Kobili Traoré has never stood trial for the death of Sarah Halimi, the Jewish neighbor who died in the 11th arrondissement of Paris on the night of April 3 to 4, 2017. He was 27 and lived in the same public housing complex in the east of the city. Police arrested him that morning. Over the next two and a half years, investigating judges in Paris charged him, three separate rounds of psychiatric experts examined him, and the case moved up through the courts. On December 19, 2019, the chambre de l'instruction of the Paris Court of Appeal found "charges suffisantes," sufficient charges, that he had committed murder and unlawful detention, and that the acts had been committed because the victim was Jewish. In the same ruling it declared him "irresponsable pénalement," criminally irresponsible, because a psychiatric disorder had abolished his judgment at the time, and it sent him to a psychiatric hospital instead of to the assize court.
The civil parties appealed. On April 14, 2021, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation, France's highest court for criminal matters, ruled "REJETTE les pourvois," it rejects the appeals, and held that the law on criminal irresponsibility draws no distinction according to what caused the disorder, even when the cause was regular drug use. That ruling closed the criminal case without a trial; it set off protests and a national debate, and in January 2022 Parliament passed a law on crimes committed after voluntary intoxication, which does not reach back to this case. The Paris prosecutor announced on February 27, 2026, that he had been placed under formal investigation and remanded in custody in a separate case; as of February 2026 he was in custody, he had not been tried in that case, and he is presumed innocent in it.
The victim was a Jewish woman who lived in the same complex, and she was his neighbor. The same night, according to the investigation, a neighboring family was held against their will, and the charge of unlawful detention concerns them. Police arrested Kobili Traoré that morning.
He was a heavy drug user, and he had a previous criminal record. No mental illness had been diagnosed in him before that night. After his arrest he was held first in a psychiatric hospital.
The Paris prosecutor's office opened a judicial investigation on April 14, 2017, for intentional homicide and unlawful detention. Investigating judges took over the case. On July 10, 2017, they placed Kobili Traoré under formal investigation, the French step that corresponds to charging, on both counts. The next day he was moved from the psychiatric hospital to a prison in the Paris region.
The first psychiatric expert's report came in September 2017. It found that he had consumed large amounts of drugs but was aware of the nature of what he had done. In the chambre de l'instruction's later summary, that expert accepted that he had suffered a genuine and alienating mental disorder at the time but concluded that his judgment had not been abolished, because his drug use had been regular and voluntary. That conclusion pointed toward a trial, with the disorder weighed at most in his sentence.
Whether the case would be prosecuted as an antisemitic crime stayed unsettled for months. A further order notified him of the aggravating circumstance that the offense had been committed because of the victim's real or supposed membership of a religion or race. In January 2018 a judicial decision reopened that question because of his mental state. On February 27, 2018, after questioning him directly that day, the investigating judge kept the antisemitic aggravating circumstance in the case.
The judges then commissioned more opinions. A second panel examined him and found that he had suffered an acute delusional episode, which French psychiatry calls a "bouffée délirante." That panel concluded that the episode marked the start of a likely chronic psychosis and that the disorder had abolished his judgment.
A third panel followed, and its report became public in March 2019. Those experts also found an acute delusional episode, but they attributed it to an outside toxic cause, his drug use, and they wrote that his free will had been nil at the time of the acts. Seven psychiatrists took part across the three examinations. Only the first had found his judgment altered rather than abolished.
The distinction decided the case. Article 122-1 of the French penal code treats the two states differently. A person whose judgment was abolished by a psychiatric or neuropsychiatric disorder is not criminally responsible. A person whose judgment was only altered remains punishable, and the court takes the disorder into account when it sets the sentence.
On July 12, 2019, the investigating judges sent the file to the chambre de l'instruction, the appeals chamber that supervises investigations. They found sufficient charges against him of homicide and unlawful detention, and plausible reasons to apply the rule on abolished judgment. Under a procedure created in 2008, the question of responsibility went to the appeals chamber, which would first decide whether he had committed the acts and only then whether he could answer for them. The civil parties and the prosecution appealed the order, and the civil parties asked for a trial before the assize court.
The chamber ruled on December 19, 2019. It had to choose between conflicting expert reports, and it chose the later panels. It found sufficient charges that Kobili Traoré had voluntarily caused the victim's death and had unlawfully detained the neighboring family, and, following the submissions of the prosecutor general, that both acts had been committed because of the victim's membership of the Jewish religion. It then declared him criminally irresponsible by reason of a disorder that had abolished his judgment.
The chamber explained why the drug use did not change the result. The fact that the delusional episode had an outside toxic origin and came from regular drug use did not prevent a finding that a mental disorder had abolished his judgment. Nothing in the file showed that he had taken the drug knowing it could bring on an episode of that kind.
The ruling ended his pretrial detention and ordered his admission to compulsory psychiatric care in the form of full hospitalization. It imposed safety measures for 20 years, barring him from contacting the civil parties and from returning to the place where the events took place. There would be no assize trial.
The civil parties took the case to the Cour de cassation. They argued that drug use was not a mental illness, that a person who chooses to take drugs commits a fault that rules out a defense of irresponsibility, and that a finding of a crime committed because of the victim's religion could not stand beside a finding that his judgment was abolished. The criminal chamber rejected each argument. Article 122-1, it held, does not distinguish according to the origin of the disorder that abolished judgment; the chamber had relied on expert findings and had justified its decision without gaps or contradiction; and the charges of an offense committed because of the victim's religion did not stand in the way of the finding on his judgment. The December 2019 decision became final.
After the December 2019 ruling he remained in psychiatric care. The Paris prosecutor has set out its course: he was treated in a unit for difficult patients until 2020, then in an ordinary psychiatric hospital until 2023, then again in a unit for difficult patients for a year, and he was hospitalized again from September 2024.
In the months before January 2022 he was allowed out of the hospital on supervised day release several times. A police prefect's order kept him hospitalized, and under the rules for compulsory care he could be discharged only if two separate, independent psychiatric evaluations found that he was no longer a danger to himself or to others.
Whether Kobili Traoré's judgment was abolished or only altered was the central dispute of the case, and the experts themselves were split. The first expert found it altered, because his drug use had been regular and voluntary; the two later panels found it abolished. The courts adopted the later view, and the Cour de cassation held that the chamber had resolved the conflict lawfully.
The civil parties argued that he was aware of what he was doing. The courts rejected that argument, and it has never been tested at a trial.
Because there was no trial, none of the evidence was ever heard before a jury. A finding of sufficient charges is not a conviction, and in French law he has not been found guilty of murder.
April 4, 2017: A Jewish neighbor dies in the 11th arrondissement of Paris; police arrest Kobili Traoré the same morning.
April 14, 2017: A judicial investigation opens for intentional homicide and unlawful detention.
July 10, 2017: He is placed under formal investigation on both counts.
July 11, 2017: He is moved from a psychiatric hospital to prison.
September 2017: The first psychiatric report finds his judgment altered, not abolished.
February 27, 2018: The investigating judge keeps the antisemitic aggravating circumstance.
March 2019: A third expert report finds his judgment abolished.
July 12, 2019: The investigating judges send the file to the chambre de l'instruction.
November 28, 2019: The chambre de l'instruction of the Paris Court of Appeal hears the case.
December 19, 2019: The chamber finds sufficient charges of murder aggravated by the victim's Jewish religion and of unlawful detention, declares him criminally irresponsible, and orders full hospitalization and 20 years of safety measures.
April 14, 2021: The Cour de cassation rejects the civil parties' appeals.
September 2024: He is hospitalized again.