LEVI KING: RANDOM RAMPAGE

On the evening of September 30, 2005, a maroon pickup truck rolled up to the inspection lanes at the Bridge of the Americas in El Paso. A Customs and Border Protection officer had noticed it because it was riding too close to the car in front. The driver, a 23-year-old from Missouri, was shaking. Asked for identification, he handed over a card bearing the name and photograph of Brian Conrad, a farmer from the Texas Panhandle. He could not tell the officer the birthday printed on it.

Brian Conrad had been dead since the early hours of that morning. So had his wife, Michell, and her 14-year-old son, Zach Doan. The day before, in rural McDonald County, Missouri, a 70-year-old man named Orlie McCool and his daughter-in-law Dawn had been shot to death, and the pickup at the border was Orlie McCool’s. In little more than a day, the man in the inspection lane had killed five people in two states. His name was Levi King.

The walk-away

King’s record before 2005 was one of property crime, not violence against people. In 2003 a Missouri court sentenced him to 14 years for second-degree arson and burglary. He served 17 months, according to Amarillo’s NewsChannel 10 and The Pampa News, and was paroled; CBS News later put his time in prison at less than three years. In July 2005 he was released to a halfway house in St. Louis.

He did not stay. NewsChannel 10 reported in 2006 that he walked out of the halfway house seven days before the Texas killings, in breach of his parole, and that the authorities were never notified. From St. Louis he made his way to his father’s place in Pineville and took several guns, CBS News reported. Texas Monthly later wrote that his father had thrown him out, and that King told investigators the anger he felt over it was what led him to decide to go out and shoot people.

His defense lawyers would later fill in the years that came before, in a Lubbock courtroom, as they argued for his life. They described a boy who grew up poor in Missouri, surrounded by guns and drugs, with parents who used drugs regularly and neglected him emotionally. He left school at 15, they said, and his parents eventually gave up custody of him. At 20 he was diagnosed with bipolar disorder. King told the Texas judge he had also been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and had been told he was psychotic; his lawyer Maxwell Peck III said he had been suicidal. In the same breath, King assured the court that he had been sane and fully competent when he killed.

Pineville

Orlie McCool was 70 and lived in rural Pineville. Dawn McCool was 47. Most reports called her his daughter-in-law; the Joplin Globe called her his former daughter-in-law. Little else about their lives has been made public, and no connection between them and King has been reported.

They were killed between about 1:30 and 3 p.m. on September 29, 2005, according to Steve Geeding, then the McDonald County prosecutor. Both were shot. Relatives checking on them found them the following morning, about 10 a.m., the Joplin Globe reported. By then their pickup, a Dodge Dakota, was gone, and so was the man who had taken it.

King’s own explanation, given to El Paso detectives on videotape and later played for a Texas jury, was that the killings grew out of a dispute over stray horses. Missouri investigators had something firmer to work with. Shell casings from the scene matched a gun that had been reported stolen, and a local man had told the authorities that his son, Levi King, had broken into his home and taken several guns, CBS News reported. By the evening of September 30, a Missouri warrant for King on a double homicide was active.

Near Pampa

From Pineville, King drove south and then west into the Texas Panhandle, Missouri authorities said. Near Pampa, in Gray County, he stopped.

Brian Conrad was 31 and farmed. His wife, Michell, was 35 and about six months pregnant. Her son, Zach Doan, was 14, and her daughter was 10. CBS News’s 48 Hours described the family as well liked, which left investigators at first with no motive to work from. The Conrads had never met King.

In the early hours of September 30, 2005, he shot and killed Brian Conrad, Michell Conrad and Zach Doan. Michell Conrad’s unborn child did not survive. Her 10-year-old daughter did. After the gunman had gone, the girl called 911, a little after seven in the morning, and Gray County deputies came for her.

What they found offered little to go on. There were shoe prints and the tracks of an unidentified vehicle, but no fingerprints and no DNA, according to 48 Hours. In Pampa, with no suspect and no reason for the killings, fear settled in, and a judge would later move the trial away from the town because of it.

The Bridge of the Americas

King kept driving. He reached El Paso, crossed into Ciudad Juárez, and within hours turned around. It was on the way back, on the evening of September 30, that the officer at the bridge noticed the pickup tailgating.

Three officers described the stop to a jury four years later, KCBD in Lubbock reported. The first said King seemed very nervous and shaky, and that once he had stumbled over the birthday on Brian Conrad’s card the officer asked whether he had any firearms. King said he did, and that they were loaded. He was handcuffed and did not resist. A second officer remembered him as calm, cool and collected, and said King claimed the man on the card was his brother; in the courtroom, family members reacted with open disgust. A third officer testified that King had given him an "evil stare," a detail the defense pointed out had not appeared in his original written statement.

A check of King’s name turned up the active Missouri warrant for a double homicide in Pineville. Officers found four loaded guns in the truck. Texas Monthly reported that he was fingerprinted at the border and identified as a man wanted for questioning in the Missouri shootings. By CBS News’s count, about 11 hours had passed since the McCools were found.

El Paso detectives sat him down. About 15 minutes into the interview, according to 48 Hours, he admitted killing Orlie and Dawn McCool.

Two cases, one man

For a time the two investigations ran on separate tracks. Missouri had its suspect in custody, the McCools' truck and King’s admission. Gray County had a frightened town, a few shoe prints and very little else.

The connection came from King himself. According to 48 Hours, about two weeks after he was returned to Missouri custody he told a deputy there that there were four more bodies in Texas, and the deputy passed the tip to Texas investigators. Texas Monthly gave a shorter interval, reporting that he confessed to both the Missouri and the Pampa killings within a few days of his arrest. Either way, the evidence was already waiting. A name tag bearing Brian Conrad’s name was found in the pickup, McDonald County Chief Deputy Gregg Sweeten told the Joplin Globe, and the Texas Rangers announced a preliminary ballistics match between King and the Gray County killings, NewsChannel 10 reported.

Missouri

King was held without bond in McDonald County on two counts of first-degree murder. He pleaded not guilty, and his lawyers filed a motion arguing that the associate circuit court no longer had jurisdiction. At one point he was moved from the county jail to a maximum-security state prison after officials heard that he might be planning an escape, NewsChannel 10 reported. In 2006 Missouri prosecutors gave notice that they would seek the death penalty.

The case left McDonald County. The defense waived a preliminary hearing, King was bound over for trial, and on a defense request the case was moved to Pulaski County, according to Janice Durbin, by then the county prosecutor.

It ended without a trial. On April 18, 2008, King pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Orlie and Dawn McCool. In exchange, the state gave up its bid for death. He received two sentences of life without parole, to be served one after the other.

The road to Lubbock

Texas had moved early. On March 24, 2006, two days after King was indicted in Missouri, a Gray County grand jury indicted him for capital murder in the deaths of Brian Conrad, Michell Conrad and Zach Doan, with one indictment carrying a second count for Michell Conrad’s unborn child. The deliberations were "fairly quick," District Attorney Lynn Switzer said. The district attorney filed notice that Texas would seek death, and warned that it might be several years before King stood before a judge in Gray County, because Missouri had to finish with him first.

The Missouri plea did not bind Texas. Under an agreement between the two states, a Texas death sentence would take precedence over the Missouri terms; if King were acquitted, a spokeswoman for the Missouri attorney general’s office said, he would go back to Missouri to serve his two life sentences. In December 2008 The Pampa News reported a motions hearing set in the 31st District Court, and described the case as four counts of capital murder.

The defense tried to end the prosecution before it began. King’s lawyer Joe Marr Wilson asked for the charges to be thrown out under the Interstate Agreement on Detainers, arguing that King had not been tried within 120 days of being brought back to the Panhandle. A district judge denied the motion, and on May 20, 2009, Wilson took the question to the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo. The trial went ahead.

District Judge Stephen Emmert moved it out of Gray County to Lubbock, citing widespread fear in Pampa, and placed the lawyers under a gag order. On August 31, 2009, at the defense’s request, he postponed the start while both sides waited for DNA test results.

Guilty, and the question of death

The trial began at the Lubbock County Courthouse on September 3, 2009. Soon after it began, King pleaded guilty to all three counts of capital murder. He told the judge he understood that the state still meant to seek his execution. From that moment the jury had one question left: death, or life in prison without parole.

Switzer spoke first for the state. The defense answered with a childhood of "anger, despair and destruction," and told the jurors that the man in front of them was no longer the man who had committed the crimes. The first witnesses were law enforcement: the 911 dispatcher and Gray County deputies who had answered the call. NewsChannel 10’s reporter watched King slouch and sip coffee in the morning, sit upright and motionless while the 911 recording played, and by the afternoon smirk, look around the room and joke with his lawyers.

The state showed the jury photographs from the scene, and a forensic pathologist testified about the autopsies. Days later the border officers and two El Paso detectives took the stand, and the jury watched King’s videotaped interview. On September 11 Michell Conrad’s daughter, by then 14, testified. King offered to leave the courtroom while she spoke, to make it easier for her; the prosecution insisted he stay. Relatives and friends of the victims followed her to the stand, and one of them looked King in the eye and called what he had done a "horrendous and evil crime." The state rested that day.

The verdict

To send King to death row, the jurors had to answer two questions: whether he would remain a continuing threat to society, and whether anything in his life or character called for mercy. They found that he was a threat. They could not agree on the second question, and that made life without parole automatic.

Deliberations began at 8:15 on the morning of October 6, 2009, and ended nearly eight hours later. Most of the jurors were in tears when the sentence was read, KCBD reported. One juror, Texas Monthly later wrote, had refused to vote for death, and a death sentence required all twelve.

"We’re gratified the system worked like we wanted it to," Peck said. Switzer declined to comment to the Associated Press, but told KCBD that justice is served whenever a jury of one’s peers hears the facts and decides. In a statement on the cost of the case, put at about $750,000, roughly a tenth of the Gray County budget, Switzer said that relatives had a right to confront the man who had killed their loved ones as they slept. Years later, as the former district attorney, Switzer told 48 Hours that if any man had ever deserved to die, it was Levi King.

The families

Michell Conrad’s brother spoke for one side of the family. King had taken his sister, his brother-in-law and his nephew, he said, and September 30, 2005, had changed many lives and many families forever. Brian Conrad’s mother said there was no such thing as closure, only one more phase to get through; the family had been torn apart, and part of it was gone for good. She said they respected the jury’s decision.

Michell Conrad’s daughter spoke to King after the sentence. She told him she still struggled to sleep and felt guilty for not saving her family, and asked why God had chosen her to live and not them. Then she told him she forgave him, and that she hoped he would ask God for forgiveness too. In 2014 she told Texas Monthly she had wanted him to know that her life was still going to turn out well. Police officers and deputies who had worked the case raised money for her college education, the magazine reported.

Afterward

After the Texas verdict King was sent back to Missouri to serve his sentences, KCBD and CBS News reported. In November 2010 NewsChannel 10 found him in a Missouri state prison, living in an incentive unit that allowed inmates with good records to spend most of the day out of their cells and wear their own clothes.

He said there was hardly a day he did not think about what he had done. He acknowledged that some people believed he should have been executed and said he could not really argue with anyone who felt his sentence was too light. Why he stopped near Pampa, and why he chose that family, he said he still could not explain. The closest he came was to describe the killings as aggression he might have turned on himself, turned outward instead, "all that pent up aggression and rage." Asked about the officer who had called the crime evil, he allowed that there was "a certain amount of that there." He said he now tried to use his own history to steer other inmates away from the road that had brought him there.

No appeal of either judgment has been reported. In June 2024, revisiting the case, CBS News said only that King had been extradited to Missouri to serve his sentence.

Disputed points

The motive for the Missouri killings is not settled. King told El Paso detectives the shootings followed an argument about stray horses; Texas Monthly reported that he told investigators his anger at being thrown out by his father led him to decide to shoot people.

Accounts of how Texas learned of his role differ: 48 Hours says he told a Missouri deputy about two weeks after his return, Texas Monthly that he confessed to both states' killings within a few days of his arrest. Reports also differ on the number of Texas counts (three in the 2006 indictment reports and the 2009 plea, four in The Pampa News in 2008) and on how long he served before his 2005 parole (17 months, less than three years, or two years, as his own lawyers told the Texas jury).

Timeline

• 2003: Sentenced in Missouri to 14 years for second-degree arson and burglary.

• July 2005: Paroled and released to a halfway house in St. Louis.

• Late September 2005: Walks away from the halfway house; the authorities are not notified.

• September 29, 2005: Orlie McCool, 70, and Dawn McCool, 47, are shot and killed in rural Pineville, Missouri.

• September 30, 2005: Brian Conrad, 31, Michell Conrad, 35, and Zach Doan, 14, are shot and killed near Pampa, Texas; Michell Conrad’s 10-year-old daughter survives. The McCools are found that morning.

• September 30, 2005, evening: King is arrested at the Bridge of the Americas in El Paso, driving Orlie McCool’s pickup.

• March 24, 2006: A Gray County grand jury indicts him for capital murder, two days after his Missouri indictment.

• 2006: Missouri prosecutors give notice that they will seek death.

• April 18, 2008: Pleads guilty in Missouri to two counts of first-degree murder; two consecutive terms of life without parole.

• May 20, 2009: The defense’s detainer appeal is argued before the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo.

• August 31, 2009: Texas trial postponed for DNA results.

• September 3, 2009: Pleads guilty in Lubbock to three counts of capital murder; the punishment trial begins.

• September 11, 2009: The surviving daughter, now 14, testifies; the state rests.

• October 6, 2009: Sentenced to life without parole after the jury does not agree on mitigation.

• November 2010: Interviewed by NewsChannel 10 in a Missouri state prison.

• June 2024: CBS News’s 48 Hours revisits the case.