On August 7, 1998, the United States embassy in Dar es Salaam was struck minutes after the embassy in Nairobi, Kenya. In Dar es Salaam eleven people died and eighty-five were hurt. Every one of the dead was African. Across the two cities the attacks killed 224 people, twelve of them Americans, and injured thousands more, most of them Kenyan and Tanzanian citizens.
Khalfan Khamis Mohamed, a young man from the island of Pemba, was tried in New York for his part in the Dar es Salaam attack. A federal jury in Manhattan convicted him on May 29, 2001, together with three other men, and then spent days deciding whether he should die. It could not agree. On October 18, 2001, he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Between his capture and that sentence, South Africa's highest court ruled that the way he had been handed to the United States broke the South African Constitution, a judgment the court directed to be sent to the American judge trying him.
Mohamed came from Pemba, a small and poor island in the Zanzibar archipelago off the coast of Tanzania. His father died when he was seven. He grew up with a twin sister and an older brother. He was 27 in the summer of 2001 and 28 by that October.
The government's case was that he had been recruited by a member of al Qaeda, the organization prosecutors said was led by Osama bin Laden, and that he had taken a direct hand in the preparations in Dar es Salaam in the weeks before the attack, then left Tanzania for South Africa once the work was done. After his arrest he told FBI agents that he had no regrets.
The toll in Dar es Salaam was far lower than in Nairobi, where 213 people died. Within days two men associated with bin Laden were arrested and charged, and three months later a federal grand jury in New York indicted bin Laden himself. Mohamed was not among those first arrests. He had already gone.
Mohamed reached Cape Town in September 1998, the month after the attack. He applied to stay in South Africa while he sought political asylum, using the name Zahran Nassor Maulid, and he found work in Athlone, a suburb of the city, living there on a temporary residence permit.
The FBI knew when he arrived and, by its own account, kept that knowledge to itself. In 1999 South African officials identified him, and the information reached the FBI through Interpol. In early October 1999 immigration officials arrested him in Cape Town when he went to renew his permit, on the ground that he had entered the country illegally under a false name, an offense under the Aliens Control Act. He was held for at least two days and questioned. Then he was sent to the United States in the custody of FBI agents.
Mohamed appeared in federal court in Manhattan in October 1999 and pleaded not guilty to more than 200 counts of murder, conspiracy to murder and international terrorism. The United States had jurisdiction because American government property had been targeted, even though the attack took place abroad. He was eventually tried with three other men: Mohamed Rashed Daoud Al-'Owhali, Mohamed Sadeek Odeh and Wadih El-Hage.
The government sought the death penalty against two of the four: Al-'Owhali, for the Nairobi attack, and Mohamed, for Dar es Salaam, both under a federal law passed in 1996. No federal prosecutor had sought a death sentence in New York since 1954, and the government had never before sought one for terrorism against Americans on foreign soil.
While the American case moved toward trial, lawyers in South Africa challenged the handover. Mohamed's side argued that he had been sent to face a possible death sentence in breach of his rights to life, to dignity and to freedom from cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment, and that any consent he was said to have given was not valid. The government relied on his unlawful status under the Aliens Control Act.
On May 28, 2001, the Constitutional Court ruled in his favor. It found that the Act did not authorize deporting him to the United States, a country with which he had no qualifying link, and that the difference between deportation and extradition did not matter, since the procedure was unlawful either way. The state was bound to protect the rights to life and dignity and the right not to be subjected to cruel punishment, and handing him over without first seeking an assurance that he would not face death, or would not be executed if sentenced, was unconstitutional. The immigration authorities had sought no such assurance, and the court saw no reason to think the United States would have refused one. Nor was his consent valid: he had not been told that he could insist on protection from the death penalty, and he had no chance to consult a lawyer. The court declared the handover unlawful and ordered that the full text of its judgment be conveyed to the trial judge in the United States.
The trial in the U.S. District Court in Manhattan ran, with the penalty hearings, for more than six months. Mohamed's own statements to the FBI after his arrest, in which he admitted his part in the preparations in Dar es Salaam, were part of the government's case.
On May 29, 2001, the jury convicted all four defendants. Mohamed was found guilty of the conspiracy against Americans and of crimes arising from the attacks of August 7, 1998: murdering the eleven people killed in the Dar es Salaam attack, destroying United States property resulting in death, the murder of two United States government employees because of their duties, and a further offense under the federal terrorism laws for an attack on Americans. Odeh and El-Hage were also convicted on every charge they faced.
The same jury heard the penalty case against Al-'Owhali first and spared him. Mohamed's penalty hearing followed, and his mother, his twin sister and his older brother came from Zanzibar to testify in his defense. The government argued that he remained a danger, pointing to a 2000 assault on a federal jail officer in Manhattan in which it said he had taken part; the defense disputed his role.
The jury deliberated for several days. On July 10, 2001, the forewoman told the court, "We, the jury, are unable to reach a unanimous verdict." Under federal law that left a single outcome: life in prison without the possibility of parole. The jurors' findings showed how they had divided. All twelve found the four threshold factors needed for a death sentence proven beyond a reasonable doubt, but they rejected the government's claim that he posed a continuing and serious threat to others. Ten jurors found that he had not been a leader and that his part was relatively minor. Eleven found that others who were equally or more culpable would not face execution. All twelve found that his execution would cause his family grief and loss. Seven found that it could make him a martyr for future attackers to exploit, nine credited a recent psychological report showing a low danger of harm to others, and three found that life in prison was a harsher punishment than death. Not one juror accepted the defense's claim that he was remorseful.
Formal sentencing came on October 18, 2001. Mohamed was the first of the four to be sentenced. His convictions carried a mandatory life sentence, and the judge imposed life without the possibility of parole. Mohamed declined to address the court; through his attorney he said he wished "to express gratitude to a jury that spared his life." Al-'Owhali, Odeh and El-Hage were sentenced to life without parole the same day. Each of the four was ordered to pay $33 million in restitution, $7 million to the victims' families and $26 million to the United States government.
Mohamed has served his sentence in a maximum-security federal prison in Colorado, where he has written journals and manuscripts and at times refused food in protest at prison conditions. In a suit he brought himself over his treatment by staff in 2018, a federal judge in Colorado ruled on October 24, 2025 that one of his three claims was proven and awarded him $10,000. As of that ruling he remained in federal custody in Colorado, serving life without parole.
The 2000 jail assault was never the subject of a conviction against Mohamed; it was put forward by the government as an aggravating factor at his penalty hearing, the defense disputed his part in it, and no juror found that he posed a continuing danger. Ten jurors found that his role was relatively minor and that he was not a leader; those findings shaped the sentence, not the verdict.
August 7, 1998: The U.S. embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam are struck; 11 people die and 85 are injured in Dar es Salaam.
September 1998: Mohamed arrives in Cape Town and applies for asylum under the name Zahran Nassor Maulid.
October 1999: South African immigration officials arrest him in Cape Town and hand him to the FBI; he pleads not guilty in Manhattan.
May 28, 2001: South Africa's Constitutional Court rules the handover unlawful and orders its judgment sent to the U.S. trial judge.
May 29, 2001: A federal jury in Manhattan convicts him and three co-defendants.
July 10, 2001: The jury cannot agree on death, leaving life without parole.
October 18, 2001: He is sentenced to life without parole and ordered to pay $33 million in restitution.
October 24, 2025: A federal judge in Colorado awards him $10,000 on one claim in his suit over his treatment in custody.