Lemaricus Davidson

Victims
2 people murdered in Knoxville, January 2007; death sentences. Jury verdict, October 28, 2009: first-degree and felony murder in both deaths, with kidnapping, robbery, rape and theft counts.
Years active
January 6, 2007, and the days that followed
Location
Knoxville, Tennessee
Method
First-degree murder and felony murder in the course of kidnapping and robbery
Status
Two death sentences (October 2009), affirmed in 2016; post-conviction relief denied 2019, affirmed 2021; federal habeas pending; on death row in Tennessee (March 2026)

In January 2007 a young Knoxville couple, Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom, were kidnapped in their own city, and within days both were dead. Five people were eventually convicted for what was done to them. The man at the center of the prosecution's case was Lemaricus Devall Davidson, who was 28 when he went on trial in Knoxville in October 2009. On October 28 the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder and felony murder in both deaths, of facilitation of aggravated rape, and of the related kidnapping, robbery, rape and theft charges. The same jury then sentenced him to death twice.

He was the only one of the five to receive a death sentence, and it nearly did not hold. After the state's trials were over, the judge who had presided over every one of them pleaded guilty to official misconduct, and it emerged that he had been abusing prescription drugs while on the bench. A special judge threw out Davidson's verdicts in December 2011. The Tennessee Supreme Court reversed him the following spring, and in December 2016 the same court unanimously affirmed Davidson's convictions and both death sentences.

The couple were kidnapped in Knoxville on the night of January 6, 2007, and both were killed in the days that followed. The investigation moved fast. On January 11, five days after the kidnapping, Davidson was taken into custody in Knoxville, and within a day four others had been arrested or charged.

Davidson was charged with 46 counts, among them premeditated murder, felony murder, rape, robbery, kidnapping and theft, and he pleaded not guilty to all of them. On March 4, 2008, the district attorney for Knox County announced that his office would seek the death penalty against the four defendants in state court.

The state tried its four defendants separately, in the criminal court in Knoxville, before the same judge. Davidson's trial came in October 2009 and ran eight days. The jury returned its verdicts on October 28, and in the penalty phase that followed it imposed a death sentence for each of the two murders.

The verdicts were sweeping. The jury convicted him on two counts of premeditated first-degree murder and sixteen counts of felony murder, together with especially aggravated robbery, especially aggravated kidnapping, aggravated rape and facilitation of aggravated rape. After the verdict the trial court dismissed two of the felony-murder counts.

The four others were convicted for their parts: his half-brother was sentenced to life without parole plus 100 years in 2009; the half-brother's friend was convicted twice and received two consecutive life terms plus 25 years after a 2013 retrial; the half-brother's girlfriend was convicted twice of facilitation and related counts and received 35 years after a 2012 retrial; and a fifth man who had helped Davidson hide was sentenced to 18 years in federal court in 2008 as an accessory after the fact, then to two consecutive life sentences plus 90 years after a 2019 state murder conviction.

Then the case came apart. The presiding judge resigned from the bench, and in March 2011 he pleaded guilty to official misconduct. He had been abusing prescription drugs during the period in which he was hearing cases, and every conviction he had presided over was suddenly in question.

A special judge took over the defendants' motions for a new trial, and on December 1, 2011, he granted new trials to all four, ruling that the trials had been undermined by structural errors. The state carried the question to the Tennessee Supreme Court. On May 24, 2012, that court overturned the new-trial ruling for Davidson, holding that the former judge's conduct outside the courtroom had not denied him a fair trial. By the end of October 2012 a different senior judge had taken over his case, and Davidson's convictions and his two death sentences were back in force.

With the verdicts restored, Davidson's appeal went forward. The Court of Criminal Appeals heard it first and affirmed the convictions and sentences. One of the questions before the Tennessee Supreme Court concerned evidence that police had gathered under a warrant whose supporting affidavit an officer had unintentionally failed to sign.

On December 19, 2016, in a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed Davidson's convictions and both death sentences, holding among other things that the evidence gathered under that warrant had been properly admitted. It found no merit in any of his claims of evidentiary error and held that the trial court had properly merged the overlapping murder convictions. On the sentences themselves, the court found that neither had been imposed arbitrarily, and after comparing his case with others in which Tennessee juries had weighed death, it held that neither was excessive or disproportionate.

On October 2, 2017, the Supreme Court of the United States denied certiorari, declining to hear his case and ending his direct appeals.

Davidson returned to court in Knoxville to attack the convictions again, this time through a petition for post-conviction relief. The amended petition put his trial lawyers on trial. They had never moved to take the case out of Knox County despite heavy local coverage, it argued; they had not hired an independent forensic expert to answer part of the State's scientific evidence; they had offered no expert testimony at the guilt phase that his mental state left him unable to form the intent that first-degree murder requires; and they had built their attack on the trial judge's conduct almost entirely on the state investigators' report about the judge, a report that said nothing specific about Davidson's own trial. The petition also faulted them over the makeup of the jury pool and over the mental-health evidence they presented at sentencing.

While that petition was pending, the case took a new turn. In September 2018 prosecutors told Davidson's post-conviction lawyers that the half-brother's friend, preparing to testify against the fifth man at that man's coming murder trial, would say that the fifth man, not Davidson, had killed the young man, and that Davidson had not been present. The friend had never told police any of this after his arrest in 2007; he first gave the account to the State in 2018. Davidson's lawyers added new claims built on it: that he was innocent of the death penalty for that death because the jury had sentenced him on aggravating circumstances that could no longer stand, that the new evidence required a new sentencing jury, that the State's treatment of an equally culpable co-defendant made his own death sentence unconstitutional, and that the prosecution had argued inconsistent theories of who did the killing.

The court heard the petition over two days at the end of January 2019 and denied it on February 27. It agreed that the trial lawyers had fallen short of the professional standard by not seeking a change of venue, but it found that the jury had been fairly chosen and that careful jury selection had rebutted any presumption of prejudice from the publicity, so the failure had not harmed him. The forensic-expert claim failed because nothing suggested an independent expert would have reached different conclusions from the State's, and the diminished-capacity claim failed for want of evidence. On the judge, the court noted that the Tennessee Supreme Court had already considered the questions about him twice and rejected them, and it found that the evidence at the hearing did not show that his conduct had affected Davidson's trial.

In June 2019, with his appeal of that ruling pending, Davidson filed a petition for a writ of error coram nobis resting on the friend's new account. The friend testified at a hearing on October 21, 2019, and on November 7 the court denied the petition.

The Court of Criminal Appeals took up both rulings together. On August 19, 2021, it affirmed the denial of post-conviction relief and of coram nobis relief. On venue, it found that the defense and the court had used every available safeguard against juror prejudice and that Davidson had failed to show the lawyers' lapse had made the trial unreliable or fundamentally unfair. It agreed with the trial court on the forensic-expert claim, on the diminished-capacity claim and on the claim about the judge, which it held Davidson had not supported with clear and convincing evidence.

The case then moved into federal court. By March 2022 Davidson's petition for a writ of habeas corpus was before the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee in Knoxville, challenging his convictions and both death sentences. Its claims include the trial lawyers' failures, a claim that the trial judge was biased, a claim that the State withheld evidence about the fifth man's role, and a claim that the late emergence of the friend's account rendered the convictions and sentences unconstitutional.

At the same time Davidson went back to the state courts once more, with a motion to reopen his post-conviction case, two further coram nobis petitions and a second post-conviction petition. These leaned on new expert opinions and witness statements in support of claims the state courts had already decided, and on a new equal-protection argument: that the Supreme Court's 2023 decision striking down race-conscious university admissions also condemned the method the Tennessee Supreme Court had used to review his death sentences for proportionality. He asked the federal court to pause his case until the state courts ruled.

On March 31, 2025, the district judge refused. Four of the trial-counsel claims had already gone through a full round of state appellate review, the court held, so Davidson was seeking to add new evidence to exhausted claims rather than to exhaust new ones, and a pause was not available for that. He had offered no reason for failing to appeal the other two claims after the post-conviction court rejected them. The equal-protection claim did not clear even the low bar of being potentially meritorious, since nothing suggested that a ruling on university admissions could reach Tennessee's review of death sentences.

On March 12, 2026, a federal magistrate judge denied his request for discovery. Requests for records behind the state investigation of the trial judge were denied without prejudice as premature, because the court could not yet tell whether any new evidence on those claims could legally be considered. Requests for police, prosecution and federal agency files about the fifth man were denied outright. Davidson had not been diligent in raising that claim in state court, the court found, and he had offered no specific facts suggesting the State had withheld anything, particularly since the friend had not given his account to the State until 2018, long after Davidson's trial.

At that point Davidson was serving his two death sentences in a Tennessee maximum-security prison, and his federal petition remained pending.

No court made a finding on motive.

The share of the blame each defendant bore was contested at every trial, and the half-brother's girlfriend was acquitted twice of the charges concerning one of the two deaths. Davidson pleaded not guilty to every count; the jury's verdicts and the Tennessee Supreme Court's 2016 opinion fixed his own role in law.

The account the half-brother's friend first gave in 2018, that the fifth man and not Davidson caused one of the two deaths and that Davidson was not present, had won him no relief in any court by March 2026. The trial court denied coram nobis relief in 2019, the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed in 2021, and the federal claims built on that account had not been decided as of March 2026.

Timeline

January 6, 2007: A young Knoxville couple are kidnapped in Knoxville; both die in the days that follow.

January 11, 2007: Davidson is taken into custody in Knoxville.

March 4, 2008: The Knox County district attorney announces he will seek death against the four state defendants.

October 28, 2009: Davidson is convicted of first-degree murder, felony murder, facilitation of aggravated rape and related counts; the jury then imposes two death sentences.

March 2011: The trial judge, who has resigned, pleads guilty to official misconduct.

December 1, 2011: A special judge orders new trials for all four state defendants.

May 24, 2012: The Tennessee Supreme Court overturns the new-trial ruling for Davidson.

October 2012: A different senior judge takes over Davidson's case; his convictions and death sentences stand.

December 19, 2016: The Tennessee Supreme Court unanimously affirms Davidson's convictions and death sentences.

October 2, 2017: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari.

September 2018: Prosecutors disclose that the half-brother's friend will testify that the fifth man, not Davidson, caused one of the deaths.

February 27, 2019: The court in Knoxville denies post-conviction relief after a two-day hearing in January.

November 7, 2019: The court denies Davidson's petition for a writ of error coram nobis.

August 19, 2021: The Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the denial of post-conviction and coram nobis relief.

March 2022: Davidson's federal habeas corpus petition is before the federal court in Knoxville.

March 31, 2025: The federal district judge refuses to pause the habeas case while Davidson pursues new state filings.

March 12, 2026: A federal magistrate judge denies Davidson's request for discovery; the petition remains pending.