Lin Senhao was a master's candidate at the Shanghai Medical College of Fudan University when the man who shared his room, Huang Yang, died in Shanghai on April 16, 2013. Lin confessed to police four days before the death, and he never disputed in court that his own act had caused it. What he disputed, from his first trial to his last appeal, was what he had meant to do. He told the courts it had been an April Fools' prank meant to make his roommate uncomfortable, not to kill him.
Three Chinese courts heard that account and rejected it. The Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People's Court convicted him of intentional homicide on February 18, 2014, and sentenced him to death with deprivation of political rights for life. The Shanghai High People's Court rejected his appeal on January 8, 2015. The Supreme People's Court approved the sentence, and Lin was executed in Shanghai on December 11, 2015. The arguments over intent, over the cause of death and over whether a confession should have spared him carried through every stage.
Lin came from Shantou, in Guangdong Province. He entered the master's program at Fudan's Shanghai Medical College in 2010, and he was 27 when he was sentenced.
The man who would become his roommate came from Rong County, near the city of Zigong in Sichuan Province. He moved into Lin's room in August 2011, joining a third man who had shared it with Lin since 2010, and at first the three got along. Classmates remembered the newcomer as friendly and generous, someone who preferred an evening in with a television drama to a night out.
The friendship between the two men did not last. The first-instance court found that Lin had come to bear a grudge over trivial daily matters. Lin himself rejected that finding on appeal. He said the two had never quarreled and that he had felt no jealousy toward his roommate.
Lin's roommate fell ill on April 1, 2013, and his condition grew worse over the days that followed. The courts later found that Lin knew from the start why his roommate was ill and said nothing. The Supreme People's Court held that he concealed the truth and told lies while the victim's condition deteriorated, and that this deception delayed the help that might have reached him.
Shanghai police questioned Lin twice on April 11, and both times he kept the truth from them. On April 12, once their inquiries had pointed to him, police summoned him as a suspect, and he confessed. The victim died on April 16. A forensic appraisal found that his death resulted from the act Lin had confessed to.
A recording of a later interrogation, made on April 18, 2013, would be shown in court at the appeal. In it Lin wept and apologized to the victim and to his family.
The Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People's Court tried Lin on November 27, 2013, on a charge of intentional homicide. He did not contest the part of the indictment that said his act had caused the death. He did contest the motive. He denied that he had acted out of a grudge, and he described what he had done as an April Fools' joke that had ended in a death he had not intended. Defense counsel argued for a lesser finding of indirect intentional homicide, and the prosecution opposed it.
The court delivered its verdict on February 18, 2014. It convicted Lin of intentional homicide and sentenced him to death, with deprivation of political rights for life. It rejected the April Fools' explanation as unable to stand against his evident understanding of the danger, and it found that he had acted to vent his anger. The court accepted that Lin had confessed. It held that the confession was not enough to justify a lighter sentence, given the cruelty of the means, the gravity of the consequences and the harm the crime had done to society.
In an interview from custody before the verdict, Lin called his own conduct despicable and blamed it on his recklessness. He said that hurting another person had not seemed to cross a moral line for him at the time.
Lin's first instinct after the verdict was to accept it. He appealed all the same.
The Shanghai High People's Court heard the appeal in open court on December 8, 2014. Lin had new counsel for the appeal, and he was far more active in court than he had been at the first trial. He again denied any intent to kill and any motive. He said the idea of a prank had come to him only briefly, after he heard that his roommate was planning an April Fools' trick of his own, and that he had decided to act first and see how the other man would react. He said he had tried, after the fact, to lessen the effect of what he had done. Asked by the prosecution about the consequences, he said he had not thought of them and could not control them. Asked whether he had anything to say to the victim's parents, he wept and said he did not want to say any more.
His two defense lawyers agreed that he had not intended to kill, but they asked the court for different outcomes. One argued that the facts amounted at most to intentional injury. The other argued for negligent homicide. The defense also challenged the official finding on the cause of death, calling a forensic specialist as a witness with specialized knowledge to dispute it, and a forensic expert who had signed the appraisal defended it for the prosecution. The prosecution asked the court to uphold the first judgment.
The High People's Court announced its decision on January 8, 2015. It identified three disputed issues raised by the defense: the identity of what had been used, the cause of death and the charge itself. It rejected the defense on all three. It held that the facts found at first instance were clear and the evidence sufficient, that Lin's conduct was intentional homicide rather than intentional injury or negligent homicide, and that the crime was so serious and its social impact so great that his confession could not earn him a lighter penalty. It dismissed the appeal and upheld the death sentence.
On the specialist's testimony, the court ruled that the written and spoken opinions of a witness with specialized knowledge are not appraisal opinions under the Criminal Procedure Law. They could be heard as a challenge to the appraisal, but they could not on their own serve as the basis for a verdict.
The defense took its challenges to the Supreme People's Court. Through counsel, Lin said that he was not satisfied with the judgment but still believed the judicial system was fair, and he said he hoped society might one day forgive him.
Because the sentence was death, the case went to the Supreme People's Court in Beijing for approval. A collegial panel reviewed the full case file, questioned Lin in person at his place of detention, heard the views of his defense counsel and sought expert consultation.
The panel took the defense's remaining challenges to the evidence and to the cause of death one by one and rejected each. It relied on the findings of both lower courts and on a second examination commissioned by the prosecution, carried out by a group of experts, which confirmed the cause of death and ruled out any other.
On intent, the panel held that Lin's intent to kill was clearly evident. He had understood the danger long before the crime, he had acted deliberately and with planning in order to vent his anger, and he had then concealed the truth and fabricated lies while the victim's condition worsened. On sentence, the court accepted that Lin had confessed after he was taken into custody and had shown a good attitude. It held that this was insufficient to warrant leniency, for three reasons: he confessed only after police had already identified him; he had used specialized knowledge to commit a crime whose circumstances were particularly egregious; and his deception had deliberately delayed help for the victim. The court described the consequences as exceptionally severe and approved the Shanghai High People's Court's ruling upholding the death sentence for intentional homicide, with deprivation of political rights for life.
On December 11, 2015, acting on an execution order signed by the President of the Supreme People's Court, the Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People's Court carried out the sentence, and Lin Senhao was executed in Shanghai. The Supreme People's Court published its findings in the case the same day.
Lin's own account never changed in its core. He admitted the act, said it was meant as an April Fools' prank, and denied wanting his roommate dead. Each court rejected that account, and the conviction rests on their finding that he intended to kill.
The defense contested the medical cause of death at the appeal and again before the Supreme People's Court, relying on a specialist who rejected the official appraisal. The original appraisal, the second examination by a panel of experts and the courts at all three levels all found against the defense on this point.
The defense carried its remaining challenges to the Supreme People's Court, which addressed them in its review and approved the sentence.
2010: Lin Senhao enters the master's program at Fudan University's Shanghai Medical College.
August 2011: The future victim moves into the room Lin shares in Shanghai.
April 1, 2013: Lin's roommate falls ill in Shanghai.
April 11, 2013: Shanghai police question Lin twice; he does not disclose his act.
April 12, 2013: Summoned as a suspect, Lin confesses.
April 16, 2013: The victim dies in Shanghai.
April 18, 2013: In a recorded interrogation, Lin weeps and apologizes to the victim and his family.
November 27, 2013: First-instance trial for intentional homicide at the Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People's Court.
February 18, 2014: Lin is convicted and sentenced to death, with deprivation of political rights for life.
December 8, 2014: Appeal hearing at the Shanghai High People's Court.
January 8, 2015: The High People's Court dismisses the appeal and upholds the death sentence.
December 11, 2015: After the Supreme People's Court approves the sentence, Lin is executed in Shanghai.