Kon'ichi Nakaoka

Victims
1 prime minister killed in Tokyo, November 4, 1921. Sentenced to life imprisonment after a trial in Tokyo, 1922; freed under an amnesty in 1934.
Years active
November 4, 1921
Location
Tokyo, Japan (killing; preliminary examination; trial); Harbin, Manchukuo (now China) (emigration, 1934).
Method
Stabbed.
Status
Sentenced to life imprisonment, Tokyo, 1922. Three amnesties cut the term. Released under an amnesty for the crown prince's birth, 1934.

On the evening of November 4, 1921, the prime minister of Japan, Takashi Hara, was killed in Tokyo. He was the president of the Rikken Seiyukai, the head of the first full party cabinet the country had known, and the first Japanese prime minister not drawn from the aristocracy. The man who killed him was Kon'ichi Nakaoka, a switchman on the national railways who worked at Otsuka Station on the Yamanote Line. He was 18 years old.

Nakaoka was examined by a judge of the Tokyo District Court and tried in Tokyo in the spring of 1922. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, and he did not serve it. Three amnesties cut the term in turn, and in 1934 he walked free under the last of them, an amnesty decreed to celebrate the birth of the crown prince. By July of that year he had left Japan for the Japanese-controlled state of Manchukuo, and from there his life becomes hard to follow.

It was the first such killing since Japan had become a constitutional state, and it sent shock waves through the political world. The questions it raised were never answered in court: whether anyone had urged the young switchman on, who had shaped his thinking, and how much of his anger at the government was politics and how much was something more private.

Nakaoka was born on October 12, 1903. As a boy in Tokyo he worked as an apprentice at a printing company, where he also lived. In 1919 he went to work at Otsuka Station, and in 1921 he was made a switchman. He held that post when he killed the prime minister.

He loved films and literature, and he knew the writers of the Shirakaba circle. He entered a competition for film screenplays, hoping his entry would be chosen. It was not. Before the judge who later examined him, he described his reading of the nationalist ideas around him as critical, and he seemed somewhat ashamed of them.

The grievances he carried were public ones. He resented what he saw as the prime minister's arrogance. He was outraged by the Nikolaevsk incident and was critical of the government's handling of the intervention itself. He accused the prime minister of corruption and of drawing the zaibatsu, the great business combines, into politics, and he came to see the governing party as an organ of narrow partisan interest.

The man he killed had come to national power by an unusual road. He learned French at the law school of the Ministry of Justice, spent about three years at the Japanese legation in Paris, and rose in the foreign ministry under Munemitsu Mutsu, who made him vice-minister among other posts. In 1897 he left the ministry for a leading Osaka daily newspaper and became its manager the following year. In 1900 he joined the Rikken Seiyukai when Hirobumi Ito founded it, and he rose within it to the party's presidency.

He became prime minister in September 1918, at the head of Japan's first full party cabinet, made up mainly of elected members of the Diet. He disliked factions and made a point of appointing men on merit. He sought to limit unnecessary military expansion in order to spend on education, transport and communications, opened up higher education through an ordinance, and moved to withdraw Japanese troops from Siberia. When he was killed he was still in office.

No one else was accused of taking part in the killing itself. The investigation that followed turned on a narrower question: whether anyone had urged the young switchman to it.

Nakaoka's preliminary examination was conducted by a preliminary judge of the Tokyo District Court, under the direction of a prosecutor of the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office. The judge questioned him about his reading, his work and his reasons, and later set down in a memoir much of what Nakaoka had told him.

A written statement of grievances against the prime minister was attributed to Nakaoka. Its language was dense and hard to follow, and who actually wrote it has been questioned. The examination also drew in a second man, a fellow employee of the government railways, who was charged with instigating the killing.

The public trial opened in Tokyo on March 6, 1922, with Nakaoka and the railway employee charged with instigation in the prisoners' box together. Nakaoka's plea was that he had considered the prime minister harmful to the country. He was sentenced to life imprisonment. The judgment left the background of the killing unexplained, and it reads as the act of a man on his own.

Nakaoka went to prison under a life term, and three amnesties reached him there. The last, decreed to celebrate the birth of Crown Prince Tsugu-no-Miya, set him free in 1934. He wrote an account of his years behind bars, published as Tesso Jusan-nen, which may be rendered as Thirteen Years Behind Iron Bars.

Within months of his release he emigrated to Manchukuo. By early July 1934 he had reached Harbin. He played down any standing his past might give him there and said that most people had surely forgotten what he had done. His later life is obscure.

Whether Nakaoka had backers remains unsettled. Some have suspected ties to right-wing groups. The court left the background of the killing unexplained, and the truth is unknown.

His motive is disputed as well. The judgment reads as the act of a young nationalist who killed for the sake of the country. The examining judge's own record of his questioning points to a youth whose disappointments were personal as much as political: the failed screenplay entry, made to win the attention of a young woman connected with the printing company where he had lived, and his lost hopes of her, which a Tokyo newspaper turned into a serial at the time. How far each drove him cannot be settled from what survives.

Accounts differ on his age at the killing: one standard dictionary gives 18, a historian gives 19. The authorship of the written statement attributed to him has been questioned.

What became of him later is unsettled. One standard Japanese biographical dictionary gives his death as October 18, 1980; another leaves the date of his death unknown, and a historian writes that he vanished from view in Manchuria after his release.

Timeline

October 12, 1903: Nakaoka is born.

September 1918: The Seiyukai leader becomes prime minister at the head of Japan's first full party cabinet.

1919: Nakaoka goes to work at Otsuka Station on the Yamanote Line.

1921: He is made a switchman.

November 4, 1921: Nakaoka kills the prime minister in Tokyo. A preliminary examination before a judge of the Tokyo District Court follows, and a fellow railway employee is charged with instigation.

March 6, 1922: The trial opens in Tokyo. Nakaoka is later sentenced to life imprisonment.

1934: He is freed under the third amnesty, decreed for the birth of the crown prince.

July 1934: He arrives at Harbin, Manchukuo, as an emigrant.