Kunti Kamara

Victims
1 woman killed among crimes found in Lofa County, Liberia. Convicted (2022, upheld 2024) of complicity in crimes against humanity and of acts of torture and barbarism, 1993 to 1994.
Years active
1993 to 1994
Location
Foya and Lofa County, Liberia (crimes); the Netherlands (later residence); Bobigny, France (arrest); Paris, France (trials).
Method
Torture and acts of barbarism (conviction); one woman killed by him (court finding; Foya witnesses said she was shot); rape and sexual slavery by his soldiers (complicity).
Status
Life, November 2, 2022; appeal: guilty verdict upheld, 30 years, March 27, 2024; Cour de cassation: appeal lapsed, June 25, 2024, conviction final. In custody in France as of June 2024.

Kunti Kamara was a young commander in the United Liberation Movement of Liberia for Democracy, known as ULIMO, when the movement held Foya and the surrounding country of Lofa County in northwestern Liberia in 1993 and 1994. Nearly three decades later, in a courtroom in Paris, a French jury found that the civilians of that district had lived under his authority through torture, forced labor, rape and killing. On November 2, 2022, the Paris Cour d'assises convicted him of complicity in crimes against humanity and of acts of torture and barbarism, and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

The case made history on two continents. It was the first conviction anywhere for crimes against humanity tied to Liberia's civil wars, wars in which Liberia's own courts had tried no one. In France it was the first trial before the Paris court's crimes against humanity division that had nothing to do with the 1994 genocide in Rwanda. On appeal, on March 27, 2024, a second jury upheld the guilty verdict and set the sentence at 30 years. On June 25, 2024, the Cour de cassation ruled that his last appeal had lapsed, and the conviction became final.

Kamara denied every charge at both trials. He said he had been a soldier on the front line, away from the town, and that he had seen no violence against civilians. Two juries, hearing many of the same survivors, did not accept that account.

Liberia's first civil war began in 1989, when Charles Taylor's National Patriotic Front of Liberia, the NPFL, launched its rebellion. ULIMO was one of the factions that rose to fight it, and it contested control of northern, western and central Liberia. Lofa County, on the borders of Guinea and Sierra Leone, became one of its strongholds. ULIMO held the county from 1993 to 1994, after capturing Foya in 1993.

Kamara took part in that capture. He was in his teens at the time, though his exact age would become a point of contention at his appeal.

Investigators said he headed the local ULIMO faction in Lofa County. By his own account at his first trial he was a commander in Foya with some 80 men under him, though in his final words to the court he called himself only "a simple soldier." He described himself as a battlefront commander who came to Foya only occasionally, from a front line several kilometers away.

The verdicts are the fixed point in a case built largely on memory, and they are specific. Both juries found Kamara guilty of the same set of acts, committed between 1993 and 1994 in Lofa County.

The first concerned the rape and sexual slavery of particularly vulnerable people by soldiers under his command. At the center of the complicity charge were two teenage girls whom his fighters raped repeatedly in 1994, and whom the court found he had failed to protect from the men he led. On appeal the court held that he had knowingly facilitated the preparation or commission of those acts by his soldiers.

The second concerned a man whom the court found Kamara subjected to severe suffering, in a public act of barbarism in which Kamara took part.

The third was a killing. The court found that Kamara killed a sick woman who had just lost her baby, after she was accused of witchcraft. She is the one death the court attributed to him as a direct perpetrator.

The fourth concerned two men whom he forced to work under inhumane conditions, and the fifth the torture of another civilian.

Several of those he harmed, or their families, traveled from Liberia to give evidence against him, and four of the original accusers, three men and one woman, had their names withheld by the court for their safety.

The case began with a criminal complaint. By 2018 Kamara had lived in Europe for many years. He had sought refuge in the Netherlands after the war and become a Dutch citizen, working there as an electrician. In 2016 he left the Netherlands, and by 2018 he was living in France.

On July 23, 2018, the Swiss nongovernmental organization Civitas Maxima filed a complaint in France, and French prosecutors took up the case. An urgent request from Swiss judicial authorities prompted French investigators to look for him. On September 4, 2018, French police arrested him in Bobigny, a suburb of Paris. His full identity was withheld at first, and he was referred to in France as Kunti K.

He did not stay in custody without interruption. A few months after the arrest he was released because of a procedural error. In 2019 he was detained again, while trying to leave France on an expired passport.

Material evidence from a war fought nearly three decades earlier in rural Liberia was scarce, and the case rested mainly on testimony. In 2019 French judicial authorities went to Lofa County on a fact-finding mission, and with the cooperation of the Liberian government they reconstructed alleged crime scenes on the ground. It was the first time foreign judicial authorities and Liberian authorities had done that together since the wars ended. In 2020 Kamara was indicted for torture and acts of barbarism committed during the first civil war; in 2021, after a prosecution appeal, the charges were widened to include crimes against humanity, sexual violence among them. The case that went to trial covered 1993 and 1994 and the district around Foya.

The trial opened at the Palais de Justice in Paris on October 10, 2022. Kamara told the court that he did not know his accusers and that he remained innocent, and he said the crimes had been committed by Taylor's men.

Over three weeks the court heard twelve witnesses and eight civil parties from Liberia. The civil parties identified Kamara as a perpetrator. Some said he had been physically involved in the acts; others spoke to the general conduct of ULIMO forces in Foya and the surrounding villages.

On October 21, 2022, the court heard from Alieu Kosiah, a former ULIMO commander who had been convicted of war crimes in Switzerland in June 2021 and sentenced to 20 years. He was brought from Switzerland to testify, largely on the question of whether Kamara had been based in Foya. Kosiah said Kamara had taken part in the capture of the town in 1993 and had probably been stationed there afterward, while admitting he had not been present himself. He said he had seen Kamara during a visit in 1994.

The defense argued that the case rested on too few witnesses and on memories of events nearly thirty years old. The legal shape of the sexual violence charges also mattered. French criminal law recognized crimes against humanity only from March 1, 1994, and the rapes of the two girls were alleged to have occurred after that date. Because rape was not then itself listed as a crime against humanity, the prosecution charged those acts as acts of torture constituting crimes against humanity. The defense objected. The court accepted the approach and placed the rapes among the most serious crimes in the case.

On November 2, 2022, the court found Kamara guilty on all counts. It convicted him of complicity in crimes against humanity, and it found him responsible as a direct perpetrator for torture and acts of barbarism. The prosecution had asked for life imprisonment, and the defense for acquittal. The court imposed life. Kamara appealed, which brought a full retrial before a new jury.

The appeal trial opened in Paris on March 5, 2024. Over more than three weeks it heard 22 witnesses, nine civil parties and five experts, among them psychologists and a psychiatrist. Kosiah testified again; by then the Swiss appeal court had upheld his conviction.

The defense opened with a new argument: that Kamara had been a minor when he fought in Foya, and that the case therefore belonged in the juvenile system. It called a former ULIMO commander whose evidence largely cut against Kamara's account of being kept away from the town. He said that on days when Kamara came back from the front, Kamara was in Foya.

Kamara repeated his denials. He described the testimony of the nine witnesses from Foya as invented stories and lies, and he accused the organizations behind the complaint of assembling witnesses to fabricate evidence against him. After three women who said they had been raped gave evidence in closed session, he told the court he was sorry for what had happened to them but knew nothing of it. Before the jury retired, the prosecution asked that the life sentence be upheld.

On March 27, 2024, the court upheld the guilty verdict. It found Kamara guilty of complicity in crimes against humanity and of committing simple and aggravated acts of torture and barbarism, covering the same acts found at first instance. It held that he had knowingly facilitated torture and inhumane acts, rape and sexual abuse among them, by the soldiers under his command, and that rape and sexual torture in Lofa County in 1994 had been committed on a massive and systematic scale as part of a concerted plan to impose a policy of terror on the civilian population.

The court did not repeat the life term. It sentenced him to 30 years' imprisonment. At the civil parties' request, it awarded each of the nine one euro in moral damages, a symbolic sum.

The same day his lawyer lodged an appeal on points of law with the Cour de cassation, France's highest court. It never reached a hearing. In an order dated June 25, 2024, the Cour de cassation ruled that the appeal had lapsed, because the memorandum setting out his legal arguments was not filed within the legal deadline. With that order the conviction became final. As of June 2024, Kamara was serving the 30-year sentence in France.

Kamara has never admitted any of the crimes. His denials, that he was at the front and not in Foya and that the witnesses were coached by the organizations behind the complaint, were heard and rejected by two juries, and the conviction is final.

His age in 1993 is contested: at the time of his arrest he was said to have been 19, while his defense argued on appeal that he had been 15, and the appeal court convicted him as charged.

The year he reached the Netherlands is given both as 1997 and as 2001.

Timeline

1989: Liberia's first civil war begins.

1993: ULIMO captures Foya, Lofa County; Kamara takes part.

1993 to 1994: ULIMO holds Lofa County; the crimes later found by the Paris court are committed.

2016: Kamara leaves the Netherlands.

July 23, 2018: Civitas Maxima files a criminal complaint in France.

September 4, 2018: Kamara is arrested in Bobigny, outside Paris.

2019: Released on a procedural error, he is detained again; French judicial authorities visit Lofa County.

2020: He is indicted for torture and acts of barbarism.

2021: After a prosecution appeal, the charges are widened to crimes against humanity.

October 10, 2022: The trial opens at the Paris Cour d'assises.

November 2, 2022: Convicted of complicity in crimes against humanity and of acts of torture and barbarism; sentenced to life imprisonment.

March 5, 2024: The appeal trial opens in Paris.

March 27, 2024: The appeal court upholds the guilty verdict and sentences him to 30 years.

June 25, 2024: The Cour de cassation rules his further appeal lapsed; the conviction is final.