On the evening of Saturday, June 20, 2020, three men were killed in Reading, a town in Berkshire west of London, and three other men were injured. The man arrested for the killings within minutes was Khairi Saadallah, a Libyan national who had come to Britain in 2012 and had been released from custody two weeks earlier. On November 11, 2020, he pleaded guilty at the Central Criminal Court in London to three counts of murder and three counts of attempted murder. On January 11, 2021, the trial judge found that all six offenses had a terrorist connection and ordered that he serve the rest of his life in custody. The Court of Appeal refused him leave to challenge that sentence in October 2021.
The case did not end with the sentence. Saadallah had been known for years to the security service, counter-terrorism police, the Prevent program, the probation service, the immigration authorities and mental health services in Berkshire and in custody. A judge-led inquest at the Old Bailey examined what each of them knew, and in April 2024 the coroner concluded that the murders had probably been avoidable.
Saadallah grew up in Libya, and as a teenager he fought for at least eight months with Ansar al-Sharia, an extremist militia now proscribed in the United Kingdom; MI5 learned of that service only in 2019. He traveled to Britain in 2012.
From late 2018 his offending escalated. Over the following months he was convicted of a racially or religiously aggravated public order offense, criminal damage, battery, assaulting an emergency worker and an assault at a sentencing hearing on March 25, 2019. He was last released from custody on June 5, 2020.
While in custody in January 2017 he had sought the company of a convicted terrorist preacher; the prison service separated the two men and entered Saadallah on its program for prisoners judged vulnerable to extremism.
The security service first received information about him in late 2016. Over the next two years it looked at him three times, in late 2017, in May 2018 and in December 2018, and each time judged that what it had did not justify an investigation.
One was opened in April 2019, jointly with Counter Terrorism Policing South East, after information that he meant to go back to Libya and join the Islamic State group. It was in the course of that investigation that the security service learned of his militia service in 2011. Its inquiries found nothing to support the report, no sign that he intended to travel and no valid travel document in his name, and in June 2019 the investigation was closed. The service never held credible intelligence that he was planning an attack in Britain.
Prevent handled him four times between February 2017 and May 2019, three referrals and one reopening. The common thread was his stated wish to return to Libya to commit violence. Every one was closed at the first assessment by counter-terrorism police and none reached the Channel panel, partly because he had gone back into custody.
A multi-agency public protection meeting on October 4, 2019, had assessed him as a high risk of harm to the public and placed him under level 2 management, but it set no date for review and his case never came back to it before his release.
The three men who died were Joseph Ritchie-Bennett, James Furlong and David Wails. Three more men survived their injuries.
Saadallah was arrested in Reading within minutes of the first emergency call. On June 21 the killings were declared a terrorist incident, and Counter Terrorism Policing South East took over the investigation from Thames Valley Police under the name Operation Vaselike.
On June 27, 2020, the Crown Prosecution Service authorized police to charge Saadallah with three counts of murder and three counts of attempted murder, and the case was sent to the Central Criminal Court.
The trial never took place. On Wednesday, November 11, 2020, Saadallah appeared at the Central Criminal Court and pleaded guilty to all six counts. The pleas settled his guilt but not the questions that would decide his sentence. He put in a written basis of plea denying that he had carried out any substantial preparation or planning and denying that he had acted for an ideological cause. Three issues were left for the judge to decide: whether there had been substantial premeditation and planning, whether the offenses were committed for a religious, political or ideological cause, and how far his mental state had influenced what he did.
The hearing opened at the Old Bailey on Tuesday, January 5, 2021, and ran across several days.
On Monday, January 11, 2021, the judge gave his rulings. He found that Saadallah had carried out substantial planning and that he had been "seeking to advance a political, religious or ideological cause." He found that all six offenses had a terrorist connection. He treated the militia service in Libya as evidence of extremist views that Saadallah still held. He rejected the argument that Saadallah had been suffering from a mental illness at the time of the killings. He gave three reasons for the whole life order: the exceptionally high seriousness of the offenses, the premeditation, and the terrorist motivation.
On each of the three counts of murder he passed a sentence of life imprisonment with a whole life order, in the words of the ruling because he had "no doubt that this is a rare and exceptional case in which just punishment requires you must be kept in prison for the rest of your life." On each of the three counts of attempted murder he passed a term of 24 years, to run concurrently. He will never be eligible for parole.
Saadallah applied to the Court of Appeal for leave to challenge the whole life order.
On Thursday, October 14, 2021, the Court of Appeal, with the Lord Chief Justice presiding over a panel of three, refused leave to appeal. The court found that there was no substance in any of the criticisms made of the sentencing judge. It held that the planning and premeditation had been clearly substantial, that the killings were carried out to advance a political, religious or ideological cause, that the mental health argument had rightly been rejected, and that there was no basis for suggesting that the whole life order was wrong in principle or manifestly excessive. That ruling left the sentence final, and Saadallah remained in custody in England under his whole life order.
The inquests were heard at the Old Bailey from January 15 to February 23, 2024, before a judge coroner, who gave his conclusions on April 26, 2024. In each of the three deaths he recorded that the victim had been unlawfully killed, and that the sole direct cause was Saadallah's premeditated act, driven by Islamist extremist views. He found that Saadallah had been known before June 2020 to the security service, counter-terrorism police, Prevent, the prison and probation services, the Home Office and mental health services, and that what each knew was never brought together; that the security service had no credible intelligence of any plan for an attack; and that if intelligence held on June 19, 2020, had been shared with the police and his probation officer, he would probably have been recalled to custody that night. He concluded that the murders were probably avoidable. On May 20, 2024, he issued a report to prevent future deaths.
Saadallah admitted the killings but contested the reasons for them. His basis of plea denied substantial planning and denied any ideological motive, and his case at the hearing was that mental illness had reduced his responsibility. The sentencing judge decided all three questions against him in January 2021, and the Court of Appeal found no arguable error in those findings in October 2021. The inquest found that he had serious psychiatric problems as well as a persistent extremist mindset, but it recorded that he had no major mental illness and no mental disability that lowered his culpability. It did not reopen the sentencing findings.
2011: Fights for at least eight months with Ansar al-Sharia in Libya, during and after the uprising.
Late 2016: The security service first receives information about him.
February 2017 to May 2019: Four Prevent referrals or reopenings, each closed at the first assessment.
April to June 2019: Security service and counter-terrorism police investigation, closed without corroboration.
October 4, 2019: Assessed at a public protection meeting as a high risk of harm to the public.
June 5, 2020: Released from custody.
June 20, 2020: Three men killed and three injured in Reading; Saadallah arrested within minutes.
June 21, 2020: Declared a terrorist incident; Counter Terrorism Policing South East takes over.
June 27, 2020: Charged with three counts of murder and three of attempted murder.
November 11, 2020: Pleads guilty to all six counts at the Central Criminal Court.
January 11, 2021: Whole life order on each murder count; concurrent 24-year terms for attempted murder.
October 14, 2021: Court of Appeal refuses leave to appeal.
January 15 to February 23, 2024: Inquest hearings at the Old Bailey.
April 26, 2024: Inquest records unlawful killing in each death and concludes that the murders were probably avoidable.
May 20, 2024: Report to prevent future deaths issued.