On December 28, 1945, at Aurich in northwestern Germany, a Canadian Military Court found SS Brigadeführer Kurt Meyer guilty of three war crimes. He had commanded the 25th SS Panzer Grenadier Regiment of the 12th SS Panzer Division when the division met the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division in Normandy in the days after D-Day. The court held him guilty of inciting and counseling the troops under his command to deny quarter to Allied troops, and responsible for the killing of eighteen Canadian prisoners of war at his regimental headquarters, the Abbaye d'Ardenne near Caen, on or about June 7 and June 8, 1944. It acquitted him of ordering those killings, and of responsibility for the killing of twenty-three Canadian prisoners at or near the villages of Buron and Authie.
The sentence was death. It was never carried out. After a second review, the officer who had convened the court commuted it to life imprisonment, judging that Meyer's degree of responsibility did not warrant the extreme penalty. Meyer served part of that term in a penitentiary in New Brunswick, was moved to a prison in West Germany in 1951 and walked free on September 7, 1954. He died in Hagen on December 23, 1961.
The case was Canada's first major war crimes trial. Its verdict turned on a rule in Canada's own war crimes regulations that allowed the court to presume a commander's responsibility from proven facts about the conduct of the men he led.
Kurt Meyer was born on December 23, 1910, in Jerxheim, in what is now Lower Saxony. From 1925 to 1928 he served a commercial apprenticeship in Minden, and he later worked in lignite mining. He joined the Hitler Youth in 1925.
In 1929 he entered the state police of Mecklenburg-Schwerin. He joined the Nazi Party in 1930 and the SS on October 1, 1931. In 1934 he transferred, with the rank of Untersturmführer, to the armed SS formation that served as Hitler's bodyguard, the Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler, and in the campaigns from 1939 to 1942 he rose to Obersturmbannführer and became a highly decorated field commander.
When the 12th SS Panzer Division was raised from members of the Hitler Youth, Meyer, now a Standartenführer, took command of one of its two Panzer Grenadier regiments, the 25th, and played a leading part in training the new formation. The training period is part of his case. The first charge on which he was later convicted concerned what he told his men in Belgium and France during 1943 and before June 7, 1944.
On June 7, 1944, the day after the Canadian landings, the 25th SS Panzer Grenadier Regiment counterattacked near the village of Authie, northwest of Caen, against the North Nova Scotia Highlanders and the tanks of the 27th Canadian Armoured Regiment (The Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment). Many of the Canadians who survived the action were taken prisoner.
Meyer had set up his regimental headquarters in the Abbaye d'Ardenne, in the commune of Saint-Germain-la-Blanche-Herbe, and prisoners were brought there for interrogation. On June 7, eleven of them were killed at the headquarters: five North Nova Scotia Highlanders and six men of the 27th Canadian Armoured Regiment, among them a lieutenant. On June 8, seven more North Nova Scotia Highlanders, all privates, captured near Authie and Buron the day before, were brought in, questioned and killed. None of the eighteen returned to his unit.
On June 17, Meyer succeeded to command of the whole division after the death of its first commander, with the rank of Brigadeführer, one of the youngest generals in the German armed forces. His command of the division in Normandy ran to late August, and during the retreat that followed he was taken prisoner in Belgium.
The killings of Allied prisoners in Normandy came first before the Court of Inquiry of the Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force, the body set up to investigate offenses by the German armed forces against Allied troops taken prisoner. Extracts from its record were later read at the trial.
In 1945 the newly formed No. 1 Canadian War Crimes Investigation Unit took up the task of establishing who had been responsible for the killings at the abbey. Its investigators questioned 99 German and 15 Canadian soldiers held in prisoner-of-war camps in Canada and the United States. Many of the German witnesses had reason to be careful. In August 1945 Canada adopted regulations under which commanding troops who committed war crimes, or serving in a unit that committed them, could itself carry legal consequences, and men who had served in the regiment were reluctant to say anything that might incriminate them.
Meyer himself was questioned at length. A special interrogation report on his command of the 12th SS Panzer Division from June 6 to August 25, 1944, records an interview held on August 24, 1945. In it he claimed that he had learned in June 1944 that Canadians had been killed at the abbey and had reported it to a superior. The investigators set out to test that account, and they found a French youth who had been at the abbey in those days and had seen nothing to support it. Over fifteen months the prosecution built an indictment of some 8,000 words.
The charge sheet, signed by Canada's Judge Advocate-General, laid five charges, each beginning with the words "committing a war crime in that he." The first alleged that in Belgium and France, during 1943 and before June 7, 1944, while commanding the 25th SS Panzer Grenadier Regiment, he "incited and counselled troops under his command to deny quarter to Allied troops." The second alleged that on or about June 7, 1944, troops under his command killed twenty-three Canadian prisoners of war at or near the villages of Buron and Authie.
The third and fourth charges concerned the seven men of June 8. The third alleged that he gave orders to troops under his command to kill seven Canadian prisoners of war. The fourth, laid in the alternative, alleged that he was "responsible for the killing of prisoners of war" when troops under his command killed those seven at his headquarters. The fifth alleged that on or about June 7, 1944, "as Commander of 25 S.S. Panzer Grenadier Regiment," he "was responsible for the killing of prisoners of war in violation of the laws and usages of war," when troops under his command "killed eleven Canadian prisoners of war (other than those referred to in the Third and Fourth Charges)" at his headquarters at L'Ancienne Abbaye Ardenne. Meyer pleaded not guilty to every charge.
The trial opened at Aurich on December 10, 1945. The prosecution's case rested on live witnesses, pre-trial statements, affidavits and the extracts from the inquiry record. Former members of the 25th Regiment testified to secret orders read on parade against keeping captured enemy troops and to remarks by Meyer that the regiment took no prisoners; under cross-examination some could not swear to the exact words. Canadian survivors and French civilians gave conflicting and partly inconclusive accounts of what happened to prisoners at Buron and Authie. Other evidence established the deaths of the eighteen at the abbey, that the men had been in German hands on June 7 and that several had been interrogated there while Meyer's headquarters was in place. On the alleged order, a single witness from the division testified that on June 8 he heard Meyer say no more prisoners were to be taken after seven Canadians were reported to him; he could not recall the exact words.
Meyer gave evidence in his own defense and answered each charge with a flat denial. He said he had never told anyone that his unit took or would take no prisoners and had issued no orders to kill prisoners during the Normandy campaign. He denied knowing on June 7 that Canadians had been killed at the abbey, and said that when two officers reported the killings to him on June 10 he ordered his adjutant to find those responsible. Defense witnesses described standing orders to send prisoners back to the division quickly and the presence of other German formations around Buron and Authie, and several gave character evidence. In rebuttal the prosecution called the French youth, who testified that he had been at the abbey on the evening of June 8 and on the evenings of June 9 and 10 and had seen nothing to suggest killings there.
The judge advocate directed the court that the killing of prisoners was a war crime under customary law, the Hague Convention of 1907 and the Geneva Prisoners of War Convention of 1929. An officer who incited, counseled or ordered a war crime could be punished even if he was not present; the first and third charges fell into that category. An order could be proved by inference, but only if the facts were inconsistent with any other rational conclusion than guilt.
The second, fourth and fifth charges were "responsible for" charges under Canada's War Crimes Regulations, made by order in council in August 1945. Under that regulation certain proven facts, for example that the accused or an officer of his unit was present when the crime was committed, could be treated as prima facie evidence of his responsibility, shifting to him the burden of explaining. The court "may convict but is not obliged to do so." In Meyer's case the presumption applied to the fourth and fifth charges because the killings took place at his own headquarters.
On December 28, 1945, the court found Meyer guilty on the first, fourth and fifth charges and not guilty on the second and third. It held that he had incited and counseled his men to deny quarter and that he was responsible for the killing of the eighteen prisoners at his headquarters, but that it had not been proved that he ordered those killings, or that he was responsible for the killings at Buron and Authie. The sentence was death.
The sentence needed confirmation by the convening authority, the General Officer Commanding the Canadian Army Occupation Force. On December 31, 1945, he confirmed both the findings and the sentence.
Senior officers at Canadian Military Headquarters in London then advised that a second review was legally required. The convening authority met the Canadian High Commissioner, a legal adviser from the Department of External Affairs and senior staff officers in London. The minutes record that the meeting agreed that the death penalty was justified only where the offense was conclusively shown to have resulted from the commander's own direct act or omission, and that the court had acquitted Meyer of ordering the killings. The convening authority commuted the sentence to life imprisonment, on the finding that Meyer's degree of responsibility was not such as to warrant the extreme penalty.
Meyer was shipped to Canada and spent about five years in the federal penitentiary at Dorchester, New Brunswick, where he worked in the prison library and learned English. In 1951 he was returned to West Germany to serve the rest of his sentence in the prison at Werl, then under Allied control; a Canadian Order in Council provided that he would be treated in the same way as the other prisoners held there. Late in 1951 he was granted seven days' compassionate leave.
He was released from Werl for good conduct on September 7, 1954, with the agreement of the Canadian government. He settled in Hagen, in North Rhine-Westphalia, worked as a sales representative for a brewery and became the spokesman of the HIAG, the association of former members of the Waffen-SS. He died in Hagen on December 23, 1961.
The court did not find that Meyer ordered the killing of any prisoner. It acquitted him on the third charge, which alleged that he gave orders to kill the seven men of June 8, and on the second charge, concerning twenty-three prisoners at or near Buron and Authie. His convictions for the killings at the abbey rest on his responsibility as commander under the Canadian regulations, not on proof of an order.
Meyer denied every charge to the end of the trial. He said he did not know of the deaths at his headquarters until two of his officers reported them on June 10, and that he then ordered an inquiry. The prosecution's rebuttal witness and the court's verdict on the fifth charge went against that account.
December 23, 1910: Kurt Meyer is born in Jerxheim, Germany.
1929: He joins the state police of Mecklenburg-Schwerin.
October 1, 1931: He joins the SS.
1934: He transfers to the Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler.
1943 to June 1944: The period of the first charge, incitement to deny quarter, in Belgium and France.
June 7, 1944: Eleven Canadian prisoners of war are killed at Meyer's headquarters at the Abbaye d'Ardenne.
June 8, 1944: Seven more Canadian prisoners of war are killed there.
June 17, 1944: Meyer takes command of the 12th SS Panzer Division.
August 1944 to May 1945: The SHAEF Court of Inquiry investigates offenses against Allied prisoners.
August 24, 1945: Meyer is interrogated about his command in Normandy.
December 10, 1945: His trial opens before a Canadian Military Court at Aurich.
December 28, 1945: He is found guilty on three charges, acquitted on two and sentenced to death.
December 31, 1945: The convening authority confirms the findings and sentence; after a second review he later commutes the sentence to life imprisonment.
1951: He is transferred from New Brunswick to the prison at Werl, West Germany.
September 7, 1954: He is released.
December 23, 1961: He dies in Hagen.