Laurent Bucyibaruta

Victims
Gikongoro massacres, Rwanda, 1994; complicity, appeal unheard. Convicted in Paris, July 12, 2022, of complicity in genocide and crimes against humanity; acquitted as principal; died in 2023.
Years active
April 21, 1994 (Murambi, Cyanika, Kaduha); May 1994 (Marie Merci school, Kibeho); April to July 1994 (roadblocks and patrols)
Location
Gikongoro prefecture, Rwanda (Murambi, Cyanika, Kaduha, Kibeho); Troyes area and Paris, France
Method
Complicity, by aid or assistance, in genocide and in crimes against humanity committed in Gikongoro prefecture, April to July 1994
Status
20 years' réclusion criminelle (July 12, 2022); appealed; released on medical grounds pending appeal in 2022; died December 6, 2023; case closed

Laurent Bucyibaruta was the senior civil authority in Gikongoro, a hilly prefecture in southern Rwanda, when the genocide against the Tutsi began in April 1994. Within weeks Gikongoro had become one of the worst-affected regions of the country. On a single day, April 21, about 75,000 people were killed at a technical school under construction at Murambi and at the Catholic parishes of Cyanika and Kaduha. Students were killed at the Marie Merci school in Kibeho. People were stopped and killed at roadblocks and by patrols across the prefecture. Bucyibaruta did not kill anyone with his own hands, and the prosecution never claimed he had. The question put to the court was what the prefect had done, and failed to do, while the killing went on around his office.

Twenty-eight years later, on July 12, 2022, the Cour d'assises de Paris answered it. The court acquitted him as a principal perpetrator of genocide and convicted him of complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity for the massacres at Murambi, Cyanika and Kaduha, the killings of the Marie Merci students, and the killings at roadblocks and during patrols. It acquitted him over the massacre at the Kibeho parish on April 14, 1994, and over the killings of Tutsi prisoners, three priests among them, in the Gikongoro prison. He was sentenced to 20 years' réclusion criminelle and was taken into custody by gendarmes in the courtroom. He was the highest-ranking Rwandan official ever tried in France for crimes connected to the genocide.

He appealed. The appeal was never heard. Released on medical grounds while it was pending, he died on December 6, 2023, and the case was closed.

A career inside the state

Bucyibaruta was born in 1944 and came from Gikongoro; the area around Kaduha was his native region. He spent decades in the service of a single-party system in which the ruling MRND and the state were, for practical purposes, the same institution. He worked as a local administrator and later sat in parliament. Before he returned to Gikongoro as prefect in 1992, he had held the same post in Kibungo, in eastern Rwanda.

A prefect in Rwanda at that time was the government's representative in his prefecture, with authority over the sub-prefects and the burgomasters who ran each commune, and a seat at the security meetings where civil and military officials met. Bucyibaruta co-chaired those meetings in Gikongoro with a senior army officer from the prefecture whose influence grew steadily through 1993 and 1994.

April 1994

On April 6, 1994, the plane carrying President Juvénal Habyarimana was brought down over Kigali. The killing of Tutsi began the next day and continued for about a hundred days. The United Nations puts the number of dead at no fewer than 800,000.

Bucyibaruta was among the first officials to declare support for the interim government on national radio. On April 11 he attended a meeting with that government in Kigali. When he came back to Gikongoro he met his sub-prefects and burgomasters but gave them no direction, and officials who wanted to resist the violence were left to manage on their own.

In the communes, Tutsi fleeing their hills began to gather at churches and public buildings. Some of those who reached Gikongoro town in the first days of the genocide took shelter at the bishopric. Witnesses at his trial said the prefect advised them to move to the technical school at Murambi, a complex of buildings under construction since 1990, where they would be protected, and that they went there under gendarme escort. A witness told the court that the prefect came to Murambi a few days before the massacre, promised the refugees food and security, and discouraged them from leaving.

On April 14 the killing reached the parish at Kibeho, where thousands of Tutsi had gathered; the prosecution later put the dead at about 25,000. Across the prefecture, Tutsi at other parishes waited for protection that did not come. At the church of Muganza, in Kivu commune, the burgomaster went to the prefect more than once to ask for help for the people sheltering there. On or around April 18 or 19, Bucyibaruta met a delegation sent by the interim president.

April 21: Murambi, Cyanika and Kaduha

The massacre at Murambi took place in the night of April 20 to 21. An estimated 50,000 people died at the school during the first month of the genocide, most of them that night. Those who escaped and reached the parish of Cyanika were killed there the same afternoon; the parish's former abbé, Joseph Niyomugabo, a Tutsi, was among the dead. At Kaduha, the parish in the prefect's native region, the Tutsi who had been sent to the church by the local sub-prefect were killed on April 21 as well. The sub-prefect reported the massacre to the prefect afterward.

The three massacres were the core of the case against him. Survivors and testimony before Rwanda's community gacaca courts described him directing events from his office through his subordinates.

The prefect's correspondence

Bucyibaruta did not stay silent through April. He called a meeting of the prefecture's burgomasters for April 26 to carry out orders from the Ministry of the Interior to tighten control. Three days later, on April 29, he issued a seven-page message. It was, in many ways, a well-argued plea to end the violence, framed around the harm it was doing to the population, and it prohibited "massacres, pillage, and other acts of violence of whatever kind." The same message organized self-defense units by sector, with barriers and patrols, and ordered communal authorities to draw up inventories of the land and goods left by Tutsi. Burgomasters were to read it aloud at public meetings with a prefectural official present.

The killing did not stop. In Kinyamakara commune the meeting held to read the message was followed by fresh violence against Tutsi, and across Gikongoro the "pacification" meetings often came just before new killings. The prefect was able to write a convincing appeal for an end to the violence, Human Rights Watch and the FIDH concluded in 1999, but he never backed his words with action. By early July 1994 no authority was left in Gikongoro to protect the Tutsi. On May 18 he informed his burgomasters that the senior officer with whom he had shared the security meetings had been appointed civil defense adviser for Gikongoro and Butare.

The Marie Merci school and the roadblocks

The Marie Merci school in Kibeho held Tutsi and Hutu students together into May. A 2020 report by Rwanda's national commission for the fight against genocide described how gendarmes and school authorities kept the Tutsi students from leaving. On May 4, 1994, the school's director, a priest, organized a meeting attended by several dignitaries, Bucyibaruta among them. On May 7 about 100 Tutsi students were killed. Eight survived. The prosecution argued at trial that the prefect had requisitioned gendarmes he knew would take part.

The roadblocks were the other part of the charge. The prosecution's case was that the prefect left barriers in place knowing they were being used to identify and kill Tutsi, and that patrols set up under the prefecture's authority carried out killings across the communes. It also accused him of announcing that peace had been restored, which drew Tutsi out of hiding.

Bucyibaruta remained prefect until the interim government collapsed in early July 1994. He left Rwanda on July 23, after the genocide had ended.

From Rwanda he went to what is now the Democratic Republic of the Congo, then to the Central African Republic, and in 1997 he settled in France, where he lived as a refugee in the suburbs of Troyes. On January 5, 2000, the FIDH and its French member, the Ligue des droits de l'Homme, filed a complaint against him; the association Survie and families of victims joined the proceedings. On May 3, 2000, the Troyes prosecutor's office questioned him and he was held in custody. He was released on December 20, 2000. A judicial investigation was opened, and he was placed under judicial supervision.

The Arusha indictment and the referral to France

The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, brought its own case. Its indictment, confirmed in 2005, charged him with direct and public incitement to commit genocide, genocide or in the alternative complicity in genocide, and extermination, murder and rape as crimes against humanity, on the basis of his individual responsibility and his responsibility as a superior.

In June 2007, under the tribunal's plan to finish its trials by the end of 2008, the tribunal's prosecutor asked for the case to be referred to France. He was held in France from July 20, 2007, at the prosecutor's request, together with a Rwandan priest whose case was also being referred. On August 1, 2007, the Paris Court of Appeal ordered both men released, holding among other things that the arrest and detention violated the presumption of innocence. The French prosecution chose not to appeal that decision. On August 13, 2007, the tribunal issued its own arrest warrant and transfer order. He was detained again on September 5, 2007, and placed under judicial supervision, which barred him from leaving metropolitan France.

On November 20, 2007, a three-judge trial chamber in Arusha granted the referral. It found that French law gave French courts jurisdiction, that the accused was present on French territory, that he could not be sentenced to death there, and that he would receive a fair trial. The chamber ordered the case sent to the French authorities, to be brought immediately before the competent court, and directed the tribunal's prosecutor to report on the French proceedings every three months. The next day the tribunal's president revoked an earlier order that France transfer him to Arusha.

Twenty-two years of procedure

The French investigation absorbed the file from Arusha and went on for a decade. In 2013 the tribunal expressed concern at how slowly it was moving. On May 9, 2017, the investigating judge informed the parties that the investigation was complete. On October 4, 2018, the prosecution asked for him to be tried for genocide and crimes against humanity. On December 24, 2018, the investigating judges sent him for trial on charges of complicity in genocide and in crimes against humanity. Several allegations fell away in the investigation: the judges dismissed the murders of a gendarme and of a woman, his alleged complicity in rapes in Gikongoro prefecture, and a count of criminal conspiracy.

Both sides appealed the committal. The investigating chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal heard the appeals on October 7, 2020, and ruled on January 21, 2021. It confirmed the trial and widened it, recasting certain counts from complicity to genocide as principal and restoring charges the investigating judges had rejected. The indictment that came out of that ruling accused him of having had serious harm to life and to physical and mental integrity inflicted, between April and July 1994, on the people gathered at the Murambi school, on Tutsi prisoners in the Gikongoro prison, and on people seized at roadblocks and during patrols. It accused him of complicity, by knowingly aiding the perpetrators, in the massacres at the parishes of Kibeho, Cyanika and Kaduha and in the killing of the Marie Merci students. Rwandan counts put the dead at the six sites in Gikongoro at more than 110,000.

The trial

The trial opened in Paris on May 9, 2022, before a court of three professional judges and six jurors. It was the fourth trial in France for crimes committed during the genocide, and it came 22 years after the first complaint. He appeared free, under judicial supervision. He had always denied any part in the genocide. His lawyers first asked the court to end the case over the unreasonable length of the proceedings, and, failing that, to acquit him.

The prosecution was brought by France's national counter-terrorism prosecutor's office, which handles crimes against humanity. About 115 people were called over two months, among them historians and other experts, witnesses to the events and witnesses for the civil parties, and more than 100 statements were heard. Survivors flew in from Rwanda or testified by video link from Kigali. The case turned on the security meetings the prefect had called or attended, which the prosecution described as planning sessions for the killings, and on the gathering of thousands of Tutsi at Murambi on promises of food, water and protection.

In court, Bucyibaruta presented himself as a man overtaken by events, without the means to stop killings carried out by soldiers, militiamen and gendarmes, and he denied any part in the massacres.

In early July 2022 the prosecution asked for life imprisonment. It went beyond the indictment, which charged him as a principal only for Murambi. It asked the court to convict him as a principal of genocide for the massacres at Murambi, Cyanika and Kaduha, with some 75,000 dead, and for the killing of the Marie Merci students; as an accomplice, by aid or assistance, for the Kibeho parish; and of complicity in crimes against humanity for the same acts. It asked for his acquittal over the prisoners in the Gikongoro prison, because doubt remained about his responsibility. The defense asked the jury to acquit an official it described as isolated and powerless.

Verdict and sentence

The court retired on July 12 and returned that evening. It acquitted Bucyibaruta as a principal perpetrator of genocide. It found him guilty of complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity for the massacres at the Murambi school and the parishes of Cyanika and Kaduha on April 21, 1994, for the killings of the students of the Marie Merci school in Kibeho, and for the killings carried out at roadblocks and during patrols.

It acquitted him of genocide and crimes against humanity at the Kibeho parish on April 14, 1994. That massacre was the first of the whole series, the court found, and it did not have sufficient evidence to say that he had given instructions, or that at that point he knew the full extent of the genocidal plan. It acquitted him, as the prosecution had asked, over the killings of Tutsi prisoners, among them three priests, in the Gikongoro prison.

He was sentenced to 20 years' réclusion criminelle. He had come to court free; gendarmes took him into custody as soon as the verdict was read, and he spent the night in prison. He was the fourth person convicted by French courts, under universal jurisdiction, for crimes committed during the genocide in Rwanda.

Appeal, release and death

He had ten days to appeal, and he did. In September 2022, with the appeal pending, he was released on medical grounds.

The appeal trial had not taken place when he died on Wednesday, December 6, 2023. The case was closed, and the conviction of July 2022 never became final.

Context: the French law that tried him

France tried Bucyibaruta under a law of May 22, 1996, which adapted French legislation to the statute of the tribunal in Arusha. Its first two articles give French courts jurisdiction over genocide, crimes against humanity and serious violations of the Geneva Conventions committed in Rwanda in 1994, and, for Rwandan citizens, in neighboring states, provided that the person is found in France. In a ruling of January 6, 1998, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation confirmed that French courts had jurisdiction to try genocide and crimes against humanity committed in Rwanda in 1994. When the Arusha chamber examined French law in 2007, it noted that the French penal code defines genocide and crimes against humanity and punishes both by life imprisonment, and that France had abolished the death penalty in 1981.

The verdict rested on the penal code's definition of complicity. An accomplice is a person who knowingly, by aid or assistance, facilitated the preparation or commission of a crime, or who provoked it or gave instructions for it by gift, promise, threat, order or abuse of authority or power; the accomplice is punished as the principal. That was the line the Paris court drew: it held that the prefect had knowingly aided the massacres of April 21 and after, but found the evidence insufficient to show that he had given instructions at Kibeho on April 14, or known at that stage the full scope of the plan.

Disputed and unproven points

Bucyibaruta denied every charge from the first complaint in 2000 to his last words in court, and he died with his appeal pending, so no final judgment ever settled his responsibility.

The extent of his authority was contested throughout. The prosecution treated the prefect as a powerful official who chose to keep serving; the defense, and his own testimony, presented a man isolated and without means while soldiers and militias held real power. The 1999 assessment by Human Rights Watch and the FIDH placed him between those positions: a loyal bureaucrat who was not an enthusiast of the genocide, who wrote against the violence, but who failed to oppose his superiors and left those resisting the killing without protection.

The court rejected the prosecution's call to convict him as a principal for Murambi, Cyanika, Kaduha and the Marie Merci school, and acquitted him of the Kibeho parish massacre and the prison killings. Earlier in the case, French judges had dismissed allegations of two murders, of complicity in rapes and of criminal conspiracy that had formed part of the Arusha indictment. None of those allegations was proved.

Witnesses placed him at Murambi before the massacre and described him urging the Tutsi to stay. He said he could not see the school from his office and that the killing happened at night. Survivors and gacaca testimony described him directing the April 21 massacres from his office; he denied it. The court's conviction for complicity, not for genocide as a principal, was its answer at first instance, and the appeal that would have tested it was never heard.

Timeline

1944: Laurent Bucyibaruta is born in Rwanda.

1992: After serving as prefect of Kibungo, he becomes prefect of Gikongoro.

April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana's plane is brought down over Kigali; the genocide begins the next day.

April 11, 1994: He attends a meeting with the interim government in Kigali.

April 14, 1994: Massacre at the Kibeho parish (count on which he was later acquitted).

April 21, 1994: About 75,000 people are killed at Murambi, Cyanika and Kaduha.

April 26, 1994: He convenes the prefecture's burgomasters.

April 29, 1994: He issues a seven-page message prohibiting massacres and organizing self-defense units.

May 7, 1994: About 100 Tutsi students of the Marie Merci school in Kibeho are killed.

July 23, 1994: He leaves Rwanda.

1997: He settles in France, near Troyes.

January 5, 2000: The FIDH and the Ligue des droits de l'Homme file a complaint.

May 3 to December 20, 2000: He is questioned and held in custody, then released.

2005: The tribunal in Arusha confirms an indictment against him.

July 20 to August 1, 2007: He is held in France at the Arusha prosecutor's request; the Paris Court of Appeal orders his release.

November 20, 2007: The Arusha tribunal refers his case to France.

May 9, 2017: The French investigation is declared complete.

December 24, 2018: Investigating judges send him for trial.

January 21, 2021: The Paris Court of Appeal confirms and widens the committal.

May 9, 2022: Trial opens before the Cour d'assises de Paris.

July 12, 2022: Convicted of complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity; sentenced to 20 years; he appeals.

September 2022: Released on medical grounds pending appeal.

December 6, 2023: He dies; the case is closed.