Konrads Kalejs

Victims
Salaspils camp deaths alleged in Latvian charges (2000); never tried. US civil courts found he assisted Nazi persecution
Years active
1942 to 1943 (Latvian charges); US civil findings cover 1941 to 1944
Location
Salaspils, Latvia (killings); Porkhov, Russia (killings); Riga, Latvia (birth); Winnetka, Illinois (residence); Chicago, Illinois (trial); Toronto, Ontario, Canada (residence).
Method
Prisoners killed, tortured or starved at a guarded camp (Latvian prosecutors' case; never tested in a criminal court)
Status
Deported from the US (April 1994; one report says 1993) and Canada (August 1997); left Britain January 6, 2000. Died untried in Australia, November 8, 2001, while appealing extradition

Konrads Kalejs spent the last seventeen years of his life moving between four countries, and in each of them the same question followed him: what had he done in Latvia between 1941 and 1944? The United States answered it in a civil courtroom. An immigration judge in Chicago, the Board of Immigration Appeals and a federal appeals court all concluded that he had served as a company commander in the Arajs Kommando, the Latvian auxiliary security police unit that took part in the mass murder of Latvia's Jews, that he had commanded guards at camps where prisoners were held and killed, and that he had lied his way into the country by hiding all of it. He was deported in 1994. Canada ordered him out in 1997. Britain served him with notice of deportation in January 2000, and he left on his own before the process ran its course.

No criminal court ever heard the evidence against him. In September 2000 Latvia charged him with genocide and war crimes over his alleged command of a guard unit at the Salaspils camp outside Riga in 1942 and 1943, and asked Australia, where he held citizenship, to surrender him. A magistrate in Melbourne ruled in May 2001 that he could be extradited, the first such ruling by an Australian court. He appealed. On November 8, 2001, at 88, he died with the appeal undecided, and the charges against him died with him.

He denied the allegations to the end. He called his accusers liars and storytellers, insisted that he had been a student during the war, and at other times said that German officers had ordered him to head an Arajs Kommando unit but that he was never present when civilians were killed. Because he was never tried, every allegation of a crime against him remains exactly that, and the findings of the American courts, reached under a civil standard in a deportation case, are findings about his immigration status, not a criminal verdict.

A soldier in Riga

Kalejs was born in Riga on June 26, 1913. He was a professional soldier who rose to lieutenant and then first lieutenant in the Latvian army, and when he applied for an American visa decades later he listed his army service as running from 1929 to 1941.

The country he served was swallowed twice in quick succession. The Soviet Union annexed Latvia in August 1940, and Kalejs joined the Red Army. In the summer of 1941 Germany invaded the Soviet Union, and German forces entered Riga in early July. When the Germans displaced the Soviets, Kalejs deserted the Red Army. On the evidence the American courts later accepted, he then joined the Latvian Auxiliary Security Police, the unit known after its commander, Viktors Arajs, as the Arajs Kommando.

The Arajs Kommando

The German occupation turned Riga into the capital of the Reich Commissariat Ostland, and the occupiers moved quickly against the city's Jews. German Einsatzgruppen units, working with Latvian auxiliaries, killed several thousand Jews in the first days after they entered the city. A ghetto was ordered in mid-August 1941 and sealed in October with some 30,000 people inside it. Between November 30 and December 9, 1941, German SS and police units and Latvian auxiliaries killed at least 25,000 of the ghetto's Jews in the Rumbula Forest. By the time Soviet forces retook Riga on October 13, 1944, almost all of the city's Jews had been murdered.

The Arajs Kommando was the local unit the German Einsatzkommando used to carry out killings in Latvia. It also took part in operations against partisans in Russia and supplied the guards for the Salaspils labor camp outside Riga. Arajs himself was convicted by a West German court decades later, sentenced to life imprisonment, and died in prison in January 1988.

The evidence before the American immigration court placed Kalejs among six or seven officers directly under Arajs, a company commander with a hundred or more men below him. The documents told the same story. A University of Riga form signed by Arajs on November 28, 1941, identified Kalejs as a member of the Latvian Auxiliary Security Police. A second form from the unit's deputy chief was dated November 5, 1942. A handwritten note by Kalejs himself, dated May 15, 1943, described him as a company commander. Certified copies of his identification badges were also produced. Three witnesses told the court that he was a company commander and first lieutenant in the unit, and four placed him as the head guard at Salaspils. Several picked him out of an array of 250 photographs.

The camps

The Latvian charges of 2000 centered on Salaspils. Prosecutors in Riga alleged that in 1942 and 1943 Kalejs led the guard unit at the camp, a forced-labor camp near the capital where Jews and Soviet prisoners of war were held and where large numbers of them died. It was the largest concentration camp in Latvia.

The American immigration findings went further, and covered more places, though always under the civil standard of a deportation case. The immigration judge found that Kalejs had commanded the exterior guard at Salaspils and at a camp at Sauriesi, and that this amounted to assistance in persecution. The Board of Immigration Appeals agreed. The judge also found that in 1943 Kalejs had been company commander of a guard unit at a camp at Porkhov, in Russia, and that men under his command took part in the killing of between 20 and 39 Roma. The board affirmed that finding as well, although the only evidence for it was the deposition of a single Soviet witness.

Not every allegation survived the appeals. The immigration judge had found only that Kalejs signed the unit's rolls in the second half of 1941, and that the government had not proved more; the board reversed him on that point. The judge had also found that Kalejs took part in persecution during service on the eastern front between January and November 1942, and on that point the board reversed in the other direction, setting the finding aside.

His own account

Kalejs gave a very different version of his war. He said he was a student and a farm laborer, not an officer of any police unit. In early 1942, he said, he joined a police unit of skiers and was sent to the eastern front, where he developed an ulcer that kept him out of service for about two and a half years. In 1944 he was called up to the Latvian Legion and sent for training in Germany in late 1944 and early 1945. When the war ended he was serving as police chief in a camp for displaced persons.

He denied ever belonging to the Arajs Kommando. The University of Riga certificates that named him as a member, he told the immigration court, had come to him from a friend so that he could continue his studies. He said he did not know Arajs and did not learn what the unit had done until after the war. In later years he told reporters a version that sat awkwardly beside his court testimony: that German officers had ordered him to head an Arajs Kommando unit, but that he was never present when civilians were killed.

Australia and America

After Germany's defeat Kalejs left Europe for Australia. He arrived around 1950 and later became an Australian citizen. The citizenship would shape everything that happened to him afterward, because no later deportation could send him anywhere but back to Australia.

On December 3, 1958, he signed a visa statement before an American vice consul in Melbourne. Question 25 on the form asked for his past residences and occupations. He listed his Latvian army service from 1929 to 1941, and for 1941 to 1944 he wrote that he had been a farm laborer at Nurmuiza, in the Talsi district of Latvia. He said nothing of any police unit. He entered the United States in 1959.

He did well there. By the 1980s he owned four homes and held more than a million dollars in assets. He lived in Winnetka, Illinois, a Chicago suburb, and kept a second residence in St. Petersburg, Florida.

The American case

The Justice Department's Office of Special Investigations filed its first papers against Kalejs on November 30, 1984. He did not wait for them. As the department prepared to act in late 1984, he took $350,000 and left for Canada and Australia. He later came back into the United States and lived for about six months under a new identity before he was arrested in Florida on April 19, 1985. He was released after a friend posted a $750,000 cash bond.

The case was tried before an immigration judge in Chicago in the summer of 1988. Much of the wartime evidence came from archives then under Soviet control, and the witness depositions had been taken in Riga in September 1987. Kalejs did not attend the depositions, and his lawyers were refused access to the Soviet archives and to the witnesses before they testified. The defense argued that evidence gathered that way could not be trusted and that the restrictions denied him a fair hearing.

On November 1, 1988, the judge found Kalejs deportable and ordered him sent to Australia, as Kalejs himself had asked if he lost. It was the first time the special investigations office had defeated a Latvian war crimes suspect in a denaturalization or deportation trial. Kalejs appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals. The board, sitting in Chicago, reworked parts of the judge's findings in both directions and affirmed the core of them. A final order of deportation was entered on April 30, 1992, on two grounds: that he had assisted in persecution under the direction of, or in association with, the Nazi government, and that he had obtained his visa by willfully misrepresenting a material fact.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld the order on November 17, 1993. The majority held that the board "was amply justified in concluding that Kalejs assisted in the persecution of people," because as a commander of guards and an officer of the unit his role supported attributing the unit's acts to him, and that his lies on the immigration documents were material and had won him his visa. It declined to set aside the case because some of the evidence came from the Soviet Union, pointing to Western documents and eyewitness testimony that corroborated it, and it found the hearings fair.

The court was not unanimous. One judge concurred only in the result, holding that evidence tainted by Soviet involvement had no place in an American proceeding but that the untainted evidence was enough. The third judge dissented. He would have ordered a new hearing, on the ground that the Soviet depositions and documents had never been properly tested and that without them the government had not proved membership in the unit by clear and convincing evidence.

The Supreme Court declined to hear the case on March 21, 1994, and in April 1994 Kalejs was put on a plane to Australia.

Canada

Australia received him as an ordinary returning citizen, and its federal police began assessing whether to reopen the case. Kalejs did not stay to find out. He settled in Toronto on a visitor's visa.

Canadian immigration officials moved to deport him, and a hearing was set before the Immigration and Refugee Board for August 4, 1995. On June 21, 1995, a few hours before his visitor's visa expired, he left Canada for Australia on his own. Canada added his name to a list of people barred from entry.

He came back anyway. On September 3, 1995, he was detained at Pearson International Airport in Toronto trying to re-enter the country, then released to await a second deportation hearing. The proceedings that followed took nearly two years. In August 1997 the Immigration and Refugee Board ordered him expelled, and he arrived in Australia a day later.

After the Canadian deportation, the Australian Federal Police assessed the evidence gathered in the United States and Canada and judged it insufficient to secure a conviction in Australia. In May 1998 the police dropped their investigation.

Britain

By late 1999 Kalejs was in England, living in Leicestershire. His presence became public in December 1999, and the Metropolitan Police began to look at the allegations of war crimes in Latvia. On December 31 the Home Secretary was told that the evidence did not justify an arrest, and the Metropolitan Police Organised Crime Unit completed its assessment on January 4, 2000, concluding that there were no grounds to charge him.

The Home Secretary took a different route. On January 2, 2000, he served Kalejs with notice of his intention to deport him on the ground that his presence was not conducive to the public good, a decision made on the balance of probabilities, a lower standard than a criminal prosecution requires.

Kalejs announced that he would leave. He bought his own ticket, and on January 6, 2000, he flew out of Heathrow for Melbourne by way of Singapore, ahead of any deportation order.

Latvia's case

Latvia had looked at Kalejs before. Its authorities first investigated him in 1992, and in 1997 they found no evidence to support the allegations. On January 3, 2000, as he prepared to leave Britain, they told British officials they were reopening the investigation.

There was no extradition treaty between Australia and Latvia. In February 2000 the two countries agreed to negotiate one, and it was signed in July 2000. In September 2000 Latvian prosecutors charged Kalejs with genocide. A municipal court in Riga issued a warrant for his arrest in October, and in December the prosecutor general's office sent Australia a formal request for his extradition on one charge of genocide and one charge of war crimes. The charges alleged that in 1942 and 1943 he had led the guard unit at the Salaspils camp. Had he been surrendered and tried, he would have been the first suspected Nazi collaborator to face trial in Latvia after the end of Soviet rule.

Australian police arrested him in Melbourne in December 2000. He appeared before the Melbourne Magistrates' Court and was released on bail on condition that he surrender his passports. Through his lawyer he said he would fight extradition on the grounds of his age and health. Kalejs admitted having been an officer in the Arajs Kommando, but denied committing any atrocities.

The extradition fight

The proceedings in Australia turned on law rather than on what happened at Salaspils: the magistrate did not have to decide whether Kalejs was guilty, only whether the conduct alleged would amount to crimes under Australian law. In February 2001 Kalejs sued the minister who had allowed the Latvian request to come before an Australian court, arguing that he was too ill to defend himself; his lawyers said he had cancer and dementia. In April 2001 the court ordered him to attend the extradition hearing the following month.

On May 29, 2001, the magistrate ruled that he was eligible for surrender to Latvia on the charges of genocide and war crimes, the first such order an Australian court had made. He came to court in a wheelchair. He appealed to the Federal Court the same day and was released on bail again.

The appeal was argued in October 2001. Kalejs was brought into court on a stretcher and excused from the rest of the hearing. The arguments were technical: that the Latvian extradition documents had not been properly authenticated, and that a 1924 extradition treaty between the two countries was still in force, which would have required Latvia to produce evidence of at least a prima facie case.

No ruling on the appeal ever came. Konrads Kalejs died in Australia on November 8, 2001, at 88, while he was still appealing his extradition. The Latvian charges were never tried.

Disputed and unproven points

The central fact of the case is that the allegations were never tested in a criminal trial. The American findings that Kalejs assisted in persecution were made in a civil deportation case under a lower standard and with evidence that one appellate judge thought should have been excluded. The Porkhov finding rested on a single Soviet deposition. The British Home Secretary told Parliament he was satisfied there were reasonable grounds to believe Kalejs had been complicit in war crimes, an assessment made on the balance of probabilities, while the Metropolitan Police found no grounds to charge him.

The record also disagrees on two dates. One contemporaneous report put his removal from the United States in 1993, while others place it in April 1994, after the Supreme Court declined his case in March of that year. Reports likewise give the year he became an Australian citizen as 1957 or as 1959.

Kalejs's own accounts did not agree with one another. Before the immigration court he denied membership in the Arajs Kommando. Later he said German officers had ordered him to head a unit of it, and when Latvia charged him he admitted having been an officer in the unit while denying any atrocities.

Viktors Arajs gave conflicting statements as well. He signed an affidavit for Kalejs saying that Kalejs had not been in the unit, but an investigator for the special investigations office said Arajs had earlier told him, without reservation, that Kalejs had served under him.

Timeline

June 26, 1913: Konrads Kalejs is born in Riga, Latvia.

August 1940: The Soviet Union annexes Latvia; Kalejs joins the Red Army.

July 1941: German forces occupy Riga; Kalejs deserts the Red Army.

November 28, 1941: A University of Riga form signed by Viktors Arajs identifies Kalejs as a member of the Latvian Auxiliary Security Police.

1942 to 1943: Period of Kalejs's alleged command of the guard unit at the Salaspils camp, the subject of the Latvian charges.

May 15, 1943: Kalejs writes a note describing himself as a company commander.

Around 1950: He arrives in Australia.

1957 or 1959 (reports differ): He becomes an Australian citizen.

December 3, 1958: He signs an American visa statement in Melbourne listing himself as a farm laborer for 1941 to 1944.

1959: He enters the United States.

November 30, 1984: The Office of Special Investigations files its first papers against him.

April 19, 1985: He is arrested in Florida after months under a new identity.

November 1, 1988: An immigration judge in Chicago finds him deportable.

April 30, 1992: A final order of deportation is entered.

November 17, 1993: The Seventh Circuit affirms the deportation order.

March 21, 1994: The Supreme Court declines to hear his case.

April 1994 (one report says 1993): He is deported to Australia.

June 21, 1995: He leaves Canada before a deportation hearing.

September 3, 1995: He is detained trying to re-enter Canada at Toronto.

August 1997: The Immigration and Refugee Board orders him expelled from Canada.

May 1998: Australian police drop their investigation for insufficient evidence.

December 1999: He is found living in England.

January 2, 2000: The Home Secretary serves notice of intention to deport him.

January 6, 2000: He leaves Britain for Melbourne.

July 2000: Australia and Latvia sign an extradition treaty.

September 2000: Latvian prosecutors charge him with one charge of genocide and one charge of war crimes.

October 2000: A Riga court issues a warrant for his arrest.

December 2000: Latvia formally requests his extradition on charges of genocide and war crimes; he is arrested in Melbourne and released on bail.

May 29, 2001: A Melbourne magistrate rules him eligible for extradition; he appeals.

October 2001: The Federal Court hears his appeal.

November 8, 2001: Kalejs dies in Australia, aged 88, untried.