said King claimed the man on the card was his brother. A third said King gave him an "evil stare," a detail the defense pointed out was missing from the officer's first written statement.

His name was run through a database, which showed an active warrant for a double homicide in Pineville, Missouri. Officers found several guns in the truck.

El Paso detectives questioned him. According to 48 Hours, about 15 minutes into the interview he confessed to killing Orlie and Dawn McCool.

Linking the Texas killings

Accounts differ on how the Texas killings were tied to King. 48 Hours reported that about two weeks after he was returned to Missouri, King told a deputy there that there were more bodies in Texas, and that the deputy contacted Texas investigators, who connected him with the Conrad case. Texas Monthly wrote that within a few days of his arrest he confessed to both the Missouri and the Pampa killings.

The physical evidence pointed the same way. After investigators brought the pickup back from El Paso to Missouri, a name tag bearing Brian Conrad's name was found inside it, McDonald County's chief deputy, Gregg Sweeten, told the Joplin Globe. Texas Rangers announced a preliminary ballistics match, and investigators later said ballistics tests tied one of the guns from the truck to the Texas killings.

Charges in two states

King was held without bond in McDonald County on two counts of first-degree murder. In 2006 Missouri prosecutors announced that they would seek the death penalty. He pleaded not guilty, and his lawyers filed a motion arguing that the associate circuit court lacked jurisdiction. NewsChannel 10 reported that he was moved from the McDonald County jail to a maximum-security state prison after officials heard rumors that he was planning an escape. The defense waived a preliminary hearing, and the case was moved on a change of venue to Pulaski County, according to McDonald County Prosecutor Janice Durbin.

In March 2006 a Gray County grand jury indicted him for capital murder. NewsChannel 10 reported three capital murder counts, with one indictment carrying a second count tied to Michell Conrad's unborn child; The Pampa News later described four counts of capital murder. District Attorney Lynn Switzer filed notice that Texas would also seek death, and she warned that it might be several years before King stood before a judge in Gray County, because the Missouri case had to be resolved first.

On April 18, 2008, King pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Orlie and Dawn McCool. Under the agreement he avoided a possible death sentence and received two life sentences without parole, to run one after the other.

The Texas case

Texas was not bound by the Missouri bargain. Under an agreement between the two states, a Texas death sentence would take priority over the Missouri sentences. Nanci Gonder, a spokeswoman for the Missouri attorney general's office, said that if King were acquitted in Texas he would be returned to Missouri to serve his two consecutive life terms.

Before trial, King's lawyer Joe Marr Wilson asked for the charges to be dismissed under the Interstate Agreement on Detainers, arguing that King had not been tried within 120 days of being brought back to the Texas Panhandle. A district judge denied the motion, and in May 2009 the question was argued before the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo. No ruling has been reported, and the trial later went ahead.

State District Judge Stephen Emmert moved the trial from Gray County to Lubbock and issued a gag order. On August 31, 2009, he postponed the start at the defense's request while the parties waited for DNA test results.

The trial opened at the Lubbock County Courthouse on September 3, 2009. Shortly after it began, King pleaded guilty to all three counts of capital murder. He said he understood that he could still be sentenced to death. The jury's task then changed from guilt to punishment: death, or life in prison without parole.

The punishment trial

Switzer opened by walking the jurors through the morning of the killings. Peck, for the defense, described a childhood of "anger, despair and destruction," and argued that King was no longer the same person.

The first witnesses included the 911 dispatcher and Gray County deputies who had answered the call, several of whom were visibly moved on the stand. NewsChannel 10's reporter described King sitting upright and expressionless through much of the testimony, and later in the day smirking and joking with his lawyers. The prosecution showed the jury more than 100 crime-scene photographs. A forensic pathologist testified about the autopsies.

On September 8 the three border officers and two El Paso detectives testified, and the jury watched King's videotaped interview. On September 11 Michell Conrad's daughter, then 14, testified. King offered to leave the courtroom while she spoke, to make it easier for her, but the prosecution insisted that he stay. Relatives and friends of the victims also testified, and one of them looked at King and called what he had done a "horrendous and evil crime." The state rested that day, and the defense case began the following Monday.

Peck urged the jurors not to act out of revenge. The verdict came nearly five weeks after the guilty plea.

The verdict

To impose death, the jury had to answer two questions: whether King was a continuing threat to society, and whether any mitigating circumstance warranted mercy. The jurors answered yes to the first. They could not agree on the second, which made a life sentence automatic.

The jury began deliberating at 8:15 a.m. and returned its answer after nearly eight hours. On October 6, 2009, King was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Most of the jurors were crying when the sentence was read, KCBD reported.

One of the twelve jurors would not vote for death, Texas Monthly later reported, and a death sentence required a unanimous jury.

Peck said the defense was gratified that the system had worked as it had hoped. He also said King would be held accountable for the rest of his life and that there were no winners. Switzer declined to comment to the Associated Press. To KCBD she said the decision belonged to the people of Lubbock County, through a jury that heard the facts, rather than to her, the defense or a judge. In a statement about the cost of the case, put at about $750,000 and roughly 10 percent of the Gray County budget, she said relatives had a right to confront the man who killed their loved ones while they slept. Years later she told 48 Hours that if any man deserved to die, it was King.

The families

Michell Conrad's brother told reporters that King had taken his sister, his brother-in-law and his nephew, and he called September 30, 2005, a day that had changed many families forever. Brian Conrad's mother said there was no real closure, that the trial had been one more hard stage to get through, and that the family had been torn apart. She said they respected the jury's decision. In a 2010 interview she said one man's act had touched so many people that there were "too many victims to even count."

After the verdict, Michell Conrad's daughter spoke to King in court. She said she was still haunted by that night and struggled to sleep, and that she felt guilty for not saving her family. She asked why God had chosen her to live and not them. She also told him that she forgave him and hoped that when he met God he would ask for forgiveness as well. Texas Monthly reported in 2014 that he kept his head down and did not look at her while she spoke.

She went to live with relatives in the Pampa area and was helped by therapy that Switzer arranged. Officers and deputies who had worked the case later raised money toward her college education, Texas Monthly reported.

In prison

After the Texas sentence, King was returned to Missouri to serve his sentences, KCBD and 48 Hours reported. In November 2010 NewsChannel 10 interviewed him in a Missouri prison, where he lived in a unit that gave inmates with good conduct records more time out of their cells.

He said there was hardly a day when he did not think about what he had done. He acknowledged that some people believed he should have been hanged on the courthouse lawn and said he would not argue with anyone who felt his sentence was too light. He said he could not explain why he stopped at Pampa or why he chose a family he did not know. He said one explanation that made sense to him was that he had turned outward an aggression he might otherwise have turned on himself, that pent-up rage had come out, and that at the time he had not cared about the people he killed. Asked about a Texas officer who had called the crime evil, he said there was "a certain amount of that there." He said he now tried to use his past to steer other inmates away from crime.

No appeal of either judgment is on record.

Disputed and unproven points

The motive for the Missouri killings is not settled. King told El Paso detectives that he shot the McCools after an argument about stray horses; investigators told 48 Hours they believed he wanted their pickup.

The timing of his first admission about Texas differs between 48 Hours (about two weeks after his return to Missouri, to a deputy) and Texas Monthly (within a few days of his arrest).

Reports also differ on the number of Texas counts (three counts in the 2006 indictment reports and the 2009 plea, four in The Pampa News in 2008), and on Dawn McCool's relationship to Orlie McCool (daughter-in-law or former daughter-in-law).

Timeline

2003: Sentenced in Missouri to 14 years for second-degree arson and burglary.

July 2005: Paroled after 17 months and released to a halfway house in St. Louis.

Late September 2005: Leaves the halfway house; authorities are not notified.

September 29, 2005: Orlie McCool, 70, and Dawn McCool, 47, are shot and killed in rural Pineville, Missouri.

September 30, 2005: Brian Conrad, 31, Michell Conrad, 35, and Zach Doan, 14, are shot and killed near Pampa, Texas; Michell Conrad's 10-year-old daughter survives.

September 30, 2005, evening: King is arrested at the Bridge of the Americas in El Paso in Orlie McCool's pickup.

March 2006: A Gray County grand jury indicts him for capital murder; Missouri and Texas prosecutors both give notice that they will seek death.

April 18, 2008: Pleads guilty in Missouri to two counts of first-degree murder; two consecutive life terms without parole.

May 2009: A defense appeal under the Interstate Agreement on Detainers is argued before the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo.

August 31, 2009: Texas trial postponed for DNA results.

September 3, 2009: Pleads guilty in Lubbock to three counts of capital murder; the punishment trial begins.

September 11, 2009: The surviving daughter, now 14, testifies; the state rests.

October 6, 2009: Sentenced to life without parole after the jury cannot agree on mitigation.

November 2010: Interviewed in a Missouri prison by NewsChannel 10.

June 2024: CBS News's 48 Hours revisits the case.