Leonid Nikolaev was a thirty-year-old former party functionary in Leningrad when, on December 1, 1934, he killed Sergei Kirov, the head of the Communist Party organization in the city, a member of the Politburo and a secretary of the Central Committee in Moscow. He was detained on the spot. Four weeks later the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court, sitting in closed session in Leningrad, convicted him and thirteen co-defendants of belonging to an underground terrorist group the prosecution called the "Leningrad Center," and sentenced all fourteen to death. He was executed in Leningrad on December 29, 1934.
That Nikolaev carried out the killing has never been seriously disputed. Almost everything else about the case has been. The conspiracy the court described was assembled during the investigation and taken apart decades later: his co-defendants were rehabilitated at the end of the Soviet period, and he was not. Soviet commissions returned to the question of whether he had acted alone again and again between the 1950s and 1990 without a settled answer. The killing became the pretext for a purge, the wave of arrests, trials and exiles that grew into the Great Terror of 1937 and 1938.
Nikolaev was born in 1904 in St. Petersburg, in the working-class Vyborg district. He studied reasonably well and read widely. From 1921 he worked as a clerk in a communal services office, and in 1922 he became office manager of the Vyborg district committee of the Komsomol, the Communist youth league. That committee was the center of his working world for years, and several of the men later tried beside him had worked there with him.
He joined the Communist Party in April 1924, enrolled in the first, workers' category. A year earlier he had received a Komsomol recommendation for membership and not used it, and he had asked for a transfer to an artillery school and been turned down. When he was called up in 1925, a medical commission rejected him. That same year, after a spell heading a department of the Komsomol committee in Luga, he married, and at the end of 1925 he settled in Leningrad.
His record over the next decade was one of steady decline. He worked as an apprentice fitter at the Krasnaya Zarya telephone equipment plant and then in several posts at the Krasny Arsenal works. He also served as Komsomol secretary at the Krasnaya Zarya, Arsenal and Karl Marx factories. He was dismissed from one post for what his employer called quarrels, and the party reprimanded him for stirring up a quarrel in the press. In April 1931 he became an instructor in the Leningrad regional committee of the party, a post he held for about six months. In September 1931 he moved to the regional council of the society Down with Illiteracy; his labor book listed it as his thirteenth job. In August 1932 he became an inspector in the price inspectorate of the Workers' and Peasants' Inspection, at 250 rubles a month. He took leave in August 1933 and was released on October 1, officially to study. In October 1933 he joined the regional Institute of Party History as an instructor and traveling employee and enrolled at the Communist University.
In April 1934 Nikolaev was dismissed again and expelled from the party for breaching party discipline. He had tried to climb within the Leningrad party apparatus, and he had been told instead to take a lower post at a factory. The expulsion was later softened to a severe reprimand and he was readmitted, but he did not get his work back. When he was questioned in October 1934, he put the expulsion at about eight months earlier.
The months that followed sharpened every grievance he had. He was out of work for about seven months and faced eviction. He appealed to the Leningrad city party committee, to the Politburo and to Stalin personally, and received no reply. He was refused treatment at a sanatorium despite heart trouble, and he lost the food rations reserved for party functionaries.
In mid-October 1934 guards assigned to the Leningrad party chief detained Nikolaev in Leningrad, questioned him and released him after he produced his party card. The release was made on the authority of a deputy chief of the Leningrad security police, and every later inquiry into the case went back to it.
The man Nikolaev killed was born Sergei Kostrikov on March 27, 1886, in Urzhum, in Vyatka province, and was raised in a charitable institution for orphans. He studied at a mechanical and technical school in Kazan, joined the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party in Tomsk in 1904, worked in an underground printing shop and was arrested four times between 1905 and 1911. From 1909 to 1917 he lived in Vladikavkaz and wrote for the newspaper Terek, taking the pseudonym by which the country later knew him. In October 1917 he went to Petrograd as a delegate to the Second All-Russian Congress of Soviets.
In the Civil War he took part in the defense of Astrakhan, and he helped establish Soviet power in Azerbaijan and Georgia. As first secretary of the Azerbaijan Communist Party he oversaw the recovery of the oil industry. In February 1926 he became first secretary of the Leningrad provincial party committee, where he built up the region's industry and power supply, and by 1934 he sat on the Politburo and served as a secretary of the Central Committee.
On December 1, 1934, Nikolaev killed the Leningrad party chief in Leningrad and was seized at once. That night the senior officers of the Leningrad security police questioned him twice. He told them he had no accomplices and that his motive was his expulsion from the party. His wife was arrested the next day and executed in March 1935.
Within hours the state answered with law. On December 1 the Presidium of the Central Executive Committee issued a decree on the handling of terrorist cases. It allowed the security police to hold suspected terrorists, try them without defense counsel, and carry out death sentences without appeal, and it remained in force until 1956.
Stalin traveled to Leningrad with Vyacheslav Molotov and other senior leaders, and he questioned Nikolaev in person. A senior officer of the central security police arrived from Moscow and took over the investigation on December 3. Over the following days the line of inquiry changed. After Stalin returned to Moscow, an informer placed in Nikolaev's cell supplied the names of former Trotskyist and Zinovievist associates, and from December 4 the investigation treated the killing as a political murder.
Under questioning Nikolaev first named a former Komsomol colleague against whom he bore a grudge, and then a long list of others. He also claimed to have received 5,000 rubles from a foreign consul, a claim later shown to have been fabricated. At one point he stopped testifying and refused food.
On December 16 the former opposition leaders Grigory Zinoviev and Lev Kamenev were arrested, and on December 22 the security police announced that the murder had been part of a bid to restore the Zinoviev and Trotsky platform. Stalin personally edited the draft indictment and ordered the trial finished within two days, with a single penalty for every defendant.
The Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court heard the case in closed session in Leningrad on December 28 and 29, 1934. Nikolaev stood trial with thirteen co-defendants, almost all former members of the Zinovievite opposition in Leningrad. The indictment charged that the murder had been committed by an underground terrorist group inspired by Zinoviev's ideas and directed by what the prosecution called a "Leningrad center." Nikolaev was convicted under Article 58, paragraph 8, of the 1926 Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, the article on terrorist acts against a statesman, and the court found all fourteen guilty of taking part in the terrorist organization.
The case against the others rested on Nikolaev's statements. Three of the co-defendants had never met him before the trial, and a fourth may not have. All fourteen were sentenced to death, and the sentences were carried out in Leningrad on December 29, 1934, as the decree of December 1 allowed.
After Stalin's death the case was reopened. In April 1956 the Presidium of the Central Committee set up a commission, chaired by Molotov, to verify the circumstances of the killing. Its conclusions of December 1956, kept in its report of April 23, 1957, held that Nikolaev had killed for political reasons, while admitting that there was no conclusive evidence of criminal ties between him and the other accused.
Further commissions examined the case into the 1960s and again in the perestroika years, the last under Politburo member Alexander Yakovlev. In June 1990 the USSR Prosecutor General's Office prepared a report on the case in answer to a note from Yakovlev. The rehabilitation of the thirteen men executed with him was set in motion in 1989. Nikolaev himself has never been rehabilitated.
In December 2009, seventy-five years after the killing, Russia's Federal Security Service published previously secret documents from the file. The papers contained no evidence of the alleged conspiracy. The full file runs to fifty-eight volumes, and only part of it has been declassified.
Three explanations have been offered for the killing. The 1934 verdict held that Nikolaev acted for a Zinovievite terrorist center; that version was abandoned, and the men convicted with him were rehabilitated. Khrushchev, in 1956 and 1961, and some historians have suggested that Stalin arranged the killing through the security police; no document establishing that has been produced, and the 1956 and 1957 commissions did not find one. The third view, advanced by Yakovlev in 1990 and supported by the documents released in 2009, is that Nikolaev acted alone out of personal grievance.
1904: Leonid Vasilyevich Nikolaev is born in St. Petersburg, on the Vyborg side.
1922: He becomes office manager of the Vyborg district Komsomol committee.
April 1924: He joins the Communist Party.
1925: He marries and settles in Leningrad.
August 1932: He becomes an inspector in the Workers' and Peasants' Inspection.
October 1933: He joins the regional Institute of Party History.
April 1934: He is dismissed and expelled from the party; the expulsion is later reduced to a severe reprimand.
Mid-October 1934: Guards detain him in Leningrad and release him.
December 1, 1934: He kills the Leningrad party chief in Leningrad and is detained; the decree on terrorist cases is issued the same day.
December 16, 1934: Zinoviev and Kamenev are arrested.
December 28-29, 1934: The Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court tries Nikolaev and thirteen co-defendants in closed session in Leningrad and sentences all fourteen to death.
December 29, 1934: Nikolaev is executed in Leningrad.
April 1956: The Presidium sets up a commission to verify the case.
December 1956: The commission concludes that he acted for political reasons.
April 23, 1957: A further commission report keeps that conclusion.
1989: Rehabilitation of his thirteen co-defendants begins.
June 1990: The USSR Prosecutor General's Office reports on the case.
December 2009: The Federal Security Service publishes documents from the file.