King Fisher

Victims
6 murder charges in South Texas, 1870s; never convicted. Fifteen lesser counts, horse and cattle theft among them, ended without conviction; an 1870 housebreaking conviction was pardoned.
Years active
Attributed killings: mid-1870s, Nueces Strip. Arrests: June 1876; November 19, 1877. Died: March 11, 1884.
Location
Collin County; Florence; Goliad; Dimmit County; Eagle Pass; Uvalde; San Antonio (Texas)
Method
Murder (charged, never convicted); horse and cattle theft (charged, never convicted); housebreaking (convicted, pardoned).
Status
Never convicted of a killing. Deputy sheriff of Uvalde County, 1881; acting sheriff, 1883. Killed in San Antonio, March 11, 1884; a coroner's jury ruled it self-defense; no one was charged.

John King Fisher was one of the most powerful men in the Nueces Strip of South Texas in the 1870s, and one of the most frequently charged. The Texas Rangers arrested him more than once, and grand juries indicted him for murder and for horse and cattle theft. None of those cases ended in a conviction. By 1881 he had cleared his last charges and taken a badge as deputy sheriff of Uvalde County, and by 1883 he was running the sheriff's office. He was killed in San Antonio on March 11, 1884. A coroner's jury found that killing to be self-defense, and no one was ever tried for it.

The state marker placed for him in Uvalde records the legal fact that frames his life: he faced many charges, murder among them, and was never convicted.

Fisher was born in Collin County, in North Texas, in 1854, and grew up in Florence, in Williamson County, north of Austin. His first brush with the law came in 1869, when he was accused of stealing a horse he had borrowed without telling its owner. A posse arrested him, and he got away, reportedly with help from the horse's owner, who had decided not to press charges.

The next arrest was more serious. In Goliad he was taken in for housebreaking, convicted, and sent to the state penitentiary. He entered it on October 30, 1870, under a five-year sentence. The governor pardoned him about four months later. Authorities in Goliad kept a close watch on him after his release, and he left for the brush country to the southwest.

He settled in Dimmit County, in the triangle of thinly settled land between the Nueces River and the Rio Grande that Texans called the Nueces Strip. He went to work as a cowboy and was hired by ranchers to guard their herds against raiders coming over the river from Mexico. He founded a ranch of his own on Pendencia Creek, and the place became the center of what came to be known as King Fisher's Territory. Later he bought a second ranch near Eagle Pass, on the border, and the state's marker describes the country he controlled as a large stretch of Southwest Texas centered on that town.

The ranch drew a steady crowd of drifters, wanted men and rustlers. Cattle theft was the main industry of the Strip in those years, and Fisher's men took part in it even as he was paid to guard against it. He built his influence through patronage and intimidation, and he cultivated powerful friends on both sides of the border, Porfirio Díaz of Mexico among them. Fisher's bands of cattle thieves and fugitives dominated Eagle Pass through the 1870s, and with it Maverick County and its courts, and they held the town despite repeated interventions by the Texas Rangers. Officials with ties to him repeatedly blocked efforts to bring him to court. Later histories attribute a string of deaths to him in these years, three men in one quarrel and four in another. None of those deaths produced a conviction.

The state's answer to the disorder in the Strip was a company of about forty Texas Rangers known as the Special Force, raised for service in South Texas and the Nueces country. In June 1876 the Special Force raided the Pendencia and arrested nine members of Fisher's band. The prisoners never reached a cell: a lawyer won their release before they arrived. The state's marker dates Fisher's turn toward a settled life from this 1876 arrest. In 1877 a new captain took over the company and sent part of it after Fisher's band.

On November 19, 1877, the Rangers arrested Fisher on five counts of murder. In all he was indicted on twenty-one charges in these years: six for murder, by the count on the state's marker, and fifteen lesser counts, horse and cattle theft among them. The cases dragged through the South Texas courts for years, and Fisher spent about five months in the county jail in San Antonio. Every charge ended without a conviction. No court ever convicted King Fisher of a killing.

By 1881 the charges were behind him. That year the sheriff of Uvalde County appointed him a deputy. In 1883 the sheriff was himself indicted, and Fisher became acting sheriff in his place.

In March 1884 Fisher met Ben Thompson, the former city marshal of Austin. The two men traveled together to San Antonio on March 11, 1884, and both were killed there that night. Fisher was still the acting sheriff of Uvalde County. A coroner's jury sat the next day and found the killing of both men to have been done in self-defense. No one was ever charged with their deaths.

The number of murder charges against Fisher varies from one history to the next. The state's marker gives six murder charges and fifteen lesser counts; one history agrees on twenty-one charges in all but counts five of them as murder; another gives six murder indictments and two for horse theft; a magazine account of 1928 put the murder charges at seventeen, a figure its own editor disputed.

The way the murder cases ended is also disputed. One version has a single trial in Maverick County ending in acquittal; another has each charge dismissed. Both agree that no case ended in a conviction.

The deaths attributed to Fisher in the Nueces Strip rest on later histories rather than on any court finding, and none of them was tried to a verdict.

Which arrest marked his change of course is uncertain. The state's marker ties it to the Special Force raid of 1876; other histories point to the arrest of November 19, 1877, and the months in the San Antonio jail that followed.

Fisher's title in March 1884 is given both as deputy sheriff and as acting sheriff of Uvalde County. He was appointed deputy in 1881 and became acting sheriff in 1883, when the sheriff was indicted.

Timeline

1854: Born in Collin County, Texas.

1869: Arrested over a borrowed horse; escapes.

October 30, 1870: Enters the state penitentiary under a five-year sentence for housebreaking after a conviction in Goliad; pardoned about four months later.

Early to mid-1870s: Settles in Dimmit County and founds a ranch on Pendencia Creek.

June 1876: The Rangers' Special Force raids the Pendencia and arrests nine of his men, who are freed before reaching jail.

November 19, 1877: Arrested by the Rangers on five counts of murder.

1877 to about 1881: Murder and stock-theft charges dismissed or ended in acquittal; about five months in jail in San Antonio.

1881: Appointed deputy sheriff of Uvalde County.

1883: Becomes acting sheriff after the sheriff is indicted.

March 11, 1884: Killed with Ben Thompson in San Antonio.

March 12, 1884: A coroner's jury finds the killings self-defense; no one is charged.