Kujtim Fejzulai

Victims
4 people killed in Vienna on November 2, 2020, attributed by police; never tried
Years active
November 2, 2020
Location
Vienna, Austria (killings; 2019 conviction; helpers' trials 2022 to 2024)
Method
Shot (police account; he was never tried)
Status
2019: 22 months; conditionally released December 2019 with probation. Killed by police in Vienna, Austria, November 2, 2020; never tried for the deaths.

On the evening of Monday, November 2, 2020, four people died in the center of Vienna and more than twenty others were hurt in the space of a few minutes. Police officers killed the attacker before the night was out, and police named him as Kujtim Fejzulai, 20 years old, a dual citizen of Austria and North Macedonia and an Islamic State supporter who had been released early from a terrorism sentence less than a year before. It was the first deadly jihadist attack in Austria's history.

Because he died that night, Fejzulai was never charged, never tried and never convicted of the four deaths. Police attributed them to him, and the legal reckoning fell on others. Six men who had known him went on trial in Vienna in the autumn of 2022, accused of helping him prepare. In February 2023 a jury convicted four of them of contributing to multiple murder and of terrorist offenses, and two were sentenced to life. Austria's Supreme Court left those murder convictions standing but sent part of the case back, and the retrials that followed in 2024 raised two of the sentences.

Fejzulai grew up in Vienna. From about 2014, in his early teens, he came under the influence of Salafi preachers in the city and took up a strict reading of Islam, and his schooling fell away as his fervor rose.

In September 2018 he traveled to Turkey intending to join the Islamic State in Syria. Turkish authorities arrested him on September 18, 2018, before he could cross. He spent nearly four months in Turkish custody before he was deported to Austria on January 10, 2019.

Back in Vienna he was prosecuted for trying to join the group. The Vienna Regional Court convicted him in 2019 of membership in a terrorist organization under Section 278b of the Austrian Criminal Code and sentenced him to 22 months in prison.

Inside he did what was expected of him. He attended meetings with Neustart, the probation and reintegration service, shaved his beard and stopped wearing Salafi dress. In August 2019 he applied for early release. Prosecutors opposed the application. The prison authorities supported it on condition that he keep working with Derad, a nongovernmental organization that works with extremist offenders, and imposed no other conditions.

He was conditionally released in early December 2019, under the provisions of Austrian juvenile law, after serving two-thirds of his sentence. He was placed on three years' probation and required to report regularly to his probation counselors and to the Derad program. Had he served the full term, his sentence would have run out in July 2020.

On paper his year of freedom looked like a success. Between his release and October 2020 he attended fifteen sessions with Derad and met his probation service every two weeks. He lived on his own, went to vocational workshops, applied for jobs and worked for a time for a security company.

Beneath that surface he had gone back to the world he had come from. He kept to Salafism and fell under the influence of followers of a pro-Islamic State preacher. He grew his beard again and returned to Salafi dress. He refused to cooperate with the Vienna state office for the protection of the constitution, the LVT, when it wanted him as a witness against another extremist. Austrian officials had tried to strip him of his Austrian citizenship, but the effort failed for lack of evidence about his activities.

On December 17, 2019, within days of his release, officers carried out a formal risk interview with him. It went badly, and a risk assessment was ordered. The LVT did not submit it until September 11, 2020. It had to be revised twice and was completed only on October 7, 2020, when his risk rating was raised from moderate to high.

Other warnings came in during those months. German authorities had told Austria about his links to militant Salafists. In February 2020 Austria's military intelligence service reported his contact with a person linked to the Islamic State to the federal domestic intelligence agency, the BVT. In July 2020 he hosted four men from Switzerland and Germany in Vienna. Austrian officers observed the meeting, but the observation was dropped the next day, and the BVT never analyzed what it had gathered. The same month Slovak police warned Austria's Federal Criminal Police Office about his conduct during a visit to Slovakia; the warning passed to the BVT, which never acted on it, and it was not clearly matched to Fejzulai until October. None of this reached the prosecutors who could have asked a court to revoke his conditional release.

The evening of November 2 was the last before a national coronavirus lockdown. Within minutes of the attack's start in Vienna's old city center, four people had died and police officers had killed Fejzulai in the inner city. A police officer was among the wounded. Officials at first feared there had been other attackers, and residents were asked to stay indoors. The Islamic State group claimed the attack the following day.

All four of the dead were strangers to him, people who happened to be in the old city center that evening. Two were women and two were men, and three were Austrian citizens.

Nedzip V. was from Korneuburg, a town just north of Vienna, and a keen footballer who played for the club in neighboring Bisamberg.

The other three have not been publicly named. One was a young German woman who had made her life in Vienna. One was an Austrian woman. The fourth was an Austrian man.

The people who were hurt that night came from across Europe and beyond, among them Austrians, Germans, Slovaks, a Bosnian and a Luxembourger.

Within a day officers had raided 18 properties in Vienna and Lower Austria and detained 14 people associated with Fejzulai for questioning. The public sent police more than 20,000 videos, and by November 4 the interior ministry said the footage had confirmed that Fejzulai had acted alone at the scene. In Switzerland, police in Winterthur arrested two men who had met him in person. Austrian prosecutors eventually opened investigations into 21 people connected to him, and arrests followed in Germany, Italy and Turkey as well as in Austria. By the time charges were filed, six men stood accused of helping him prepare.

A government-appointed commission of inquiry was set up on November 26, 2020. Its interim report, delivered on December 22, found that the justice system had acted correctly and that the intelligence services had failed in their handling of the risk assessment and in the flow of information between agencies. It concluded that none of those failures could be considered a cause of the attack. The final report, published on February 10, 2021, found no criminal conduct by any official.

The trial opened at the Vienna Regional Court in the autumn of 2022 before a jury. None of the six was accused of taking part in the attack itself. The prosecution charged them with helping Fejzulai prepare, with terrorist offenses in connection with participation in murder, and with membership in a terrorist association and a criminal organization. All denied knowing what he had planned.

The jury gave its verdicts on February 1, 2023. Four men were convicted on the central counts. The man who had lived with Fejzulai for weeks before the attack was found to have encouraged him from July 2020 up to the day itself and to have helped him prepare; he was convicted as a contributor to the murders and sentenced to life. A second man was convicted of contributing to multiple murder and of further offenses under two federal statutes for help he gave Fejzulai in June and September 2020, and was also sentenced to life; the jury acquitted him of membership in a terrorist association, the only one of the four not convicted on that count. A third man, found to have supported Fejzulai from May 2020 until the attack, was sentenced to 20 years. The youngest of the four, found to have helped organize Fejzulai's preparations and to have put him in contact with the second man, was sentenced to 19 years, the court sparing him a life term because of his youth.

The other two defendants were acquitted of complicity in murder; the jury did not find it proven that either had helped Fejzulai prepare. Both were convicted of membership in the Islamic State and of spreading its propaganda, and each was sentenced to two years, eight months of it to be served and the rest suspended. Both accepted the verdict. Of the four convicted on the central counts, three said they would appeal and the fourth was considering it.

Austria's Supreme Court, the Oberster Gerichtshof, announced its decision on December 4, 2023. It set aside, in part, the first-instance convictions of five defendants for terrorist association and criminal organization, finding an error in the legal instructions given to the jurors and a verdict worded too vaguely. Everything else stood. The convictions for terrorist offenses in connection with participation in murder became final, as did the convictions under the two federal statutes. A new jury would decide only whether the five men had belonged to a terrorist association and a criminal organization.

The second man's case went separately, because the jury had already acquitted him of belonging to any terrorist network. The Supreme Court rejected his plea of nullity as unfounded and confirmed his convictions in full. The Higher Regional Court in Vienna rejected his appeal against the length of his sentence in January 2024, and his life sentence became final.

The two men who had been acquitted of complicity in murder came back before the Vienna Regional Court first. On February 7, 2024, they were again convicted of membership in a terrorist association and given slightly shorter terms than before: 18 months, six of them to be served, for one, and 21 months, seven to be served, for the other. Both had already served the unsuspended part in pretrial detention, and both accepted the sentences.

The three men whose murder convictions were already final returned to court in March 2024, and the jury gave its verdicts on April 24, 2024. The only question before it was whether they had been members of the Islamic State. The jurors found unanimously against all three, and found two of them to have sent Islamic State propaganda as well. The youngest, sentenced to 19 years in 2023, was given 20, the maximum for a young adult. The man who had supported Fejzulai from May 2020, sentenced to 20 years in 2023, was now sentenced to life. The man who had lived with Fejzulai received life again. As of that report, the verdicts were not yet final, and at least one defense lawyer had announced an appeal on grounds of nullity against both guilt and sentence. The convictions for contributing to the murders were already beyond appeal.

Fejzulai was never tried, and no court ever ruled on his guilt. The four deaths are attributed to him by police. What the courts did find, in convicting the four men who helped him, was that multiple murder had been committed and that they had contributed to it.

The accused maintained throughout that they had not known what Fejzulai planned. The jury accepted that in part: two of the six were acquitted of complicity in murder, and the second man was acquitted of belonging to any terrorist network. The 2024 verdicts on the membership count against the other three were still open to appeal at the last report.

The commission of inquiry found serious failures in the intelligence services' handling of Fejzulai before the attack, but it held that none of them could be considered a cause of it.

Timeline

About 2014: Fejzulai comes under the influence of Salafi preachers in Vienna.

September 18, 2018: Turkish authorities arrest him before he can cross into Syria.

January 10, 2019: He is deported from Turkey to Austria.

2019: The Vienna Regional Court convicts him of membership in a terrorist organization and sentences him to 22 months.

August 2019: He applies for early release.

Early December 2019: He is conditionally released under juvenile law, with three years' probation.

December 17, 2019: A formal risk interview with him goes badly; a risk assessment is ordered.

February 2020: Military intelligence reports his contact with a person linked to the Islamic State.

July 2020: He hosts four men from Switzerland and Germany in Vienna; Slovak police warn Austrian police about his conduct during a visit to Slovakia.

October 7, 2020: His risk rating is raised from moderate to high.

November 2, 2020: Four people die in central Vienna in an attack police attribute to him; police kill Fejzulai the same evening.

November 3, 2020: Raids in Vienna and Lower Austria; 14 people detained; two men arrested in Winterthur, Switzerland.

November 26, 2020: A commission of inquiry is set up.

December 22, 2020: The commission's interim report goes to the ministries.

February 10, 2021: The commission's final report is published.

Autumn 2022: Six men go on trial at the Vienna Regional Court.

February 1, 2023: Four are convicted on the central counts; two receive life sentences, two receive 20 and 19 years; two are acquitted of complicity in murder.

December 4, 2023: The Supreme Court partly sets aside the convictions for terrorist association and confirms the murder convictions.

January 2024: The Higher Regional Court in Vienna rejects the second man's sentence appeal; his life sentence becomes final.

February 7, 2024: Retrial of two men ends in sentences of 18 and 21 months.

April 24, 2024: Retrial of three men ends in two life sentences and one sentence of 20 years; the verdicts are not yet final.