Lee Harvey Oswald

Victims
President Kennedy and Patrolman Tippit killed, 1963; never tried. Charged by complaint with both murders; killed November 24, 1963; the Warren Commission attributed both deaths to him.
Years active
November 22, 1963
Location
Dallas, Texas
Method
Murder (as charged by complaint, never tried); assassination of the President, as found by the Warren Commission (1964) and the House committee (1979).
Status
Never indicted or tried. Killed in Dallas on November 24, 1963, by Jack Ruby, later convicted of murder with malice (death); reversed on appeal in October 1966.

On November 22, 1963, President John F. Kennedy was killed in Dallas during a visit to Texas. Within hours the Dallas police held a 24-year-old warehouse worker named Lee Harvey Oswald. That evening he was charged with the murder of a Dallas patrolman who had died in the Oak Cliff district about 45 minutes after the President, and early the next morning he was arraigned on a second complaint charging him with the murder of the President. He denied both. On Sunday, November 24, as he was about to be moved from police custody to the county jail, he was killed by a Dallas nightclub operator, Jack Ruby. Oswald was never indicted, never tried and never convicted of anything connected with that weekend.

What exists in place of a verdict are the findings of two federal inquiries. A presidential commission chaired by the Chief Justice of the United States, known by his name as the Warren Commission, concluded in September 1964 that Oswald had killed both men and that he had acted alone. Fifteen years later the House Select Committee on Assassinations agreed that Oswald had killed the President but concluded that the President had "probably" been assassinated as the result of a conspiracy. Neither panel was a court, and neither finding is a conviction. The legal record of the case against Oswald ends with two complaints filed before a justice of the peace in Dallas County.

Oswald was born on October 18, 1939, in New Orleans, and grew up in New Orleans, the Dallas and Fort Worth area and, for a time, New York City, where a truancy case brought him before the city's courts in 1953; it was dismissed in March 1954. He left school in Fort Worth in September 1956.

On October 24, 1956, he enlisted in the United States Marine Corps and served in the United States and in Japan. He was court-martialed twice in 1958. In 1959 he applied for a dependency discharge, which was approved, and on September 11, 1959, he was released from active duty and transferred to the Marine Corps Reserve.

He had applied for a passport on September 4, 1959, while still on active duty, and it was issued as a matter of routine six days later. He entered Moscow on October 16, 1959. On October 31 he went to the United States Embassy in Moscow to renounce his citizenship, but he never completed the formalities, and his citizenship was never surrendered. The Commission later found that he had never executed the required forms before a consular official, and so had never given up his citizenship under the law.

The Soviet government refused his application for citizenship and let him stay as a resident alien. The Commission found "no indication" that agents of the Soviet Union had prompted him to go, and nothing to show that he was a Soviet agent when he arrived. It accepted that the KGB "undoubtedly investigated Oswald as fully as possible," and the House committee, years later, reported that there were "no records of interviews of Oswald by the KGB." The Marine Corps Reserve gave him an undesirable discharge on September 13, 1960.

In 1961 he asked the embassy for his passport back. The consul concluded that he had not lost his citizenship and returned it, valid only for direct travel to the United States, and the Commission found that the State Department's dealings with him revealed "no irregularity suggesting any illegal actions or impropriety." He returned to the United States in June 1962.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation already had a file on him. It had started one in October 1959, after the first reports of his defection, "for the purpose of correlating information inasmuch as he was considered a possible security risk." An agent interviewed him in Fort Worth on June 26, 1962, and again on August 16, 1962, concluded that he was not a security risk and recommended that the case be closed. It was reopened in March 1963, after the Bureau learned among other things that he subscribed to the Worker, the Communist Party newspaper.

His politics in those months ran mostly through the mail. He had subscribed to the Worker in August 1962; in October 1962 he tried to join the Socialist Workers Party, which turned him down because it had no Dallas chapter, and in December he subscribed to its paper, the Militant. Officials of both parties testified that he was never a member, and the Commission found no other significant contact with either.

In April 1963 he moved to New Orleans, where, that summer, he handed out leaflets in support of the Fair Play for Cuba Committee. In May he had obtained the committee's literature, applied for membership and asked its New York headquarters for a charter for a New Orleans chapter. The national office never authorized one and never paid for his activities, and the Commission concluded that the chapter was "entirely fictitious"; no other member was ever found. On August 9, 1963, a dispute with three Cuban exiles over the leafleting ended with all four arrested on a peace charge; he pleaded guilty and paid a fine of $10.

The House committee looked hard at those New Orleans months and could not settle them. It found that the confrontation over the leaflets was his only dealing with the exile group involved, and it tended to agree that he had been trying to infiltrate the anti-Castro movement, though it "was not able to determine why Oswald approached the anti-Castro Cubans." It said it "could not explain Oswald's associations--nor at this late date fully determine their extent--with anti-Castro Cubans," and it noted that "Oswald consistently demonstrated a left-wing Marxist ideology."

In late September 1963 he went to Mexico City, where he sought visas at the Cuban and Soviet embassies and obtained neither. The Commission found "no evidence that Oswald's trip to Mexico was in any way connected with the assassination," and no evidence of foreign help. The House committee found that the man who presented himself as Oswald at the Cuban consulate "was not an imposter," and, on balance, that he had not voiced a threat to Cuban officials. He was back in Dallas on October 3, 1963.

The President was killed in Dallas that day, and the Governor of Texas, riding in the same car, was wounded and survived.

The second victim of the day was a Dallas police officer who had served on the force for 11 years. He died in Oak Cliff that afternoon. The Warren Commission later put its finding in these words: "Oswald killed Dallas Police Patrolman J. D. Tippit approximately 45 minutes after the assassination."

Oswald was arrested in Dallas later that afternoon by officers of the Dallas Police Department.

For roughly 48 hours Oswald was held at Dallas police headquarters and questioned. Throughout, he denied any part in the President's death and in the patrolman's.

The charges came on the first night. On Friday evening the captain in charge of the homicide bureau signed a complaint charging Oswald with the murder of the patrolman, and an assistant district attorney added his signature. A justice of the peace of Dallas County arraigned him on that complaint the same evening. Later that night the captain signed a second complaint, charging him with the murder of the President, and in the first hours of Saturday, November 23, the same justice of the peace arraigned him on it.

Before the first round of questioning on Friday, the homicide captain warned him that he did not have to make a statement and that anything he said could be used against him. At each arraignment the justice of the peace advised him of his right to counsel and his right to remain silent. Oswald had no lawyer at any point.

On Sunday, November 24, 1963, as he was being moved from police headquarters to the county jail, Jack Ruby, who ran a Dallas nightclub, killed him. Oswald died later that day. The Warren Commission found "no evidence that Jack Ruby acted with any other person in the killing of Lee Harvey Oswald."

His death ended the case against him. No grand jury was asked to indict him, no evidence was tested before a jury, and the complaints of November 22 and 23 were never brought to trial.

A Dallas County grand jury indicted Ruby for murder with malice. His trial in Dallas ended on March 14, 1964, when the jury of eight men and four women, after just over two hours of deliberation, returned its verdict: "We, the jury, find the defendant guilty of murder with malice and assess the penalty at death."

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the conviction in October 1966. It held that the trial judge had wrongly allowed the jury to hear a statement Ruby made after his arrest that he had planned to kill Oswald, and that the refusal to move the trial out of Dallas was by itself enough to overturn the verdict. The judgment was "Reversed and remanded with directions." Ruby fell ill before a new trial could be held, and he died in Dallas in January 1967, never retried.

President Lyndon B. Johnson created the Commission by Executive Order No. 11130 on November 29, 1963, five days after Oswald's death, and directed it to "evaluate all the facts and circumstances surrounding the assassination." The order did not name Oswald. It spoke of "the subsequent violent death of the man charged with the assassination." The Commission had seven members: the Chief Justice, two senators, two representatives and two lawyers from private life. It heard 552 witnesses and delivered its report to the President on September 24, 1964.

The Commission was clear about its own limits. "The Commission has functioned neither as a court presiding over an adversary proceeding nor as a prosecutor," it wrote, and it acknowledged that "under our system there is no provision for a posthumous trial." Had Oswald lived, it said, a judge and jury would have presumed him innocent, and he "could have participated in and guided his defense."

The Commission traced Oswald's money from his return in June 1962 to November 22, 1963, and found that the funds known to be available to him "were sufficient to cover all of his known expenditures during this period." On the old question of whether he had worked for the government, it was categorical: "there was absolutely no type of informant or undercover relationship between an agency of the U.S. Government and Lee Harvey Oswald at any time."

On the central question it was unequivocal. "On the basis of the evidence before the Commission it concludes that Oswald acted alone," the report said, and: "The Commission has found no evidence that either Lee Harvey Oswald or Jack Ruby was part of any conspiracy." On why he had done it, the Commission was candid about its limits: "The Commission could not make any definitive determination of Oswald's motives."

Oswald was charged and never tried. Every statement that he killed either man rests on the findings of the two inquiries, not on a verdict, and he denied both killings throughout his time in custody.

The two inquiries agreed on Oswald's part in the President's death and differed on whether he acted alone. The House committee found that Oswald's other actions tended to support the conclusion that he had assassinated the President, but it also found that the President "was probably assassinated as a result of a conspiracy," and said it could not identify any other participant or establish the extent of that conspiracy. It found that the Soviet government "was not involved" and that the Cuban government "was not involved"; that anti-Castro Cuban groups, "as groups, were not involved," and that the national syndicate of organized crime, "as a group, was not involved," while leaving open the involvement of individual members; and that the Secret Service, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Central Intelligence Agency "were not involved in the assassination." The Warren Commission's finding that he acted alone has never been adopted or overturned by any court.

On the patrolman's death the House committee reached the same conclusion as the Commission, resting it on physical evidence tied to Oswald soon afterward and on eyewitness identifications. Like the Commission, it found "no credible evidence that Oswald was an FBI informant" and "no evidence of any relationship between Oswald and the CIA."

Theories of a wider conspiracy, in many versions, have circulated since 1963 and remain contested.

Timeline

October 18, 1939: Lee Harvey Oswald is born to a family living in New Orleans.

October 24, 1956: He enlists in the United States Marine Corps.

September 10, 1959: His first passport is issued.

September 11, 1959: He is released from active duty and transferred to the Marine Corps Reserve.

October 16, 1959: He enters Moscow; on October 31 he goes to the U.S. Embassy to renounce his citizenship, which he never completes.

September 13, 1960: The Marine Corps Reserve gives him an undesirable discharge.

July 8, 1961: The embassy returns his passport, valid only for direct travel to the United States.

June 13, 1962: He lands at Hoboken, New Jersey, and returns to the Fort Worth area.

June 26 and August 16, 1962: The FBI interviews him in Fort Worth.

August 9, 1963: He is arrested in New Orleans on a peace charge; he pleads guilty two days later and pays a $10 fine.

September 26 to October 3, 1963: He is in Mexico, where he seeks Cuban and Soviet visas and obtains neither.

October 3, 1963: He returns to Dallas.

November 22, 1963: The President is killed in Dallas; the patrolman dies in Oak Cliff; Oswald is arrested and that evening charged by complaint with the officer's murder.

November 23, 1963: He is arraigned on a complaint charging him with the murder of the President.

November 24, 1963: He is killed in Dallas by Jack Ruby while being transferred from police custody.

November 29, 1963: Executive Order No. 11130 creates the Warren Commission.

March 14, 1964: A Dallas jury finds Ruby guilty of murder with malice and assesses death.

September 24, 1964: The Warren Commission delivers its report to President Johnson.

October 1966: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reverses Ruby's conviction.

January 1967: Ruby dies in Dallas before a new trial.

1979: The House Select Committee on Assassinations issues its report.